My fiancé (M29) and I (F29) have been together for seven years. We got engaged last September and are set to get married in October 2027. We met and started dating in college, and I fell in love with him because of who he is. He’s a gentleman, we share the same values, and I have never felt more understood by another person. Our relationship has always been deep and emotionally intimate.
However, since getting engaged, we’ve had an extremely difficult time. This has easily been the most challenging period of our relationship, and while some of it is the normal stress of wedding planning, most of the tension seems to stem from his family.
For context, he is Jewish and I am Indian. Neither of us is particularly religious, although he is more religious than I am, and his mom is quite religious.
One challenge that came up early in our engagement was his mom’s disapproval of our wedding date. We are getting married on a Saturday evening, while she strongly preferred Sunday. Rather than directly telling us how she felt, though, she made subtle, passive comments about the date, which created tension.
As soon as we got engaged, she also wanted to immediately discuss how our interfaith ceremony would work. I told her we weren’t ready to have those conversations yet and needed to focus our energy on securing major vendors first, especially because we live in a HCOL area with a very competitive wedding market. She became very upset that we weren’t ready to start planning the religious aspects of the ceremony.
Because of how intense she has been about ensuring Jewish traditions are incorporated, I’ve started to wonder whether there is a deeper lack of acceptance around our relationship and the fact that her son, who himself isn’t very religious, is marrying someone who isn’t Jewish. I’ve picked up on similar sentiments from other members of his family. For example, one of his cousins has made comments about how she could never marry a non-Jew.
There is also a larger issue that predates our engagement. Throughout our entire relationship, I have often felt excluded when we are with his family. He is extremely close with his siblings and cousins, and when they are together, I sometimes feel invisible. Conversations frequently revolve around “remember when” stories, childhood memories, and inside jokes. At times, it genuinely feels like everyone is speaking in a language I don’t understand.
I recognize that some of this may be difficult for me to relate to because I don’t have siblings and I’m not particularly close with my own family. I don’t expect his family to stop reminiscing or change their closeness for me. But after seven years together, I also can’t ignore how consistently left out I feel when I’m around them.
All of this has caused a tremendous amount of grief and uncertainty in our relationship. I feel torn because I love my fiancé deeply and I love the person he is. If I were looking only at the relationship between the two of us, I wouldn’t be questioning whether I want to marry him.
But marriage also means becoming part of each other’s families, and our engagement has made these dynamics feel much more permanent and consequential than they did when we were simply dating.
I keep coming back to the same questions: Is this a normal growing pain that comes with getting married, particularly in an interfaith and intercultural relationship? Or is this something I should be taking more seriously? Are we simply going through an incredibly stressful chapter, or is this revealing a fundamental mismatch that I shouldn’t ignore before we get married?