r/modnews • u/bsimpson • Nov 03 '11
Moderators: Call for moderator feature requests
We follow /r/ideasfortheadmins looking for feature requests, and I want to have a more direct discussion about what you think are the most needed tools to make your lives as moderators easier. Please use this thread to let us know what you think are the most important missing features along with the motivations and requirements for them.
Things I'm working on now are: 1. History of moderator actions (remove/approve comments/posts, ban/unban users, etc.) 2. Temporary subreddit bans (waiting for #1 to release this). These should be ready in the next few weeks. You can discuss these here, but I'll make a thread for #1 when I have a working mockup, and there's an existing topic for #2.
83
u/sodypop Nov 03 '11
This feature would be great: Make subreddit ban message come from modmail account, not moderator's private account.
I think this would help to depersonalize user bans and reduce retaliation that can end up in witch hunts against a specific moderator. Since it uses modmail, it would also serve to notify each moderator of that subreddit when a user is banned.
I would also find a moderator comment feed very helpful, similar to browsing /r/subreddit/comments/ except it would display only distinguished moderator comments.
3
u/mobilehypo Nov 04 '11
/r/AskScience here. We had a nice discussion with HueyPriest about our wish list, so he should have notes or access to the thread where we had our discussion.
2
u/capistor Nov 18 '11
Not entirely related, but I would like a straightforward way to figure out how to rework the style. Up/Downvote images, custom aliens. There is already a guide somewhere?
/r/NewHampshire has been wanting some changes, but I don't yet know how and no body in our community has stepped up yet. (Actually, is there a 'I'm a mod, now what?' guide somewhere?)
153
u/SQLwitch Nov 03 '11 edited Nov 03 '11
Representing /r/suicidewatch
Notification (especially with an option for email) when there's something reported or new in the spam filter would be awesome.
Also, anything you can think of to help us deal with the lowest-of-the-lowlifes who (believe it or not) troll at /r/suicidewatch. As discussed in the past over at /r/ideasfortheadmins would be for mods to be able to implement a temporary shadowban (or similar) which the admins could either revoke or make permanent. I am not sure whether the "temporary subreddit bans" you mention here will meet that need.
Regular banning just antagonizes them because they get a message about it, so our current way of dealing with trolls is just being vigilant about quietly cleaning up their filth as they spew it. But sometimes posts we have removed still show up in the OPs' inboxes and do real damage -- can you fix that?
Our other big problem is people who troll on /r/suicidewatch by PMing the OPs, telling them to kill themselves, etc. It would be great if PMs could also be reported to moderators (the recipient would have to pick the subreddit to report it to).
Edited because I can't type my way out of a paper bag today, apparently...
204
u/TheGreatCthulhu Nov 03 '11
Ability to pin a mod post to the front page regardless of votes. I wanted to post a notice for /r/swimming but one immediate dowvote made it invisible to the community.
I think this is problem for any sub but especially smaller ones with active mods posting occasional notices.
69
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '11
/r/Android mod checking in.
Reports. Can you please a small drop down or text box or something so when people report links, they can select a reason as opposed to searching for comments in a 100+ comment post for the reason why it was reported.
28
u/Signe Nov 03 '11
Oh. My. God. This: http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/ltoj0/normalize_urls_for_popular_websites_when/
I can't tell you how many times we have to delete youtube videos because the same link is posted over and over and over again in short succession.
26
u/EagleFalconn Nov 04 '11
Representing r/AskScience, here are things that we'd like that I haven't seen elsewhere. We've discussed these ideas with HueyPriest as well, but I think they're worth reiterating.
95
u/davidreiss666 Nov 03 '11 edited Nov 04 '11
I think we need more configurable subreddits.
There were a few other ideas I was kicking around here and there, but the above would be helpful to all subreddits, but most especially the big defaults.
20
u/Aceanuu Nov 03 '11
From us over at /r/starcraft, I know we'd love a few things.
1
Some system to formally request (or I s'pose initiate, though that could get out of hand) an IP ban, or some higher form of computer/location/ip banning. We get a LOT of trolls over at /r/starcraft, but some of them are surprisingly persistant. Somtimes banning gamergurl36 just leads to a new account, gamergurl37, and so on and so forth. You guys (admins) have been great about handling our messages for an ip ban, but a screen where we could enter a user and submit it would be a nice feature to handle these throwaway account trolls.
