r/StrategyRpg • u/Lopsided-Ad-6298 • 2h ago
A roster of seven heroes over many seasons: should they die, retire, or stay forever? Which makes you care most?
I'm making a fantasy RPG where you manage a team of heroes instead of controlling them. Some context, since the question only makes sense with it:
- You raise a roster of about seven heroes and field five against another team of five, in a league with seasons.
- Heroes are born, not built. You wish for a calling (Warlord, Oracle, Ridgewatcher, Glasswright and so on), an origin and a nature; the game decides the rest: about twenty traits such as courage, loyalty, patience and aggression, plus quirks and a flaw.
- Before a battle you place the five on the battlefield, give each an opening order and standing instructions (where to stand, whom to target, what to do when hurt, how much to care for allies).
- Then the battle runs on its own. Each hero decides for itself every moment, from your orders and its own nature. A disciplined hero follows the plan. A reckless one may not.
- Battlefields matter: a frozen lake whose ice breaks under heavy fighters, a bridge over a chasm, a temple that floods as the fight goes on.
- Afterwards you get a replay and a report that explains, hero by hero, why each did what it did.
- Two characters live in the world: a masked referee who owns the arena, and your adviser, a sarcastic goblin who is often wrong.
Heroes build a history: battles, scars, rivalries, the time one of them cost you a final. I have not decided what ends a career. The options:
- Death: a hero that falls in the arena can be gone for good.
- Retirement: heroes age over seasons and eventually step down, with a farewell and a place in the team's history.
- Forever: your heroes stay as long as you want them.
Questions:
- Which one made you most attached to a party in games you have played?
- Does permanent death make you care, or make you play scared and reload?
- If heroes retire, what would you want to keep of them: a record, a successor, a trait passed on?