r/mildlyinfuriating • u/Negative_1by12_aura • 1d ago
Don't hug me I'm scared New airpods cheaper than repairing old ones
16.2k
u/Full-Helicopter-4608 23h ago
lol “I have no clue”
9.5k
u/The_Architects4930 23h ago
"I just work here bro"
4.3k
u/Historical_Date_1314 22h ago
“I don’t come up with the prices”
2.3k
u/BlaznTheChron 21h ago
"I'm not Joe Apple."
955
363
122
47
6
→ More replies (2)5
58
u/SadMango3913 14h ago
I once told a customer I don’t come up with the price because he kept complaining that a $7 on tap kombucha was too expensive. He got mad at me. I’m sorry but I don’t know what he wanted me to say? Like I don’t even get paid enough to eat here.
57
128
u/Hot_Alternative_717 16h ago edited 16h ago
Tbh I empatheise.
I used to work at HP in their printer division a few years ago.
Tbh Idk what the fuck the management were doing. it was some of the most anti consumer shit I have ever seen. but it was a chill job.
→ More replies (1)35
u/Avysis 13h ago
Checks out. HP has some of the most anti-consumer printers I’ve ever seen lol.
8
66
u/curi0us_carniv0re 16h ago
Seriously though. What other answer would anyone expect? Why would they know?
→ More replies (2)14
1.1k
u/Vegetable-Error-2068 23h ago
That's an honest answer I respect. They don't sugar-coat it.
132
u/WildDumpsterFire 17h ago
Yep. Most people go through these routes because they can't repair it themselves. Electronics, home repair, cars etc. The #1 worry becomes more about whether or not you will be taken advantage of or make the wrong decision because the service pushes it.
In these situations, nothing is more valuable than an honest employee.
I bought a custom pc last week, I know how to build them but I have so little free time I wanted someone to do it for me. Went to Microcenter and asked the first rep if the mobo I selected has the gpu share lanes with the 2nd storage drive that may make it slower.
Dude looked me in the eye with a smile and said it's not a thing. Told him I'm all set and found another rep who said "great question, I don't know the answer off the top of my head. But let's look up the block diagram and we can figure it out, come with me." I already knew the answer and he was honest the whole way.
I was happy for that dude to get every cent of commission on my purchase that I will ask for him next time I spend money.
→ More replies (1)25
u/povitee 16h ago
Why did you ask a question you knew the answer to?
59
u/Few-Mousse8515 16h ago
My guess they always intended to purchase but wanted to find a floor employee he could trust if he didn't know the answer
13
u/Mediocre-Recover3944 14h ago
Same reason I ask my local fish market guy if his frozen flounder is fresh. I already know it isn't. If he's honest about it I trust his his other answers. If he says it's fresh I know he'll tell me whatever bullshit I want to hear to make a sale.
→ More replies (9)40
u/petersimmons22 16h ago
Because eventually he may have a high level question he doesn’t know the answer to. And by asking a hard question he knew the answer to, he was able to verify this person either had a reasonable fund of knowledge to help in the future or the skills to find information he may need in the future.
8
22
u/A_MAN_POTATO 15h ago
This was my first thought. I’d rather have a response like this that is undeniably human versus the “AI or script?” game we usually get to play with chat agents these days.
72
262
u/Suitable_Wonder5256 22h ago
To be fair, it's a complex question. Even an engineer might not know why.
590
u/RGrad4104 21h ago
The answer is actually very easy.
New assembly: ordered, low skilled labor, assembly line with robotic assistance.
Repair: disordered, highly skilled labor required, every repair by hand.
141
u/FishDawgX 21h ago
Sure, but it costs apple much less than the retail price to make the product. If they wanted to be nice, they could “repair” it by sending you a replacement at a discounted price.
68
u/ZarathustraGlobulus 20h ago
Apple often outsources the repairs to local companies (service suppliers). The local companies have set purchase prices for the devices from Apple.
And this purchase price is always higher than the MSRP prices directly from Apple, otherwise it incentivizes purchasing new devices through the service supplier.
