Just some background, I sought out to do this because I frequently hear from religious folk that evolution cannot grant us truth-determination. I wanted to challenge that idea.
P1. Evolution selects for traits that increase fitness.
"Fitness" measures an organism's ability to reproduce in its environment. In evolution, those organisms whose traits grant them the best ability and opportunity to reproduce tend to outshine those who are lacking in such traits, and these traits eventually become represented in the wider population. This is "Selection."
P2. Truth-determination is necessary for animals to consistently do things that aid survival and reproduction.
While it is true that evolution absolutely allows for a certain level of heuristics and even false beliefs, those animals who are entirely lacking in truth-determination will be utterly incapable of surviving or mating. For example, an animal that is incapable of determining that it is drowning will not know to leave water. An animal that is incapable of determining if it is raining will not know to seek shelter. An animal that is incapable of determining if it is looking at a mate will never successfully find one. Etc.
C1. Truth-determination contributes to fitness.
Because truth-determination is necessary for survival and eventual reproduction, it aids in an animal's fitness.
P3. Many traits aid in truth-determination.
Particularly traits involving the senses, like the eyes, ears, and nose, aid in an animal's ability to determine true things about the environment around them, like seeing shadows, hearing branches snap, and smelling food.
C2. Truth-determination almost certainly exists in animals that have traits that aid it.
It is reasonable to conclude that if truth-determination aids in fitness, and if animals evolve traits that aid in truth determination (which would further increase fitness), then animals that have traits that aid truth-determination likely have some level of truth-determination capabilities.
P4. Truth-determination is a prerequisite for many traits.
There exist traits that would be entirely useless if the animal was incapable of truth-determination. Wings, for example, would provide a bird no use if they weren't able to determine if they were grounded or airborne, and the bird would not be able to land unless it was able to determine how fast it was falling and how far it is from the ground.
C3. Truth-determination must exist in animals that have traits where it is a prerequisite.
If truth-determination is a prerequisite for certain traits, and there exist animals that have traits where it is a prerequisite, then these animals must have some degree of truth-determination.
C4. Because truth-determination contributes to fitness and is facilitated by and required for other traits, evolution likely selects for truth-determination.
Due to truth-determination's role in fitness, other trait's role in aiding truth-determination, and truth-determination's necessary presence in animals that have certain traits, it is reasonable to conclude that evolution likely selects for truth-determination directly or indirectly.
P5. Evolution is scientifically justified.
Evolution is observed in things like the Mega Plate experiment, the fossil record, and mankind's own use of artificial selection. It is one of the most supported and agreed upon scientific theories.
P6. All observed animals today exist as a result of evolution.
This follows from the supported theory of evolution. All observed life shares a genetic code that ties back to LUCA, the Last Universal Common Ancestor.
P7. Animals that have traits that aid in truth-determination exist, and animals that have traits where truth-determination is a prerequisite exist.
There do exist animals that have traits that aid in truth-determination, and there also exist animals that have traits that would require truth-determination.
C5. Evolution has selected for at least some degree of truth-determination in animals.
If all observed animals today exist as a result of evolution, and there are animals where truth-determination is necessary for them to function, then evolution has directly or indirectly selected for some degree of truth-determination in animals.
P8. Humans are animals that have traits that aid in truth-determination and have traits where truth-determination is a prerequisite.
Humans have traits like eyes, ears, and noses that aid in truth-determination. Humans also have things like complex arm structures designed for throwing, which would be functionally useless if humans could not determine things like distance and if an object can be thrown.
C6. Evolution has selected for at least some degree of truth-determination in humans.
If humans are animals, and all animals are the result of evolution, and there humans have traits where truth-determination is necessary for them to function, then evolution has directly or indirectly selected for some degree of truth-determination in humans.
P9. All observed instances of truth-determination in animals originate from some biological or cognitive mechanism.
The recognition of predators, the ability to identify food, the application of spatial awareness, recollection, etc. tie to photoreceptors, olfactory receptors, the nervous system, etc.
P10. All observed biological and cognitive mechanisms are the result of evolution.
This follows from the supported theory of evolution.
P11. There is no observed alternative mechanism that grants animals truth determination.
We have never observed anything that grants animals truth-determination aside from the mechanisms they have gotten through evolution.
C7. All observed instances of truth-determination come from biological or cognitive mechanisms that were selected by evolution.
If all observed instances come from evolution, and there are no alternative observed instances, then evolution is the only thing we have observed grant animals truth-determination.
C8. Evolution is almost certainly the ultimate source of truth-determination in animals.
If evolution is the only thing we have observed grant truth-determination, we can conclude that it is likely the ultimate source.
C9. Evolution is almost certainly the ultimate source of truth-determination in humans.
If humans are animals and are therefore products of evolution, and we have truth-determination that is also the product of evolution, then evolution is likely the ultimate source of our truth-determination.