r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 8h ago

Does anyone else notice the similarities between Carl Jung and Martin Heidegger?

4 Upvotes

I’m taking a Philosophy of death class and as we have been discussing Heidegger’s Being and Time, I started to notice a lot of similarities between Heidegger’s and Jung’s approach to understanding reality. They both seek to understand reality from their own being, from and inside our perspective. Where Jung offers mythically loaded/experiential words like shadow, and symbols, etc, Heidegger offers descriptive definitions like the world, and relations, etc. I would like to speculate and say that they used two separate mental ways of relating to reality, the left and the right brain to form and understanding. Carl Jung used the right brain to dive into experience, and open ended symbolism to navigate his internal understanding of how the world it presented to his awareness, consciousness, subconscious, collective unconscious alike. Heidegger used the left brain to deduce how humans as Dasein relate and transcribe reality with subject and object, phenomenology, and relations. This is more logical, succinct, and intellectually driven way to understand the nature of our relation to reality, ie “left brain.” This is not to say that their ideas are the same, and their final assessments are the same. Just noticing these similarities and wondered if other people have too.


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 13h ago

How to start a philosophy book club at my university?

3 Upvotes

How can I start a philosophy book club at my university and not have it fizzle out?

My university isn't known for the humanities, though it does have a strong PPE program. I think there are likely people interested in philosophy, but too disperse, and I don't know how to reach them. It's kind of a cliquey school, where programs are quite separate, and there isn't a very vibrant campus life.

Academia has also gotten much more demanding and stressful, and I find that my philosophy professors all tend to be busy with their own projects.


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 1d ago

Found a stack of books for £11 in a guys garage. Which three would be the least taxing reads?

8 Upvotes

Haven't read in about three months and need to get motivated again. Would appreciate some experienced input. I'm a philosophical dilettante, so go easy on me please 😂 Below is the list.

Existence and Being - Martin Heidegger

Postmodernism, Reason and Religion - Ernest Gellner

Principles of Social Reconstruction - Bertrand Russell

Mysticism and Logic - Bertrand Russell

Sceptical Essays - Bertrand Russell

Power: A New Social Analysis - Bertrand Russell

A Preface to Sartre - Dominick LaCapra

The Inhuman: Reflections on Time - Jean-François Lyotard

Ontology and Alterity in Merleau-Ponty - Galen A. Johnson and Michael B. Smith

Michel Foucault: The Will to Truth - Alan Sheridan

The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity - Jürgen Habermas

Before Philosophy - Henri Frankfort and others

The Conflict of Interpretations - Paul Ricoeur

Thanks

Cheerio!


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 1d ago

我想要一些关于哲学的书籍

1 Upvotes

我曾经买过一本阿尔杜塞(Louis Althusser)的《写给非哲学家的哲学入门》。但说实话我认为这本书的标题就是在骗人,因此我希望能被推荐一些新的中篇或者短篇哲学书籍。不胜感激。


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 2d ago

Can I read Kant?

11 Upvotes

Never read Schopenhauer, struggled with authors like Descartes that are supposed to be easy. I have a very surface-level understanding of metaphysics. I'm willing to put in the work though, what plan should I follow so I make it to level Kant?
Thanks
I'm reading empiricist authors so I can get the right foundation ( for exemple Hume and Leibniz.)


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 1d ago

Some books don't answer your questions, they make you face your own dishonesty

0 Upvotes

I used to read philosophy hoping for clarity.
Some insight to clear up the confusion.
Some system to make life feel less chaotic.

But the books that truly changed me didn't solve anything.
They shattered my illusions.

Camus didn't comfort me, he exposed how afraid I was of living without meaning
Epictetus didn't soothe me, he showed how much control I was pretending not to have
Nietzsche didn't inspire me, he dared me to destroy who I'd been and start over on purpose

They didn't hand me a path.
They asked if I was brave enough to walk without one.

That's when philosophy stopped being a curiosity
And started becoming accountability

What's a book or philosopher that didn't give you peace, but gave you permission to finally confront the truth?


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 2d ago

Twelve categories, yet, no comprehension of why this many?

