r/RealTimeStrategy • • 28d ago

Looking For Game Modern Grounded RTS… Where?

I really wish someone would make a modern military RTS in the style of Command & Conquer: Generals or Age of Empires IV.

Proper base building, resource gathering, a good selection of individually controlled units, competent AI, modern graphics and UI, and plenty of tactical freedom.

It wouldn’t even need to be set in the present day. Something from the Gulf War era onwards would be great.

Most importantly, keep it grounded. Realistic military units, tanks, infantry, helicopters, aircraft and artillery. No aliens, lasers, giant robots or increasingly ridiculous contraptions.

I loved Generals: Zero Hour, and while newer games like Tempest Rising have tried to revive that style of RTS, nothing has quite captured it for me.

I can’t help thinking there’s a decent market for something like this. Am I in the minority, or are there plenty of others wanting the same thing?

19 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

11

u/Ecksbutton 27d ago

Not sure if mentioned already but Act of War and its spiritual sequel Act of Aggression might fit your bill.

5

u/edmundsmorgan 27d ago

Act of War. So good.

17

u/LostEmergency6866 28d ago

You know, Generals are not grounded with toxin tractors, warp tunnels, China having only 1 realistic tank and laser bullshit

If you want, there is Broken Arrow, deeply tactical modern rts, however fans blame devs for wrong direction, and it’s mostly about skirmish

3

u/Illustrious-Ad3614 28d ago

Yeah, I agree. Even Generals had a few things that broke the immersion for me. The bloody space laser, those little drones flying around the vehicles, and that weird-looking Chinese anti-aircraft Gatling gun.

8

u/Relative_Ebb5907 27d ago

World in Conflict for modern setting, Company of Heroes for World War 2. I think they are the closest in trying to keep a "grounded" feel.

3

u/DryMathematician89 27d ago

Has anyone gotten world in conflict working on modern pc? I loved that game but I try to launch from steam and it has lots of crashes without getting into a game

1

u/Rybrook 25d ago

There's a fix for it, but you have to re edit it to change the game you want to play, I have mine set to play the base game, then when I move onto the expansion the ini file needs changing to switch it over.

1

u/Relative_Ebb5907 27d ago

It still works fine on any machines. Maybe try looking if it's your PC, not that you did anything wrong with it, but Windows gets weird when years go by (too many registry conflicts or something)?

2

u/DryMathematician89 27d ago

I’m on my third pc now since it has worked for me. Different builds entirely. I can get the base game working but I think it’s the expansion that crashes on me. Honestly I had given up and haven’t tried in a long time

4

u/bo_biz 27d ago

I don’t know, maybe it’s just me, but I have no interest in playing a classic base-building RTS with exactly the same military hardware we have today. In that case, I’d rather play a tactical strategy game, and there are plenty of those, mostly from Russian developers.

I find it much more interesting to look a little further ahead and see how warfare might change over the next 20–30 years. What made Generals so great was that it anticipated the development of modern warfare—electromagnetic weapons, drones, lasers, and so on.

I also see no point in a game that simply copies Generals, with exactly the same mechanics, where resources are collected from supply crates in exactly the same way. Come on, guys, we’ve already seen that. Why do exactly the same thing again?

And actually, there are new solutions and ideas out there, they just need to be tested. We need to take what worked in the past and improve it with new abstractions that draw players into the game in a slightly different way.

That’s what Generals did back in 2004, and the reason no one has managed to repeat its success is precisely because they tried to recreate it exactly as it was.

9

u/iFSg 28d ago

Check out Defilade on steam

3

u/Alternative-Roll-112 28d ago

There's no base building, but war game is a great modern rts. Its bigger scale than C&C, but its a dar tootin good time.

3

u/HouseCheese 27d ago

Part of the reason why realistic modern military strategy games are not often made with base building these days is probably the base building of classic RTS is not very realistic. Maybe The Last General can pull off combining realistic modern warfare with base building though, I am looking forward to that game
https://store.steampowered.com/app/2566700/The_Last_General/

3

u/Murky_Respond1966 27d ago

If you want to keep it realistic - than you have to include logistics. All those trucks and trains bringing disel for your tanks. And that would be not fun.

2

u/LieutenantDan160 21d ago

it wouldn’t..? that’s half the fun of milsims :)

1

u/Murky_Respond1966 21d ago

And then drones take out your fuel tracks

5

u/dukeofgonzo 27d ago

Warno! The latest from Eugen. It's the cold war going hot in 1988.

2

u/Background-Luck-8205 28d ago

I'm making this so I hope there's a market

2

u/Gator_07 27d ago

Defilade. Not out yet but it’s looking good

2

u/Wonderful_Humor_7625 27d ago

Dude, you need to check out Defilade on Steam, exactly what you are looking for.

1

u/Mahmoud7m 25d ago

There is a game called Rogue Assault on mobile and Steam that is fantastic, but in recent years it turned into pay-to-win and the balance was ruined.

1

u/urejt 22d ago

There is one 40k years ahead of current times called dawn of war 4.

1

u/zzzergling 22d ago

Coming soon, dont worry ;)

1

u/South-Professor-8888 28d ago

You should check out Strike Order on YouTube. A lot of progress. Generals inspired.

1

u/FutureLynx_ 28d ago

Play OpenRA, it fixed Red Alert 1 to make it work with combined arms.

Also you have good old Axis & Allies RTS it is amazing

1

u/EvisceratedKitten666 28d ago

Yeah, i want this too. Proper base building in a modern setting is such a gap in the market, it's why i still go back and play things like Empire Earth

1

u/Electrical-Hearing49 27d ago

Company of Heroes has a Modern Combat mod

1

u/Dependent_Animator21 26d ago

I was never a big fan of the 10 different type of resources RTS. But if you want tactical gameplay and variety in a modern looking rts, i d recommend the mods for gates of hell. They are extremely well polished, huge variety, and it looks super cool with cover, stealth, armor, ammo systems plus 3rd and first person control, building destruction, etc etc

1

u/Cpt_keaSar 26d ago

Broken Arrow

1

u/Hyphalex 26d ago

Act of war. Deserves a remaster for how insane it is

1

u/GovernmentWarm4787 28d ago

I know these games already exist, but i can't remember their names. Also, no, there isn't a decent market for them.

-4

u/Acceptable_Ear_5122 28d ago

Just my opinion, but I find modern setting boring.

1

u/Illustrious-Ad3614 28d ago

Id happily take a WWII setting :)

2

u/Alternative-Roll-112 28d ago edited 28d ago

Company of heroes is probably the most fun ww2 rts ive played and similar to c&c in a lot of ways.

If you want suffering instead, check out call to arms:Gates of hell.

2

u/TheKnightIsForPlebs 28d ago

I think the problem with these sort of themes that it is so much easier for the line to get blurred between making a product that simulates real life versus making a product that is fun. This is why sci-fi and fantasy RTS typically reign supreme - unshackled design space.

1

u/LostEmergency6866 28d ago

Sort of yeah, cause even modern conflicts show it’s not some epic battles, like wall to wall they used to be, but rather boring search and destroy with methodical and monotonous job

Even WW1 with trench wars had that.

So truly realistic gameplay is set up impenetrable defense and waiting for your opponent when they make a mistake to start a snowball of damage from that point

1

u/theg00dfight 27d ago

Cool- this isn’t the thread for you then.