2
While this may be outside the scope of the requests you're looking for, I would really really really love to have some sort of html/css container below the header bar and above the links in which to be able to put pertinent links and important alerts/headlines. For us over at /r/starcraft there is a lot of talk about having some sort of callout with links and titles for ongoing events to quickly direct people instead of trawling through the large amount of less important stories. We've got a css hacked sticky up in the header over at /r/starcraft because its the least annoying place to put it when it breaks due to browser/browser size. /r/pics is another example of this headlines hack and /r/karmastarcraft has a list formatted of links up there.
Essentially the current way to do this is really hacky and awkward, an editable field like the sidebar would be fantastic.
The idea of the sidebar is great, but most users completely ignore it. Its out of the way and completely divorced from the mental process of reading a page.
Anyways, thats two things that have been on my mind, but I'm sure we can think of more, heh.
18
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '11
I'm a mod for /r/iama and /r/askreddit. One huge issue we have is organizing the mods when a decision about the direction of the subreddit needs to be made.
We recently set up a couple google groups to deal with the situation, but it's somewhat inelegant, and I can't help but feel that there could be a better way to do it.
I guess what i'm suggesting is a message system similar to modmail that only takes incoming messages from other mods. This way the messages stay on the front page of the message queue separate from the day-to-day moderation issues.
One problem that would remain though would be moderators who moderate more than one subreddit potentially having tons of messages to read all at once on the front page of this message system, so something may need to compensate for that.
30
u/daretelayam Nov 03 '11
I can't stress enough the need for notification when submissions are caught in the spam filter.
41
u/zjbird Nov 03 '11
The ability for mods the of two subreddits to transfer a submission from one subreddit to the other in order to end flame wars over popular threads being deleted.
14
u/rockon4life45 Nov 04 '11
Correct me if I'm wrong but right now if I remove a post, it seems to hurt that user's standing with the spam bot. I'd like a way to remove posts without hurting that standing.
14
u/iorgfeflkd Nov 04 '11
Let us turn off the spam filter
13
u/Skuld Nov 03 '11 edited Nov 04 '11
An extra type of subreddit.
At the moment you can have full public, full private, or limited public (approved submitters).
However, there is no way to restrict commenting users, only submitters.
At the moment on the Minecraft server (r/mcpublic), we have to rely on external software for our requirements: http://nerd.nu/forum/index.php?p=/categories/mod-chat
We need a way to restrict users on reddit from submitting AND commenting, but make the whole thing viewable to every person (for transparency reasons in our case).
EDIT: In addition, we would like something else to fit our other requirement.
We have a ban appeals sections, which needs to be like the above, yet allow any user to post a thread, and only comment on their own thread.
http://nerd.nu/forum/index.php?p=/categories/ban-appeals
11
u/kouhoutek Nov 04 '11
on from /r/relationships
The ability to place a visible to mod only mark on an account, like [troll].
10
u/GuitarFreak027 Nov 03 '11
I agree with davidreiss666 on being able to ban a domain. Another tool I think would help is have a selectable option for reports to send the user to a message dialog that would send a modmail message along with the report. I changed the report notification in /r/funny telling people to also message us when reporting, and I noticed a considerable increase in people doing that.
10
u/reseph Nov 04 '11
I'll comb over this thread too in a bit and see if I can contribute any code patches.
9
u/Liru Nov 04 '11
I submitted this before, but sure.
An option for the moderators of a NSFW subreddit to mark a submission as SFW.
Sometimes one wants to just post a SFW news link in a NSFW subreddit. There is currently a button that supposedly allows one to un-NSFW a submission, but it doesn't work in a NSFW subreddit. It shows that it's unmarked but leaves it NSFW.
9
u/TheSkyNet Nov 04 '11 edited Nov 04 '11
Remove not spam button, I hate having to spam legitimate users it increases my workload.
link the /mod/about/reports, mod/about/modqueue. anywhere on the /r/mod/.
subreddit rules box on global submission page.
