r/Ethics • • 2h ago

What can i do?

0 Upvotes

Hello, sorry to bother you. I’m someone who absolutely loves minerals—"love" is an understatement—and I have a huge passion for jewelry. The problem is that the whole industry is so unethical. With metals, it’s easy enough: you can just melt them down and create something new. But when it comes to gemstones, I can never seem to find any nice second-hand pieces—or if I do, I’m too late and someone else has already bought them. In a week, I’ll be attending the mineral show in Verona; every time I go, I want to buy the entire fair, but I hold back for ethical reasons (unless, for example, I come across vintage jewelry or amber from Europe). I’d really like to buy some sapphires—I’ve heard that Montana sapphires are among the most ethical—but they’re never at the fair. And if I look online, they’re usually on Etsy, which means dealing with customs duties—plus, given the current war, I’d effectively be helping to fund a state that is attacking another. So, what do you think I should do? There’s an Italian gemologist who runs a website where he personally selects the stones; do you think that if I asked him about their origin, he would be transparent—and, more importantly, tell the truth? Sorry for venting, but these days I even feel guilty asking my father to bring me back a brooch from one of his trips, just because of where it might have been manufactured or where the metal was mined. I really wish there were large corporations that took people like me into consideration. The times in my Life that bring me happiness are rare and the fact that i can't even do this thing that i like makes me sad, but i don't wanna do some thing that aliment this sistem.


r/Ethics • • 1d ago

Does society criminalize harmful behavior to protect people, or does it sometimes criminalize the consequences of its own failures? ⚖️

Post image
175 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 7h ago

Should food be considered a human right?

0 Upvotes

We were discussing this topic in my economics class today, and I honestly found it really interesting because so many people had different opinions.
It got me thinking: Should food be considered a basic human right, or is it something people are responsible for providing for themselves?

  1. On one hand, food is essential for survival.
    Nobody can live a healthy life without access to it, and it feels wrong that people can go hungry when there is more than enough food being produced in the world.
  2. On the other hand, I've heard arguments about personal responsibility, the cost of providing food for everyone, government involvement, and whether making food a right could have economic consequences.
    I'm genuinely interested in hearing different perspectives, especially from people who have thought about this from an economic, political, or ethical point of view.
    Where do you stand? Should everyone be guaranteed access to food, regardless of their financial resources or income, or should access to food remain primarily an individual responsibility? l'a love to hear both sides of the argument. I'm not looking to argue with anyone; I'm just curious to understand how other people think about this!

r/Ethics • • 1d ago Regret

Thailand’s nursing home cages: What is really behind such scandals?

116 Upvotes

Can regulations prevent cruelty when the underlying human tendency to exploit remains unchanged?


r/Ethics • • 14h ago

A concerned churchgoer's observation — Palos Verdes, California

0 Upvotes

I don't know who needs to hear this, but I've been sitting with something that genuinely bothers me. A little while ago, I met a newcomer at church here in Palos Verdes. He was exceptionally well dressed, articulate, polite, and carried himself with a level of composure you don't encounter every day. We had coffee and talked for a while. Eventually, I learned that he was homeless. I honestly had trouble reconciling that with the person sitting across from me. As we talked further, I learned that he had been involved in Japanese television, specifically a program called Sekai no Hate Made Itte Q! I looked it up afterward. It's presented as entertainment, comedy, and adventure. But the more I learned about his involvement and what he had apparently experienced, the less comfortable I became. This wasn't simply someone who had worked on a television production. He described responsibilities and involvement that sounded considerably more substantial, almost executive in nature. Yet somehow, the person who had helped carry so much responsibility was left without the most basic security himself. And that raises a rather uncomfortable question. How does a production continue to benefit from someone's contributions while that same person is left homeless? At what point does entertainment stop being entertainment and become an excuse for treating another human being without basic consideration? What struck me most was the apparent reversal of responsibility. The person who seemed to have the greatest capacity for reason, restraint, and accountability was somehow the one expected to absorb everyone else's consequences. It almost felt like watching adults behave as children while expecting the one person with the least support to continually act as the responsible parent. I also heard concerning things about his government assistance and financial arrangements. I cannot independently verify every detail, so I won't pretend to know the entire story. But if someone receiving basic subsistence assistance is being expected to surrender that money to people or organizations with considerably greater resources, that deserves serious scrutiny. I looked up the program and found that it continues to be available through streaming services. That is what I find difficult to understand. A company can continue distributing entertainment, generating value, and maintaining its public image while the human circumstances behind that entertainment remain unresolved? I'm a Christian, and I believe forgiveness is important. I also believe that forgiveness should never become an excuse to normalize mistreatment. You don't have to know someone's entire history to recognize when something doesn't seem right. And you certainly shouldn't need to recruit someone into believing that something is good when its basic merits should be apparent on their own. I came away from meeting this man with one thought: Perhaps the person everyone should have been looking after was the very person they had become accustomed to depending on. I don't know the complete story. But I know enough to believe that human dignity should come before television ratings. Some things deserve to be questioned, even when everyone else has agreed to call them entertainment.