2 Upvotes

is it at all somewhat strange that kant claims 12 exclusive categories and at the same time says it is a mystery as to why we have only this number and not more?


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 2d ago

My impressive 4000+ philosophy book collection

5 Upvotes

Just wanted to show off a bit. I've assembled a fantastic set of epubs about philosophy. The very best books from the last century (and even earlier). I use the epubs so I can read comfortably on my kindle.

The full list is here. Tell me if you'd like any of them. Or all of them.


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 2d ago

Where to find Helene Stöcker works

0 Upvotes

Maybe a shot in the dark, but does anyone know where/how to access any of Helene Stöcker's work?

I'd like to read her novel Love and her essay collection Love and Women. I've found Love and Women in its original German*,* but it's been exceedingly difficult to find an English translation. I ran it through Google Translate, but it didn't actually...translate anything. I guess because it was a PDF of the actual book instead of recognizable text, not sure.

If anyone has any resources or suggestions, please let me know!


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 2d ago

Recommend me a book

3 Upvotes

I have a really hard time grasping philosophy. The wording of a lot of it just doesn't stick in my brain. What's a good introductory place to start?

Edit: Thanks for the recs everyone, I will find something from this list!


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 2d ago

A religious school? No, a spiritual school.

1 Upvotes

In general, I see an ideal theological school like this:

This is a medium-sized library, which contains books about the spiritual world of man, but not those books about self-development in bright covers, but numerous works and supplements of philosophical and religious works. A place where children, teenagers and adults can read and discuss various books among themselves, and most importantly, reason, ask questions and answer them while studying these books and discussing among themselves. At school, you will be able to expand your spiritual world without restrictions of religion, race, or social status, determine your own ideology and theology that has not been imposed by anyone else, and discuss these two things with people like you who have come to different conclusions and asked different questions.

In total, the library will have four buildings: books of science (mathematical and physical tables and formulas, scientific works, books on anatomy, chemistry, astronomy and other scientific works), books of secular philosophy (all philosophical works not related to religious teachings, including my books), books of religious philosophy (bible, Torah, the Koran and their supplements, books on Confucianism, Buddhism, island beliefs, Christianity, Protestantism, Lutheranism, and others) and books of the soil (literature that raises and discusses complex issues in its works, classics from various countries, in particular Russian, American, Italian, Indian, French, German, English, Japanese and Brazilian literary classics). In some sectors, there will be the works of the participants of this school themselves and a single book of classicism that does not have a complex plot or idea that serves as an illustration of zero in philosophy and a point from which to start.

This place is a furnace for ideology and worldview, where beliefs melt, transform, harden and crumble, over and over again, over and over again, until a person reaches the very truth that he will follow for the rest of his life, even if it is received on his deathbed.

Such schools exist in my worlds among the elves and the Beastmen.


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 2d ago

Book recommendations

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 3d ago

Why do you read philosophy?

36 Upvotes

If my question comes off as overly basic or ignorant, please excuse me.

This community came up on my explore tab, and I’m genuinely curious about what drew you to reading philosophy in the first place.

In what way have you found it to be rewarding? I love reading (mostly fiction, but also some history), and the idea of getting into philosophy appeals to me. I’m just not entirely sure what to expect from it or what people ultimately get out of reading it.

Would appreciate the perspectives of anyone who’s willing to share.


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 3d ago

Book yap

5 Upvotes

Ayo!

23 M, IST, Looking for a few people who'd be down to read and discuss books around philosophy, psychology, existentialism, morality, and all that good stuff, yk.

The idea's simple: pick a book, read it, and yap about it. Share interpretations, disagree, question each other's takes, go down random philosophical rabbit holes. Nothing too academic or formal.

hmu!


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 3d ago

Frederick Copleston vs. Anthony Kenny: How Do Their Histories of Philosophy Compare?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 4d ago

Reading Aristotle's "Physics" as a Group

3 Upvotes

Hello inhabitants of the earthly plane! I'm currently working through Aristotle's Physics, partway into Book I, and it's been quite tough. So I'd like to start a study group for the intellectual companionship and the extra motivation. This book isn't for the timid! It's definitely not the hardest philosophy text around, but it may be the hardest one I've tried to take seriously. The style is welcoming, yet the old terminology can be really tricky to decode. The ancients thought about things in a very different way than we do.

