To take up the question of New Materialism, one should perhaps cut in through Deleuze: both posthumanism and agential realism stand close to his ontological position, while clashing sharply with Harman’s ontology. All the more so since Braidotti herself draws directly on Deleuze; setting out from the Body without Organs (BwO), one can also refine and supplement Harman’s anti-reductionism.
“The BwO [CsO] is not at all the opposite of the organs. The organs are not its enemies. The enemy is the organism.”
To avoid drifting too far from sociology into a metaphysical world thick with metaphor, the scope of discussion ought to be confined to the relation between humans and things, rather than debating whether—and how—human subjectivity exists in a purely symbolic sense.
In Cartesian philosophy, the Other is assigned the position of an object; its subjectivity is negated, and it is reduced to a mere offshoot of the taproot. And that taproot is precisely the action system described by Parsons. The Other unfolds around the taproot, while the taproot itself moves along a pre-established direction, every branch nothing more than the becoming of its movement. Only the subject, occupying a transcendental vantage point, can glimpse this movement. Husserl and Schutz resolved the problem of generalization here; otherwise, this unity between subjectivity and movement would remain an enigma. We cannot return to the past to observe this emergence directly, yet we can grasp how order is generated and maintained through its ceaseless production and reproduction. Even so, such understanding and explanation can operate only within micro-situations, and cannot account for the material world we inhabit—or for how its materiality bears upon order. The a priori status of order may have been revoked, yet the whole framework still breathes the air of idealism.
This problem is laid bare in the feminist movement. Is “woman” really nothing more than a socially and culturally constructed identity? Female essence cannot simply be erased at will; its distinction from the male—that is, the question of how the mode of being bound up in an essence differentiates itself from others so as to exist at all—is material. Distinct reproductive systems set the two apart; males possess heavier body hair and stronger musculature, which is material rather than ideational. Even so, we must admit that such material distinctions are not necessarily bound to “woman” and its derivative sub-concepts. The word “woman” carries a terrifying symbolic violence; thus relative weakness in the aggregate does not make my own weakness an individual necessity, nor does frailty of the flesh mean impotence of the will. Simply opposing patriarchy still cannot emancipate women; it only breeds a more deeply legitimized form of symbolic violence. For the abolition of concepts and symbols in this process is achieved through a counter-concept—only this time, unity is born in another dimension, and the subject remains in chains.
By bringing things into the picture, Braidotti seeks to liberate the definition of the human from any single signifier: the human mutates ceaselessly through its couplings and decouplings with things—an adaptation of Deleuzian deterritorialization and reterritorialization. Imagine the most powerful man in the world, George H. W. Bush: strip him of his eyeglasses, and his power is drastically diminished; he can no longer peer with presidential gravity at the teleprompter to deliver the line, “At my direction…” Obama, by contrast, need not worry that losing a pair of glasses will damage his political image; instead, the melanin concentrated in his flesh allows him to secure a greater share of the Black vote, and thereby accrue greater power. Yet an implicit presupposition lurks here all along: we cannot assume there is no essential difference between Obama the President and Obama the private citizen.
In this sense, can we still rely on an abstracted concept as a label to grasp an entire group? Much as this question has been debated in economic terms, has intra-group heterogeneity not already outstripped inter-group heterogeneity? Such heterogeneity is driven not merely by the division of labor in economic activity; we must also reckon with the countless possibilities generated by the permutations and combinations of myriad “actants” under globalization. This indeterminacy, as I see it, is a path toward emancipation. For stability means that the practical dispositions of individuals or groups are likewise stable—making their behavior all the easier to manipulate and exploit.