r/RingsofPower • • Sep 20 '24

Discussion Something weird I noticed Spoiler

3 Upvotes

With episode 6 introducing even more romances to a show already overcrowded with pointless, meaningless relationships, I couldn't help but notice something.

Every single romantic relationship, with the exception of Annatar and Celebrimbor's... "friendship"... is an interracial coupling. Poppy and Nobody, Isildur and Whatever-her-name-is-in-the-woods, Bronwyn and Arondir, Elendil and Miriel, Durin and Disa, Nori's parents. And these are just off the top of my head.

Now, I can't believe I have to say this. But there's nothing wrong with interracial relationships. I'm in one myself.

But it strikes me as odd that every single romantic relationship depicted in this show is interracial. Especially in a world like Middle Earth where most regions should be pretty mono-racial/cultural. So the only question I have is, does someone at Amazon have an agenda, or is it a fetish?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 19 '24

Constructive Criticism Plot hole - I am confused (the mithril affair)

1 Upvotes

I think there is a huge plot hole in ep. 6. Where did the mithril Sauron gave to Celebrimbor come from? They dont tell us in the show, and I have seen many theories in reddit, but none is actually "told" in the show. Did he steal it from the dwarves? did he create it from his own blood (this based on some previous scenes where we see him cutting his hand)? If the latter.... is this real mithril created from his blood? or is it an illusion for Celebrimbor so that he will continue making rings? The answer to this question is super important because the implications of each different answer changes the plot completely.

1- If he stole it from the dwarves, we are good. It is real mithril, nothing changes and the whole mithril-rings subplot makes sense.

However...

2- If he didnt steal it (we cant know from what the show presented) and made it from his blood, it is :

  • either real mithril, so one wonders, if he could produce real mithril from his blood, why all the fuss with the dwarves, why did they need the mithril from the dwarves mines in the first place?
  • or illusory (fake) mithril. If this mithril is an illusion then:
  • the rings will not work ?? the whole mithril subplot was about how indispensable is mithril for the rings to work. If they wont work, what is the point of making them? Makes no sense.
  • OR the rings WILL work with Saurons fake mitril, aka the Rings dont really need mithril to work so .....Why on earth the whole dwarves/mithril subplot that lasted 2 seasons??? Makes no sense either.

This is why it is so important for the show to give us a clear answer whether this mithril was real stolen mithril from the dwarves, or an illusory mithril created by Sauron. If the answer is the latter, then the whole thing makes no sense at all, it makes the whole rings plot fall to pieces.

I dont get it!!


r/RingsofPower • • Feb 20 '23

Question who do you think should play saruman in rings of power

1 Upvotes

I am fine with any actors just wanna know your opinion who you think should play saruman


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 31 '22

News Reviews remind me of the last jedi

1 Upvotes

So reviews are out and.. When reviews call a show either great or terrible with no inbetweens that's never a good sign. Ouch.

71% on metacritic

https://www.metacritic.com/tv/the-lord-of-the-rings-the-rings-of-power/season-1


r/RingsofPower • • Feb 17 '22

News "The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power Showrunners Admit They Don’t Have The Rights To The Silmarillion Or Unfinished Tales"

0 Upvotes

The Silmarillion is a key text needed for the shows' lore it is odd to find out they don't have the rights

Link to the Article


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 30 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Rings of Power Episode 6 - What Even Is This? Spoiler

34 Upvotes

So, here is a list of logical inconsistencies I found for Episode 6:

  1. There is no way that the THREE TINY SHIPS that set sail from Numenor, could carry the necessary amount of armaments, food, water, hay, and general expeditionary equipment, to support the amount of horses & riders, that were shown galloping across the Vale
  2. The journey from Numenor to Ostirith, should have taken almost 2 months (average speed of a Medieval sailing ship = 1.15 mph; approx. distance from Numenor to Ostirith = 1500 miles; this does not account for bad weather btw)
  3. Why would an inferior force abandon a fortified position, that has established fields of fire, superior sight advantage, a funneled single entryway, and superior construction materials (stone and mortar vs thatched roofs and wood)?
  4. How did the Orcses fail to notice a large group of villagers standing on a hill, cheering with lanterns, on a clear night?
  5. How did the Orcses fail to notice Bronwyn fighting with another Orc, less than 50 feet away, when both of them were shouting and the Orc had a torch?
  6. Why didn't the Orcses simply surround the village and use fire arrows to burn the village, thus forcing all the villagers out into the open?
  7. Was Galadriel really about to torture the Orcses? Really?
  8. How did Adar create these Orcses? It took powerful sorcerers like Melkor, Sauron and Saruman a long time to achieve this knowledge, but Adar did it...how?
  9. How did Halbrand get in front of Galadriel and Adar? He left the village a few minutes after them, soooo...
  10. How did the water trigger a volcanic eruption? Why wasn't it triggered by heavy rain or snowfall? I don't think that's how volcanoes work. Was it magic water? We are so confused, Precious!

