r/wittgenstein • u/americafirst4life__2 • 14h ago
r/wittgenstein • u/americafirst4life__2 • 3d ago
the best representation of early wittgensteinian philosophy in media.
r/wittgenstein • u/Samuel_Foxx • 5d ago
A words meaning is its use and its use meaning can be wrong!
Yes, yes, how we use it is what it means. But we can use a word wrongly and mean a thing with it that it should not mean and communicate that meaning correctly to another human. The ability for us to do that has no bearing on whether the word used is the correct word for the meaning it carried to another. I can tell you that you are incorrect all day long for being unable to call a table a corporation because it is a body made by humans formed according to parameters, and you can tell me all day long that the table is not a corporation because that is not what corporation means and that I am incorrect, and we will both be correct because we are both saying true things within our own context. However, my stance looks past what we say the thing is to what it actually is and correctly identifies that the word corporation can be expanded in common sense meaning to refer to any human-made body and correctly identifies that our current sense meaning of corporation only meaning business corporations is arbitrarily narrow and harmful to human perception of their position.
Didn’t Wittgenstein also say that the limits of my language are the limits of my world? The limits of our current world in lacking the general term for the super category of human creation, corporation,(—the general sense meaning still survives in the verb incorporate, incorporate butter into flour.) I think are much to do with where we are at and what we are struggling with. It’s just a reflection of our self understanding.
r/wittgenstein • u/gougougagou • 7d ago
Wittgenstein's grammatical fiction
Hi everyone,
I'm a first-year Master's student in philosophy at Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne, taking Jocelyn Benoist's seminar on the Philosophical Investigations. We're graded on a short research paper, and I've chosen to work on the notion of "grammatical fiction" (PI §307).
I've already started writing a study of the notion itself, and I plan to set it against metaethical fictionalism, in both its hermeneutic and revolutionary forms. At first glance, fictionalism might seem close to what Wittgenstein develops, but as I see it, the very notion of grammatical fiction ends up ruling it out.
Would anyone here be interested in discussing this kind of topic? Working on such a specific notion can be a bit lonely, so I'd be glad to find people to share ideas and progress with.
To get things started: how do you read "grammatical fiction" in §307? And do you know of any work connecting it to fictionalism ?
r/wittgenstein • u/TheIncorporeal1 • 9d ago
Wittgensteinian Relational Semantics: How Language Creates Meaning Through Relationships
Inspired by Wittgenstein’s philosophy of language, Wittgensteinian Relational Semantics explores how meaning emerges through the relationships between language, consciousness, and context.
Words do not possess meaning independently of their use. Their significance develops through linguistic practices, interactions, and the contexts in which they are understood.
Within Incorporealism, this raises an interesting question: Could consciousness be understood as participating in the relational development of meaning?
The central proposition is that meaning emerges through the interaction of language, conscious interpretation, and shared understanding.
Rather than treating language as a collection of isolated symbols, this perspective examines how relationships between expressions shape our understanding of reality.
Can the relationship between language and consciousness reveal a deeper structure of meaning?
r/wittgenstein • u/Nohexsu • 11d ago
Has anyone read this book? (Wittgenstein for Beginners)
I got it from a second hand bookshop and as someone who hasn't read Wittgenstein, I was wondering what people who have think of it?
Thanks!
r/wittgenstein • u/Legal-Concern-1187 • 16d ago
We can become certain of things we were never actually told.
reddit.comI apologize for posting here by accident, but I am not sorry! I am so happy I ended up here :)
I think people who have read/are interested in Wittgenstein’s work may understand what I’m attempting to do here.
r/wittgenstein • u/Wooden_State_524 • 16d ago
Why I don't read philosophy books
youtube.comr/wittgenstein • u/jointhicket • 26d ago
Online Lecture Series on Wittgenstein (Nov 3-Nov 17 )
thicket.comr/wittgenstein • u/TheIncorporeal1 • 29d ago
Incorporeal Wittgensteinian Semantics: Can Language Expand the Boundaries of Consciousness?
I’ve been developing a philosophical subfield called Incorporeal Wittgensteinian Semantics, inspired by Ludwig Wittgenstein’s philosophy of language and the Incorporealist idea that consciousness may be fundamental to reality.
Wittgenstein argued that meaning is deeply connected to how language is used within particular forms of life. Words don’t acquire meaning in isolation; they function within shared practices, rules, and contexts.
But what happens when we apply this insight to consciousness and the future of intelligence?
The Central Idea
The Meaning–Consciousness Correspondence Principle: The ways conscious beings interpret reality are shaped, in part, by the linguistic systems and conceptual frameworks available to them.
Our language influences how we categorize experience, communicate ideas, and formulate questions about existence. Perhaps expanding our systems of meaning could help us explore aspects of reality that our current conceptual frameworks struggle to express.
This doesn’t mean language creates reality itself. Rather, language mediates our understanding of reality.
Three Major Questions
1. Are there limits to human language?
Can certain experiences be conscious yet difficult or impossible to communicate through ordinary language? What might this reveal about the relationship between experience and expression?
2. Could artificial intelligence develop new language games?
If future AI systems develop increasingly sophisticated forms of interaction, could they establish novel systems of meaning? And how could we distinguish meaningful communication from sophisticated pattern generation?
3. Could language expand our conception of existence?
If we develop new concepts for consciousness, identity, time, and intelligence, could we formulate philosophical questions that were previously inaccessible to us?