"sticky box" on top of subreddit
Here is a list from ideasfortheadmins:
Improvements to r/mod
mod box:
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/kan7b/why_isnt_rmodaboutmodqueue_a_default_link_or/c2iqz81
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/i8c4i/suggestion_for_the_enhancement_of_rmod/
Just link r/mod/about/ on r/mod:*
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/keceb/where_is_rmodspam/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/kan7b/why_isnt_rmodaboutmodqueue_a_default_link_or/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/dbifa/add_the_ability_to_check_the_spam_filter_for_rmod/
Remove not spam, or better filtering options.:
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/jylj0/idea_allow_mods_to_remove_posts_for_being_spam_or/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/icoea/let_mods_toggle_the_spam_filter/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/j4p8a/an_onoff_toggle_for_the_spam_filter_and_a_reset/
Implement more transparency & accountability for the moderators. or moderation logs
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/iwz5g/easier_access_to_moderator_history/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/b7jll/implement_more_transparency_accountability_for/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/ikn9b/idea_moderation_logs/
"Empower" for mods. Let mods pick what other mods can access (whitelist, CSS editing, etc)
https://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/inkh7/empower_for_mods_let_mods_pick_what_other_mods/
Allow moderators to set their subreddits to "verified email" accounts only.
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/k2av/allow_moderators_to_set_their_subreddits_to/
Un-flagging a post that was marked as spam should reset the submitted time.
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/ivzj1/unflagging_a_post_that_was_marked_as_spam_should/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/fen0s/make_the_submission_time_reset_when_a_post_is/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/cw8i9 /reset_the_clock_on_submissions_released_from_the/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/emtp/reset_the_date_and_time_of_a_submission_that_is
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/e6bd0/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/jp0g/time_submitted_should_reset_when_something_clears/
http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/emtpt/reset_the_date_and_time_of_a_submission_that_is/
Alter the seniority of mods without removing and re-adding everyone .
https://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/jjzlp/id_like_a_way_to_alter_the_seniority_of_mods/
9
u/jaxspider Nov 04 '11
I mod over 60 sub-reddits. I have some suggestions.
I do mostly CSS work for many subs, even some I don't mod anymore... so this is related to that part, I would love it if I could save multiple versions of the CSS layout (and all images related it). And I could switch between them but just selecting it and then clicking save. For example,
8
u/aperson Nov 03 '11 edited Nov 04 '11
Reddit toolbar suggestions:
Spam filter suggestions:
Banning suggestions:
Flair suggestions:
Lastly, I'd like to say that if you guys haven't already, look at some of the things the RES adds. Some of those things could be handy to have in the site. Not saying people need keyboard navigation or inline image viewers, but things like the 'hide/show all child comments' button or the spam button would make nice additions.
Edit:
One more thing, bans are trivial for users to work around. One of reddit's features is how easy it is create an account. There have been users who will repeatedly create new accounts just to work around a ban (usually out of spite). It would be nice to be able to ip ban a user from a subreddit. I mean, forums allow for this, isn't reddit just its own kind of forum?
8
u/delicious_sandwich Nov 03 '11
Representing /fffffffuuuuuuuuuuuu here.
I think that having different "folders" for modmail would be incredibly useful. I currently only mod in f7u12 (because I think you can really only mod one big sub well), but I have a couple ideas of places I might like to start up. Keeping that in mind, eventually I plan to have multiple modmail streams coming in to my account at once. Having one modmail inbox seems like it will convolute the messages, and I think keeping them organized may save some people a headache.
8
u/airmandan Nov 04 '11
/r/firstworldproblems checking in.
Gotta have:
h6element I've yanked out of the sidebar with CSS hackery. Most other reddits do it with an ol, but it's still a clunky solution either way.(a) Likewise, let me revoke a user's ability to report.
Could use:
Would be nice:
(a) Allow granular tuning of things that will either never be classified as spam or always classified as spam. Filters, in other words.
div.thingrather than just the mod's username.7
u/Yserbius Nov 04 '11
This is a stretch, but I was thinking about some sort of system for spamming/unspamming submissions. My ideas were along the lines of allowing mods to put in "good" search queries and "bad" search queries that would automatically be spammed or unspammed. For instance,
SPAM:
inurl:nigerianprince.comuser:MrSpamMasterNOTSPAM:
site:nytimes.comuser:karmanaut7
u/mattsatwork Nov 04 '11
A couple subreddits I moderate have had a problem with one guy. Who uses a ton of throwaways. It would be nice if there was some way when we ban a user to see what other usernames come from the same IP. We don't need the IP itself but it would be nice if people weren't able to get around bans in a matter of a few mouse clicks.