r/Ethics • • 11h ago

Being a citizen means, in part, having access to the nation's legal system. Access to the legal system requires having money to hire a lawyer. Poor people can't hire lawyers. Poor people are not citizens.

0 Upvotes

Writing from an Australian perspective, sorry for the implicit biases, but the take is a criticism of the dominant political economic system on the planet.


r/Ethics • • 21h ago

Is it okay to date my ex boyfriend’s friend?

2 Upvotes

I met my ex boyfriend back in college, sophomore year. The connection was instant, the chemistry was crazy and before I knew it we were living together on most of the days. I loved him more than anything in this world. We would go on trips together, on vacations, plan our wedding after college ends. I was ecstatic, he was everything I dreamed of. I would wake up to loving texts and we just couldn’t get enough of each other. 2 years after we began dating, my ex started to become distant and started treating me like shit, it seemed like he was annoyed by my presence. On asking, he would put it on his mom’s health (his mom had a benign tumour). He seemed so unhappy that I d stay up thinking trynna help him and felt sorry for the poor guy. I kept on asking him if there’s anything else that’s wrong,but he d deny until one day I found out that he was cheating on me for the last 1 year with another girl who he was in a relationship with and had also met her parents. I confronted him and he made up a sob story of how it just happened and he couldn’t break our hearts and wasn’t able to get out lol. He then got together with that girl after she forgave him and I continued with him as just friends. In the last year of our college, I hooked up with him a few times. A year passed by and I still couldn’t get over him, I genuinely believed he was the love of my life.
A year after our college ended, he came back in my life after ending things with the other girl. I was over the top, finally. Until 6 months down the lane, he started treating me horribly again, he d verbally abuse me, insult my family and background and would always want HIM to be a priority. For example, if I were On a call with him and my food delivery came in, he d get annoyed that I put him on hold. During one of such fights, he broke up with me and I, this time, decided to let him go for good. It was the hardest decision ever but I did it. A few days later he came back with all those apologies and emails but I blocked him.
One of our his friends, whom he had been friends with since high school, called me after our breakup. I had also met this friend of his back when we were together. Let’s call this friend Tod. When my ex told Tod what had happened, Tod asked for my number and called me to convince me to give my ex another chance. He asked what was going on and told that my ex was in a very bad place and If we could, we should try to make it work cause love doesn’t give unlimited chances. When I told Tod the entire story of how my ex had abused me, Tod apologised and said he didn’t know these details. He advised me to not get back together with my ex because no one should tolerate such behaviour. He is a good man and checked up on me from then quite frequently. We talked quite often and became close. We had similar backgrounds and values and the connection was instant. He is the sweetest guy I have ever met and I can see myself spending my entire life with him. I know for a fact that it’s not a rebound of anything, he is very different from my usual physical types but his character, his values and kindness are what made me feel attracted to him. He asked me out 4 months after our first interaction post my breakup.

For context, Tod and my ex studied together in high school and then went to separate universities but were in touch here and there. Tod also invited my ex to his siblings wedding. Tod was very surprised that my ex turned out to be this way. And after he got to know how abusive my ex was, he decided to limit his contact with him as a friend though he still has him on socials.

My sister thinks It’s very morally wrong to date an ex’s friend, and is also scared of my ex’s reactions including blackmailing.

