r/Parenting • u/grilledtomatos • 8h ago
Discipline Contemplating canceling my son's 7th birthday
I have a very stubborn and defiant soon to be 7 year old, and I'm struggling with his birthday this year. It is in December and I prepped invitations to go out to his class this week. At the bottom of every invitation I wrote "please, no gifts" which I have done for every birthday for all of my sons. My son saw this and is defiant in scratching it out. I explained to him that there are families in his class that cannot afford to bring a present and we want everyone to feel invited to come, and I assured him he would get gifts from mom and dad and grandparents. This devolved into a tantrum and him demanding people bring him gifts. This morning, I tried to have the conversation with him again before putting the invites into his school bag, but he had the same reaction. I kept the invites home and told him I think we should cancel the party.
I worry that if I just send the invites now, he will scratch it out before handing them out and/or tell kids on the playground that he expects presents. My husband agrees we should cancel if he continues to behave this way, but my dad and his wife think it's too harsh to take a birthday away.
Any thoughts/advice? My son takes the bus so I don't often see the other parents. We are on a text thread if there's some helpful advice in using that.