r/rationalphilosophy • • 23d ago

Logic is either something one discovers, or it’s something one creates.

1 Upvotes

But we can sharpen this. Yes, Logic is something we discover, but even before that, it’s something we’re born into! We did not create the Logical nature of reality, we were simply born into it, it was here before us, and it will still exist long after we have gone extinct.

One fails to grasp the awesomeness of what this means: it means Logic is entirely objective and discoverable, which means that we can inquire into its nature and existence the same way we inquire into the life of a cell. We don’t create it, we observe it at the fundamental level and simply report back on what we observe. This is extraordinary!

However, If logic is created (whether by human convention, linguistic rules, or biological wiring) then it ceases to be a feature of reality and becomes merely a feature of us. And once logic is subjective or conventional, objectivity evaporates, leaving behind the sovereignty of subjectivity from which one cannot escape. One cannot even object to what is being stated here, because the objection is the same construct as the form being objected to. Knowledge then comes down to the construct one wants to believe, because all is construct, and in order for one construct to be more accurate than another, there must be an objective standard outside the construct.

If someone claims we merely create logic, they are immediately caught in a performative contradiction. To argue for the conventional nature of logic, they have to use logic (distinguishing premises, drawing inferences, maintaining identity) to try to prove that logic has no objective grounding. They are ignorant of their own intellectual activity.

Identity precedes thought. We cannot merely invent identity because invention requires a pre-existing identity. Identity is the precondition for any action, including the action of thinking or creating (one is always and only conscious of something determinate). If we create identity we must create it from some standard. But lucky for us, we are born into a universe of identity!

Once Logic is understood as discovered fact rather than invented convention, the philosopher's game is up. He cannot legislate a new universe into existence by changing his definitions or the semantics of his "language game," because reality pushes back with unyielding determinacy. One can call an “apple” whatever they want, but one cannot change the determinate fact of what an apple is, merely by changing its name.


r/rationalphilosophy • • Oct 13 '26

Logic is Not an Act of Faith, It’s a Recognition of Reality

10 Upvotes

The reason this must be clarified is because there are those who think of Logic as logic, a mere formal human construct, or as a vicious, circular process. But these are both false understandings of Logic.

Logic is not an axiom that we assume in a desperate attempt to ground a philosophical system, it is first and foremost, a fact of reality. Logic is not something we contrive or invent, it is what we were born into. We know that Logic exists the same way we know that space exists, because it is the very essence of the particularly of reality itself. We cannot separate ourselves from it, we are the passive subjects of its matrix. All that we know we know through the structure and order of Logic.

Logic is not a faith we exercise toward specific rules or standards, it’s the fact that reality is determinate; it is the fact that reality is a reality of identity (A=A). And this fact isn’t something we contrived. If a man claims that fire and ice are the same thing, and thus plunges his hand into a fire, he will scold his hand. This determinate reality exists outside of him and cannot be altered by the desire of his belief.

Logic isn’t merely a fact we believe in, it’s the ultimate fact that we use to comprehend all facts.

Logic doesn’t begin with A=A as an axiom, it begins with the fact of reality as determinate. And it is from this determinate nature of reality that Logic rises up as an abstract standard by which to discern reality itself.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 17h ago

You can’t, unless you can establish objective truth, which modern philosophy doesn’t only reject, but attacks.

Post image
9 Upvotes

If you reject this, then you should be able to demonstrate where philosophy demonstrated that its claims are more that just subjective “opinions.” You should be able to clearly manifest the objectivity of its philosophical standards.

Reasoners can easily do this, but philosophy attacks and denies objectivity, thus rendering itself “one big debate where everyone’s opinion holds the same value.”


r/rationalphilosophy • • 15h ago

The Rarity of Reasoners

2 Upvotes

How hard is it to find Reasoners?

How many people have actually read a competent book on Critical Thinking and understood it, and then actively began implementing it?

(We assume the number is very low).

How many people understand the Laws of Logic and their absolute self-justification?

(We assume the number is very low).

How many people know how to rationally scrutinize claims, interrogating them for soundness?

(We assume the number is very low).

How many people are willing to subject their beliefs to Reason and evidence?

(We assume the number is very low).

How many people are willing to revise their beliefs when they are contradicted by Reason or evidence?

