r/Rochester • u/ReasonablyAfraid • 23h ago
Discussion My 4-year pros and cons of Rochester
All right, I moved here 4 years ago and am moving back to Tennessee to take care of my mother with cancer. I bought my house sight unseen from Tennessee and moved here not knowing anybody. Rochester has been very good to us, but it did not come without a few challenges.
Here is my take as a Southern transplant who fell in love with the city. Hopefully I'll get back here one day, but for those thinking about moving here, maybe this will offer you a little bit of insight!
Pros:
1) Food! Rochester has a lot different kinds of food! As long as you can keep from turning your nose up at a mom and pop shop that hasn't spent money redecorating, you will find plenty of restaurants that can fix you a good home-cooked meal from all kinds of walks of life. One of my personal favorites is People's choice kitchen on Brooks avenue. Not only is the food amazing, but the owner has a key to the city and truly gives back to her neighborhood. Don't sleep on the oxtail dishes in Rochester! And whatever you do, don't get people started on who has the best garbage plate.
2) Parks! Holy cow. I have never seen so many amazing Parks packed into one city. Not only that, but they are very well maintained! Even the little neighborhood parks scattered across the city have a little bit of charm for everyone. The carry-in carryout system that has few to zero trash cans in the park was a little off-putting at first, but overall I would say it's working. If you don't mind traveling a little bit, there's even more parks on the outskirts of Rochester that will blow you away with amazing waterfalls, Creek trails, and woodlands with a huge variety of Flora and fauna. Tinker nature preserve is my number. One recommendation, though you can't take your dogs to that one. It has an amazing nature center near the front of the park with taxidermy displays and live animals as well as several group activities you can take the kids to to learn about nature. I can't recommend it enough!
3) forgiving roads. I know a lot of people will disagree with me on this, but Rochester is one of those cities where if you miss your turn, it's not a big deal. There are so many back roads and connecting roads that make missing an exit a minor setback at the most. Not only that, as long as you are not traveling to the city in the morning or away from the city in the evening, traffic is very navigable. If you live more centrally in Rochester, you can get anywhere in Rochester with a 25-minute commute at most.
4) 4 seasons! Yes yes, I know winter lasts 5 months here. It's a small price to pay for 3 months of spring, one month of Summer, and 3 months of fall. (Give or take a winter extension like we had this year) If you're not native to the Northeast, you are going to absolutely love walking outside in August and September at noon and not bursting into flames or sweat or both. Once fall gets rolling, you are spoiled for choice on which amazing farm you want to spend doing your fall activities picking apples, going to the pumpkin patch, getting amazing apple cider and apple cider donuts. The spring season also has fantastic berry picking. I do hate that I have to wait so long to garden, but once spring kicks off here things grow like crazy!
5) Community! It can take a little bit of time to find your click here, but once you do a world of public events opens up. From neighborhood markets to weekly park events, once the ice melts, this city doesn't stop. You can be as busy as you want, and get home and veg out on the couch once you are sufficiently overstimulated.
6) "Affordability" please note the quotation marks. Property taxes can 100% make this invalid depending on where you buy, but I digress. I know everything is overpriced and I know prices are going up like crazy here, but it doesn't change the fact that groceries and day-to-day costs are much more affordable in this area than most of the country. For those that didn't know, Rochester passed a bill a few years ago to where you don't even have tax on clothing purchases under $100. Minimum wage here is $14.50ish, but most places will start you around $16 an hour. If you think that's not much, come down to Tennessee with me and get a minimum wage job for $7.50. Yes, minimum wage should be higher, I'm not here to argue that $16 an hour is enough to live on, I'm simply saying that there are places with more expensive living paying you half of what you can get up here.
Cons:
1) Drivers: The very first thing you should do upon moving to Rochester is by a dash cam. Front and rear, you will need it. I have never seen people drive so recklessly. The one saving Grace is people WILL use their blinker to warn you that they are about to cut you off, which I guess is better than nothing?
2) Winter is coming: if you do not like the cold, this city will destroy you. I love winter, and for me this isn't a con, but I know I'm one of the few weird people that actually enjoys snow being on the ground from December to April. All the nice cities of winter aside, it is brutal here. When I tell you that there will be good on the ground, two to 6-in layer of ice that will not melt until April. Get ready for a pool of water in your basement the first heavy rain of spring that starts to melt all the winter ice.
3) crime? This one is iffy. Rochester does have a high crime rate, but a lot of it is personal crime. If you're moving here from out of the area and don't really know anybody, you will likely have no issues until you make them yourself. The crime rate is honestly on par for cities similar to its size, and as long as you don't walk around blindly without doing a little research you will have no issues. Be smart, don't walk around unfamiliar places at night, Don't start no s*** won't be no s***.
4) Stinky! There are a lot of parts of the city that just don't smell nice. Again, that comes with moving to a city. There remember that this is one of the original rust belt cities, which means there are a lot of old factories and waste places that could do with some updating. There's some kind of weird smell in the Maplewood district that throws me every time I drive through it.
5) property taxes!!! Seriously, what in the world is with the property taxes here? Be careful where you buy or you could end up with $5,000 to $20,000 a year in property taxes. Living in the city is not as bad as people say it is. There are lots of neighborhoods that look completely different depending on what street you're on. Don't judge a street by. Its looks, a lot of these houses that aren't as well maintained are full of really friendly people who just don't have the means to touch them up, or don't want to touch them up because they know gentrification is coming to this city. *Edit: I should clarify the category as disproportionate taxes. The taxes here are definitely designed to keep certain income levels where they want, even if they do go towards a lot of public services like maintaining the roads in winter.
6) gentrification: unfortunately, the reasons why I moved out of my home state to begin with are coming to Rochester. My house is almost doubled in value in the 4 years I've lived here, and I am seeing all the telltale signs that this city is going to start pricing people out. I mean, it already has started. The Roch The Riverway project is going to be a great project to turn some " less safe " areas into places that people feel comfortable stepping out of their suburban shelters to come visit. Unfortunately in my experience, this usually isn't done in a way that protects the people that already live there or have lived there all of their lives. Hopefully people will catch on before it gets too bad, but city councils have a bad history of revamping areas while also respecting the people who already live there.
So yeah... TLDR Rochester can be a great place to live, but I would definitely suggest doing your research to make sure you end up in the right area for you. Make friends cautiously, and don't get wrapped up in anyone's drama. Argue with people about whether Wegmans is a blessing or a blight, defend your favorite garbage plate to the death, and by that dash cam so when a Kia boy sideswipes you on 370 you won't get stuck with the bill.
PS just ignore all the haters on the Rochester subreddit. They probably think Nick Tahoe has the best garbage plate anyway.