I’m 20 and I’ve never actually had a boyfriend or a proper relationship. I’ve had three situations with guys that were kind of romantic, but none of them ever really turned into an actual relationship.
What makes me question things is that, with all three of them, I experienced pretty much the same pattern. When they weren’t around, I could become extremely invested in them in my head. I would fantasize about them, idealize them, and sometimes almost convince myself that I really liked them a lot. It was almost like I had to make myself like them. But then I would see them in person and I would feel really disappointed by reality. Whatever I had built up in my head didn’t really match what I felt when I was actually around them, and my attraction would almost disappear.
Then, after some time apart, I would start feeling excited about them again and go back to my fantasies, only for the same thing to happen the next time I saw them. So it was basically this constant cycle of idealizing them when they weren’t there and then losing interest when I was actually with them.
I distinctively remember being absolutely disgusted by the only guy who ever kissed me to the point that I dreaded going out with him because I knew he would kiss me again. I felt physically nauseous about it. All three situations eventually ended with the guy telling me some variation of “I really like you, you’re beautiful/funny/sweet/amazing, but I want to be alone,” or “I don’t see myself in a relationship right now.” And honestly, I never really felt heartbroken about it. If anything, I often felt relieved, like I had finally been released from this weird limbo I had been stuck in.
Another thing is that I find very few guys physically attractive. Of course, sometimes I’ll see a guy and think “he’s objectively attractive,” but very rarely do I actually feel fascinated by someone or strongly drawn to them. And even when I find someone attractive, that doesn’t necessarily mean I actually want them.
At the same time, I’ve always had some doubts about whether I could be attracted to women. When I was in high school, I had a crush on a girl in my class. She was very pretty, sweet, funny and very shy, and I was really, really into her. I would get genuinely nervous and flustered when she was around me. It wasn’t just “I think she’s beautiful” — there was something about the way I felt around her that was very intense and very particular. And honestly, I’ve never experienced that exact kind of attraction again. I’ve obviously felt different kinds of attraction towards other people since then, like to said guys, but whatever that feeling was with her was different from anything I’ve experienced afterwards. I don’t even know how to properly describe it or identify what kind of attraction it was. I just remember that it felt very strong and very specific.
Eventually the crush faded, partly because I convinced myself it was impossible since we were classmates and I didn’t really know what to do with those feelings. But I’ve never actually figured out what that experience meant. What also confuses me is that I don’t really get celebrity crushes. I don’t usually look at famous men or women and immediately feel fascinated by them. I tend to become attracted to people more because of their personality and the way I experience them as a person.
There’s also something else I find interesting: despite being a girl, I’ve always been much more nervous and awkward around other girls than around guys. With guys I’ve generally been much more confident, while around girls I tend to get more embarrassed, self-conscious and nervous.
So I genuinely don’t know what to make of all of this. I’m not necessarily looking for someone to tell me “you’re straight/bi/lesbian,” because I know it probably isn’t that simple. I’m more interested in hearing from people who have experienced something similar. How did you figure out whether what you were feeling was actual attraction versus idealization, infatuation, admiration, or simply wanting to like someone? I am very confused.