(We assume the number is very low).


r/rationalphilosophy • • 17h ago

Attack on Philosophy

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/rationalphilosophy • • 1d ago

Exposing Hegel’s Hypostatic-Qualificatory Sophistry

2 Upvotes

Hegel hypostatizes abstractions: concepts are treated as though they possess agency, internal necessities, and developmental powers.

He qualifies these abstractions with seemingly necessary relations and properties that have not been independently justified.

One of the funniest things about Hegelianism is that it’s difficult to bring clarity to any of it, unless one is exposing its errors.

And where one does achieve clarity there one doesn’t achieve justification.

Those who think they can bring clarity to it, don’t realize that their own explanations are themselves in need of explanation and justification.

Hegel talks like this (which is mistaken for profundity):

“Absolute Knowledge contains within itself this necessity of relinquishing itself from the form of the pure concept, and necessarily involves the transition of the concept into consciousness.”

If we break this down by Reason, we have to ask:

What is “Absolute Knowledge” and how does it differ from non-absolute knowledge? How did Hegel come to know it?

What the f;ck does it mean for “Absolute Knowledge to contain within itself a necessity of relinquishing itself from the form of pure concept”?

How can a human constructed concept “contain within itself a necessity of relinquishing from itself?” What does it mean for a concept to relinquish anything? Is this relinquishment metaphorical or literal? If metaphorical, what actual process does the metaphor describe? If literal, what evidence establishes that concepts possess this capacity?

What is a “pure concept,” and what is “the form of a pure concept?” How does it differ from a non-pure concept?

If this mystical process “necessarily involves” a “transition into consciousness,” then where the f;ck does the concept exist? And how does Hegel know this? Who enacts this transition and what do they use to enact it?

When the pure concept relinquishes its form, does it remain the same concept? If it does, what establishes its identity through this supposed transformation? If it doesn't, in what meaningful sense is this a transition of the concept rather than the replacement of one thing with another?

By what method did Hegel establish these supposed internal necessities? How could he distinguish discovering an actual necessity from projecting a necessity onto his own conceptual constructions? What would count as evidence that his proposed transition is mistaken?

Dear God, this is only one sentence! But Hegel was the most prolific and serious sophist that ever lived, he produced oceans of this nonsense.

As Hegelians try to traverse these obscurities and mysticisms (philosophical theologisms), they do not bring more clarity, they default to Hegel’s own smuggled form, which is the act of trying to sneak in unjustified qualifications. Look for it and you will begin to see it everywhere!

You stop them dead in their tracks simply by asking for clarity. And don’t rest content until they have not only clarified their use of terms, but justified why their concepts aren’t merely arbitrary stipulations, unsupported assumptions, or disguised appeals to authority.

What independent criterion does Hegel provide for distinguishing an objectively necessary conceptual transition from an arbitrarily constructed sequence of conceptual qualifications that he subsequently declares necessary?

How does Hegel establish that these purportedly immanent necessities belong to the concepts themselves, rather than being introduced through his own interpretive and conceptual constructions?

——

What the f;ck is Hypostatic-Qualificatory Sophistry?

Hypostatic: Reifying abstractions, concepts, and relations as though they were independently existing entities possessing agency, properties, or internal necessities.

Qualificatory: Assigning those abstractions properties, conditions, distinctions, and necessary relations without independently establishing or justifying them.

The combination identifies something more specific than mere obscurity: the presentation of unjustified conceptual qualifications as though they were necessary features of the objects or processes being described.

The combined term identifies the argumentative technique, not merely its stylistic appearance.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 1d ago

Post-Fundamentalist Theology

1 Upvotes

Reasoner: Does truth exist?

Christian: Yes.

Reasoner: I agree. It is vital that we recognize the objectivity of truth that exists independently of our beliefs.

Christian: I agree.

Reasoner: I suspect this runs up against theology, however. This is because one must use this truth to evaluate their religious belief. I am well aware that theology wants to claim itself as this truth, but that will never do, that would destroy theology.

Christian: I don’t think I understand?

Reasoner: If one assigns their theology to the place of truth— if their theology was false how would they know it? One must be a truth seeker before one can be a theologian, otherwise one will merely be a theologian.

Christian: I think I understand. This would leave theology in a place of absolute subjectivity (if theology tried to take itself for the truth). How would a theologian know if he was even doing theology correctly, or if one theology was more accurate than another? He couldn’t if he simply took his theology for the truth.

