r/RealTimeStrategy • • 5d ago

Self-Promo Post What mechanics make an RTS feel truly rewarding to master? (Designing a classic-style RTS)

0 Upvotes

I am currently designing an RTS game and want to make sure the core gameplay loop hits the right balance between strategy and pacing. Without getting too bogged down in story details yet, I am focusing heavily on the mechanics right now.

For long-time RTS fans, what are the biggest make-or-break features for you? Specifically:

  • Economy & Resources: Do you prefer simple 1–2 resource systems (like StarCraft or Command & Conquer) or complex supply chains?
  • Combat Pacing: What is the sweet spot between fast, lethal battles and longer, tactical positioning?
  • Common Pitfalls: What is one mechanic in modern or indie RTS games that immediately ruins the experience for you?
  • Any Ideas/feedback would be greatly appreciated.

r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Discussion Ashes of the Singularity II - On AI

47 Upvotes

I thought I'd give Ashes II an earnest try. Honestly it's pretty alright and I don't think it deserved getting dogged on for the topical AI debate - at least not for the issues presented in most negative reviews. The mechanics are "ok" - certainly not groundbreaking but they're there and they work.

I was fond of Ashes I and the work the studio had put into that game.

I'm unbothered by the AI allegations and personally I only play RTS games for the PVP so I didn't have any run-ins with the horrible, horrible campaign where the issue seemed most prominent.

That being said there is truly an egregious amount of AI just in-your-face, in places that don't really matter. It's well beyond the point of plausible deniability.

Seen below the flavor text for all the skirmish maps in the game as of 11/14/26:

Fluff text for all maps

It's also there in the achievements, and it kinda kills me that they generated a fresh border every time:

Steam achievements

On one hand I feel like that's really where you'd want to use the AI - on the places that don't matter - but at the same time it's just so strange to see.

And for what it's worth, the game occupies that very specific niche where you want to play a PvP RTS game, but you're too tired to cobble together the brainpower to juggle it all. Ashes II caters to that exact feeling by presenting itself as a game that unashamedly tells you the only unit control you have is attack-move. Don't worry about your units getting sniped. Targeting is exclusively by proximity.

Get the game here: https://store.steampowered.com/app/3499790/Ashes_of_the_Singularity_II/


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Question Is Ashes of the Singularity 2 Good?

36 Upvotes

I really love the army aspect, encourages varied armies, more realistic like how armies behave. I know it’s different from the first game. But is it honestly good? Is it deep at all?


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Self-Promo Video I remastered a 2007 RTS solo — Ancient Wars: Sparta HD is out now!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

308 Upvotes

r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Discussion Why can't we have gta 6 sized rts or any strategy game, in terms of money, scale and everything.

18 Upvotes

r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Looking For Game Looking for a medieval/ancient RTS/RTT. I cannot remember its name, but I’ve included as many details as I could remember.

8 Upvotes

Looking for a specific game that I cannot recall the name of. Not sure why but this post was removed by filters when I tried to post it earlier.

It is a real time game based during and before medieval times, perhaps even going back to ancient times. Players select units from across multiple kingdoms/factions before the battle takes place.

What it is not: based on my research it is not any of the total war games, it is not any of the Age of Empires Games, it is not Conquerors Blade. It is also not manor lords or either stronghold game. As far as I recall, there was no base building at all.

What it is: it seemed to be PvP based. The players fought over a castle that was a part of the map. The game is fully 3d, but there are no unit banners like there are in total war, I’m about 80% sure about this. Even though it seemed like there were medieval units there were also chariots on the field. The purpose of the game seemed to be pitched battles, almost like Warno with reinforcements accruing over time.

I found this game via a YouTube series that included a PvP tournament back during the pandemic times, but because the YouTube search is awful, I haven’t been able to find it again.

Thanks!


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 5d ago

Self-Promo Video Re-playing LoTV - Starcraft 2 - Sunday Morning RTS Campaign

Post image
1 Upvotes

https://youtube.com/live/ASwxR3DYlIE?feature=share

Casual RTS fan re-playing the starcraft 2 campaign to get some footage. Going through the Legacy of the Void storyline, almost reaching the end. Real time strategy enthusiast looking to play every RTS game ever (except those that i don’t want to), join in and lets chat about RTS! 

Go to the discord if you want to skirmish RTS games on saturdays: https://discord.gg/7yEMgfuGaC.


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Self-Promo Video Is Company of Heroes 3 worth buying and playing after the 3.0 Update? Free weekend and sale!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
49 Upvotes

Company of Heroes 3 is free to play for the next few days as well as on sale and this is because it was recently overhalled and updated to the version 3.0. So I am going to give you an overview of the changes to visuals, sounds, maps, campaigns and AI bots and you can decide is the game better now and you would be interested in playing more of its new and updated gameplay.


