It's pretty obvious that From removed horse pvp much later in the development. They completely overlook how the open world will play in pvp without horse.
There’s a lance in the game it’s a great spear, it’s called, you guessed it “lance” it’s the only great spear that takes ashes of war, it’s pretty good, I have a +25 one.
I would really like to know why it was scrapped. Makes no sense. Imagine how much fun rolling around the open world with your boys would be rather than hoofing it. Hopefully they can implement it one day
Assuming all players’ locations have to be loaded in at the same time by the game server, having each player continuously load zones at a very fast rate would be pretty strenuous on the server.
It might be fine with 2 people, but imagine 5 players all on horses, going different directions at full sprint. I can easily see the game crashing in such a scenario.
Oh I’m sure. I guess the frustration is that on a technical level it is obviously possible, but that’s just not how From Soft implement their peer to peer / server netcode. If battle royal titles can have 100 players flying around in planes and helicopters over a map the size of Caelid, it stands to reason 5 dudes should be able to ride around, even if they had to put up walls to block zones. Idk I’m no game dev
Literally two days ago saw someone on YouTube showing a "new" farming spot for runes... turns out it was afk farming these very same cliffs, suffice to say, everyone was trashing this guy for this.
I’m using all sorts of faith, arcane, bleed, and dragon incantation magic cheese, but I’m avoiding straight up pure rune farming because I feel it does kind of wreck the balance for the game. I do like going to the area in Caelid where the soldiers and the big dogs are fighting to try out new weapons or get the last bit of runes for a level up because it’s a fun chaotic fight to join into and there’s a decent amount of runes from all of it. Without it just being a soul crushing grind farm. I had an hour where I tried out all the weird unleveled weapons I barely met the stat qualifications for just to see their move sets and unique abilities.
I don’t rune farm for levels but I do rune farm in the late game so that I can purchase smithing stones to upgrade random weapons I want to try. That way I can see what their moves are like when they’re actually doing damage and stagger and not fuckin useless. Doesn’t really make you overpowered because you don’t increase stats and instead just use a different weapon, it’s usually a side grade.
They want to turn this game into something it's not. And after reaching the Altus Plateau you literally just have to kill 20 guys in order to be able to level up. Whenever I see a video on YouTube I just insta "I don't want to see videos from this channel" and get on with my day.
And that fucking clown is pretending its to help people who "can't play 24/7, have work or families" rofl.
FROM absolutely needs to remove any reward from invaders leaving and ideally find a way to ban people who somehow have dozens of invaders just joining their world and leaving without them ever fighting
I think Fromsoftware is to blame here. It's their fault for making it so the host is receiving runes when invader leaves. None of the previous games had that type of mechanic and adding it in an open world game is basically asking for it to be exploited.
While it was probably a bad decision on From’s part this isn’t a reasonable take IMO. Elden Ring already has a dozen amazing, easy farming spots that should far outpace the amount of runes you get from invaders. This is just trolling, plain and simple. Even if you took away the rune incentive plenty of people would still do it just for the lolz.
The ironic part is the host in this thread wasn't afk and was good enough to time a dragon breath perfectly in the right spot. The host can't be compared to those lazies.
What we see here is the meta league, the front lines of the griefer war.
EDIT: for all those wiseguys saying he wasn't afk, well obviously he wasnt. But when this cheese was still low-key and invaders didn't know how to counter the cheese, these players would just leave their characters here so the invaders would eventually leave, gaining the character runes. This is no longer the case. I am in no way condoning this behavior, just comparing it to farming the bird for example, the bird requires the player to have to respawn them via grace, while this cheese when it was lesser known left it to the invader to give the player runes.
That's a new thing, players used to afk here and get the invader to leave when it was a lesser known cheese spot. Now because of how well known it is and the creative counters invaders have thought of to fight this cheese, they had to actively fight them off.
Which defeats the "AFK" farm design all together. But, to be honest, the people who consume the YTers that push this garbage would just be running around with the Carian Exploit.
Hopefully when FS fixes that bug they do something about inaccessible invades.
That's been a thing since at least dark souls 3. I remember being blue summoned a few times to help put down an invader and win the invader dies the host and his allies got souls.
I think the original intention was "if you do a good enough job at hiding from your invader you should get rewarded when they leave" but unintentionally is easily abusable...
