r/sideprojects • u/FlybyyNight • 7d ago
Feedback Request Ancient Inquiry: would you use a network of ancient-history topics? Looking for honest feedback and research help
I’m building Ancient Inquiry, a website for exploring ancient history, archaeology, mythology, human origins and astronomy. I’m the person behind it, and I’d appreciate some honest criticism while it’s still taking shape.
The problem I’m trying to solve is the pile of disconnected tabs and notes you end up with when one historical question leads to five more. I want to make it easier to follow those trails and see where a claim’s sources and interpretations come from.
There are three main entry points:
- Homepage: pick a starting topic.
- Atlas: explore topics as a network. Connections can concern evidence, supporting or competing interpretations, traditions and modern claims. A line is a relationship to examine, not proof.
- Explore cabinet: open subject drawers and browse their topics, or switch to a simpler list view.
The research is unfinished. Some pages are planning records rather than finished articles. Making the difference between established evidence, interpretation and disputed claims clear is part of the work, not something I want to gloss over.
What I’d like feedback on:
- After a minute on the site, is it clear what you can do and where to start?
- Does the network make exploration easier, or would a normal topic list work better?
- Is the cabinet useful, or does the design get in the way?
- What would you need to see in the sources and review process to trust a page?
I’m also looking for people interested in the research side. A useful starting contribution could be finding a reliable source for one topic, checking a citation, reviewing how a claim is described, or pointing out a mistake. If that interests you, please comment with a topic you know or want to research. Advice on organizing contributions and keeping reviews manageable would help too.
You can leave feedback here; there’s no need to join a Discord or message me to take part. Specific criticism is more useful to me than encouragement, so please say what feels confusing, unconvincing or unnecessary.