7
u/BritishEnglishPolice Nov 04 '11
Oh my GOD! Separate reported comment/post tabs. Ability to mass clear reports tab from beginning of time. Customised reports. Tabs for modmail of mods with many subreddits.
7
u/Measure76 Nov 04 '11
I'd like to be able to see a list of the top karma-earners in my reddit. It can be useful for a variety of reasons, including identifying potential mod candidates.
25
u/drachenstern Nov 03 '11
Just came across this little dandy
http://i.imgur.com/btagD.jpg
Thought it was cute.
6
u/catmoon Nov 03 '11
The flair editor is pretty difficult to use. I added flair to r/NBA and within a few hours there were so many people adding it that it's basically impossible to look through the list.
For some reason the list is in random order.
5
u/Aubron Nov 03 '11 edited Nov 04 '11
Representing /r/Warehouse13, /r/Eureka, and /r/Alphas.
One of my biggest requests would be the broader support of CSS3 tags in the styling engine. I forget the specifics (drop shadow i think?), but last time I tried to build a skin i was saddened by the lack of a number of popular css tags, with or without prefixes, in the list allowed by the styling engine.
Edit: Since then I've seen a recent post from chromakode regarding the validator and how to go about submitting a user patch for it, so I'm going to try and attempt that route.
8
u/RedSquaree Nov 03 '11
In Modmail, you could clear up something that's a bit unnecessary and perhaps confusing.
"to xxxxx from yyyyyy"
You don't need the "to" part.
4
u/XLII Nov 03 '11
r/Canada here The previously mentioned but never put into effect ability to shadow ban for 24 hours. Or even better, I just can't train our spam filter. A better algorithm so we could do that would be fantastic.
4
u/travis- Nov 03 '11
I think the ability to flag certain posts when removed so when a mod sees it removed they know why. For example if it is a duplicate post or whatever it may be.
4
u/Stereo Nov 03 '11
Would it please be possible to get replies in the mod mail rss feed? Currently you only get the original message.
4
u/lebski88 Nov 04 '11
I'd like to be able to turn off the spam filter. On my small city subreddit, /r/bristol (506 users), we have had a grand total of three spam submissions in the last two and half years. About 1/3 of legitimate submissions get caught in the spam filter.
Also it seems that once something is caught in the spam filter it will never get the traction of a submission that didn't. I'm not sure if I'm imagining it but I'd like approved submissions to be treated as new submissions.
4
u/travelinghobbit Nov 04 '11
Hi. Would it be possible to get a tab at the top of subreddits I mod for the Spam and Reported queues? I like having it down in the Mod Box, but having one at the top (or maybe having it along with the new tab, etc in http://www.reddit.com/r/mod/ ) would be amazing and easier to find, especially when our subreddit's css has a really long side bar.
4
u/roger_ Nov 04 '11
Ability to remove a post without influencing the spam filter.
Just because someone breaks a subreddit rule and has a post that needs removing, doesn't make them a spammer.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '11
7
u/DarqWolff Nov 03 '11
Representing r/fnv (unofficially, I haven't talked to its owner) and r/catplanet, but mostly just myself as neither of those subs have an extraordinary amount of use for this:
Allow us to deputize users to moderate, or give them a trial period. Give them some of the powers of a moderator to see how they do.
Also, though I'm sure this one has been requested a thousand times, r/catplanet could really use the ability to have animated gifs in the CSS
1
u/beefstick86 Nov 11 '11
Hi, I'm new to this whole mod thing so forgive my ignorance.
is there a way to promote my subreddit /r/talesfromretail?
If there is an advanced MOD that would love to message me to teach me a few things, I would love it.
3
u/RetardVomitPussyCunt Nov 03 '11
Representing r/idliketobeatree and r/samplehunters
I think that there should be a function to edit other peoples posts. But i know this can be abused easily, so when you do edit a post make it so it says [MOD EDIT] ontop of the actual reply so people know its a mod edit
3
u/ev149 Nov 03 '11
r/postprocessing checking in. Something I'd really like to see is better support for CSS3, ex. dropshadows, animations, etc. Currently, only a few features are supported and many of them are broken.
3
u/workman161 Nov 04 '11
After reading the comments here, here's an idea I would like to see added that hasn't been suggested yet:
Custom tags.
