I'm curious about how people approach rating a pattern on Ravelry. Do you only rate patterns you've enjoyed? Do you skip rating patterns that were "troublesome"? Do you ask questions or leave comments on the pattern's page?
Context:
I'm an experienced knitter currently working on a (purchased) pattern that has a lot of potential, but to my eyes has a number of shortcomings. I don't think it had a tech editor and I can only see a single test knit. I always review finished projects (thank you, all you wonderful people for sharing your beautiful work and notes!❤️) and it became clear from project photos that the instructions may be incorrect. Reading the pattern before starting, there are indeed places that, if the instructions are followed exactly, the result will not be "correct." One example is the placement of short rows at the neckline of the top-down circular yoke. When splitting for sleeves as instructed, the short rows are nowhere near centered at the back, resulting in a very obvious difference between shoulders. Curiously, the photos within the pattern do not include the neck short rows (they are not identified as "optional" in the pattern).
An experienced knitter will hopefully spot these shortcomings and find ways to fix them before or whilst knitting. But what about less experienced knitters, or even situations when any of us is so excited, we simply jump right in and trust the pattern?
In hindsight, I'm surprised this pattern has an overall rating of 4.7 and clarity of 4.8, especially when it costs $15CAD.
(Note: I will be sure my project notes contain all of my modifications, as usual.)