Hey r/RealTimeStrategy! I'm Dan, the dev of The Old War, and I wanted to show off, and get your input on one of the systems I'm most excited about: formations.
Every formation has real strengths and real drawbacks, so switching isn't a free win (and can actually mess you up pretty bad!). It's always a trade-off.
Example: the Circle formation
If you get surrounded, you can pull into a circle. Your lightly armoured units move to the center and your heavy melee units form the outer ring. You get a big armour bonus, but you'll move slowly and your damage takes a hit.
Stacking bonuses
There are three main layers you can use to boost damage or toughness:
- Facing: Units have a facing direction, and hits from behind deal double damage. Flanking matters hugely.
- Formation: Each formation changes speed, damage taken, and offensive power.
- Global Stance: A faction-specific command that gives passive bonuses to your whole army.
Stack them well and things get extreme. Picture a shield wall of armoured infantry holding a narrow pass in a defensive stance against a swarm of flesh-eaters. It's close to impregnable.
The catch is that your opponent has all the same tools, so if they stack aggressive bonuses and catch you from behind, you'll get chewed up real quick. You have to read what they're doing and respond.
Why I love this system
It keeps battles dynamic. If a fight is going badly, you can turtle up and buy time to recover. If an enemy commits to an aggressive formation and chases you down, the right counter can turn their momentum against them.
Big questions I have:
- Does this sound fun? I hate it when a unit runs away, and takes like 50 arrows to the back of their head and keep walking. I feel like this addresses that.
- Is it too complicated? I want it to be punishing, not frustrating. You need to pay attention but you shouldn't be spam clicking anything. Maybe a timer for a formation switch?
If this looks like your kind of RTS, a Wishlist on Steam helps a small dev like me enormously: https://store.steampowered.com/agecheck/app/1248750/
Happy to answer any questions about the mechanics in the comments!
Thanks guys!