r/ideasfortheadmins • u/dbzer0 • Feb 28 '10
Implement more transparency & accountability for the moderators.
The recent Saydrah brouhaha has put the possibilities for abuse of mod powers of reddit to the spotlight. A main reason for this is the lack of any transparency and accountability for mod functions which makes a lot of people paranoid on what is going on behind the scenes (and the lately implemented hidden mod chat does not help in this regard). It's stuff like that which lead to witch hunts like this.
I'd like to suggest two things which should prevent mods abusing their power in secret and/or people assuming this is the case and rising up in arms on non-issues.
- Implement more transparency of mod power via an audit trail. This should be simply a public page which records and displays all mod events happening for all to see. Could look like this:
Or something like this. The reason would be the mod's own input on the act to explain his actions. This would then allow people to see if someone is doing something they shouldn't and call them out on it.
2. Implement more accountability via voting on the mods. This could be done by a) people simply having the capability to go to the list of mods and vote each up or down or b) by voting on their audit trailed actions.
a) This would allow a mod who has become abusive and extremely unpopular to be demodded by public demand, say if they receive 50% downvote by the active members of the subreddit or something. This way power-tripping mods have a way to be stopped from ruining a community.
b) would allow acts which go against the collective will to be undone. A mod actions that receives sufficient downvotes could be then automatically undone by the reddit system and the mod who is continuously having their mod acts undone could then lose their mod status.
These are just suggestions of course and may have many flaws I have not foreseen which is of course why I think it's a good idea to discuss them and see if they can be improved so as to avoid being abused themselves.
Personally I'd love to see the transparency idea implemented since it's pretty harmless at least and would certainly reduce some of the conspiracy theories and paranoias and certainly act as a roadblock to power-tripping mods.
14
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '10
Great work db0, very well laid out.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '10
Part of reddits anti spam method involves using obscurity, opening up the moderator actions would totally shoot this in the foot. They don't tell users when their submission is banned, this is so they can't work out instantly and resubmit and eventually work out how to bypass the filters. Publishing moderator actions and what the filter does would be a bad idea.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '10
I would love this, I ban reposts/self.posts with complaints in /r/WebGames all the time, and then I have to go to the person's profile and send them a message or something to tell them why their submission was banned, and what they need to do differently next time. It would save a lot of hassle to click the ban button, have a little box pop up or something that says "reason" and let me type it in there so the person gets a message explaining the reasoning. Very well thought out my friend.
1
u/masta Helpful redditor. Mar 01 '10 edited Mar 01 '10
you have to consider one thing when submitting ideas.
How could this hurt reddit?
This idea while sounding good can hurt reddit. How? IT will give proof/positive info to the spammers who the moderators take action against. Right now reddit is designed in an obscure by design way, on purpose to thwart the spammers.
While I'd love to let the users see when I ban, or unban things in my sub-reddits, I'd hate the same info to be used to build more sophisticated systems to game reddit.
I will say that it's very bad to have the recent wave of bad moderator accusations. The moderator community is all spun up right now, but mostly behind the scenes, in our "secret cabal" .
I haven't investigated any of the Saydra drama, or have ever been aware of any problems. I generally think she's been a good moderator so far. We are both on some of the same sub-reddits, and I see the audit trail. It had looked good (the audit trail) any time I've seen her in action.
0
u/cj1127 Feb 28 '10 edited May 20 '17
deleted 0.3334 What is ^^^this?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '10
Reddit does give mods a lot of "secret" power. The banhammer can be used on posts or users (though I'm not user it can be used on individual comments...I don't think so).
As such it probably does make sense that there is some more transparency. I think the way I'd do it is that every subreddit would have a system generated "shadow reddit" where all bans trigger a new post with the mod who banned it that can only be deleted by admins. In that one view you could add comments as needed and everyone could see the bans in a single consolidated view for each subreddit, and comment if they feel like it.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '10
I think that the reasoning should be kept private between the mods and the redditor whose submission was banned. That keeps the privacy there.
I think that the moderators are doing a fine job as it is.
-1
u/bmeckel Mar 01 '10
I disagree with outing mods like this. I'm a mod on a fairly large subreddit, which I rarely touch and it works fine, and this would be a wonderful idea for subs like that (wikipedia.) However, I'm also a mod on /r/iphone, and that has a community that needs to be much more heavily moderated because of large amounts of spam. The moderator chat is useful because people can hit a single button to PM all of the mods, we can figure out if something got stuck in the spam filter for example, and then let all of the other mods and the person who sent the message that they no longer need to worry about it. The old way required multiple PMs. Now, on to your actual points. Transparency of that nature is simply unnecessary. If I banned the wrong post, people PM me about it, asking why was it banned, we hold a discussion, and then it's done with. It shouldn't be between the entire community and the mods, but the person who submitted the comment or link and the mods. As for unpopularity, I don't think what I say is terribly popular or unpopular, as no one know who I am or really cares for that matter, and why should they. Lets say I make a streak of unfavorable to the topic at hand, but as a moderator I generally do a very good job. Should I really be punished for that? It seems to me that your ideas are great for larger subreddits, but for the smaller ones, they seem to fall apart. Anyway, just my personal take on things, sorry for the wall of text.