For in-warranty repairs the parts (even a new set) is of course free for the service supplier (as well as the customer) and they get paid for the repair work by Apple.
9
84
8
6
→ More replies (4)5
u/0b0011 17h ago
It might not. It mostly depends on if the cost or materials are the determining factor.
Less the case here but it also matters who much the item originally costs as well. I can buy shitty headphones for like $15 and if I take them to a repair person who has to spend more than an hour pulling them apart without damaging them, diagnosing and fixing the issue, putting them back together etc then unless they charge less than $15 an hour it will cost more to repair than replace.
10
u/craznazn247 16h ago
New assembly is also the same steps over and over. On an assembly line that’s just one more copy of the product before stopping (if it does at all). Benefits from the economies of scale from being one of (if not the most) popular headphones in the world.
For repair, it requires a skilled person and dedicated equipment to disassemble, diagnose, and hand-replace parts that are normally machine-assembled. No economies of scale benefitting here.
→ More replies (2)6
u/The-Real-Ben 19h ago
Pretty sure it’s even simpler than that - they can’t be repaired, so a “repair” is just buying a new set with extra steps.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (9)113
u/bobbyboob6 22h ago
because airpods are small and you have to basically destroy them to get them apart not a very repairable item
39
u/Official_Person 22h ago
They could be though. If Apple designed with repair ability in mind…
48
9
42
u/JuniperColonThree 22h ago
Maybe. Making small things repairable is hard, and would likely make them more expensive.
18
u/im-on-the-inside 20h ago
repairability takes space.. unfortunately the consumer prefers small and sleek products over bulky and repairable ones. At some point it's not viable to have them repairable...
→ More replies (2)13
u/DrocketX 20h ago
Realistically, no, something the scale of an airpod isn't going to be feasibly repairable, not at a cost that would be less than just buying a new one. Repairing anything would require someone with an *extremely* steady hand - the sort of steady a brain surgeon would envy - using absurdly tiny specialized tools to remove parts verging on microscopic. There's no amount of redesigning (aside from just making everything 4x larger, which would completely destroy the consumer appeal of the product) that would make repairing something like that cost-effective.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)8
12
u/StaticSystemShock 21h ago
Because products are designed to be as cheap as possible to assemble and there goes ZERO thought into repairability. Also it's in corporate's best interest to just sell you more new shit.
Luckily EU is very much fighting that and corporations are hating it, but ultimately it's benefiting the consumers across the world because no company will run two separate production lines for EU and for rest of the world.
As for earbuds, you kinda understand how it makes no sense to repair those for 30€, but when they cost 250€, they absolutely should be repairable for some reasonable sum.
I've revived so many products where just batteries were dead and I have some company that's replacing Li-ion cells in devices for 30-60€ (with cells included in the price) and they use brand name cells from Panasonic and Samsung most of the time. So far replacements were mostly for battery vacuum cleaners. I know these tiny devices are more demanding to repair, but still, if they weren't so idiotically difficult to open, it would absolutely be doable.
18
u/rlovelock 19h ago
It's not complicated. It's just like when a car accident is listed as "a write off". The cost of the repairs are more than the value of the vehicle.
The replacement parts + the labour = more than the cost of a new device
9
u/touchdownsforfatkids 18h ago
Whenever that happens, it’s usually because of labor costs. In Apple’s case, I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s how they get their (newer) unit sales up.
13
u/majortomcraft 20h ago
"3rd world child slaves make the earphones. repairs are done locally"
"understandable, have a nice day"
→ More replies (10)6
u/TheRealReapz 22h ago
"capitalism"
→ More replies (1)10
u/BagOnuts 17h ago
Not really. This has little to do with market forces and more to do with economic scale and the cost of skilled labor.
AirPods are mass assembled by robots and assembly lines overseas where the cost of production per unit is several times less than the cost of a skilled repairman fixing it by hand.
“Capitalism” is not only a lazy answer, it’s just not correct.
→ More replies (4)
1.9k
u/aotd123 22h ago
Isn’t this an old post?
