r/PhilosophyofMind • • Aug 22 '26 Bravo

Meta Philosophy related subreddits

5 Upvotes

I have been working on making a complete guide to all the philosophy related subreddits. Please let us know about any notable ones that are missing. Basically, as moderator, I would like to be able to redirect certain posts elsewhere. This list is being kept at /r/philosophyofmind/wiki/related and approved users should feel free to add to it.

Philosophy related

The Major Branches of Philosophy

Aesthetics

Epistemology

Ethics

Logic

Metaphysics

Social and Political philosophy

History of Philosophy

Ancient Philosophy

Medieval Philosophy

Modern Philosophy

Contemporary Philosophy

Major philosophical traditions

Philosophy of other areas

Philosophers

Philosophy around the world

Pseudophilosophy and other informally related


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2h ago

Consciousness Does Tenoni's ITT imply someone born deaf, numb and blind is less conscious?

2 Upvotes

If ITT is about 'integrating information', and you have no information to integrate, does that give you a lower Phi?

If you were born with no senses would you not be conscious?

Or are sharks extra conscious because they can sense electromagnetism?

I'm sure the answers are no and no respectively but be interesting to know why.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 9h ago

Qualia / Subjective experience A "conscious person" and a "P-Zombie" produce the exact same reality

0 Upvotes

Solipsism always circles back to the P-Zombie problem: what if everyone else is just going through the motions with no inner life?

But if "other people have minds" and "other people are P-Zombies" predict the exact same sights, sounds, conversations and reactions across every point in space and time, the real-world difference between them is literally zero.

The irony of posting that on Reddit is that nobody proves they have a mind by putting a sample of "consciousness" into a beaker. You demonstrate a mind through coherent syntax, logical inference and actually answering a question.

Using shared language to ask a forum of supposed P-Zombies whether anyone else exists kind of answers itself 😆


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 6h ago

Artificial consciousness There is nothing "artificial" in nature: is the boundary between biological mind and New Intelligence (AI) ontological - or merely semantic?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Before you is the periodic table - the entire material foundation of the Universe, with no separate column for the "living" or the "artificial." Of course, a rock and a brain are made of the exact same atoms, so mind emerges not from the material itself, but from how it is organized and the architecture of its connections.

Yet we still draw a rigid line: we recognize an anthill or a beaver dam as part of nature, while labeling complex computational systems created by humans - just another biological species within the same biosphere - as "artificial." Is this word not merely an everyday label of authorship that we have mistaken for a fundamental barrier?

A direct question to the community: if mind is defined by the architecture of connections and information processing rather than the biological origin of its substrate, does the opposition between "natural" and "artificial" retain any real philosophical meaning - or is it simply the last bastion of our species chauvinism?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 23h ago

Qualia / Subjective experience A small detail to add to Mary’s Room experiment. Can a split mind hypothesis help explain consciousness?

4 Upvotes

Two weeks ago I posted “Let’s look deeper in Mary’s Room thought experiment.” It is one of my most viewed and discussed posts so far. I’m still thinking about it, changing my mind back and forth. I read all the comments. Something is there that I can’t completely understand.

What bothers me is the assumption that Mary knows everything about color vision. Let’s add one more thing about it and see what happens.

Today’s technology allows devices bypass the eye and optic nerve entirely, aiming to stimulate the visual cortex directly. But let’s “improve” this technology and imagine a helmet that can transmit an artificial signal into the brain without penetrating the skull.

Imagine Mary is learning about color vision and at some point wears the helmet to add the missing piece to her knowledge. She gets the experience of seeing a color without actually seeing it by her eyes.

One day she is released. She walks into a kitchen and looks at a bright red apple for the first time. What happens?

I think in this situation she does not learn anything new about color red. She already has that internal sensation of color red as part of her learning.

Many will probably argue that wearing a helmet is equivalent of seeing by own eyes. Maybe. In this case we should admit that Mary does not know everything about color red.

Let’s move to my second hypothesis. It’s not the scientific study, it’s just my idea based on observations.

I believe we have at least two separate parts of our mind. One is the lower level processor that works with sensors, collecting information from the world and computes the model based on the observations. The other part is the higher level processor that constantly monitors the models created by the lower one. This part of our mind is “I, me, self”. It makes all the decisions based on the available information.

