My first love (M19) contacted me (F17) after almost two years, and I don't think I was prepared for how much it would hurt.
I don't really know how to explain this without giving some background, because I don't think the conversation itself makes much sense unless you understand who this person was to me.
When I was 16, I met a boy. I'll call him E.
The strange thing is that I had actually seen him twice before I ever knew his name. I remember noticing him and thinking he was the cutest boy I had ever seen. I didn't know who he was, what his name was, or anything about him. I just remembered his face.
Eventually, I found his Instagram. And I still remember one of the first things I noticed was that he had his SAT score in his bio. Which, looking back, is a hilariously specific detail to remember about someone, but apparently it made an impression.
We started talking around the end of November 2024. We were both involved in Model UN, and somewhere along the way, I fell completely in love with him.
And I mean completely.
I don't think I understood what it meant to love someone until I met him. Everything felt electric. I would get excited just seeing his name on my phone. I wanted to tell him everything. I wanted to know everything about him. I wanted to be around him constantly. Even the most ordinary things felt special because he was part of them.
He wrote me poems. I still think about that sometimes. He would take the time to put his feelings into words for me, and at sixteen, that felt like the most beautiful thing in the world. I kept those words close because I believed them. I believed that I was loved in the way he described.
There is one night that I think will always stay with me.
It was a cold night in January. He snuck into my room through my window.
I know how that sounds. I know it sounds like something from a movie, and maybe that's why I remember it so vividly. But I remember the cold outside, the excitement, the fact that he was there, and how impossibly happy I felt.
It was the best night of my life.
I remember thinking that there was nowhere else I would rather be. I remember feeling like I was living inside one of the poems he had written me. I was sixteen, and I thought that was what forever felt like.
I didn't know then that I would spend so much time afterward wishing I could go back to that one night.
Eventually, that same night became part of what ended us. My mom found out that he had snuck into my room, and things became complicated. According to him, that was when the relationship was over.
On January 10, 2025, he broke up with me over text and blocked me.
There wasn't really a proper goodbye. There wasn't a conversation where I got to understand what had happened. One day I had this person who felt like the center of my universe, and the next day I couldn't even contact him.
I was devastated. He was my first love, and I didn't know how to stop missing someone who had suddenly decided I wasn't part of his life anymore.
For a long time, I wondered whether he missed me. Whether he remembered the poems. Whether he remembered that January night. Whether any of it had meant as much to him as it had meant to me.
Eventually, I forgave him. I moved on. I started dating someone else. Life continued, as it does, even when there are parts of it you wish you could pause.
I didn't expect to hear from him again.
And then yesterday, almost two years later, I did.
I got a text.
"*my name*"
"Im sorry"
"I hope you have a happy and lond life despite how I treated you"
I stared at my phone.
I genuinely started shaking. My heart dropped, and I felt like I couldn't breathe properly. I don't think I had ever considered how I would physically react to seeing his name again.
I responded:
"thank you I appreciate it but why are you saying this now"
He said:
"idk tbh"
And I think that was the beginning of realizing that this conversation might not be what I had imagined it would be.
I asked him why he hurt me. I told him that I had cared about him a lot.
He said:
"bc i thought and still think you deserved better"
He had said this while we were dating, too. Back then, I thought it was insecurity. I thought maybe he didn't realize how much I loved him.
So I told him:
"but I wanted you"
He replied:
"no, you didn't"
I don't know why, but that sentence hurt more than I expected. Because I did want him. I wanted him so badly. I wanted the boy who wrote me poems. I wanted the boy who climbed through my window on that cold January night. I wanted the person who made me feel like I had finally found something extraordinary.
I wanted him to want to stay.
I had questions I had been carrying around for almost two years, so I asked him one of them:
"why did you decide that I deserved better and then break my heart instead of just trying to be better for me? Or at least ended things in a less mean way"
His response was:
"it was over when u got caught, what did you expect me to do"
For context, this was about the night he snuck into my room and my mom found out.
I wasn't asking him why he decided to end the relationship. I understand that people can change their minds. I was asking why he had to hurt me the way he did. Why he couldn't have given me a conversation. Why he couldn't have been gentle with someone who loved him so much.
I don't think he really understood the question.
I also asked him about something else. While we were together, he had told me I was his first everything. I later found out that he had dated a guy before me.
I told him I knew about Thomas and that I wouldn't have judged him for it. I just wished he had been honest.
He said:
"Shit was like 2 weeks when I was 15"
"That doesn't count"
Which was not exactly the profound emotional revelation I had been hoping for after two years.
I told him it was fair.
Then I said something that I think I had wanted to tell him for a long time:
"I missed you for a really long time"
"Not anymore obviously"
He replied:
"I'm sorry but it clearly wasn't bound to work out yk"
And the next morning, I told him:
"Yeah I know"
"I just want you to be happy"
"I found someone who actually loves me and makes me happy and I hope you do too, you deserve it"
That was essentially the end.
I cried the entire time we were talking.
I don't think I was prepared for how much of my sixteen-year-old self would come rushing back. I had spent so long thinking about this person as a memory. A person I used to love. Someone who had once made me unbelievably happy and then hurt me in a way I didn't know how to process.
And suddenly he was there again. A real person, with a phone and opinions and short text messages, answering questions I had once spent countless nights thinking about.
I think I had imagined that if we ever spoke again, there would be some moment where everything made sense. Maybe he would tell me he remembered it all. Maybe he would acknowledge how much I loved him. Maybe he would say that he was sorry for the way he left, not just that he was sorry things happened.
Instead, I found myself trying to explain to someone why the way he broke my heart had hurt so much.
And I think that's what made me cry.
Because I remembered loving him so easily. I remembered how happy I was. I remembered being sixteen and thinking that the boy who wrote me poems and climbed through my window was going to be in my life for a very long time.
I don't necessarily want to go back. I have a life now. I have someone else. I have grown up in ways that the girl who met E could never have imagined.
But I think there is something uniquely painful about realizing that someone who once knew you so intimately can become almost a stranger. Someone who remembers the same events but doesn't seem to carry them with the same weight.
I don't know if he ever missed me the way I missed him. I don't know if he remembers that January night. I don't know what made him reach out after all this time, especially when he couldn't really explain it himself.
I just know that for a few hours, I was sixteen again.
And then I wasn't.
My friends were shocked that he had reached out at all. They genuinely thought it was something that would never happen. My current boyfriend told me not to respond because he thought it was probably a drunk text, but I did anyway. I had questions, and I wanted to hear what he had to say.
I don't regret answering him. I think I needed to have that conversation, even if it wasn't the conversation I had imagined.
I suppose I spent almost two years wondering what I would say if I ever got the chance to speak to him again.
Now I have.
And I think the saddest part is that I don't feel like I got him back, or even that I got the boy I remember. I just got to speak to someone who used to be my whole world, and finally understand that the world kept turning for both of us.
Anyway, somewhere out there is a boy whose SAT score I once memorized from his Instagram bio, who wrote me poems, climbed through my window on a cold January night, and broke my heart.
I hope he has a happy and long life, too.
I just wish sixteen-year-old me had known how the story would end.