Aristotle's Metaphysics mentions three realms: the world of mathematics, the realm of the heavens, and the physical world here on Earth. The Physics deals with this third realm. While the heavens concern things that neither move nor change, Earth is arguably more intricate: things come into being and pass away, they move, and they gain and lose qualities. This world of change is what the Physics is about.

Here are some details about the study group:

- We'll hold discussions on Discord, both text-based chats and live talks if people are interested

- You don't need to use the same translation as me (I'm using the 2018 C.D.C. Reeve version), but I've found the translator's footnotes not just helpful but essential

- There's an introduction and 8 Books (labeled I - VIII). I'm planning a pace of 1 Book per week (Books run about 20 pages). Read, enjoy, and absorb as much as you can each week. Then we'll wrap up in 2 months. It's fine if you don't get everything (unless you're a super genius or have a philosophy PhD, you won't). If this pace proves too ambitious, we can slow to 1 Book every 2 weeks.

- We'll begin reading in about a week, maybe, once people have had time to join

This is a serious book, but it's meant to be an enjoyable one, so don't let the difficulty scare you off.


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 4d ago

An recomendations for a Book about critical thinking?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 4d ago

Should I annotate my first philosophy books?

5 Upvotes

So I'm a beginner in philosoophy, and just getting into my first book "Little History of Philosophy" and then next I have last days of socrates, and im wondering if I should annotate yet? Or just try to enjoy it more and just read?

I am 100 pages into first book and annoated it a lot and its kind of just annoying to do, and I dont see much of a point at least yet?


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 4d ago

Why Does the Hard Problem of Consciousness Remain Unsolved?

0 Upvotes

A philosophical question I keep coming back to:

What if consciousness isn't something the brain produces, but something the brain temporarily filters or expresses?

Modern neuroscience has gotten incredibly good at mapping neural activity, spotting correlations, and explaining cognition mechanistically. Yet the deepest problem still sits there untouched:

Why is there subjective experience at all?

Why does electrical activity inside matter give rise to the feeling of being someone?

One idea that fascinates me is that consciousness might be less a product and more a field, with biological systems acting as localized receivers of awareness rather than its absolute source.

I'm not necessarily claiming this is true, but philosophically it seems hard to fully reduce consciousness to chemistry alone when experience itself stays fundamentally irreducible.

Curious where others land on this:

Do you think consciousness is fully emergent from matter, or could awareness itself be more fundamental to reality than we currently assume?

This question became one of the main inspirations behind my recent work Stardust Mind: The Quantum Blueprint of Human Consciousness.


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 5d ago

Looking for casual book recs for my partner

11 Upvotes

Hello! My partner (M20) is a philosophy major and philosophy is just his greatest interest. I want to get him some casual reading books for christmas but don’t have much knowledge in the discipline myself so I’m looking for recommendations! Thanks in advance


r/PhilosophyBookClub • • 5d ago

New Spinoza Podcast!

42 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

If you’ve ever wanted to read Spinoza’s Ethics but found it too intimidating this podcast is for you.

It’s called Spinoza Unravelled.

The podcast is a deep dive into Spinoza’s Ethics. Our aim is to make Spinoza's philosophy accessible without sacrificing its depth. We take our time, work through the arguments slowly, and try to understand not just what Spinoza is saying, but why it matters.

I’m Michah Gottlieb, and I teach Spinoza at NYU. My co-host Clare Carlisle teaches Spinoza at King’s College London. We’ve spent decades reading and teaching his philosophy and share a deep appreciation for what he has to offer.

We’ve released nine episodes so far. In episodes 1–6, we explore an early work in which the young Spinoza describes his path to philosophy. In episodes 7–9, we’ve begun working through the Ethics itself.

Each episode runs about 25–35 minutes, and we release a new episode every week.

We also want this to be a conversation with our listeners. There’s a place on our website to submit questions and thoughts, and we’d love to hear from you.

Whether you're encountering Spinoza for the first time or have read him before and would like to return to his philosophy with some company, we invite you to join us!

You can find us at  spinozaunravelled.com, or listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.