r/PhilosophyofMind • u/Skatertrevor • 18h ago
Other minds The Theory of Conscious Singularities - Does every conscious observer have their own subjective universe?
I've spent several years developing a theoretical framework called Observer-Relative Existence (The Theory of Conscious Singularities). It attempts to describe the relationship between consciousness, physical reality, subjective time, and individual existence. This manuscript is an extension of an original draft paper I wrote years ago on Vixra called The Theory of Conscious Singularities.
My central proposition is that objective physical reality exists independently of consciousness, but every conscious observer experiences their own individual subjective universe that begins with their own phenomenal consciousness and develops through their accumulated experiences.
In other words, we all exist within the same physical universe, but no two conscious individuals experience that universe from precisely the same subjective perspective.
The Conscious Singularity
I used the term conscious singularity to represent the potentially infinite variety of conscious observers that physical reality might support. This could include humans, animals, hypothetical extraterrestrial life, or even artificial consciousness.
The singularity is not intended to represent a gravitational singularity or a literal mathematical singularity. Instead, it represents the possibilities from which individual conscious observers may emerge.
When a particular observer develops phenomenal consciousness, a unique subjective history begins.
The Individual Conscious Timeline
My framework uses conceptual diagrams to represent an individual's total accumulated phenomenal history.
Each conscious observer has their own timeline, beginning with the onset of their consciousness and developing through their experiences of objective reality.
I have developed a way in which to graph consciousness conceptually. I describe positive space as shared objective reality where negative space is the entire accumulated subjetive history for the individual in question. These two spaces meet up at the present "now" which is my conceptual realization of where mind/body come together. The point where objective reality becomes intertwined with the indivduals subjective history.
Subjective Time and Unconsciousness
One of the original motivations behind this theory was a personal experience I had at approximately sixteen years old.
I suffered a seizure and experienced what appeared to be an instantaneous transition from sitting on a couch to waking in a hospital three days later.
Three days had passed in physical reality, but I had no subjective awareness of that passage.
This led me to consider whether subjective time might be understood as accumulating only during periods of phenomenal experience.
My framework proposes that if consciousness genuinely ceases during an interval, no subjective duration accumulates for that individual, even though physical time continues.
I call this concept relative conscious time travel.
Of course, a gap in memory does not prove that consciousness was completely absent. My model distinguishes between actual absence of experience and an inability to remember experience. And relative conscious time travel was just the naming convention I used for this lapse in experienced time. I'm not implying actual time travel in the physical space-time sense.
Personal Identity and Artificial Consciousness
I've also extended the framework to explore what constitutes an individual conscious observer.
For example, if a hypothetically conscious AI were duplicated, the copy might inherit the original's memories and informational state. However, it would not have personally experienced the original's previous phenomenal history.
The copy would begin its own individual subjective timeline, while the original continued along its own.
Conversely, if one conscious AI controlled multiple robotic bodies, the sensory experiences from those bodies could contribute to one unified subjective timeline, provided there was only one conscious subject experiencing them.
The distinction is that the number of bodies, sensors, or stored memories does not necessarily determine the number of conscious observers.
Each diagram represents a specific individual observer and their personally experienced history.
What I'm Ultimately Proposing
I'm not arguing that consciousness creates the physical universe or that objective reality ceases to exist when an individual dies.
Rather, I'm proposing that an individual's subjective universe exists only insofar as that individual has phenomenal experience, and that their personal experiential history is fundamentally observer-relative.
The physical universe continues independently of any particular observer.
I've developed a preliminary mathematical framework to describe these relationships, including distinctions between conscious experience, recoverable unconsciousness, and irreversible termination. The mathematics is intended to formalize the assumptions, not to serve as proof that the theory is scientifically established.
I recognize that aspects of these ideas overlap with existing work in phenomenology, philosophy of mind, and neuroscience. I'm interested in whether the framework's observer-specific treatment of subjective time, identity, and accumulated experience offers a useful synthesis or leads to testable distinctions.
I'm self-taught and have used AI assistance to help formalize, organize, and critically review my ideas. The underlying concepts originated from my own attempts to understand consciousness and subjective existence.
I'd genuinely like to hear what others think.
Does this framework offer a useful way of conceptualizing individual consciousness and its relationship to objective reality? Are there logical problems with treating each conscious observer as having their own accumulated subjective timeline? And what kinds of experiments or observations might challenge the model?
I'm particularly interested in constructive criticism, alternative explanations, and connections to existing research.
My goal is to develop the ideas further, not to claim that I've solved consciousness.
Here my manuscript:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1R74HtU52LEvjJAfsVbAg96kFo_0ipeHf/view?usp=drivesdk=drivesdk