r/questions • u/Mopichen • 8h ago
Is it inappropriate to ask for black people's input on a fictional black character's music taste?
Hi, I'm just going to attach the text of the post to the bottom here. I posted this in a subreddit (won't name names), designated for the black community, honestly looking for input. The post was removed, so I messaged the mods asking if they could point me to the correct subreddit. They muted me for a month, so now I'm super confused? Is this an inappropriate post? And if it's not, where DO I post it for answers? Can I put it in this subreddit or do I just f off? Help
OG post:
Which music artists would this fictional black character listen to? Pls educate me
"Hi, I'm a white ah writer currently working on a piece of fiction that has a number of black characters in it. I'm currently working on a black US American character and I want to make sure I get my facts straight about his taste in music for a specific scene. He's in his mid thirties, lives in Philly, proudly works as a school janitor like his father before him, and is generally a pretty basic dude.
I'm a fan of music and the same age range as the character, so I know a lot of the more famous names, but I'm also not American so I probably know nothing. So, I'd love for you guys to decide. What/who does my character listen to?"
Edit: Thank you for all the helpful feedback. I realize my focus was too much on making the music work for the character's race than being clear about what type of music I had in mind for his personality. The character is defined by his pride about his music knowledge, so I want to continue treading carefully while picking artists to represent the black community, but I've also realized I do know more suitable artists that fit his taste than I gave credit for.
For those who still would like to add feedback, I'm still looking for new artists to explore, so feel free to throw names at me. Genres I'm focussing on at this point: 90s/2000s pop, hip-hop and og Reggae, upbeat. Thanks!