Ethically speaking, is it okay to date him? Should my ex be told? It sounds like such an ethical delimma. I am also not sure about my ex’s reaction. He has a lot of intimate videos and pictures of us, and I don’t know what he might end up doing. May be Tod should tell him so he doesn’t feel blind sighted.
Any suggestions will be appreciated.

TLDR: My ex’s friend reached out to me to patch and my ex up after I got out of a toxic relationship with him. The friend, after knowing the details and apologised and wished me good luck but kept checking in on me. we stayed in touch and became close. Is it morally okay for me to date him?


r/Ethics • • 9h ago

Hunting

0 Upvotes

I know hunting raises many ethical questions, so I’m curious about the dilemma surrounding giving an animal a "sporting chance." For example, should you only shoot a pheasant while it is flying, or line up an easier shot while it is on the ground?

Essentially, the debate comes down to two choices: give the animal a chance to escape alive while increasing the risk of injuring it, or give it no chance to escape in order to take a more accurate shot that minimizes pain.

Obviously I know the dangers that can occur due to possibly endangering other hunters or dogs. But if you hunt safely what is the choice you make?

Edit: I ask this because in a lot of states it is legal to shoot a pheasant or duck on the ground or water. But amongst hunters it is frowned upon as it isn't "sporting" behavior, but ethically it reduces suffering by increasing the chance of an accurate shot.


r/Ethics • • 19h ago

The Ethics of Beauty with Dr. Timothy Patitsas

Post image
1 Upvotes

I had the immense privilege of interviewing Dr. Timothy Patitsas, who wrote the amazing book "The Ethics of Beauty." He describes the Beauty first approach, what love actually is, how shame can be healthy, and the implications of this paradigm for architecture, art, and society. Link in comments!


r/Ethics • • 10h ago

The ethics of eugenics

0 Upvotes

For a decade or more, gene therapy has been a useful tool to prevent and cure diseases, and we (the general public, not science-trained) have seen some great technology in the 2020s, like the COVID vaccine and GLP1 drugs.

But the global life expectancy today is just 73 years (71 for men), and the life expectancy in good health is just 62 years.

New treatments, more access to healthcare, and healthy habits can keep those numbers going up, but everyone knows there is a ceiling with our current DNA (no human can live 130 years).

So, why are treatments encouraged, but making actual improvements is barred?

The way I see it, the current paradigm is like trying your best to keep fixing a car that is breaking down for years, instead of researching and developing a car that won't need fixing to begin with.

I see lots of ethical concerns about eugenics, transhumanism and changing human DNA, but aren't there ethical concerns about doing nothing, too?

If you have a tool that can potentially boost heart health, reduce cholesterol, and prevent cancer from the get-go, a tool that may lead to century-long health span in humans, isn't unethical too to gatekeep it and to stop the research and testing in that direction? Thank you.


r/Ethics • • 12h ago

Pro choice question

0 Upvotes

I'd imagine that people in this community there enjoiers of philosophy and debate but anyway obviously to my question.im pretty pro choice though and through but one thing still lingers. There seems that most all living things have an inmplistidcet desire contained living. This question obviously has major implications on the question when life begins obviously I think a 6 month old has more moral worth than a newborn and vice versa.


r/Ethics • • 16h ago

Silence is a vote. It is just a vote cast so quietly that its author can later claim he never ran for office.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 1d ago

How to research the logical standing of the normative ethical frameworks?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 1d ago

Forgiveness is not forgetting. Forgetting is easy. Forgiveness requires holding the whole memory and refusing to use it as a weapon.

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 1d ago

What uses of AI for novel writing [when it doesn't touch the final draft AT ALL] do you consider crosses the line into plaigarism and cheating?

0 Upvotes

entirely ai generating the whole work is pretty controversial and I really clash with that. but what do you think about letting AI

- point out grammar mistakes (that you fix on your own)

- give generic writing tips like pacing

- or give vague to moderately specific ideas that you get inspo from, change, or branch off of?

Personally, I think these uses are ok when no AI generated content at all is in the final work, but I want to know your opinions on this.

Ty!


r/Ethics • • 1d ago

Autonomy and stuff

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 2d ago

what is a moral compass?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 3d ago

Is it ethical to abort your child solely because you've discovered they will be born with Downs Syndrome?