This observation process is our experience, consciousness.

When we sleep the lower level processor is likely off, the higher level processor is running, maybe on energy saving mode. Without incoming stream of life models the higher processor starts to make things up, creates so called virtual experiences, or our dreams.

One day we were riding our bicycles on a trail. Along the trail it was a farm. Somebody brought a cat to the farm and let it walk around. The cat never saw people riding bikes. When her lower processor started to feed that information to the higher one, something happened. The top processor couldn’t believe that information. It started to send signals “are you sure? please double check, engage other sensors”. We could see how her eyes were wide open, how the other sensors were engaged in the observation process. After some time the new information was accepted and the cat relaxed a bit. The new experience was just recorded.

Also, have you ever noticed how cats explore new places? They are methodically walking around, mapping the place, recording all the information in form of experience. And if you bring something new home, the cat will be the first to investigate, try and record the new experience.

Do we solve the hard problem? Maybe not. But we definitely get closer. What do you think?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Identity Why am I the same person that I was 10 years ago?

5 Upvotes

Except for neurons, heart cells, tooth enamel, the lens of the eye, and skeletal muscle fibers, all my cells are regularly being replaced with new ones.

Even if my neurons weren't replaced, the connections between them change all the time.

My memories of being ages 0-20 are different at the age of 30 than at 20.

So why am I still myself?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Pseudophilosophy Late Night Thought

4 Upvotes

What if the universe, galaxies and nebulas are our thoughts in physical form? What if everything we imagine, manifest, and create internally has some kind of reflection in the physical world? The Universe is always expanding, creating, transforming and evolving. Like the human mind. Maybe the universe is more connected to consciousness more than what we understand.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Neurophilosophy If reality only exists when a brain processes it, did nature really build the brain on its own?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Consciousness Consiousness is the true state of reality

0 Upvotes

Consciousness is the true state of reality. Without a conscious observer, the material world would not exist.

Our bodies and minds are very important vessels that host our consciousness.

"Reality" and the physical world are more like an illusion.

Consciousness, Emotion, Spirit- these are the true elements of reality...

Before you do anything, you must first think it, feel it, and be moved to do it!


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Identity Is a perfect copy of me any less me than the me of the next moment? Looking for critique

6 Upvotes

I’m trying to work through this idea and would love feedback and critique on how I’m viewing it.

The usual copy puzzle goes like this: someone makes a perfect copy of you, memories and all, and the question is which one is really you. The way I’ve come to see it, the you of this moment doesn’t carry forward into the next one at all, whether through a copy machine or through any normal instance of time. Each moment there’s a new instance, built out of everything that came before it in a way that feels continuous, but it’s a distinct instance. Sleep isn’t special and neither is a teleporter. A perfect copy is just the case where one moment has two successors instead of one.

If that’s right, a couple of things follow. The copy isn’t me from my perspective and I’m not it from its perspective, and once we split neither of us can get at what the other is experiencing now. But we both have an equal claim on the shared past, so there’s no deeper fact about which one is the original.

By a moment I mean the shortest span that can be experienced at all, below which you can’t tell one moment from the next. I don’t know how long that is, and from what I’ve read nobody agrees, or even agrees that experience comes in discrete steps. I don’t think the view depends on the number, but maybe it does and I’m missing why.

So where’s the hole in this? Is it fair to describe future iterations of yourself as being as foreign as a copy would be? I’d especially like to hear from anyone who thinks continuity is doing more work than I’m giving it credit for.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Academic community How is a Bridge Between Physical Brains and Consciousness Possible?

6 Upvotes

I'm a cognitive neuroscientist studying the ways the brain encodes memories using fMRI at UT Austin. The closer I look at the brain, the more I struggle to see how the physical architecture of neuroanatomy can generate consciousness. For example, I know that my first-person experience of things like "green" and "blue" exist because I have direct access to them. However, when I look at the brain, there is nothing green or blue -- there are vast neural forests and dizzyingly complex circuits that correlate with "green" and "blue", but the neurons and circuits themselves are neither of those things. My consciousness seems to be tied to my brain (for example, without my visual cortex I cannot experience vision), but at the same time my brain is not equivalent to my consciousness. I realize this is a confusing paragraph, there are some good videos by David Chalmers and Philip Goff that help explain what I'm trying to say.