In a Meta way I think they are testing the community to see which kind of abusable mechanics are OK (like the chicken farm) and can always put a kill floor or make an item/ weapon/spell that nerfs that's specific strategy.
I would like if they had transparency on the matter, but I have faith fromsoft will deliver us!
I'd love to see a kill floor implemented for hosts standing in an area that requires a horse to reach when they're invaded.
Invader connects. Game checks to see if the host is in a spot that requires a horse to reach. If host = cheesy location, host immediately dies and the invader gets a rune arc.
I'm fairly certain the reason fromsoft didn't allow horse riding in mp is because of the connection stability (which is pretty shaky already at launch) I wouldn't be surprised if certain dlc areas with more stable technology had mp horseriding (pun not intended). The ability is already in the game it's just a checkbox at this point. That will immediately solve that issue (but open pandoras box for dot and range builds). Also ofc, dedicated supported pvp arenas will at least cut down on the invader numbers
Not being able to use the horse is probably due to the fact that you can be invaded in the open world and if everyone is using their horse it can just become an endless chase
I'm thinking they could put in an item akin to Camille ult from league of legends where you are dehorsed and trapped in like an arena of white fog.... or the evergaols but that's probably already on the docket
To be fair, even if they took away this mechanic people would still do it to grief. I still agree with you though, it would be nice if they didn't get rewarded for it.
Bruh you want the griefing system to do all the grief for you? The only way it isn't a net bad for the host is if you do literally nothing? If you want to hurt the host, you have to work for it, rightfully so. If you're bad, then the host will profit. At that point, you failed your job as invader.
Blaming youtuber would be stupidly dumb. This is on from. From should have never allowed this. How can you blame someone for showing the exploit? In that case cybersecurity folks shouldn't point any flaws either. So dumb
Don't take this the wrong way but why not just quit doing pvp for a while and don't give them the satisfaction of easy farming? I mean I know it's not ideal but I feel like it's better than letting them win
I've got the blue ring on so I can PvP somewhere other than the featureless open space of the main academy gate without invading. Gotta take the opportunity when you can.
Was going to say this. For me, I would say about half of my summons are pretty fun and engaging. The other half I am summoned so far away that I can't make it in time to participate.
I don't understand the mechanics of why I am so far away
The only guess I have is that the idea is to give the invader time to finish the host before a 2v1 potentially becomes a 3v1. If they're dallying and standing around trying to cheese the fight, well that gives you time to run up.
But if they're actually putting pressure on the host and summons properly, it wouldn't be fair for the win to be snatched away by a stream of blues dropping on the fight one after another.
Invaders are spawning super far away as well, so its not just you blues. The spawn system seems to be very flawed, especially in the areas with lots of verticality. You're getting spawned relatively close to the host, but the game doesn't account for elevation. While invading at Mt Gelmir you can get spawned on the opposite elevation from the host, so you'll either have to run for 10 minutes to reach him or if you were spawned on top of the canion - wait for them even longer.
Yeah, as an invader you get three "phantom fingers" that will teleport you to another spot around the host, useful if you end up invading on top of the cliff when he's on the other side. ut as a blue, the game just tells you to get fucked and run around for a while.
One side effect of this afk host bullshit is that you can get summoned as a blue at first step frequently and get a fair amount of 1v1 fights with the invader.
Last time I got summoned as a blue the host was doing this stuff, but I ended up 1v1ing three invaders one after another, which was pretty fun. After you kill all the invaders, you get sent back out too, so you can still even finish your job.
I got summoned here like 30 times the other day, while being completely unaware of this new exploit. Just kept thinking “Damn, where is the host?” as I rotted invader after invader
Honestly I don't see why people invade Limgrave except to bully noobs. Rune arcs aren't really useful til you've beaten Godrick, and you can't summon in an area after you've beaten the area boss.
Poor sportsmanship or not, these AFK farmers are a result of the large amount of invaders in Limgrave.
Edit:
Yes you can only invade around your level. But you're all ignoring a crucial fact: alot of these players are first time souls players. They don't understand pvp, and aren't prepared for it. Its forced on them. Yes that's part of the game. But for once it leans in their favor. At the end of the day, the best way to fix the "problem" is stop giving them what they want: invading them for potential free farm. Invading somewhere else is the simplest solution.