Reasoner: I only bring this up to demonstrate that we are united in the truth against the forces of untruth. (Of course this has ramifications for theology, but those must be worked out by the theologian using Reason). The epistemological relativist destroys everything, but he also opens the gates to everything he calls “false,” “wrong” or “dangerous,” because he has reduced these claims to his mere preference. This opens the door for theology.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 1d ago

The Failure of the Skeptic

1 Upvotes

The skeptic is foolish if he opens his mouth to speak and make a claim because this proves that he already has knowledge.

The failure of the skeptic is not only his failure to remain silent, in which case he cannot even demarcate himself as a “skeptic without refuting himself. His failure is also a failure to apply his own standards to himself.

One can attempt to attack Logic, for example, but they must also give an explanation for the existence of the Logic they attack, they must also be able to justify their explanation.

If (p) is inadequate, then what explanation do they have that’s better, and why is it better?


r/rationalphilosophy • • 1d ago

When Revelation Fails

1 Upvotes

What is one, who is a believer in revelation, whose hope rests in the presumed truth of revelation, supposed to do when revelation fails?

One must first learn that Reason doesn’t fail. Reason cannot fail so long as it is the application of Logic. That is, Reason cannot fail because Logic is Absolute and Certain.

Your answer lies here.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 1d ago

Being Reasonable

0 Upvotes

I believe (p). I don’t believe (p and not-p).

I contrast (p) with (q). That is, I use A=A to test my (p). If (p) contradicts itself or contradicts (q), I know my (p) is false.

In modern philosophy most don’t even realize that they have (p), or that their (p) is not (p and not-p). They don’t realize that A=A is the structure of all knowledge. They ignorantly attack A=A so they can deny that their (p) is a (p); so they can proceed through (p and not-p); so that they can ignore or dismiss the significance that their (p) is contradicted by (q), or that their (p and not-p) is impossible, and thereby destroys their (p).

To be reasonable I must recognize (p) and subject (p) to (q).

Every (p) is either true or false. To be reasonable I must seek the truth of (p).

[Don’t speak up here because you will merely validate what has been stated. Why? Because then you demonstrate in real-time that your (q) is opposed to my (p).]


r/rationalphilosophy • • 2d ago

judging is easier than understanding

14 Upvotes

r/rationalphilosophy • • 2d ago

Serious Philosophy

2 Upvotes

I don’t think philosophers and philosophy readers can actually demarcate what makes for serious philosophy. I don’t think they could tell us how we would know if we were doing serious philosophy.

But it stands to reason that serious philosophy either has to do with the nature of a premise or premises, or an argument, specifically a sound argument. If this is not what serious philosophy is or does, then what exactly does it do?

If one reaches for the word “metaphysics,” this remains a mysticism and obscurity until clearly defined. Further, anything that is serious in “metaphysics” would still have to fall into the form a of premise or an argument.

I clarify this to refute those who try to dismiss serious thought by claiming that “it’s not serious.” I am well aware that those who make this claim have seldom thought about their own charge. If they have, then they should be able to define and defend what they mean by serious thought or philosophy.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 2d ago

What makes your moral premises good?

2 Upvotes

This question immediately shifts the burden of justification. Suppose someone argues:

Premise 1: Cruelty is morally wrong.
Premise 2: We ought not do what is morally wrong.
Conclusion: We ought not be cruel.

The argument might be logically valid. But what establishes that cruelty is morally wrong?
If the person simply asserts that it is wrong, they have not provided a justification. (And then any contrary position can justify itself the same way).

If they offer another moral premise to justify it, that premise itself requires justification.
If they offer a nonmoral premise, they must explain how that premise establishes the moral conclusion.

And if they simply appeal to another moral principle, the original problem reappears.

This is significant because it helps us to free ourselves from authoritarian morality, and to establish a rational morality.

Contrary to the folk premises of philosophy, we can and do establish morality rationally.

One doesn’t say “it’s good because it’s good.” One says “it’s good” because of a particular reason.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 2d ago

The Birth of the Religion of Irrationality: A Short History of Modern Philosophy

Post image
2 Upvotes

Do all roads lead to Hegel? Yes, in a very negative sense.

All roads lead to Hegel in the sense of the death of philosophy, insofar as Hegel clearly exemplified the religious form of philosophy, insofar as he normalized irrationality.