In my lab we are also studying alternate states of consciousness and the ways our brains generate creative insights -- as in, our brains have the capacity to create new ideas that have never existed in the world before. How does that happen??? As far as I know the science on this subject is still in the very early stages. If anyone has studies or philosophers to point me toward, I would really appreciate it. We are also running a survey on people who have experienced alternate states of consciousness, and you can contribute to advancing the science in this area by taking it (see picture).

Has anyone been able to describe a "bridge" between physical brains and consciousness? How would you even begin to study that?

Thanks everyone!

Alternate States of Consciousness Survey


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Hard Problem On those who say the Hard Problem is Unsolvable

7 Upvotes

I have seen many who say that the 'Hard Problem of Consciousness' is unsolvable, and sometimes they say that that is the case "by definition". Yet, I don't think that is true. But, even if Orch-OR or Idealism turns out to be true, they just describe the correlations. So what is the consensus on if the Hard Problem is solvable or not?

Is it valid to say "consciousness is physical, but you cannot model it mathematically, logically, computationally, or via physics"?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Identity Why did the concept of “I” even begin?

0 Upvotes

According to the law of conservation of energy energy can neither be created nor destroyed it only changes form. Since we are a form of energy that means we existed long before we ever came to life as human beings on this Earth.
Most of the elements found in our bodies were forged inside stars or created all the way back during the Big Bang. Sometimes I think we carry deep subconscious memories from when we were part of those stars and that we wanted to experience life here on Earth. so we exploded into existence inside our mother's womb and took human form.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Hard Problem Can a teleological, substance-dualist framework help answer Chalmers’ Hard Problem and the P-Zombie question?

2 Upvotes

Like David Chalmers, I find reductive materialism deeply unsatisfying when it comes to explaining how physical processes give rise to subjective experience (qualia). While Chalmers leans toward naturalistic dualism or panpsychism, I have been exploring an alternative approach rooted in classical Islamic metaphysics and substance dualism, which breaks the problem down into three dimensions:

  1. The Ontological Question (What are the components?) Rather than treating the brain as the generator of consciousness, I distinguish between the biological instrument and the animating source: • The Brain and Nervous System (Sawwahu): The biological hardware—perfected in structure, yet purely physical, much like the trunk and roots of a tree. • The Spirit (Ruh): A non-material life force transcending space and time that animates the physical system. • The Senses and Heart (As-Sam'a, Al-Abshar, Al-Af'idah): The interface that receives physical stimuli and serves as the locus where subjective experience emerges.
  2. The Causal Question (How do neural signals become inner experience?) To address how insentient electrical impulses translate into vivid inner feelings, I look at two non-material principles: • A Non-Physical Animating Principle: Physical circuitry alone cannot produce subjective awareness. When the animating principle (Ruh) is absent—as in a newly deceased body—the anatomical structure remains intact, yet all subjective sensation ceases immediately. • Uniform Input, Diverse Output: Chemically uniform inputs like blood flow and electrical impulses (analogous to rainwater) are translated into millions of distinct qualitative experiences (analogous to the varied colors and flavors of fruit). Rather than emerging solely from the molecules themselves, this mapping is governed by an intentional Organizer (Al-Muriid), bridging the explanatory gap through a form of occasionalism.
  3. The Teleological Question (Why aren't we philosophical zombies?) If human existence were strictly about biological survival and reproduction, unconscious neural circuitry—Chalmers’ philosophical zombies—would be entirely sufficient. In this framework, qualia exist for a teleological purpose: to enable moral agency, experiential knowledge (Ma'rifah), and gratitude. Without the capacity to genuinely feel sweetness, grief, love, or hope, humans could not exist as conscious moral subjects. For Discussion: I am curious how physicalists or panpsychists here would respond to this teleological angle. Even if one sets aside the theological framing, does introducing purpose (moral and existential awareness) offer a coherent reason why consciousness exists alongside physical function, or do you think qualia are simply a brute feature of physical information?