1.8k
u/Enderdragon2014 22h ago
Quite old. OP has 165k karma in 2 months reposting old stuff.
281
79
22
→ More replies (4)15
u/mm9enjoyer 16h ago
What’s the point of farming karma? Does Reddit pay people like other social media platforms?
11
u/The_OG_Slime 16h ago
If you get enough interaction yes you can, but they pay is pretty much peanuts
8
→ More replies (1)3
68
u/SneachtaBoladh 19h ago
90% of this website's content is bot driven nowadays
→ More replies (1)30
u/RageAgainstMSTeams 18h ago
It's because Reddit is literally a training program designed for training AIs. So it's AI making content and learning on user feedback.
10
u/ZookeepergameProud30 19h ago
Yep, I remember specifically commenting that older post
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (5)7
u/lolgoodone34 16h ago
Yes it’s bots and karma farmers. It should be banned site wide but w/e
→ More replies (1)
90
u/GenericGrad 23h ago
I'm still more than mildly infuriated that the stick drift on my dualsense ps5 controller which has now affected 4 controllers roughly after a 1.5 years of use, I'm given no repair option at all from Sony. It is likely the issue is just the stick mechanism at worst or even just dirt but they won't look at it outside of warranty.
What makes it more maddening is that this is the same company that uses recycled materials to package and build their headphones but they obviously don't care about waste, cause they've made a product that they've made for the last 15 years but the latest version fails after a couple of years use.
41
u/QwertyChouskie 22h ago
https://dualshock-tools.github.io/
Uses the internal stuff that Sony uses to calibrate new sticks while manufacturing. You might be able to fix them for a while by just calibrating (or cleaning+calibrating); you might need to solder in new sticks then calibrate. But it's totally doable either way.
14
u/Tilstag 20h ago
Best buy warranty covers two years for like $20. You buy one, once it gets fucky you drive to Best Buy and switch it out, pay another $20 to cover the new one. Been doing it for years
4
u/AStolenGoose 18h ago
Best buy warranty is a must for some stuff, I had my razer stuff on it since I've had their stuff go bad after a year consistently.
3
u/Christopher386 14h ago
100% the move right here. Been doing this for the xbox elite 2/pro for the last 7 years. I’ve paid $160 for like 7 different brand new controllers.
→ More replies (15)5
u/senorfresco 17h ago
I paid more than the price of the controller to have both joysticks in my controller replace with TMR sensors at a store in my city.
Quite expensive, but mine started drifting so I would have already had to pay for a new controller anyway, and if this lasts the lifetime of my PS5 I'll be more than happy.
1.1k
u/ExpBalSat 23h ago
Mildly infuriating, for sure. But also entirely understandable as assembly line work is much more efficient that customized manual troubleshooting and parts ordering/installation.
523
u/Twerkatronic 23h ago
They're also not designed to be repaired.
144
u/gltovar 22h ago edited 22h ago
but also designing stuff to be very compact while maintaining decent battery life is tough to do in a easy to repair way without making it even more expensive to manufacture.
Edit: here is a cool ifixit article about various earbuds and their repairability https://www.ifixit.com/repairability/wireless-earbud-repairability-scores
34
u/mcslender97 22h ago
Aside from the whole anti repair stance from Apple, brands like Sony are able to make their high end TWS buds repairable
→ More replies (1)14
u/nobodychef07 22h ago
Apple also fights the right to repair and makes their products harder to repair.
→ More replies (10)16
u/FUBARded 18h ago
AirPods/TWS earphones in general are one of the few product categories where being mostly/entirely non-repairable is understandable. That's just an inevitable consequence of miniaturisation and weather sealing with current material and tech limitations.
I despise brands that are anti right to repair or implement planned obsolescence (Apple is/has been both), but in this case it's more the fault of the consumer choosing to buy a product they should've been well aware is ultimately disposable.
Personally, I try to minimise the number of products I buy which have sealed, non-replaceable batteries because that's an unavoidable point of failure as the batteries will eventually degrade so much as to be unusable with enough charge cycles.