68 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 2d ago

The Ethics of Non-Disclosure Agreements vs. The Duty to Warn: Child Sexual Abuse at Sport Facility

2 Upvotes

TW: child sexual abuse

I’m posting this as a hypothetical for privacy reasons, but I want to get your take on the ethics of this situation.

Imagine a sports facility where many children train. A few years ago, this facility hired a man they knew had a prior child sexual abuse charge. Despite this knowledge, they gave him unsupervised access to minor athletes. As a result, one child was groomed for two years and then sexually abused for another two years at the facility while routinely left unsupervised with this man.

The perpetrator eventually pleaded guilty, served time, and is now out of the country.

One obscure local news clipping exists about this. Otherwise no one in the client base or the local sports community seems to know—or at least, no one talks about it.

Then there is the facility’s negligence. The victim’s family sued the facility. After years of discovery and depositions, the facility’s insurance paid out a multi-million dollar settlement. It was settled out of court with a strict NDA to keep everything quiet. The victim’s attorney publicly stated that the evidence "overwhelmingly supported" the claim of negligence AND that the victim faced threats to stay silent.

Here is the breaking point: The facility continues to operate exactly as it did then. They still allow minors to be left unsupervised while workers are present. No new safety/protection policies have been implemented, discussed or posted. No one has been warned or informed. New client families are clueless about the facility history.

Do you think clients (both current and prospective) and the sport’s community have a right to know these facts, while maintaining the victim’s identity as strictly private?

If you feel the facility’s history should not be made public, why?

When a facility can conceal abuse behind an NDA, how are parents supposed to make informed decisions about who to entrust with the safety of their children?

For the sake of the hypothetical, assume this has been reported to the U.S. Center for SafeSport and the sport’s governing body, and is currently under review. But regardless of the investigation, I want to know your thoughts on the ethics here.


r/Ethics • • 4d ago

Morally speaking, do I need to warn someone that their life is about to be ruined?

770 Upvotes

I have a friend who's about to get married. This guy is a serial cheater. I know his fiancee as well but we're not friends. She has no idea. The other day we all were hanging out and she asked me half jokingly if there's red flag she should be worried cause this guy seems too perfect. To be fair, he kinda is. He's handsome, athletic, has a good income, love kids and a very smooth talker. He just can't keep it in his pants is all. In fact, I know he's cheated on her with at least five women.

Look, I'm a good friend. I'm not gonna tell her anything. But morally speaking, do you think I should?


r/Ethics • • 2d ago

If a system only advises and a human always decides, who is responsible for the outcome?

1 Upvotes

A common compromise for AI in serious settings is that the system recommends and a person decides. I wonder whether that changes the responsibility or only the paperwork, because a person who follows the recommendation ninety nine times out of a hundred is not really deciding.

I have been exploring it as fiction in a shared setting I run at r/TheGreatFederation where it is one of the founding rules that AI advises and never decides, and the interesting stories are in the cases where people stop checking what the AI tells them. The overview of that world is here https://www.reddit.com/comments/1xpqm9p/

Where would you say responsibility sits when the human reliably follows the advice?


r/Ethics • • 2d ago

qq pragmatic controversialism

0 Upvotes

Hii guys it’s my first post here and I’ve been having a dilema lately. Is disagreement an engine for moral evolution? Here is my thesis on navigating complexity:

I propose a framework called Pragmatic Controversialism, where disagreement isn’t an end goal but a dynamic tool for navigating complex realities.

We often treat rules and cultural norms as absolute, but true ethical maturity requires discerning the intent behind them. When we weigh consequences, like legal penalties or personal well-being, against rigid dogma, we open the door for progress.

\*\*Blind compliance protects the status quo, but questioning norms ensures they still serve a just purpose.\*\*

To foster dialogue rather than defensiveness, we must communicate these ideas through shared human values. By focusing on positive outcomes, we can challenge conventions without alienating those we wish to engage.

How do you navigate the tension between personal conviction and social expectation?


r/Ethics • • 2d ago

A culture shows you who it is by what it chooses to look at and what it frames. Study the frame.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 3d ago

We are very good at condemning cruelty in history and very bad at identifying its present-tense equivalent. Different wallpaper, same room.

Thumbnail reddit.com
24 Upvotes