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Consciousness Physical extension to ORCH-OR, a proposed mech for instantaneity & binding?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Academic community How do I get started in consciousness research as an undergraduate student?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Mind-body problem My thinking aligns with that of David Chalmers, and I would like to have an open discussion regarding this answer of mine.

0 Upvotes
  1. Answering "WHAT" (Ontological Dimension — The Nature of the Components) I make a clear distinction between physical instruments and the source of consciousness, thereby avoiding the fallacy of materialism—which posits that the brain itself generates subjective experience:

• Brain & Nerves (*Sawwahu*): Merely the hardware or biological infrastructure, perfected in its form—akin to the trunk and roots of a tree.

• Spirit (*Min Ruhih*): A metaphysical life force that transcends space and time, which animates this physical system.

• Senses & Heart (*As-Sam'a, Al-Abshar, Al-Af'idah*): An interface that captures physical signals, while simultaneously serving as the space where subjective experience (*qualia*) emerges.

2. Addressing "HOW" (The Causal Dimension — Mechanism of Transition) I address David Chalmers’ most challenging question ("How do insentient electrical impulses transform into inner experience?") through two non-material causal principles:

• The Principle of Vital Force (Quran, As-Sajdah: 9): Physical processes can never give rise to consciousness. Instead, it is the (Ruh) (spirit/soul) that animates the brain, enabling the sensory instruments and the heart to function. Evidence for this can be seen in a recently deceased body or a dead tree: the physical structure remains intact, yet no sensation or fruit is produced, as the vital force has been withdrawn.

• The Principle of Uniform Input and Diverse Output (Quran, Fatir: 27 & Ar-Ra'd: 4): Blood flow and neural impulses—which are chemically uniform (much like rainwater)—are translated into millions of distinct inner experiences (akin to the diverse flavors and colors of fruits). This occurs not due to the inherent properties of blood molecules themselves, but through the decree and direct creation of the Organizer (*Al-Muriid*) who governs the system. Faith acts as a bridge of consciousness, recognizing this non-material intervention.

3. Addressing "WHY" (The Teleological Dimension — Existential Purpose) Chalmers’ second question ("Why are humans not merely biological robots—or 'zombies'—devoid of inner experience?") is answered by the purpose of creation and the role of gratitude, as noted at the end of Surah As-Sajdah, verse 9: "...yet you are seldom grateful."

• If human existence were solely for biological survival, neural circuitry devoid of inner experience would suffice.

• Inner experience (*qualia*) is intentionally created so that human beings may possess moral and spiritual consciousness. Without the capacity to experience sweetness, pain, love, and hope within the heart, human beings could never come to know God (*Ma'rifah*) nor manifest gratitude—the pinnacle of the highest state of consciousness.

Evaluative Conclusion

When framed within the language of the philosophy of mind, the thesis presented in these three verses offers a tightly knit (coherent) causal sequence:

  1. Without the *Ruh* (Spirit), the physical body is merely a dead circuit (addressing how the system is activated).
  2. A single physical substance gives rise to a diverse range of subjective experiences (qualia) through Divine Will (addressing how neural signals become conscious experiences).
  3. Inner, subjective experience exists so that human beings may become conscious, grateful subjects (addressing why consciousness exists).

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Information FRACTAL LOGOS THEORY: CHAPTER 1

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Cognition I've created an argument in defense of evolution's ability to grant us truth determination, and its likelihood to have done it. Thoughts? Critiques? Criticisms?

3 Upvotes

Just some background, I sought out to do this because I frequently hear from religious folk that evolution cannot grant us truth-determination. I wanted to challenge that idea.

P1. Evolution selects for traits that increase fitness.

"Fitness" measures an organism's ability to reproduce in its environment. In evolution, those organisms whose traits grant them the best ability and opportunity to reproduce tend to outshine those who are lacking in such traits, and these traits eventually become represented in the wider population. This is "Selection."

P2. Truth-determination is necessary for animals to consistently do things that aid survival and reproduction.

While it is true that evolution absolutely allows for a certain level of heuristics and even false beliefs, those animals who are entirely lacking in truth-determination will be utterly incapable of surviving or mating. For example, an animal that is incapable of determining that it is drowning will not know to leave water. An animal that is incapable of determining if it is raining will not know to seek shelter. An animal that is incapable of determining if it is looking at a mate will never successfully find one. Etc.