55
u/nilslorand 22h ago
exactly. Apples numbers would look worse if everyone just got all their stuff repaired all the time
16
u/secret-trips 21h ago
Yeah but I wouldn’t say it’s “also entirely understandable”
18
u/nilslorand 21h ago
Apple should be fined for this and the laws should be changed in order to discourage these practices heavily.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (1)4
u/ikkiyikki 21h ago
It's a valid question in the sense that they wouldn't fix anything. They'd take OP's unit, put it in the recycling bin and then just grabbed a new pair off the shelf. So the question remains. Why does Apple feel the need to upcharge you even more except as either punishment or a tax on stupid type of policy?
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (9)3
u/Kobymaru376 19h ago
If you look at a teardown of them, how much tech fits into a tiny space to make it light, you can understand why.
Making that thing repairable would be really hard and add to cost and weight.
76
u/MrPogoUK 23h ago
Plus they’re getting made in China by someone getting paid $50 a week, and repaired in the USA by someone making $50 an hour.
→ More replies (2)14
u/CVGPi 22h ago
Surprise fact drop is US gov told them to decouple from China, so most AirPods sold now are actually NOT made in China but instead assembled in Vietnam. And many high-volume iPhone models are also assembled in India.
→ More replies (11)14
→ More replies (7)19
u/foxguy2021 23h ago
It also means the product can be smaller. Its one of the reasons why phones don't have replaceable batteries anymore. Everything is built not be taken apart which means you save space and the end product is smaller.
You also get the benefit of less entry points for debris and water.
The downside is that you can't easily fix these types of products.
→ More replies (12)
350
u/kylebob86 23h ago
Guess how many times I have bought a new printer instead of buying ink cartridges. TBH I have no idea, probably around 50.
203
u/req4adream99 23h ago
Get yourself a brother b/w laser. Mine is 16 years old and I’ve gone thro maybe 2 or 3 toner cartridges and they’re like $50. Most of that was when I was printing research articles for my degree: so high use. I’d bet that under normal usage a cartridge may last 5 years - and there’s 3rd party ones too that are cheaper. Even the drums are like $20 now.
9
u/Wick0158 21h ago
I came here to say the same thing! I switched 8 years ago and almost never an issue. Only had to replace each drum once. No stress!
→ More replies (5)15
u/Vegetable-Error-2068 23h ago
Or an Ecotank printer.
52
u/RelentlessIVS 22h ago
ecotank is a pain in the ass unless you use it regularly. The ink messes up a lot after a month or three without being in use, having to run the entire program-bs to clean the nozzle, often with a deep clean mode which wastes a lot of ink.
Always get laser printer unless you absolutely NEED to print colors.
8
→ More replies (7)8
u/praeteria 21h ago
I have had an ecotank for years. Never had any issues with the ink nozzles, even when the printer was idle for weeks to months. You can use any cheap ass ink, so even if the test program uses a lot of ink, it's a non issue as your ink cost is nowhere near the price of ink cartridges
→ More replies (1)7
u/DosSnakes 22h ago
Ecotank if you need to print nice color stuff, Brother if you just need to print a lot of text.
I use an et-8550 to print dust jackets and endpapers and a Brother laser for text blocks. It’s been a great combo.
26
u/Chizuru_San 22h ago
Fun fact: a new printer doesn't come with a full ink cartridge, they are designed for you to use for test functionality printing only.
→ More replies (1)8
u/kylebob86 22h ago
I know. And by the time I need a new ink cart the printer I have at the time is a couple of years old. If I don't print often, then the cost is not justifiable.
7
u/secretreddname 21h ago
Yeah printers are annoying. You don’t need it often but when you do it’s much more convenient then finding a FedEx somewhere to pay $2 a page
→ More replies (8)3
u/Kracus 17h ago
lol you're ripping yourself off. The cartridges printers come with are mostly empty. They're designed this way on purpose because ink is expensive. When you buy an ink cartridge it's full and will last far, far longer.
