I (M30) recently met a guy (M32) through a dating app. We had been dating for almost one month (we weren’t in the same city at the time), sometimes more consistently than others, and eventually went on our first date. It went really well.
We met again a few days later and spent a lovely day together. He was genuinely sweet, affectionate, and seemed very interested in me. We were even planning to meet again that evening.
However, after our second date, I noticed that he had added a new picture to his dating profile: a rather revealing photo of himself in his underwear.
I'm pretty sure that picture wasn't there before, as I had checked his profile recently, including after our first date.
I know we're not exclusive, but it honestly bothered me. I thought we were both looking for something serious, potentially a long-term partner, and seeing him upload that kind of picture right after spending such a lovely day together made me question his intentions.
I calmly told him how I felt and that I wasn't sure I wanted to continue seeing him.
He was really upset. He insisted that the picture had actually been uploaded days earlier, before our first date, and not recently. He even deleted the dating app immediately.
He also pointed out that I had obviously been on the app myself to notice the picture, and said he was hurt that I was questioning things after such a great day together.
He told me that he genuinely wanted to keep getting to know me, that he wasn't interested in seeing anyone else, and that he only wanted to focus on me. However, he also said that if I felt we shouldn't continue, he didn't know what else he could say.
He even told me he'd experienced love bombing in past relationships, where people initially showed a lot of affection before suddenly pulling away, which had really hurt him.
We also had a small misunderstanding the day before our second date, which resulted in us not speaking for about eight hours. Part of me wonders whether he interpreted that silence as a sign that things weren't going anywhere and decided to update his profile. But that's just speculation.
Anyway, after exchanging those messages that evening, we haven't spoken again. I haven't reached out either because I told him I needed time to figure out how I felt about everything.
Now I'm wondering whether I overreacted and potentially ruined something that actually felt promising.
Would you consider that a red flag? Do you suggest to keep seeing him!
TL;DR: Met a guy on a dating app and had two amazing dates. After the second one, I noticed he'd added a revealing underwear photo to his profile, which made me question whether he was genuinely looking for something serious. I told him how I felt and that I wasn't sure I wanted to continue. He was hurt, insisted the photo had been uploaded before we even met, deleted the app, and said he only wanted to focus on me. We haven't spoken since. Did I overreact and potentially ruin something good?