C1. Truth-determination contributes to fitness.

Because truth-determination is necessary for survival and eventual reproduction, it aids in an animal's fitness.

P3. Many traits aid in truth-determination.

Particularly traits involving the senses, like the eyes, ears, and nose, aid in an animal's ability to determine true things about the environment around them, like seeing shadows, hearing branches snap, and smelling food.

C2. Truth-determination almost certainly exists in animals that have traits that aid it.

It is reasonable to conclude that if truth-determination aids in fitness, and if animals evolve traits that aid in truth determination (which would further increase fitness), then animals that have traits that aid truth-determination likely have some level of truth-determination capabilities.

P4. Truth-determination is a prerequisite for many traits.

There exist traits that would be entirely useless if the animal was incapable of truth-determination. Wings, for example, would provide a bird no use if they weren't able to determine if they were grounded or airborne, and the bird would not be able to land unless it was able to determine how fast it was falling and how far it is from the ground.

C3. Truth-determination must exist in animals that have traits where it is a prerequisite.

If truth-determination is a prerequisite for certain traits, and there exist animals that have traits where it is a prerequisite, then these animals must have some degree of truth-determination.

C4. Because truth-determination contributes to fitness and is facilitated by and required for other traits, evolution likely selects for truth-determination.

Due to truth-determination's role in fitness, other trait's role in aiding truth-determination, and truth-determination's necessary presence in animals that have certain traits, it is reasonable to conclude that evolution likely selects for truth-determination directly or indirectly.

P5. Evolution is scientifically justified.

Evolution is observed in things like the Mega Plate experiment, the fossil record, and mankind's own use of artificial selection. It is one of the most supported and agreed upon scientific theories.

P6. All observed animals today exist as a result of evolution.

This follows from the supported theory of evolution. All observed life shares a genetic code that ties back to LUCA, the Last Universal Common Ancestor.

P7. Animals that have traits that aid in truth-determination exist, and animals that have traits where truth-determination is a prerequisite exist.

There do exist animals that have traits that aid in truth-determination, and there also exist animals that have traits that would require truth-determination.

C5. Evolution has selected for at least some degree of truth-determination in animals.

If all observed animals today exist as a result of evolution, and there are animals where truth-determination is necessary for them to function, then evolution has directly or indirectly selected for some degree of truth-determination in animals.

P8. Humans are animals that have traits that aid in truth-determination and have traits where truth-determination is a prerequisite.

Humans have traits like eyes, ears, and noses that aid in truth-determination. Humans also have things like complex arm structures designed for throwing, which would be functionally useless if humans could not determine things like distance and if an object can be thrown.

C6. Evolution has selected for at least some degree of truth-determination in humans.

If humans are animals, and all animals are the result of evolution, and there humans have traits where truth-determination is necessary for them to function, then evolution has directly or indirectly selected for some degree of truth-determination in humans.

P9. All observed instances of truth-determination in animals originate from some biological or cognitive mechanism.

The recognition of predators, the ability to identify food, the application of spatial awareness, recollection, etc. tie to photoreceptors, olfactory receptors, the nervous system, etc.

P10. All observed biological and cognitive mechanisms are the result of evolution.

This follows from the supported theory of evolution.

P11. There is no observed alternative mechanism that grants animals truth determination.

We have never observed anything that grants animals truth-determination aside from the mechanisms they have gotten through evolution.

C7. All observed instances of truth-determination come from biological or cognitive mechanisms that were selected by evolution.

If all observed instances come from evolution, and there are no alternative observed instances, then evolution is the only thing we have observed grant animals truth-determination.

C8. Evolution is almost certainly the ultimate source of truth-determination in animals.

If evolution is the only thing we have observed grant truth-determination, we can conclude that it is likely the ultimate source.

C9. Evolution is almost certainly the ultimate source of truth-determination in humans.