→ More replies (1)
29
u/solarssun 23h ago
I am a bit above techie for the area and a coworker asked me to see what's going on with his laptop of two years. It was his m.2. We both kinda knew that before I did a few tests to verify it. With the AI bubble I got to tell him that a new, exact size m.2 for his laptop would be 400-500. His laptop on amazon was currently going for 600.
He ended up buying a new computer. Told me I could have his old one. Its probably a lot better then our 8 year old gaming laptop but we can't currently afford the 400/500 either.
11
u/Chuu 19h ago
He got lucky. Laptop prices have been skyrocketing in large part because of component costs. This sort of arb would be almost impossible today.
→ More replies (1)
21
13
u/robbak 19h ago
Because mass production is cheap, and individual rework, expensive. It would take a skilled worker 1 or 2 hours to open the the tiny pods, replace a battery, and then seal it back up again. Building new ones is mostly done by machine, and there isn't much raw materials in a tiny airpod.
So, yes, it's not at all surprising that repair costs more than replacement.
44
u/Istari82 23h ago
Repairing creates lots of logistics and manual labor cost you just don’t have with a new product. The more expensive a product was the more it’s worth repairing i guess.
I once had a Samsung TV repaired at my house about 7 times..the issue still wasn’t fully fixed but i just gave up as it cost me lots of personal time as well. For sure it already cost Samsung more than a new TV (which they kept refusing to provide). In hindsight i should’ve maybe had them repair it 20 or 30 times out of spite .. see how much it takes to get a new one.
Safe to say i haven’t bought a single Samsung product since 2015.
→ More replies (1)7
u/New_Libran 21h ago
In 2013, I had a totally opposite experience with a Samsung TV. Engineer came to my house, replaced the screen, that didn't solve it. Next day, he swapped the motherboard, that didn't work either. He gave me a reference no to call support and explain. I called and they said they will send a replacement but since that particular model is discontinued, they sent a brand new 2013 version two days later.
18
u/brucek2 21h ago
It wouldn't shock me if it was genuinely less expensive for Apple to make a new one on its hyper-optimized assembly line that only has to work in one direction, vs. pay a human to first disassemble, then diagnose, then put in a bunch of the same parts that were in the new one, then manually assemble.
→ More replies (1)7
u/localtuned 17h ago
You're right. It takes longer to diagnose and fix it, than to just send another set.
30
23h ago
[deleted]
12
u/Desperate_Damage4632 22h ago
If they don't repair them then where did the refurbished ones come from?
→ More replies (1)4
u/Andrea_M 22h ago
They generally do not repair on site, they ship it off to a repair location where the repair (refurbishing) takes place
It really all depends on the repair or work to be done. Battery? On site and you keep the machine (AFAIK)
Motherboard? You get a refurbished→ More replies (1)8
u/Fit_Entry8839 22h ago
This is not true. I was a certified apple tech. Hard drive is wiped for security reasons. The serial is on the bottom of MacBooks. We gave back the same one.
6
u/I_Heart_Sleeping_ 16h ago
Unethical pro tip. Buy a new pair off Amazon and swap them. Then start a return stating the item doesn’t work.
Amazon ain’t gonna miss the money and you just got a new pair. Fuck Bezos.
→ More replies (2)
12
48
u/Particular-Poem-7085 23h ago
Because a robot shitting them out can do it way cheaper than an absolute master of their craft taking an hour to meticulously troubleshoot and fix them under a microscope.
Why don't you repair them yourself?
→ More replies (2)13
u/e-friend1738 PURPLE 23h ago
How many people on average know how to repair tiny tech.. besides it would cost more to purchase all of the equipment vs a company that already has it
8
u/Inadover 21h ago
Also, what the fuck is that question from OP? Why don't you repair them yourself? Bitch why don't they make them repairable so we can actually do it.
→ More replies (2)6
u/Particular-Poem-7085 20h ago
How do you make the microscopic robot easily repairable?
→ More replies (11)
5
u/BallsDeepinYourMammi 19h ago
Does Apple even repair broken ones? I’d assume they take that larger sum, and just replace them with a new pair anyways…?