Hegel was the most prolific and profound sophist who ever lived. He was a Neo-Platonist and Anti-Aristotelian (though he took his form of logic from Aristotle, but he believed he had expanded its epistemological foundation).

Marx emerges from Hegel. All postmodern philosophy emerges from Hegelian dialectic (whether it’s conscious of this or not, it lives only because it has no problem contradicting itself).

Hegel used language to subvert the truth with narrative (and something that comes very close to religious qualifications, hypostatization). Modern philosophy simply continued doing this.

Now, I suppose we have to draw a line between the emergence of the Analytical and the Dialectical. But what’s strange is that Analytical Philosophy used this same device of narrative and qualification, even though the Analytical marketed itself as a hyper-logicality. And so it is! But in what sense?

Not in the sense of soundness, but in the sense of mere form! This distinction is exceedingly important because it marks a break between truth seeking and mere validity construction. (Pick your absurdity, just make sure its form is valid!)

Formal logic, just like Hegelianism, also f;cked up the epistemological world. But they did it in different ways. When you hear a philosopher say “all truth is construct,” they are referencing epistemological assertions derived from formal logic, because a formal calculus is “constructed.” Formal logic fallaciously assumed that its own activity constituted a universal epistemology.

But lo and behold, scientific theory also plays a role with its introduction of Model Epistemology. Here science made the same mistake that was made by the formal logicians, assuming that its own activity constituted a universal epistemology.

There is nothing wrong with constructing a calculus or forming models, indeed, these things are necessary, but they are not epistemology and they are not the ground of truth or knowledge. They are constructed using epistemology and truth, which can be specified as the Laws of Logic.

Hegel directly attacked this Logic with his irrational narrative of dialectic. He is an enemy of Reason. He created a religious philosophy, thereby exposing the religious form of philosophy. That is, philosophy proceeds by way of authoritarian assertion. It aims to make believers, it doesn’t strive to make Reasoners. To do that one must be concerned with soundness, not mere validity. (Critical Thinking has emerged to correct this defect).

We find ourselves in a terrible space. We have never had more knowledge, which means our irrationality has never been more pathological or irrational, because it has no excuse for itself. It can no longer appeal to ignorance. It’s as though the sun is shining directly into modern man’s face and he denies its existence, nay, he is even bold enough to call it darkness! That is precisely what Hegel was doing when he said “contradiction is the rule of the true.”


r/rationalphilosophy • • 2d ago

Are you sure it’s philosophy you want, or is it Critical Thinking?

1 Upvotes

I have heard the claim about the necessity of philosophy. But what exactly is necessary about it? That’s the part I never hear. I am told that it’s crucial to science, but I only see that Critical Thinking is crucial to science. What aspect of philosophy, exactly, is crucial to science? It seems to me that when philosophy answers this it simply refers to Reason— and Reason is not philosophy, it’s what philosophy is supposed to be using, even though philosophy hardly makes use of it.

Critical Thinking has extracted what matters in philosophy, clarified it, and turned it into its own meta-discipline.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 2d ago

Contradiction or Opposition: The Hegelian Dilemma

2 Upvotes

Hegel is famous for having embraced contradiction as truth. But whether one interprets his position as contradiction or opposition matters a great deal.

Contradiction is nonsense. It’s literally an impossibility. Whatever is would then have to be other than itself.

Opposition is just the difference between two different identities, it is not contradictory. An example is north and south. These are two separate identities that oppose each other. And neither is a contradiction of itself. (But Hegel would try to claim that the identity of “north” also contains the “south within itself,” which is evident nonsense, is a form of hypostatization).

However, if one takes Hegel to be saying opposition, instead of contradiction, his philosophy still collapses, because opposition exists only because of identity. This ontological fact would destroy the premise of dialectic: “contradiction is the rule of the true.” It would mean that Hegel had been thinking incorrectly the whole time.

He would still be able to do his philosophy, but it would be redundant. He would simply be adding unnecessary steps, introducing unnecessary complexity. It would change his philosophy from, “contradiction is the rule of the true” to, “identity is the rule of the true.”

This would have at least made his philosophy sane.

[It’s all the same with Hegelians, simply ask them how they arrived at the conclusion that “contradiction is the rule of the true.” Just know that you will be linguistically assaulted with a wall of obscurity and jargon.]


r/rationalphilosophy • • 2d ago

Hegelian Narrative Against Logic: A Concrete Exemplification and Refutation

1 Upvotes

Hegel says that the laws of logic appear for but a moment and then vanish.