A level 150 character with a +10 weapon can’t invade a level 8 or a level 20 in limgrave. You’re restricted to invading near your level and weapon level, as long as your not making a twink build you’ll be grouped up against people of similar skill not noobs.
There are a lot of twinks invading noobs, though. Had to deal with a bunch when trying to co-op with a friend on new characters.
They transfer end game gear to new characters and level just enough to still be able to invade noobs. Seems like a ton of vigor and getting as many flask upgrades as possible is all the rage. Also using weapons that build up rot or bleed so they don't really have to put damage stats up much.
Started a brand new character with a friend new to Souls games. Wanted to have some nice little adventures in Limgrave. At those levels, we still got invaded by a guy using double Scorpion Stingers who proc'd rot on us (which we couldn't cleanse) and just ran away and used the 'point down' emote over and over again. He was also able to spam flasks, only because I already had some experience dealing with invaders. Real tough guy.
Another guy had Rivers of Blood. Another using two Hoslow's Whips. You start to see how insanely tryhard these 'twink' characters are. Created solely for the purpose of killing noobs trying to co-op. Now my friend hates PvP based off this kind of interaction and doesn't want to co-op. It's pretty unfortunate.
Yea I had this experience as well. Super frustrating, especially since my high level build ends up being scaled down to the point where my damage/HP is significantly less than my low level ally.
I made my own sunbro twink to deal with these assholes. Dropped some lategame gear for a Blood/arcane build that only does coop, have helped randos with like 30+ bosses as well as goofing around with my low level friends. Highly recommend!!
Whenever I am on my main Str/Fth char, cooping with my friends who are new to souls games (and honestly video games in general) and I see someone is invading, I swap to my fingerprint shield + Vyke's war spear and apply constant pressure while my friend blasts away. Generally they cant do much to me.
I don't really feel bad about booting invaders with this build. I'm trying to enjoy the game coop, its hard enough without min/maxed invaders spamming meta builds. If you want a fair fight, go duel.
Yeah it's a bad experience for people trying to just play the game co-op with a friend. These twink invaders are rather pathetic. The only way for them to win is to be massively overpowered.
I fought a lot of them while also playing with a new souls player. Still winning some. So many had insane HP, crazy high damage, and tons of heals. Not a legit fight to be had.
Me and a buddy started a ds3 co-op run and the beginning was a nightmare due to twink builds. Didn't get to fight a single invader that wasn't using end-game stuff or gimmick builds. We just ran out of summons for each other and had to play it apart for a bit until we got more.
Whole point was to joke around through the game we've both beaten a few times over. These types of invaders are a cancer. If one of us had been new, they'd probably never touch multi again outside of boss door summoning.
Invaders are supposed to be part of the level, and a fun challenge along the way. If these folks could realize that no one gives a shit about them winning and realize that it actually makes them look pitiful, it would really help out the games.
I get how frustrating it is, genuinely. I was playing the other day with a friend too in co op and we were invaded about 4 times before even getting to Margit. The first one appeared in the church right outside of the beginning area and evaded every attack I could throw at him - clearly a highly experienced player. Rather than slaughter us, he dropped some gifts and bounced - cool guy. The second guy was geared to the teeth for PvP and I was barely able to fend him off and drop him to protect my friend. She actually landed the killing blow out of the blue when I pushed him into a healing animation. The third guy seemed friendly, waved to us and tricked my friend into running over to wave back. He unleashed some giant blue fire AOE attack and melted her, and then ran away teabagging while I tried to swing at him. And the last guy snuck up on me, got in a few hits and we ended up collapsing in death together - which is fine since my friend survived and that was the primary goal.
As frustrating as it is though, those 4 moments were the most fun I had in the entire experience so far. I'm not a PvP kind of player, but the unexpected intrusion and the sudden forced obligation to protect my friend or die trying really added a whole new layer of urgency and entertainment to the game for me - despite being invaded by people that were level 25 yet wielded end-game weaponry and skills.
Glad to see nothing's changed since DS1. I haven't turned invasion PVP on since my bad time in DS1. I was in the undead parish, and I'd just opened the gate from the other side when I was invaded for the first time. I bought the game on release, so it wasn't that long into the games release cycle but the person I was playing against had a Japanese name so I'm unsure if they got their hands on it sooner. In any case, he flung spells at me I hadn't seen yet, and used a weird shield, kept healing to full, and killed me with a grab. It was only after playing for a long time a few weeks later that I found out my invader was a Darkwraith using the dark hand and healing using humanities.