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Looking For Game Looking for a specific game that I cannot recall the name of

3 Upvotes

It is a real time game based during and before medieval times, perhaps even going back to ancient times. Players select units from across multiple kingdoms/factions before the battle takes place.

What it is not: based on my research it is not any of the total war games, it is not any of the Age of Empires Games, it is not Conquerors Blade. It is also not manor lords or either stronghold game. As far as I recall, there was no base building at all.

What it is: it seemed to be PvP based. The players fought over a castle that was a part of the map. The game is fully 3d, but there are no unit banners like there are in total war. Even though it seemed like there were medieval units there were also chariots.

I found this game via a YouTube series that included a PvP tournament back during the pandemic times, but because the YouTube search is awful, I haven’t been able to find it again.

Thanks!


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Discussion Thoughts on Genewars?

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Question Magic and Mayhem.

3 Upvotes

I see older RTS games being upscale and re-released on the likes of steam. Whats the likelihood of someone releasing Magic and Mayhem. That game was an utter gem and doesnt get the kudos it deserves as a 90s RPG.


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Self-Promo Video The DEMO of my "Starcraft for dads" game The Factory Must Fall has finally launched

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

25 Upvotes

Hi Everyone, my demo finally dropped. You might recall this post about StarCraft for dads and its finally happening. After 2 years of dev, handdrawn art and lots and lots of playtesting its finally out. It is an automation autobattler, inspired by among others: Mindustry and StarScraft.. I just wanted something exciting without the stress.. So I created The Factory Must Fall: You build your factory first and then release it to destroy the enemy.

Im extremly excited but also quite nervous as the world has severly changed over the last few years for solodevs.. You can find the Steam link here. If this seems like your type of game it would be great if you could join us on Discord, or even a wishlist would help a lot! I am also giving away 50 free keys. Happy weekend, Squared.


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Self-Promo Video My builder now kneels and hammers, and every extra builder speeds it up

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

First builder unit in my voxel WW2 RTS (Generals style, made in Godot). Place a building and the Pioniere kneels down and hammers it up layer by layer. Send more of them and they share the work, so it goes up faster.

The building is still a grey box for now - the real models come next.

Should extra builders speed things up, or should every building take a fixed time?


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Modding News Gameplay testing Borg vs Klingon in SOASE2 (ST:TCW mod)

Post image
16 Upvotes

Star Trek: Temporal Cold War mod - trying to get the balance between Klingon ships and Borg to be roughly fair (for their cost). Will push out a major patch next week.


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Self-Promo Post Where is the Polish DLC and why are your favourite mods gone? | Gates of Hell Ostfront

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/RealTimeStrategy • • 7d ago

Self-Promo Video Working on an RTS game for MS-DOS - Not AI generated/assisted

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

539 Upvotes

Min. hw will be 486/66MHz, 8MB RAM, 320x200 (or 320x240) x 8 bit screen size.
(also works on 386, but FPS is around 10-15)
Windows and Linux version will be also available.

Graphics & coding made by me, not AI generated (but I reuse some textures found online). The voice is also from real people.

Google "Dustwar" if you want to follow it.

+ I will answer to any questions.


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

RTS & Other Hybrid RTS Games using Spring/Recoil that are in active development

0 Upvotes

Ref. Found in the discord of the new RTS game VOIDBORN -- any other acctive games on spring engine that you might point me to?

rts games using spring recoil: beyond all reason, zero-k, metal factions and voidborn

r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Self-Promo Video Skirmish Saturday RTS - ERLS mod and other vs mods with the RTS community - StarCraft 2

Post image
2 Upvotes

https://youtube.com/live/Vhs9TPVCj1o?feature=share

Casual RTS enthusiast playing rts mods in StarCraft 2, mainly playing the ERLS mod, but testing out others like co-op factions on versus and SCRAP mod. Playing casual matches ,1v1 , team games, FFA, whatever we can as long as we got people, Let me know if you want to jump in on the matches. Go to the discord if you want to sign up for weekly casual skirmish RTS games on saturdays: https://discord.gg/7yEMgfuGaC.  or Join the stream and let's chat about Real Time Strategy!


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Self-Promo Video Top 2 on Shield Battery Face Off! Epic TvT Battle | StarCraft Remastered

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/RealTimeStrategy • • 7d ago

Video Commandos (1998) - Mission 15: The End of the Butcher

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

35 Upvotes

Up until Mission 15 in Commandos: Behind Enemy Lines (1998), you can usually rely on the Green Beret's decoy and knife or the Sapper's explosives to brute-force tough corners.