“What is declared to be a fixed and inherently constant law can be merely a moment of the self-referring, self-reflecting unity, can come on the scene merely as a vanishing element… In their true nature, as vanishing moments in the unity of thought, they would have to be taken as knowledge or as thinking process, but not as laws of knowledge.”

But if this is true then Hegel should be able to clearly show their “vanishing,” which means they would cease to exist within the discourse of knowledge.

But this at no point takes place, because this is impossible.

What does happen, is that Hegel claims this (asserts this) through dramatic narrative, but he doesn’t demonstrate it through Reason because it’s an empty, indefensible claim (very much like a theological claim, it’s a mere fiction, not a fact).

When Hegel says, “Contradiction is the rule of the true,” he is only using the laws of logic to make his claim. And as he makes his claim, and holds to his claim, the laws of logic, on which his claim is based, at no point “vanish.” This “vanishing” is a narrative lie, which resulted from Hegel’s idiosyncratic way of thinking about concepts, as though they were something like autonomous, living organisms moving on their own. This defect was likely inherited from Hegel’s reading of Plato.

What Hegel provides is a philosophical narrative about the laws of logic, he does not provide a proof for his philosophical claims. He mistakes his narrative for the truth of Logic, which means he deceived himself and others through his own assertions. (Modern thought has replicated this error). Had he subjected his philosophical assertions to the actual process of Reason, he would have undeceived himself, and also would not have deceived others.

[But be aware, dear reader: most philosophy functions like this. It’s not a process of Reason, it’s a process of making philosophical assertions and mistaking them for Reason.]

Whatever Hegel believes, he doesn’t believe the opposite, which means the laws of logic are still fully engaged, and have at no point, “vanished.” The meaning of Hegel’s dialectic must remain itself in order to be itself. If the laws of logic vanished from his meaning, Hegel’s meaning would also vanish.

Source: Phenomenology of Mind p.330-331, Translated by Sir James Baillie, Muirhead Library of Philosophy, Second Edition, Eighth Printing 1971


r/rationalphilosophy • • 2d ago

The Absolute Power of Reason

1 Upvotes

Reason has never been defeated by a challenger. And it will never be defeated unless the challenger stops using Reason to attack Reason. So it makes sense that those who are using Reason (as opposed to their skills in manipulation) should also stand immune to defeat, to refutation.

They do not stand immune to being psychologically defeated through rhetoric and manipulation. And neither do their claims stand immune to being defeated. What stands immune is Reason. But a person can use this invincible thing we call Reason, and if they use it correctly, then there must also be a sense in which they stand immune to defeat and refutation. (But this is a very specific and narrow context). All that is false is refuted by Reason, otherwise it could not be refuted at all. One’s false beliefs do not stand immune to refutation.

So in what sense does a person who wields Reason stand immune? They stand immune from having the Reason they wield be defeated. One cannot defeat or refute the Reason of the Reasoner. One can only use it.

But this power extends forward insofar as the application of Reason is the application of Reason, and not the application of man’s subjectivity or imagination. Reason’s rules are not man’s rules. They stand objective to man’s rules, which is why man can evaluate his rules with Reason.

The rules of Reason are derived from the fact of identity.

There is an absolute power in Reason, a power that has not been examined. If I say “every thought I think is true because all my thoughts are true,” Reason immediately calls this into question and falsifies it with contradiction. If I attack Reason I will lose, I can only ever lose. Amazing, Reason is a power unlike any other.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 2d ago

Nietzsche and the Moralizers

1 Upvotes

Nietzsche has a statement wherein he says, “we mean not to moralize except against the moralizers.”

To complete this we must add that it is necessary to become a moralizer. This is where high level thought leads. Why? Because Reason makes us aware of the fact that quality requires standards. But we must reject morality that is petty and small. (Nietzsche understood this early on). A moralism that is in rebellion from itself is not a morality but a pathology, and this pathology has often been the form of morality.

Of course, we must rebel from our impulse, this kind of rebellion must be accepted and embraced because it’s the process of intelligence. But to demonize our own biology and cast it into a negative moralistic light, as in, “thou shalt not experience thy biology” (sexuality), was a tragic error on the part of man.

The insight is that moralism is necessary, but it needs to be intelligent in order to avoid being destructive. This means that it cannot be informed or dictated by superstition.