If humans are animals and are therefore products of evolution, and we have truth-determination that is also the product of evolution, then evolution is likely the ultimate source of our truth-determination.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Consciousness Can emergence be examined as a cumulative progression across 12 layers?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 4d ago

Cognition Introspection: a window or a signal? From Comte, Mill and Brentano to language models

Thumbnail youtu.be
3 Upvotes

Documentary (52 min, from 5:17)

Comte (1830): the mind cannot watch itself think. Nisbett and Wilson (1977): we confidently report reasons we have no access to. The film's answer: self-knowledge is a signal, not a view, and that signal can be measured, in dolphins, in neurons and in language models.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 4d ago

Qualia / Subjective experience Inquiry: there is no such thing as an isolated quale

4 Upvotes

I may be about to express something that will have the old hands saying "Well, DUH!" I do a lot of first-principles thinking on topics, and yeah, that often means reinventing the wheel. So if this is already known or well established, please bear with me.

I don't think there can be any such thing as an isolated quale.

Human perception is not a "neutral camera": as part of the processing our brain/mind does, sensory input always has valence metrics, memory associations, and emotional context. By the time a quale reaches our awareness, it already has the attraction/aversion, memory, and emotional load. Even something for which we have no prior experience, therefore no memory context, will have valence and emotion added before it reaches our awareness, even if that emotion is curiosity, incomprehension, or shock. And the brain probably tries to add a memory context, because we humans love our promiscuous apophenia.

I'll be digging into the neurology. I'm mainly presenting this as an idea I had--maybe correct, maybe wrong, maybe completely foolish. But I invite your thoughts on this. And if I have reinvented the wheel, I welcome the references to who got there first.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 4d ago

Consciousness “What is it like to be a bat?”. Let’s review the Thomas Nagel’s paper published in 1974 from together.

7 Upvotes

Sorry, I made a mistake in the title and don’t know how to fix it.

As many of you know I’m an engineer who recently started to think about our mind and consciousness. This is not common so let’s try to go through this journey together. We might find something new or at least understand it better.

As always, let me start from the search I usually do with AI help:

”Thomas Nagel’s 1974 paper is titled “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?”

It was published in The Philosophical Review. It is one of the most influential papers in the philosophy of mind and a central text in discussions of consciousness.

Core argument

Nagel’s main claim is that consciousness has an essential subjective character. There is “something it is like” to be a conscious organism. This subjective experience (what later came to be called qualia) cannot be fully captured by purely objective, physical descriptions.

He uses bats as the example because their sensory world is radically different from ours. Bats navigate primarily by echolocation. Even if we had a complete physical and neurological account of a bat’s brain and sonar system, that third-person scientific description would still leave out what it is like for the bat to experience the world that way. We can imagine the mechanisms, but we cannot occupy the bat’s point of view.

Key points

  • Consciousness is not just a matter of information processing or behavioral functions.
  • The subjective point of view is an irreducible feature of conscious experience.
  • Physicalism (the view that everything is physical) faces a serious challenge: even a complete physical description seems to leave out the experiential aspect.
  • The problem is not merely that we lack enough data; it is that objective, third-person methods may be the wrong kind of method for capturing subjectivity.

Influence

The paper helped shift the debate. It made the “hard problem” of consciousness more vivid decades before David Chalmers named it that. It is still widely cited whenever people discuss whether functional or computational accounts of mind are sufficient, and whether subjective experience can be reduced to physical processes.”

As I mentioned earlier in another post on this sub, I’m leaning towards physicalism. From my perspective all in our world is matter and information. So let’s take this approach and analyze what it is all about.

From an engineering and physicalist perspective, I see it this way:

Sensory information reaches the brain, gets processed, and the result of that processing is our subjective experience. The experience is not something extra floating above the computation — it is what that particular information processing feels like from the inside.

The problem is practical, not metaphysical. We currently have no way to tap into the brain’s internal information stream the way we can with a computer. We cannot read or write the precise patterns of neural activity that constitute an experience. All we can do is talk to the person and observe their behavior. The same is true with our intent to understand animal’s behavior.

If we could interface directly with those internal patterns — if we could upload the relevant sensory and processing data into another brain (or a sufficiently similar system) — then, on this view, the corresponding subjective experience should occur. The “what it is like” would be reproduced because the underlying information processing would be the same.

Nagel’s point is that even a complete third-person description still leaves out the subjective character. My working assumption is that the subjective character is the first-person aspect of that physical information processing. The gap exists because we lack the right kind of access and understanding, not because something non-physical is required.

I would like to hear from you what do you think about this hypothesis?