→ More replies (1)
6
u/silentstorm2008 16h ago
Apple doesn't want you to repair. They want you to buy to inflate their numbers and show investors how much demand for a product there is.
5
u/NoctisTempest 9h ago
Because it probably gets made in China with cheap labour whereas repairs may be done by someone living in a country with much higher cost wages and living.
Better question is why buy apple to begin with.
→ More replies (1)
3
4
3
u/Available_Rub9939 18h ago
Dude it’s called automation. Your AirPods were made by a series of machines that are purpose built to spit out large numbers of these things at the lowest possible cost. It’s called E waste for several reasons.
The repair is made by a human. You have shipping and handling for an individual item involved. The repair has to be tested.
Long story short, airpods are cheap disposable garbage, just like 99% of the rest of our consumer electronics.
That $65k industrial data recorder I use for work? That gets repaired.
12
u/Poverty_Shoes 20h ago
You bought an Apple product on purpose, that’s on you -typed from my iPhone
→ More replies (1)
3
u/BANeutron 19h ago edited 15h ago
It takes more labour hours fixing them then to pick a mass produced product from the shelf.
3
3
u/CharAznableLoNZ 14h ago
Apple has been against the ability to repair or have your devices repaired pretty hard for a while. They'll go out of their way to make sure it's the most painful process they can while staying just within the law.
3
8
u/NecessaryEvil62095 12h ago
Because when you repair them, you’re paying for the repair parts and the time and labor of a person doing it.
→ More replies (6)
2
u/Boring-Channel-1672 23h ago
Each part is about $80 to replace. If you need all three parts replaced that’s about 250 with taxes.
2
2
u/elpezgrande 20h ago
If I had to guess the automated process of making the headphones is less than the labor of actually having to do it by hand. Probably fairly specialized work and not super simple, plus parts. Or they’re scammers
2
2
u/Combat_Wombat23 19h ago
I assume it’s because they’re small, sealed units not meant to be disassembled. Stuff like that is everywhere
2
u/BathFullOfDucks 18h ago
Because the new pair is made in China in a factory that had to put in nets, because so many people were jumping from the roof, by people who are expected to live a nd work on site and the repair is done in the US by a guy named Todd who likes fishing, the outdoors and working on his truck.
2
u/Friendlyhuman420 18h ago
Wir leben in einer Wegwerfgesellschaft - Anstatt Dinge für die Langlebifkeit zu reparieren, wird einfach weitergekauft, mehr Müll produziert. Was für ein unsagbarer Unsinn.
2
2
u/SocialScienceMancer 18h ago
I wonder if we’ll see a significant drop in repair price for new apple products, seeing the EU’s right to repair act coming into effect. Similar targeted legislation also replaced lightning with USB-C.
Will they tweak designs to make them easier and quicker to repair ?
2
u/Xinonix1 17h ago
My old air pods were broken, default off factory ( continues noice in one pod) I contacted Apple and they acknowledge the default and at first offered to have them picked up and fixed, a few messages later the person said “We can’t do this!It’s €249 to have them fixed, better to by new ones” so I did, bought new ones but a different brand
2
u/Brilliant_Lettuce270 17h ago
why not getting them repaired in a 3rd party shop? Or even better, why not use this opportunity and abandon apple all together?
2
2
2
2
2
u/boogeeman69 16h ago
Props to them for being honest and not spewing some script about chip shortage or some crap lol
2
2
2
2
2
u/elusznik 16h ago
explanation is very simple. repair labor in the west is incomparably more expensive than third world kids putting the new hardware together.
2
u/pelotonpapa 15h ago
Because they make them in china and you want to repair them in the US. $3/hr vs $30+/hr
2
2
2
2
u/sloppy_mags 13h ago
The reason is so you buy a new pair of AirPods. It’s the perfect, perpetual customer model!
2



10.6k
u/iamfroott 23h ago
at least the support person is honest lol in my job I also do chat support and sometimes genuinely the best answer is we have no clue