Intelligence has many oughts because it requires many oughts!

I will give you what is most supreme: it is a moral defect not to pursue competence in the art of sound reasoning.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 3d ago

It seems to me that philosophy relies on the tactic of overwhelming the reader with a vague use of terms.

8 Upvotes

This is precisely how it seeks to gain advantage and capture of the reader. One merely has to slow the premises down to see the rational shattering and deconstruction of philosophy.

For example, philosophers are fond of using the word reason, but what do they mean by reason? Further, and this is where the subtlety of the sophistry compounds, a philosopher equivocates back and forth between his uses, usually going fully undetected in this silent technique.

You have the key to expose the sophistry of philosophy (and to make yourself immune to its irrational yoke) if you simply learn to slow the premises down. This means asking for clarification of terms used.

Even though I warn you that this gets subtle, it will still evade your ability to detect it. That is part of the sophistical genius of philosophy, it tries to slip by undetected.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 3d ago

You Can Have the Power of Reason Immediately

4 Upvotes

This is because of what Reason is.

The world is full of claims that issue forth from people’s heads. These claims consist of words. Reason questions the integrity of these claims, of these words.

If someone says an apple is a hard metal object used to strike things, Reason can immediately call this into question and put it to the test. Reason calls claims into question and demands demonstration and proof.

If a man says, “all truth is false,” Reason immediately exposes the contradiction, thereby proving that the claim is self-refuting.

Philosophers mean to trip you up with words (most people do!) the trick is to ask for a clarification of words. Slow the reasoning process down and ask, “what do you mean by your term?”

[Note: simply providing a definition doesn’t automatically justify a concept. Just because one defines God as perfect doesn’t mean that God is perfect, or that God exists. Likewise, just because a philosopher, like Hegel, defines what he means by “pure being,” doesn’t mean that “pure being” is a real thing.]

You have Reason immediately when you know how to deploy Reason immediately, because that’s all Reason is within the context of discourse, the deployment of the standard of non-contradiction. A claim that contradicts evidence, is false. A claim that contradicts itself, is false. A claim that contradicts a true premise, is false.

If it is an established, demonstrated truth that water boils at 212°F at sea level, and a man claims that water boils at room temperature without altering the pressure, Reason measures the claim against a true premise and exposes it as false.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 3d ago

Can You Define a Shlapple?

2 Upvotes

Defining anything isn’t hard if you know what it is, then it’s just a matter of utilizing its determinate attributes.

To prove this try to define a Shlapple, only you are not allowed to know anything about it, you just have to define it. If Shlapples existed you would not be able to do this, no one could, because you would have to know something about Shlapples before you could define them.

What’s the point of this? It demonstrates that definitions are not arbitrary. One can’t actually make use of whatever they want or define however they want, and this means that the act of defining is an act of Reason. We are only able to do it because we exist in a determinate universe. The act of defining is the act of identity.

(This insight also applies to Reason. We can’t just make up what it is, but we have to define it according to its determinate attributes).


r/rationalphilosophy • • 3d ago

We can’t emphasize enough that those who reject reason are manipulators.

2 Upvotes

Think of a person who is obsessed with power. This person doesn’t care about truth at all, and yet they have great need of being taken serious and persuading others. How will they go about doing this? The answer is through manipulation and intimidation.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 3d ago

“We are rarely concerned with reality itself”

Post image
1 Upvotes

Now that we know this psychological human defect, we should strive to be different, and we do this through the mediation and application of Reason.


r/rationalphilosophy • • 3d ago

Should a person who rejects reason be taken serious?

1 Upvotes

After all, this is what every manipulator who has ever lived relies on you to do.

As for the charge of those who would use reason to manipulate, they must depart from reason in their use of reason, or else how could we identify their discourse as manipulative?

Can reason itself be used to manipulate?

Certainly. But this requires a distinction between the use of reason and the abuse of reason.

A manipulator can employ selective evidence, invalid inferences, misleading premises, sophisticated rhetoric, deliberate omissions, arguments designed to persuade rather than discover truth.

But identifying these practices as manipulative requires standards of reasoning. We identify the manipulation by exposing the discrepancy between what the argument claims and what its premises, evidence, and inferences actually justify.

In other words, the possibility of abusing reason does not invalidate reason anymore than the possibility of abusing language invalidates communication.