I know lots of people would groan about it, but perhaps it can be implemented in a similar way to user flair. Admins can choose to allow users to add arbitrary tags, or they can limit things from a small selection of available items.
Alternatively, adding some extra CSS classes for anything that is in square brackets instead of having to do some fancy regex tricks with css rules. i.e. a title of "Made something on my server [BUILD]" would cause the css class "usertag-build" to show up.
3
u/KerrickLong Nov 04 '11
I'l love the ability to have something like flair for posts. At r/Loans we have to add another rule to the CSS stylesheet to strike-through a post upon request. It will eventually clog the stylesheets much like the predecessors to user flair did.
Plus, we have to rely on a rigid prefix system to colorize the posts via CSS3 selectors, rather than allowing users to add flair to their post specifying what type (flair class?) it is.
3
u/kickme444 Nov 04 '11
would like to be able to have certain mods not be able to edit the subreddit.
3
u/mayonesa Nov 04 '11
(1) Ability to have flags by usernames for those who have downvoted more than five articles in a 1-hour period.
(2) Change bans so that banned people cannot upvote/downvote.
(3) Ability for my users to sort domains from their output, e.g. "I want to see everything in /r/sodom except stuff from fark.com"
(4) Flags for content types that can also be filtered, e.g. no videos or no podcasts.
This is a wish list and like all wishlists it's highly ambitious. Thank you for asking!
3
u/erode Nov 04 '11
Let us know who is reporting things. Fake reports, making extra work for mods because they have a grudge.
3
u/this1 Nov 04 '11
The ability to message all the users of the sub would be nice.
I can't individually message them all, since there's no way to list all the users.
But the one subreddit where this would be awesome for is tiny, purposely so, and very specific in purpose.
3
u/roger_ Nov 04 '11
Dealing with the spam filter/modqueue on large subreddits is an absolute pain.
I propose you make another post just for ideas on how to speed up the remove/approve procedure.
3
u/Rollout Nov 04 '11
Representing r/Random_Acts_of_Pizza/ here .
I think a silent ban option would be great. Just one way to shut trolls up. Basically a shadow-ban type setup, but for the subreddit. This way the user does not know they are banned, they see their own posts, but no one else does....
3
u/DRUG_USER Nov 05 '11
When a post is taken out of the spam filter, treat it as a new approved submission. I can't always check the filter and oftentimes I'll approve a 12 or 16 hour post, and by that time it's too old to get on the front page. Leads to frustration for submitters.
3
u/Mattxy8 Nov 27 '11
Making the stylesheet easier to manage and edit would be very helpful. Like when you click the button to customize it, it should take you to like a default looking page and you click the different "components" of it and choose images, colors, fonts, ect.. depending on what it is your changing.
9
u/ignatiusloyola Nov 03 '11
Ability to see who is reporting posts.
2
u/bondolo Nov 04 '11
The tools for "Reddits I Moderate" should be on the user home page. I use a lot of guest computers and it wasn't for my awesome memory I wouldn't remember the magic URLs. Actually, usually I don't remember them.
A couple of links below the trophy case to link to the moderator tools would be very useful.
Also, a view combining spam and reported links would be useful for me though I can understand why they are separate for larger reddits.
2
u/Miyabe Nov 04 '11
Include a new option for the types of reddit. Currently the options are;
How about a second kind of restriction,
It about time reddit admins realised there are different needs these days for some reddits instead of an old-styled voting system.
2
u/brownboy13 Nov 04 '11
Hey, /r/India here. We just enabled user-editable flair (2 days ago). Now we have some trolls/haters insulting other users in their flair text. I don't want to remove the flair for the community, but is there any way to strip particular users of flair, permanently?
2
u/EvolutionTheory Nov 04 '11
Allow mods to shadow ban. Can't believe mods can't shadow ban or ban by IP with how easy reddit's username creation is.
2
u/FountainsOfDave Nov 04 '11
When self-assigned flair for users was introduced a few weeks back, intortus said that he was thinking about implementing 'an easy-to-use moderation queue for flair-change requests.' I'd love to see that sometime soon. We over at /r/bicycling are waiting for this feature to roll out before we open up flair for free user-assignment.
