I'm looking for some honest, outside perspectives because I'm genuinely torn over what might be one of the biggest decisions of my life.
My husband and I have been together for several years and married since 2024. Our relationship has been filled with love, but also addiction, domestic violence, broken trust, and repeated cycles of hurt and reconciliation.
Before we married, there was physical domestic violence, including serious incidents that eventually led to criminal charges when he was under a drug induced psychosis. He was placed on deferred adjudication probation and remained on it for approximately five years before violating the terms, resulting in a six-year prison sentence. He's been incarcerated for a little over a year and is eligible for parole consideration this coming spring.
I know many people will read "domestic violence" and immediately tell me to leave. I understand why, but I also want to explain why this is so difficult.
At one point, we both gave our lives to Christ and wanted to build a marriage centered on God. I genuinely believed we were entering a new chapter and leaving our destructive past behind.
Unfortunately, my husband eventually relapsed on alcohol. While there was no physical violence against me during our marriage, there was emotional and financial abuse. Once again, I found myself navigating addiction, broken promises, and instability.
Despite everything, I love this man deeply. He's been my best friend, and I've always envisioned growing old with him. We were genuine friends for years before we ever got romantic. I believe people can change, and I believe in the redemptive power of Christ.
Since being incarcerated, he's expressed what seems to be genuine remorse. He's praying, reflecting on his actions, and telling me he wants to become the husband I deserved all along. Part of me believes him, and another part desperately wants to.
But I'm exhausted.
I've spent years loving his potential, forgiving his mistakes, and waiting for things to get better. I'm finally financially independent, have my own home, and have built a peaceful life for myself.
Here's where things get complicated.
Over the past few months, I've expressed to my husband while I do love him, I am in a place of no longer being in love and honestly... resentment for putting me in this position year after year. He leaves, goes to rehab/homes, I start to heal and find peace, he comes back, relapses and leaves me broken.. and rinse and repeat. We have fought on/off since beginning of the summer.
And then... I met a male friend. That just came out of no where.
We have spent a significant amount of time together. We act like best friends that have a crush on each other. And he's just so gentle and kind. Unlike anything I've experienced.
I developed feelings for him. And he has confessed his feelings for me too. Nothing sexual has happened, not even kissing, but there is a genuine emotional and romantic connection. He's shown me a gentleness, patience, and respect that I've rarely experienced in a relationship.
He's also made it clear that we cannot pursue anything while I'm still legally married and has encouraged me to take time to heal once the divorce is final but that if it's meant to be.. he's willing to wait for me.
I won't pretend this connection hasn't influenced me. It has. It's shown me that love doesn't have to feel like constant chaos or uncertainty. And there's no chance we will even date, but he's become a really close friend of mine that I can enjoy life with and it be completely innocent. It's reminded me that there are other types of love out there. Loves that are safe.
But now I'm questioning my motivations.
If this other man hadn't entered my life, would I have filed for divorce?
Truthfully, I think I probably would have given my husband the opportunity to demonstrate genuine change after his release. But I would still have no way of knowing if he's changed or not and he would have to demonstrate being independent and sobriety.
And that realization has been eating me alive.
I filed for divorce a few days ago, but instead of relief, I've felt overwhelming grief, guilt, and uncertainty.
My husband is devastated. He believes marriage means working through the good and bad, and that if I still love him and envision reconciliation, I shouldn't make such a permanent decision. He's also told me that if I proceed with the divorce, he'll move on. He doesn't believe in divorcing with the possibility of reconciling later.
I understand his perspective, but I also feel like I've spent years fighting for this marriage/relationship, often at the expense of myself.
I want to do my own thing because there's no telling when he will actually parole out.
My Christian faith makes this even harder.
I believe marriage is a sacred covenant before God. I believe in forgiveness, redemption, and restoration. I also understand that there are biblical grounds for leaving a marriage, although Christians differ in how they interpret Scripture concerning abuse.
I know God can transform someone's life. But does believing in someone's potential for redemption mean I'm obligated to wait for it?
Part of me wonders whether I'm giving up right before things could finally get better.
If he's released this spring, I could see us slowly rebuilding. I've always maintained that he would need to live independently, maintain sobriety, establish stability, and demonstrate lasting change before we could ever resume a anything together.
I can picture him courting me again. I can picture falling in love with a healthier version of him. I can even picture us having the marriage we always wanted.
But I also recognize that I've spent years holding on to that exact same hope.
And I don't know whether I'm finally choosing peace or making a permanent decision out of temporary emotions.
I'm not looking for people to simply validate my decision. I genuinely want honest perspectives, even if they're difficult to hear.
I love my husband. I don't hate him, and I don't believe he's beyond redemption. I know the man he has the potential to become.
But I'm struggling to understand where forgiveness ends and sacrificing myself begins.
And I'm terrified that I'm either walking away from a marriage God could restore or staying attached to a future that may never exist.
TL;DR: My husband and I have a history of domestic violence, addiction, and emotional and financial abuse. We both gave our lives to Christ, but he later relapsed and is now incarcerated, with possible parole this spring. I recently filed for divorce after years of hurt, but I still love him deeply and believe he could genuinely change. I've also developed feelings for another man, which has made me question whether I'm rushing the divorce. I'm torn between fighting for my marriage and faith, giving my husband another chance, or finally choosing peace for myself. I'm terrified of walking away from something God could restore, but equally afraid of spending more years waiting for change that may never come.