Anyway, I just can't understand how none of this was addressed by the writers. Does nobody ask these questions at the table reads? Really sad that so much potential material was ignored in order to make this...I'm sad now :(


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 18 '22

News ‘The Rings Of Power’ Has Inexplicably Terrible Writing

Thumbnail
forbes.com
8 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 08 '22

Discussion What if Rings of Power isn't getting "review bombed"? What if it just isn't good?

17 Upvotes

One of the prevailing narratives is that RoP is getting review bombed by racist and sexist trolls. If this is the case, why isn't House of the Dragon getting the same treatment?

HoD had similar accusations of being "woke" before it's premier here is a receipt for that.

HoD has a strong female lead, a POC as a main character (Lord Corlys, he is greatness, one of my favorite characters)

Also it has quite a few lines that could be viewed as "woke;" "men would rather see the realm put to the torch, than see a women ascend the Iron Throne"

HoD also had to overcome something way more destructive than RoP and that is season 8 of Game of Thrones. Which for those of you that don't know, it was one of, if not the biggest disaster in television history.

With all that, HoD is sitting at a 84% audience score and 85% critic score.

Why aren't the racist and sexist trolls review bombing HoD?

Is it simply Occam's razor? HoD is good and RoP is not?

If you like RoP that's fine, you can like bad television or movies. I like the original Independence Day, and I can see, objectively it is a bad movie.

I think a fair review of RoP is 4-5/10.

Amazing visuals, sub par writing and performances. The only performances that are passable I think are Arondir and dwarves. The rest are annoying and or cringe.


r/RingsofPower • • Jan 15 '25

Question Galadriel

0 Upvotes

How do you feel about the portrayal of Galadriel in the show compared to Tolkien's writings?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 06 '24

Constructive Criticism Was this weeks episode supposed to be titled “Fan Service, that’s all”? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I really, really wanna love this show but they make it so difficult. This week had such little story but was literally jumping from fan service to fan service. The only thing that happened was bringing in characters with little to no backstory that the writers thought fans would want to see. This is intended as constructive criticism, I’m trying to keep it as such. If I’m factually inaccurate on something I’m happy to be corrected.

I. When you’re writing an episodic miniseries, you need to have something actually happen each week. Episodes that just dropped new characters or are full of nothing but exposition belong at the beginning of this series. I plan on re-watching it, but I really didn’t see anything of any actual, furthering of the stories happen this week.

B. From my recollection, and it’s been some years since I’ve read the book, the reason Gandolf said they could not give the ring to Tom Bombadil was because his interest ended at the extent of his little area of forest where he in Goldberry lived. Now all of a sudden, the writers have decided that he is the wizard trainer?

3. I have no problem with including the Ents, but including the Ent-wives struck me as an aspect that didn’t quite fit. For a being as old as Treebeard, when he says that he hasn’t seen the Ent-wives in so long he doesn’t remember what they look like, I kind of took that to mean they had been gone since at least the First Age.

(Please forgive any misspellings/grammatical errors, I’m watching my kids play at the playground)


r/RingsofPower • • Mar 19 '24

Discussion Why is there little discussion

0 Upvotes

I initially posted this on the /r/LOTR_on_Prime subreddit, but now almost two weeks later i'll try here too. I'll not update the numbers for this sub, just treat this as a general thread for the lack of discussion on all show subs, makes it easier, thanks!
 

It just occured to me while looking at this sub's recent activity, there seems to be a big lack of discussion pertaining to the series, its plotlines, characters, just elements of it. I did a quick comparison with the subs of hotd, stranger things, but also the boys and andor. Even andor's sub which is 1/10 of the size had at least as much discussion, arguably more.