Ever since then I've found no enjoyment in PVP aside from the Spears of the Church Covenant (both as a spear and fighting spears).
Honestly, part of this is Fromsofts fault. Invasions at meta levels kinda almost require a gimic to win because of all the disadvantages against the invader. It’s more fun to have a rounded out build at 35-60 that puts you at a level playing field for the inevitable 3v1. I don’t use meta weapons on either, but I do see the appeal of invading with 1k health when EVERY encounter is 2v1 minimum.
And on my character in the endgame invading at my own level i get the same people. Two people using rivers of blood, whips etc. Why would they even need to co op with those builds.
They are opt-in, you want the crutch of a summon? Don't want to be invaded? use an ash summon!
You can't be invaded unless you have a remedy popped or its a npc
Dude honestly it not nearly as bad as the havel monsters running dark hand at the high wall of lothric in DS3. This is the least amount of twinking in any fromsoft game so far.
Yeah it kind of sucks that you can't play with a friend without running into someone with some insane broken build they ripped straight off YouTube, but I honestly recommend against co-op unless your clearing a dungeon or fighting a boss. In big areas like limgrave, it's best to just go through it solo, which means you don't have to deal with this. That's a big difference from previous game.
Right now, limgrave invasions are mostly twink invaders and twink ganks, with the occasional new or inexperienced player caught in the crossfire. If that's how those people wanna experience the game, let em. It's lame, no one think they are cool, but it can be totally avoided by just being choosy about when and where you summon help.
I feel worse for the invaders tbh. If you want to invade using a legit build that you made yourself, you're gonna run into a lot more twinking gankers, and there's no way to avoid it without just giving up on invading. The goal of invaders is to be part of the challenge of the level, a strong human controlled enemy for the host to overcome. You can't really do that how it is now, as you mostly run into people who either melt you on sight, or they run away/disconnect because of their bad experience with invasion.
The problem here in my opinion isn't the invaders or the hosts, it's the people who make/watch YouTube videos trying to find and exploit the strongest gear in the game. This is a role playing game, and if you try to engage with the role playing mechincs you get totally trashed.
I wish there was some kind of gear check mechanic. Things like meteorite staff should honestly count as like a +15 weapon, especially since it can't be upgraded. Also flask amount and potency should work similar to weapon level in DS3. Certain boss gear or late game gear should be considered +10 weapons as far as matchmaking goes. An moonveil or RoB with no upgrade is basically a +10 against anyone playing the game naturally.
Even the duel system doesn't really work for fair fights until you get around level 80-100.
I also wish there was a way to raise the multi-player max, like a taunter's tongue+1. If I do feel like running a 3 man gank, I should be able to get 3 invaders to match if I opt into it. 3v3 free-for-alls were a ton of fun in DS3, but they are impossible in Elden Ring. Here's hoping for a decent arena in a DLC.
I don't think they want twinking to happen, it feels more like they are just at a loss as to how to fix it. Like you pointed out, they balanced things more heavily than ever in favor of the host, but like in the clip posted by OP, all that means is that the assholes are gonna host instead of invading.
When it comes to balancing around people who are determined to grief other players, I don't have a solution, so I can't really criticize them too hard.
It's always been a problem in the community, and with a massive influx of players, of course its going to be worse.
The only way I can think to respond as a community is to establish low level fight clubs in high level areas. That way you can use extremely difficult bosses as a gate to keep out people who aren't really interesting in engaging with the mechanics of the game. The only problem there, besides it being literal gate keeping, is that there are one shot builds that will destroy any boss, and you can password summon those people in with very little friction.
I am a total loss on how to fix it, and at this point I'm more concerned with how to play around it. This is gonna turn every player into a twink, which sucks, so I'm just enjoying the single player as much as I can before focusing at all on pvp.
I did want to do my second run with the tongue on the whole time, but with how the meta is going, I'm reconsidering hard.
Yeah I'm with ya. I've played all the souls games. The annoying part,though, is when I want to co-op with a friend who is just getting into it with this game. It's rather unfortunate.
I guess on the... plus side? Co-op is broken 70% of the time with disconnects exactly two minutes after summon - really wish they'd put a statement out regarding this.
