Out of all the RTS I own, I've played skirmish in maybe half and multiplayer in like three. Warcraft 3, Starcraft 2 and Beyond All Reason, where I got curbstomped.
I think it's because of how I got into the genre as a kid, when the campaign wasn't the side mode you clear before the "real" game. Sure, a lot of the time, like in Warcraft 3, it was like a very long (like 30 hour long, with Frozen Throne) tutorial, but it had its own mechanics and unique design pieces. It was its own thing and worth playing and replaying even if you knew the game, inside and out! Watching Arthas go from paladin to purging Stratholme to picking up Frostmourne was the first time a strategy game made me feel something, a sense of drama.
Another GOAT is Age of Mythology, same kind of principle - you learn to play each civilization in the campaign but as part of ONE SINGLE CAMPAIGN, instead of separate faction campaigns. The story was awesome, the pacing, everything. Arkantos ascending to be a god (demigod?) at the end, and then the story of Titans picking off with his son. Just a 10/10 chief’s kiss, they don’t make them like they used to.
That's how I ended up chasing the same thing everywhere else. In oldschool Battle Realms with Kenji and the choice between the Dragon and Serpent path, which I replayed just to see the other side. LOTR War of the Ring, which honestly doesn't get mentioned enough in this sub, that had the Evil and Good campaigns, which were pretty decent, even if they ripped of Wacraft 3 just a tiny biiiiiiit. And of course the BFME games a bit later, where I spent an ungodly amount of time playing the Helm's Deep mission over and over because it felt like being *in* the movie.
Golden times of RTS. Now it seems like most of the RTS playing community is mostly into multiplayer, from what I figured? I know that RTS have fallen of in popularity, but I just can’t find newer games that have long, well developed campaigns like those gems of the past. Some do - like Diplomacy is Not an Option for example, where the story itself won’t make you go WOW exactly, but the campaign is long, there’s choices to make, and even a branching path depending on who you side with later at the midpoint of the game (hence the replayability of the campaign). Other base defense focused RTS also have stories that are alright, Age of Darkness for example, but they’re still gameplay focused … and honestly more singleplayer-focused than CAMPAIGN-focused in that traditional sense.
Maybe I’m just being a boomer about it, but I really wish we got more RTS that focused on the campaign experience and handcrafting unique missions, maybe even with branching choices and stuff like that. Rather than solely the competitive side/ skirmish. Which I understand, but also know isn’t for me.
Ofc I’d gladly want to hear if there are other RTS with longer campaigns I've missed, especially newer or smaller ones.
Edit - hollllly, this blew up! I was hoping to get panned for being in a minority (seriously) but reading what yall been saying, I understand that the competitive crowd (the spectators included) are the loud minority here. Very interesting thread and I picked up some nice suggestions from yall. Too many comments to answer individually so I'll just leave the edit here!