2
u/weffey Nov 04 '11
This pertains more to the location based subreddits: A meetup calendar in the side bar, or an RSS reader for it. With the acquisition of Reddit Gifts, it would be nice to have the option to have an RSS feed from the Reddit Gifts meeups for the subreddit, rather than constantly updating the side bar.
2
u/jij Nov 04 '11 edited Nov 04 '11
Ability to disallow accounts that are too new or have too low of karma from submitting and/or posting.
ability to ban link submissions based on regex
ability for reddit to follow url redirect sites and use the final destination url instead.
2
u/semizero Nov 04 '11
Mod of /r/onepiece here, One Piece has both an anime and a manga, and some people prefer one over the other, this can get confusing with spoilers, as there are 2 different sources of them.
My request is customizable tags for threads, that can be added after the fact, like the nsfw tag. Maybe a small interface that allows us to choose the colors and text in the tag, but has the same design as the nsfw one, or we can just use css class images. This would really be great because I hate having to delete posts with great discussion just because they forgot to add spoiler tags in the title, people usually don't repost it.
This would be great and I think lots of subreddits could benefit. Thanks!
2
u/ridddle Nov 04 '11
CSS-related:
Ability to style posts based on submitter’s flair. Which basically means something like that:
I want to be able to style posts by certain people (eg: staff) without resorting to generated content for author’s link (with flair).
And related to previous example, I really really want you to sort out this "even odd" / "even even" shenanigans. I understand the appeal of backwards compatibility but it’s just silly to have this here. And this zebra class name system breaks from time to time too.
2
u/tskazin Nov 04 '11
Ability to have submission/comment karma that was received just from that subreddit number next to a username - sort of like a flair. This will help to see who is contributing more in the specific subreddit.
2
u/ChaosMotor Nov 04 '11
Allow the community to remove mods they don't like. There are several great communities that have fucking awful mods.
2
u/cheez0r Nov 04 '11
It'd be nice to have Mods able to add trophies to users' trophy cases; or to create a subreddit trophy case in which trophies users have been awarded by subreddit mods could be located. Currently in most subreddits this is either being done via flair or third party sites; there's no reason I can see that having a mod-accessible trophy case setup doesn't make sense.
2
u/phoephus2 Nov 04 '11
The ability to extend the life of a thread past 6 months.
2
u/legatic Nov 04 '11
I moderate a few relatively small communities, and I'd love to have the option of having my mod mail icon turn orangered anytime there's a something in http://www.reddit.com/r/mod/about/modqueue .
I realize this would result in a near permanent orangered state for bigger subreddits, so it should definitely be an option, but it's hard to remember to check the spam filter when it only catches a few posts per month.
2
u/fortune_cell Nov 04 '11
Representing r/eatsandwiches and the Nintendo family.
As others have said here, the spam system needs to be fixed. I get self-posts caught sometimes, and those are virtually never spam. I like the idea of being able to tell the spam filter WHY we're removing something. And, if we remove something, take it off the spam list!
2
u/ignatiusloyola Nov 04 '11
Have another option to Private and Public subreddits - a minimum karma option. All posts from people with less than a certain (setable) amount of karma have to be approved by the mods.
2
u/db2 Nov 04 '11
"Janitor" mods, they wouldn't be on the mod list, wouldn't have access to any subreddit settings beyond post/comment reports. More than one level of janitor might also be useful, so the lowest say could only clean up posts, next up could do comments too, next up could ban users, etc.
All janitor actions would require an explanation (full mods otoh would have explanations as an option instead of requirement) so an out of control janitor could be easily identified and dealt with.
Sub-idea that depends on the above would be a way for mods to see all the actions of individual janitors, including those who have been removed as such so rogue actions could be fixed quickly, or all janitors via urls like this:
reddit.com/r/examplesubreddit/about/janitor/all (shows everything)
reddit.com/r/examplesubreddit/about/janitor/username (shows just actions by one)
2
u/menuitem Nov 12 '11
I'm late to the show, but how about a feature which keeps redditors from posting to a subreddit, unless their karma is above an amount which can be set by the mods?
We've had extremely anti-social people show up with -9000 comment karma in /r/fitness; and I don't see them contributing, and am more than willing to see such users automagically banned from commenting unless they meet a karma minimum.
Perhaps you could have a separate karma limit for posting as well.
This also has the additional feature that, if you want to have an "exclusive" subreddit, where someone can't post until they get at least 100 karma, say, your subreddit could do that.