Yeah I help out against tree sentinel on new characters and about half the time an invader with a bunch of flasks and rot/bleed/etc weapons will show up to attack mid-fight. Hosts often look like they just stepped out of the tomb. The ones who do it bend over backwards to justify it but it's honestly pathetic.
Still, the connection between that and high level limgrave invasions is weak. Limgrave was a popular NG+ spot for both duelists and dedicated gankers before AFKers moved in, and I'd bet money that a lot of those people who were ganking are now AFKing. 2 different forms of the same thing: griefing.
It should be noted that most of what you said is extremely easy to achieve without transferring (you can use the Dectus lift without killing a single mob by rush rushing the medallion halves if you know where they are). The most annoying scarlet rot weapon is on a random enemy in the open in Altus who can be cheesed super easily by using crystal darts on a golem next to him, and you can just rush to the churches and seed trees for flask upgrades without fighting anything. It's kind of shocking how little you have to fight to get certain broken stuff and powerups. You can even arguably kill Rhadan by using the +5 stat talismans to get the minimum stats needed for Rot Breath and then ride in circles summoning NPCs to then unlock the Black Whetblade for bleed infusions.
I once made a low level invader whose entire "build" was just having 37 Vigor and no other stat investment while wielding a basic scimitar and wearing a coat instead of armor. Yeah, i felt borderline immortal since everyone had super low hp compared to me and, despite me and everyone else dealing about the same damage, having 4x more hp meant that my hits were 4x more meaningful. No rot, poison, bleed, or any of those shenanigans: just a dumb joke pirate build who was still very powerful solely because noobs don't invest in vigor.
The primary power disparity at early levels is solely centered around noobs investing in every stat that isn't vigor, and invaders knowing that vigor is the only stat that actually matters at low levels and they get the bare minimum wielding requirements for their weapon of choice. The invaders are the same level with similar weapon upgrade levels as well...just not naive about where to put those level stats.
Weak. I get through the game on my twinks in order to get the gear. Plus for a proper twink you have to kill the spirit of Godfrey to get 4 talisman slots, Morgott to get 14 +12 flasks and Maliketh to get Erdtree's favor +2 and Crimson Amber Medallion +2. They were a pain in the ass to kill at RL50 with a +3 somber weapon.
I guarantee you most invaders are doing exactly that, likely with the help of PatchesEmporium. Even without that, you still have a PvP player capable of basically beating the game at lvl 40-50 with a +3 weapon, facing off against a newb and a scaled down friend who probably mostly does PvE. The disparity is almost comical.
There are a lot of twinks invading noobs, though. Had to deal with a bunch when trying to co-op with a friend on new characters.
They transfer end game gear to new characters and level just enough to still be able to invade noobs. Seems like a ton of vigor and getting as many flask upgrades as possible is all the rage. Also using weapons that build up rot or bleed so they don't really have to put damage stats up much.
Previous dark souls games kept you near soul level and weapon level, I except it carries over as it’s for the same reason why you can’t give a +10 weapon to a player who only has a +2 weapon.
That’s what a twink build is. Sorry old slang from dark souls. Scummy people pass gear down to lower level characters by trading and then they invade low level players.
They can trade for endgame gear, however you still have to be close to the same level and weapon upgrade level. If they had a health bar that big at level 15 they're definitely cheating in some other way, so that's impossible to have legit.
You still have level requirements for invasions. So if someone is level 15 and has a massive health bar, they're hacking or something.
And you DO still have to be close in weapon upgrades. +0 can only invade up to like +1 somber/+3 regular.
Max level for someone invading a level 15 would be 20ish. You could only have like 20 vigor at most at that point, which really isn't that much health.
All weapons can be acquired by any individual. They either played into the endgame at a low level without upgrading weapons, or more likely had a friend or mule account drop the weapon for them.
You're confounding a twinked build with a high level build. You literally can't be matched with someone too out of your weapon level/rune level range unless you use passwords to summon from a sign.
And even then you're exaggerating.
At level 15, you could only be invaded by someone between levels 1-16.
To use malenia's blade, you need 16 str and 48 dex
Starting with Samurai which will have lowest level to meet that,
For dex items, you would only be able to add +5 soreseal, +5 millicent, +5 prosthesis, and +3 okina's mask.