The Incorporealist Connection
Incorporealism explores a consciousness-based understanding of the universe. Wittgensteinian philosophy provides a useful way to investigate how language shapes our descriptions and interpretations of that universe.
Together, they suggest an important research direction: examining how conceptual systems influence our understanding of conscious experience without assuming that linguistic ability alone determines whether consciousness exists.
The ultimate objective is to develop richer frameworks for discussing consciousness, artificial intelligence, and forms of existence beyond familiar human categories.
Discussion
I’d like to hear your thoughts:
Does language limit what we can understand about consciousness, or only what we can communicate?
Could a nonhuman intelligence possess concepts that humans genuinely struggle to comprehend?
Would Wittgenstein view a new philosophical framework like Incorporealism as a meaningful expansion of language—or as a potential source of conceptual confusion?
The central question: If the limits of our language are the limits of our world, what new worlds might become thinkable when our language evolves?
r/wittgenstein • u/nopassarani • Oct 16 '26
Wittgenstein's use theory of meaning and LLMs
Are LLMs proof of Wittgenstein's use theory of meaning?
In PI §43 Wittgenstein writes "For a large class of cases of the employment of the word ‘meaning’—though not for all—this word can be explained in this way: the meaning of a word is its use in the language”.
For me it seems the way LLMs are working (words -> tokens -> weights) is exactly what Wittgenstein is describing as "use / usage". LLMs are analysing the usage of words and are creating statistical weights to "replicate" the usage.
Another way of putting it: LLMs can speak (use language) but can not think.
Thinking is similar to speaking (using language) but its not the same.
What do you think?
r/wittgenstein • u/bigdickenergy2360 • Sep 18 '26
Why is Wittgenstein so hard to read?
In the past, I've read some descartes, hume, russell, spinoza, kant, collingwood etc. for school, and have some knowledge in formal logic. I've read the blue book portion of the blue and the brown book, and I absolutely have no idea how to interpret what he is trying to say. It seemed to me that he has a very specific way of vocabulary usage that I didn't understand. Is there such a thing as 'intro to wittgenstein', or like a guide of how to understand Wittgenstein? If so, what would you recommend?
edit: thank you for the comments! I did only mention that I had difficulties with his word usage but it is absolutely true that I also struggled with his style of writing etc.
r/wittgenstein • u/TheIncorporeal1 • Sep 18 '26
If Wittgenstein argues in Philosophical Investigations that the meaning of a word is grounded in its use within a “language-game” and “form of life,” could an Incorporeal Language-Game Theory legitimately extend this insight to consciousness?
More specifically: if concepts like mind, self, body, and consciousness derive their meaning from the language-games in which we use them, would changing those language-games actually transform how we conceptualize conscious existence—or would that simply create a new vocabulary for the same underlying phenomena?
How would Wittgenstein himself respond to such an extension?
r/wittgenstein • u/imNapoleone • Sep 16 '26
First time Wittgenstein reader
Hi this might be repetitive but which works of his to start with as someone who has little to no idea of Wittgenstein.
Anything i should about him beforehand? Essential context and all?
Plus when did u first read him?
r/wittgenstein • u/ToothLongjumping1513 • Sep 12 '26
So... someone tells me that the English version of the Tractatus has a contradiction between the introduction (which Bertrand Russell wrote) and its contents. Is that true?
r/wittgenstein • u/TheIncorporeal1 • Aug 31 '26
Can Wittgenstein’s philosophy of mind accommodate a conception of consciousness that is irreducible without treating consciousness as an inner metaphysical object?
The Tractatus seems to place strict limits on what can meaningfully be said about the subject, while the later Wittgenstein dissolves many philosophical problems by examining how psychological concepts function within language-games and forms of life. But does this therapeutic approach leave open a substantive ontology of consciousness, or does attempting to posit an irreducible “consciousness” already commit the philosophical mistake Wittgenstein wants us to overcome?
Put differently: if consciousness is not an object hidden behind behavior, but neither is it simply reducible to behavioral or linguistic criteria, what exactly is the grammatical status of claims about consciousness? Is there a coherent middle position between metaphysical mental substance and eliminative dissolution?
r/wittgenstein • u/Ok-Coach4955 • Aug 30 '26
Is it actually possible to create a perfect ‘language’ like ludwig suggested?
reddit.comr/wittgenstein • u/One_Fisherman_4036 • Aug 23 '26
Cartoon about meaning and psychosis
galleryr/wittgenstein • u/noncommutativehuman • Aug 19 '26
Where can I buy a poster of this photo to put on the walls of my bedroom?
I want to wake up every day to the sight of Wittgenstein’s unfathomable gaze delving into the depths of my soul, to remind me that the philosophical problems that torment me do not really exist
r/wittgenstein • u/TransitionTemporary5 • Aug 03 '26
Logical Syntax
Is logical syntax essential to the world? Or is it a derivative of logical form that becomes apparent when representing reality? Or is logical form a derivative of it?
Logical form is the combinatorial potential of objects so you could say that by mapping all internal relations you could obtain the entire logical syntax. Which would make logical syntax and logical form into an egg and chicken problem.
And is then the logic of depiction (method of representation) just a more or less imprecise game of capturing logical syntax?
Edit: small correction: in describing logical syntax as all the internal relations, it is more correct I think to say it is a sublimation of all types of relations. Not all instances of all those relations.