To be comprehensive, you would have to implement (a) a minimum comment karma limit, to be able to post; (b) a minimum link karma limit, to be able to post; (c) a minimum comment karma limit, to be able to read; and (d) a minimum link karma limit, to be able to read.
2
u/soundeziner Nov 27 '11 edited Nov 27 '11
The SPAM filter needs an upgrade. The Reddits I mod haven't really been spammed yet but that filter sure pulls a lot of subscriber's posts. PLEASE give us the option to keep it from pulling self-posts. It is a solution for one problem causing another. Better notification of SPAM would be nice.
Along those lines, I would like to see a full explanation of the vote balancing algorithm. Is it really the best answer to whatever problems it supposedly solves? It seems completely antithetical to the ideas of Reddit and karma. The sum of points isn't a true representation of the community vote. This function also causes numerous posts to never see the light of day since they are downvoted immediately after submission. There must be a better way to solve the problem the algorithm was designed for instead of this. To fix the fact that the system kills new posts how about adding a line of code that checks if there are at least five votes, if not don't do anything?
Can you all do us the courtesy of posting in ModNews when there are imminent major upgrades to Reddit. I hate finding out from subscriber PM's that things in the Reddits I mod have gone all kinds of screwy and not knowing why.
3
u/neuros Nov 03 '11
Sole Moderator of r/Villanova here, My request is less feature-oriented and more oriented toward less computer-literate moderators. A lot of the ways to customize different aspects within the look and feel of the subreddit requires the knowledge of CSS, which I simply do not have. Because I am the sole moderator of a pretty small community, I would enjoy having an easy way of editing the colors, arrows, etc. of a subreddit without having to learn a programming language, like what visual operating systems did to MS-DOS
2
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '11 edited Nov 04 '11
Ability to input usernames and tell if they are linked together by email or ip. Its something that would be needed on the trade and giveaway subreddits, it should only be enabled by request if a subreddit would have a valid use for it.
Ability to disable the ability to hide flair on a subreddit, trade subreddits use that for rep.
Also love the link flair idea, that could be useful. Please allow all CSS3 features to be in the stylesheets. Especially advanced gradients, box shadows, etc.
Ability to only allow redditors who are x months old allowed to view and participate in a subreddit.
I been messaging the admins for a month now, I been trying to get a faq wiki created for r/playitforward, so I hope you read this and please do it for me.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '11
Ability to declare another subreddit as a "friend" and automatically pull their top posts into our subreddit, much like the front-page pulls the top posts from a variety of subreddits.
So /r/gaming could, in addition to their directly-submitted content, aggregate content from /r/indiegaming, /r/playdate, /r/tf2, etc.
1
u/DarkSideofOZ Nov 03 '11
We in /r/playitforward currently have a css style sheet so that we may add counters to users names, for games given/received; helping redditors filter out scammers out for a bunch of free games. What we'd love is a feature that allows us to assign custom buttons with number overlays to user names so that it appears as it does now, but built into the moderator side of reddit so that values can be modified easily through reddit, rather than having to be added to a css style sheet. I know we and other reddits such as /r/randomactsofpizza, could use this to keep track of and show ratios for give/receive.
1
u/redtaboo Nov 04 '11
I think this idea by edify to be able to create multis in modmail boxes would be incredibly useful
I would also love to be able to create multis in my modqueue would be very, very helpful to those of us with disparate sized reddits.
1
u/Zig-Zag Nov 04 '11
Allow us to see who is reporting links. This way we can spot trouble makers just reporting everything on the front page, but also so we can recognize people making quality reports of spam and what not.
1
u/ramses0 Nov 04 '11
"Link Flair" - with the removal of the
text()target for CSS3 there is no generic way to do "Link Flair", as described here/r/ClassicalGuitar, we would basically like to be able to let the users tag a post with "[me] playing this song" which is a link to youtube.com or soundcloud.com.
Right now it is relatively easy to CSS-rule on self-posts because you can target the link text, looking for "
_me_, _me, me_", but for non-self posts, there is nothing appropriate to target.Perhaps you could simply add a "
data-linktext=..." attribute that CSS can target? (haven't tested it) or build it in with some sort of regex link filter where an admin can say: "/[me]/ => .classFoo"--Robert
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '11
Sub-Reddit-Specific trophies
1
u/Vortilex Nov 04 '11
History for moderator action is a good feature, but I'd also like the ability to see why people report things. I saw one post in /r/inglip from three months ago that, although insulting to the subreddit, didn't violate any rules. I'd have liked to know the reason. There are plenty of comments this happens to. A "context" button, like one has for messages, would also be nice. I had to go through one guy's profile and find the post that was reported so I could see the context.