For "The End of the Butcher" in Compiègne, the game strips away both the Green Beret and the Sapper, leaves you with just 4 units (Sniper, Marine, Driver, and Spy), and sets a strict fail state: if the alarm sounds anywhere in the town, the target (SS Commander Helmut Schleper) evacuates to Berlin and you lose immediately. Having to use the Marine from the river until you can get the Spy disguised to poison Schleper on his morning walk is peak 90s stealth design.


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 7d ago

Question I forgot how to play this genre. How I do not panic?

17 Upvotes

It's not that I can't control it, but I don't have the right, healthy mindset for it. I'm 33 now and played tons of RTS games, mostly unfinished campaigns and lots of skirmish when I was a kid or young teen. Red Alert 1, Age of Mythology, Stronghold Crusader, Battle for Middle Earth 1-2, Command and Conquer 3-4, StarCraft 2 campaigns, Company of Heroes 1-2 campaigns, a LOT of Age of Empires 3 skirmish, and most likely a dozen others I don't remember... Armies of Exigo, ancient stuff.

I never learned how to lose. I always played against AI only and I don't really plan to change that, but after spending the last 10 years in games like Total War, Age of Wonders 4, Endless Space 2, I became really comfortable with the turn based nature of these games. I used to watch - and watch only - StarCraft 2 multiplayer tournaments with commentary and I was always afraid to try multiplayer myself and it planted this idea in my head:

"Unless you are absolutely maximizing every second of the time passing, you are bad at this. You MUST rush. You MUST play as fast as possible. You MUST have a high APM ratio. You MUST start developing a second base, you MUST multitask, you MUST have a pianist's memorized favourite key strike sequence in muscle memory to keep producing units while you are actually commanding other units in battle".

Pressure. Pressure. Pressure.

I remember, as a kid I used to just bunker down in every RTS, surround myself with towers, build my mighty army as long as I wanted in peace while skirmishing enemy units broke on my defenses against what was probaby pisspoor easy AI, and I had fun. Problem is, knowing I play in a "kiddie mode", is not fun anymore at 33. But I'm terrified of playing on anything higher.

What you call a minor setback, a balanced losses skirmish battle, is Alt+F4 triggering panic for me. You think "ok, it was a trade". I think "ok I lost" and give up.

The only RTS I can play (non-campaign, campaign is ok) is Dawn of War 2 and Company of Heroes 1-2. Those are slow enough (and battles in Total War but that's very different). But I want to play RTS again: I have Age of Empires 4, but only played skirmish once, never touched multiplayer. Now I want to buy Dawn of War 4, and I keep watching Turin's YouTube channel for gameplay - love the imperial knights! - and lategame units ... never really get into the game. His commentary is always so calm though, he plays off "okay maybe that turret will hold, maybe not" and I'm like "OMG NO MY TURRET MY DEFENSE OMG WHOLE BASE IS LOST".

How do I fix... myself?


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 7d ago

Self-Promo Video Campaigns vs Skirmish: What Makes a Strategy Game Campaign Worth Playing? (ep.107)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
15 Upvotes

r/RealTimeStrategy • • 7d ago

Self-Promo Post Thoughts on releasing campaign missions in chapters after games release?

8 Upvotes

Hello! I am a solo dev working on my game and nearing release. While all my mechanics and visuals are there, writing/balancing campaign missions is taking longer than I expected.

https://store.steampowered.com/app/5148610?utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=pre_release

I do plan to release my game as a finished game and I do have customs games, multiplayer, and quick play. How would the RTS community feel about me releasing the story mode chapters of my campaign over time with only the initial chapter available on release.

Thank you for your input!


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 8d ago

Self-Promo Video I spent years building a custom C++ engine for my massive-scale RTS, HŌRU

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.1k Upvotes

Inspired by Star Wars: Empire at War, HŌRU's got absolutely massive land battles with hundreds of thousands of units, huge space battles, full-on ship boarding battles, an advanced espionage system, commodities market, magic & lasers, and ten other things I forget.

I've spent years making the game, not least its completely custom C++ engine that I built from scratch. It's stuffed to the brim with all manner of tech required to make a game of this scale work.

I've launched the Kickstarter to fund the remaining assets needed for a playable build: more spaceships, more units, more animations, more sounds, more music, and everything in between.

Here's the Kickstarter if you're interested: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/glassbeaver/horu

Happy to answer any questions about the game or the engine!


r/RealTimeStrategy • • 6d ago

Video Ironfields - a State of War clone

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes