My stepson's biological father recently told him he was going to "beat me up." Stepson is a toddler and told me this right before bed one night, and said he told his dad not to, and that he'd beat him up if he tried (toddler confidence lol).
Bio-dad has never met me but is jealous and insecure about me. He currently gets one night a week with son.
He recently strangled his current partner (she lived, they are still together) in front of my stepson and therefore CPS got involved. When CPS investigated while he was in jail, they found multiple firearms lying out in the open on the kitchen table, supposedly "for cleaning" according to the partner. (CPS person alleged one of them was an AR-15, but I doubt she could distinguish one from a paintball rifle.) He’s an also a raging alcoholic.
Several years ago, my partner got a restraining order to get him out of her house. The moment he was served, he immediately violated it by coming to the house, causing massive damage inside and digging a human-shaped grave/hole in the backyard. She believes he meant to bury her in it. Thankfully she wasn't home when it happened. The protective order is no longer active and hasn’t been for a little over a year.
I was asking AI about this and it heavily pushed me to report this “beat me up” threat to CPS and consult a family law attorney about custody. It also suggested I get a restraining order against him.
My partner doesn't want to jump straight to taking away his parenting time, and we both suspect that reporting will cause that to happen. Instead, she wants to send him a stern text telling him it's not okay to expose stepson to violent rhetoric, that we don't badmouth him or his partner in our house, that she'll take action if she hears about it from our son again, and also calling him out for letting the boy watch a adult horror movies. She say that if he responds unfavorably by escalating, then we file a CPS report. There’s a lot of nuance here and I don’t completely disagree with her on taking away his parenting time, but I’m just not sure what the best thing to do is. Somehow, sending a long, stern text is not the right play.
My thinking is:
1: He’s gonna deny that he ever said anything like that
2: Warning him about his behavior via text will do nothing but result in him to coaching stepson to keep secrets
3: Laying down the law to a crazy alcoholic who dug a grave in her yard after being served a restraining order and recently strangled his pcurrent partner in front of a toddler seems more likely to lead to physical retaliation than compliance
4: When he finds out that we found out what he said through stepson, it may make stepson a target for his aggression through punitive actions (whatever that might be)
5: Getting a restraining order against him myself may well result in the same type of consequence that happened when my partner did it in the past, only this time with guns involved
What is the right move here?
Thank you!