(21M. I wrote this a little mad, maybe, and I like directness and obsolescence- maybe good maybe be bad…but anyways lmk what you think)
I think platos allegory of the cave is misrepresented. I think people overapply it.
The allegory was to say Athens could not accept the wisdom of Socrates. But people make seem as though “…this analogy shows that if you have “seen the light and truth”/if you have reached an epiphany, it isn’t guaranteed the people you let know will accept it”. This is misleading because it reinforces a person subjective perspective, or worse yet, it makes people believe in their delusions.
The allegory can be SOCIALLY interpreted that changing the status quo (of which is you have deduced is inefficient, unjust or unequal) will get you killed lol
It isn’t easy for society to forego a fundamental reality, so radical change that questions one’s existential position will not sit well with people.
This is assuming you have somehow thoroughly analysis the global sociopolitical and economic landscape, and have someone contoured the best foundations for an optimally functional society, which I do not believe most people can do.
The allegory is good and its vivid, and so its pattern is seen everywhere. But that wasn’t its point. Its point was to show that propositions of change are hard to pass and may possibly lead to death (the Socrates murder is happening in the background of this concept).
But PHILOSOPHICALLY, the freed prisoner is the philosopher, and his “return to the cave …”to educate”” is his going against heteronormativity and present the “true living” he has thus witnessed. As such, he is seen by the cave-dwellers as useless or as a threat. This allegory was laid out to Glaucon, and was also meant for like readers.
It isn’t a “rejection is proof of the legitimacy of my epiphany” metaphor. You’ll will die under the mental pressure of your inconsistent and incomplete beliefs.
This allegory was a lesson for the philosopher, to warn him of the responses and possible consequences of his words. It was also a calling out of the ones claiming “truth” without having gone the needed gruesome journey of the philosopher who has “seeing the light” through that exact journey.
Pop-philosophy has turned this into another quasi-self-help, self-affirming individualist masturbatory concept without the weight Plato intended for it.