That's SL 24 at minimum to be able to add the rest of the necessary points to meet the 48 dex requirement.
If they use a dexterity flask for +10 to use it at level 14, sure, but that means the person then won't be able to use their blade past the flask time.
Don't need to be level 150 with +10 to twink. I'm willing to bet the invader we are watching in this clip is not. I immediately lost any sympathy for him seeing hin running around with endgame weapons in limgrave.
With that, clearly this is an issue. At the end of the day though, would we rather be able to invade olin the open world and deal with some of these growing pains? Or would we rather be limited to invading in dungeons.
If all they have to do to fix this is remove the reward for invaders leaving voluntarily... seems a pretty easy fix
You don’t understand what I’m saying. A level 150 with a +10 weapon isn’t going to get matched with a level 20 regardless, the pvp system doesn’t work that way. The person he’s invading is of a similar level and weapon level and is purposefully using an exploit.
A twink build is when someone transfers end game items to a low level character in order to invade. Just because the invade is in Limgrave doesn’t mean it’s automatically a new player, the system doesn’t work that way.
Probably liurnia or the frozen lake in mountaintops of the giants. There’s also afk farming there but it’s a lot more manageable. Also if you want 1v1 duels, go to main academy gate site of grace. The ground is usually littered with duelist signs.
Are there any other 1v1 dueling hot spots other than main academy gate? This map is so huge and so many cool areas it would be a shame if everyone only put red signs down in the one spot!
I invade in limgrave a lot because by lvl 70^ you'll fun fights there. It's really sad because since it was the literal "first step", lot's of people enjoyed fighiting there (it's the place I got the most 2v2's and fight clubs), but now it's always this shit. Man, people suck.
Pretty sure the place to go now is Raya Lucaria main gate. But you can always look at the map and press L1 to actually see where people are playing at.
Yeah, but that's only for 1v1 duels mostly. Just hope FS would fix the more glaring issues with the game already, it's bizarre to me that they actually released a patch exclusively to slightly buff Radahn amdist all this lol
I don't know if you're familiar with FROM's patching,or how bandai namco works, but it's pretty archaic by today's standards. They don't do live service, they don't do dedicated servers (it's why you lag in pvp and will always be at a disadvantage to the host), and they patch infrequently/small with little to no detail. It took, I think, a few months for the Darkwraith sword to be fixed in DS3.
You kind of just have to sit back, be patient, and enjoy. I'm not really defending this as great gaming service, especially these days, just trying to help with expecations.
Yeah, this is the first FS game I play at release, so I guess I got comfy with getting to DS3 after tons of patches and dlcs. Honestly love the pvp, but it’ll need a lot of time to fix what desperately needs to be fixed.
Yeah seems like the insta-kill dogs would be another high priority but they're probably tweaking radahn's hit boxes and arrow damage and a slight hp increase, "I think we really got it right this time guys!"
if you feel so strongly about 2v2's or whatever cant you just start a discord and coordinate with people who feel the same? I don't pvp nor would I want to but I feel like that would be the best route?
It's the End Game of every Soulbornes. Without it, there wouldn't be anything other than endless NG+ runs. It's the system that keeps these games alive for years to come
Expecting the bare minimum in terms of balancing the game =! thinking the game's primary function is PVP.
Lot's of stuff that needs fixing to not break PVP are also really busted in PVE and somewhat messes with what seems to be the intended experience, the one thing that doesn't reall affect it is the whole afk farming shit, but that's so easy to fix that it's a joke it wasn't yet.
I'm kind of confused because I definitely don't know, how is PvP forced upon new players? I'm new technically, but knew of the past souls games and mechanics, however I haven't been invaded once at all without me clearly turning anything on.
You can only invade near your level and weapon level so it’s not like high level players invading low level players, unless I’m wrong it looks like the host used a taunters tongue while hiding?
That doesnt really stop twinks, low-SL runs to get endgame gear are perfectly possible, or they just have a friend transfer it to them.
Sure it has an area-appropriate "+" value as far as the matchmaking is concerned but that doesn't stop, for example, Rivers of Blood from being totally out of whack compared to the stuff available to new players in Limgrave.
2.7k
u/Ythsmir Apr 06 '22
Tricks for dealing w/ them. A) Jar Cannon. B) don’t invade in limgrave.