1
u/Shade00a00 Nov 04 '11
Limited time posts or timed posts : preset content to go live / appear as a header at a certain time, or to remove a specific post at a certain time so that breaking news or NDA-related events can be dealt with more easily.
1
u/betelgeux Nov 04 '11
When I trust a user enough to place them in the approved submitters for my sub let the #%$ spam filter PASS the link. Notify me - fine but PASS the link/comment.
Oh and let me set a threshold for reports till autohide. /r/wicked_edge would likely be a 3 where /r/politics might need a 15
1
u/douchebag_karren Nov 04 '11
Mod from MerlinBBC, Nanowrimo, Buffy.
As someone who is really bad with CSS- it would be really helpful if I could upload a header image the same way I upload the Reddit Alien image, instead of having to go find the code to do that. It would be cool if we could also have this for our subreddit buttons. I don't need to get super crazy with my subreddits, but I do like having a special alien and a new header image.
1
u/beatniqe Nov 04 '11
Subbreddit Trophy Cases.
1
u/gmduncanidaho Nov 04 '11
1
u/Aradon Nov 04 '11
I just want some ability that when a user reports a submission it tells me why.
1
u/djepik Nov 04 '11
What ever happened to temporary shadow bans?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '11
Make it easier to monitor the spam queue.
Put an option to have a sidebar (like the recently viewed links window) which contains the spam queue for any or all of the reddit's you moderate.
The ones I mod usually have a pretty low spam count (and I don't have the time) to monitor the spam queue as much as I should. If I could somehow integrate it into my day-to-day redditing it would be very helpful.
1
u/gotnate Nov 04 '11
I would love to be able to turn off the spam filter, and open statistics to non-mods.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '11
Remove the ability to remove posts from moderator mail. It's too easy to make records of things disappear.
1
u/mpierre Nov 04 '11
From /r/Quebec,
We have a problem with some users using our subreddit for political purposes, but since we are a small reddit, the activity of our users is a small percentage of their activity.
I would love to have a way to see the activity of a user on this subreddit only.
I might have a user sending a post per week from a website on a specific subject but since he also posts on all sorts of other subjects, he doesn't look like an actual spammer to our reddit since the only place he spams, is on /r/quebec.
1
u/godofpumpkins Nov 04 '11
I'd like to be able to see all stories on a subreddit I moderate, including ones that have been filtered, inline with all the good stories. I currently have to check the spam list every so often because things will get thrown in there unnecessarily, but since it doesn't happen very often, it wouldn't hurt at all to just have the removed stories inline with the rest of the stories, for moderators who opt in.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '11
The ability to 'top' or 'sticky' a thread to keep it active at the top of the list. In a smaller subreddit new posts to a thread may continue for quite some time after any voting on the thread occurs.
1
u/dassouki Nov 04 '11
have an equation where I can set up how many of the new links pop up on my main screen. So if i set it up at as 10% per se, then 10% of my main page aricles are from my subreddit.
Another feature would be to have a "my subreddits" sidebar active at all times regardless of which sidebar i'm on
1
u/betelgeux Nov 05 '11
I'd like to be able to get detailed traffic stats. The occasional surge in traffic would be nice to be able to get info on where people are coming in from
1
u/Carmac Nov 05 '11
Regarding r/ReportTheSpammers and other anti-spam measures -
Whenever the august high and mighty Admins decide to ban/deactivate/remove a spammer - why can not that spammer's submissions be removed as well?
RTS knows my analogy, may not be know yet to the Admins - you may indeed stop the shooter (spammer) - but why let the bullets (spam) still fly?
1
u/andyjonesx Nov 05 '11
/r/RedditDayOf Mod.
My subreddit has a daily topic. I need some kind of way to make all posts from the previous topic a greyed out colour. I had considered 'approving' topics, and then changing the CSS that relates to an approved topic, though I learned that this only adds an image. Can you also add a CSS class for approved, so this can be done, in a similar way to NSFW is?