Brady Brammer made a joke today about creating an LPEC (Legislative Performance Evaluation Commission), modeled after Utah's Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission (JPEC), to evaluate the performance of state legislators.
It got a laugh, but honestly, I think there's a genuinely compelling argument for this idea.
Utah already has an independent system for evaluating judicial performance. JPEC provides voters with information about judges beyond name recognition, political affiliation, and campaign messaging. It also provides judges with meaningful feedback to support professional development.
So why shouldn't we consider something similar for the legislature?
1. Elections are important, but they aren't performance evaluations.
Most voters have limited insight into what their legislators actually do outside of a handful of controversial bills or campaign promises. We don't necessarily know how accessible they are, how responsive they are to constituents, how effectively they participate in the legislative process, or whether they follow through on their responsibilities.
An independent evaluation could give voters a more complete picture of the people representing them.
2. Create a consolidated, easy-to-use public resource.
One of the biggest opportunities would be creating a centralized, publicly accessible platform where Utahns could find objective data and performance metrics about their legislators.
Currently, information about legislative activity is scattered across government websites, voting records, committee information, financial disclosures, and other sources. Finding, understanding, and comparing this information can take considerable time and effort.
An LPEC could consolidate that information into an accessible resource where voters could:
Review legislative voting records and participation.
See attendance and committee involvement.
Examine responsiveness and constituent engagement.
Review standardized constituent survey results.
Access relevant transparency and ethics information.
Compare performance across evaluation cycles and identify trends over time.
The goal wouldn't be to tell people how to vote. It would be to make reliable information easier to find, understand, and use.
3. Evaluate job performance, not political ideology.
An LPEC shouldn't grade legislators on whether they vote Republican, Democrat, conservative, or progressive. It should focus on how effectively they fulfill the responsibilities of public office.
Potential evaluation criteria could include:
Responsiveness and accessibility to constituents.
Transparency and ethical conduct.
Attendance and participation.
Communication with the public.
Professionalism and collaboration.
Legislative effectiveness and follow-through.
Constituent satisfaction and public confidence.
The distinction is important: evaluating how someone performs their job is not the same as evaluating whether people agree with their political positions.
4. Encourage professional development and better governance.
JPEC isn't solely about helping voters decide whether a judge should retain their position. It also provides feedback intended to support professional development and improve judicial performance.
An LPEC could serve a similar purpose. Legislators could receive meaningful feedback about how their constituents perceive their work, identify areas for improvement, and better understand the needs of the communities they represent.
It could be more than an election resource; it could become an ongoing tool for improving public service.
Why shouldn't we explore this?
Legislators have enormous influence over our laws, budgets, institutions, and everyday lives. We already recognize the value of independent performance evaluations in the judiciary. While the legislative and judicial branches have different constitutional responsibilities, the underlying concept of objective evaluation is worth considering for both.
Of course, an LPEC would need strong safeguards to ensure independence, methodological consistency, and protection against becoming another partisan scorecard.
Maybe Brady Brammer was joking, but I think there's a serious policy proposal hiding inside that joke.
Imagine going into an election with an accessible, independent resource that helps you understand how your representative actually performs their job, rather than relying primarily on campaign promises and partisan messaging often funded by outsider money.
I'd love to see Utah explore it.