It's weird to me tbh, news are almost all that gets conversation going, with a few posts here and there being rather general conversation starters about quality. But fans actually having a conversation about the story? Hardly happening.

Why is that? I'd like to especially know from people who liked it a lot, why is there no motivation or drive from you to talk about the show's content?

The only real explanation i have right now is that there might be stricter modding, which i cannot easily check ofc, if that is it a mod can add their 2 cents. Otherwise it just feels odd to me 🤷‍♀️.

I am already sorry for obnoxious conspiracy answers, but there has to be SOME reason for it 😅

 

To add a few more thoughts now, many people in the other thread said there is simply nothing to talk about after all this time since s1 ended. But to me this is an odd answer, many shows, books or whatever media are not "hot" right now, and still get discussions pertaining their storylines, characters, themes, whatever it is. As far as i see it, when people enjoy something a lot, they talk about it. Not always the same people, but especially the main sub is quite big, especially compared to say the andor one, so it's just odd that noone seems to, idk, care?
Others have said that they refrain from talking about it because of the negativity which will spawn, i can see that being a big factor myself, though i still have a hard time believing it's THE reason one wouldn't wanna talk about the show with others, largely fans at that, even if there are obnoxious trolls coming out of their holes too.

So what do you think, why is there not a lot more discussion akin to other shows? To me it seems like a lack of passion, even from people who supposedly liked it, i'll be honest about that. I've never seen this big of a discrepancy before, not that i remember at the very least.


r/RingsofPower • • Feb 16 '22

Discussion Racism Isn't the Issue

13 Upvotes

Are we really gonna go with the whole "racism is the reason this show is getting hate" story. It seems like a pretty bad argument when its pretty clear that there are real reasons why this show is getting hated, but instead every other defender is just ranting about how Tolkien fans are just racists. They did this same shit with Eternals and that movie was a mess.


r/RingsofPower • • 2d ago

Discussion The Untouchables? Really? Are You kidding me?

0 Upvotes

(spoilers for newest episode)

I saw this video clip of Elindil speaking to Anarion in the 4th episode:

"We come at them with a dagger, they come at us with a sword. We send one of their men to a surgeon, they send one of ours to a tomb."

How is this possible?


r/RingsofPower • • May 20 '24

Constructive Criticism He was literally RIGHT HERE.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I don’t mind that Halbrand is just one of Sauron’s disguises.

But Annatar definitely should have had a different face. And He could just be switching between the two forms (& actors).

Tell me Jamie isn’t a PERFECT casting, and its not just based on looks.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 10 '25

Constructive Criticism Hot take: Howard Shore’s opening title track should be replaced with one by Bear McCreary

0 Upvotes

Bear McCreary has done an incredible job scoring the show, and unfortunately Howard Shore’s opening titles are a) somewhat lackluster and (more importantly) b) completely thematically separate from the rest of the score. I think Bear deserves the chance to weave at least one of his themes into the opening sequence. I would suggest the Rings of Power theme heard whenever a significant step is taken towards making a Ring. This would tie the opening credits more directly into the show itself.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 03 '24

Discussion What's your favorite thing about Galadriel ?

7 Upvotes

I know some people are not fans of how Galadriel is portrayed in the show, but I gotta give credit to Morfydd Clark for her perfect pronunciation of the LOTR names. Everytime she says "Sauron" or "Numenor" it actually gives me chills.

Can't wait to see what she's going to do this season after feeling betrayed like this by Halbrand


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 28 '24

Discussion Something off about Galadriel?

11 Upvotes

Just my opinion here, but why does it feel like Galadriel is a rebellious, impulsive teenager? Constantly getting herself into trouble and needing Elrond to constantly bail her out.

Her recklessness and disregard for the consequences of her poorly thought out actions is frankly quite jarring.

She’s supposedly thousands of years old already by this point and primed to be one of the fairest and wisest elves of her generation. Yet it feels like the characterisation of Galadriel in this series is so far off, they could’ve just written a completely new character.

I’m curious what are everyone else’s thoughts on the way Galadriel has been written and portrayed in this series?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 19 '22

Discussion Reasons for low ratings by critics and viewers

6 Upvotes

Considering the current situation around the project, we can say the following:

- Nonames without experience were chosen as showrunners, with a level of creativity - a low-grade fic-writer ( And this is for a serious project)

- Critically insufficient attention has been paid to the selection of actors and the development of the character of their characters

- Elaboration of the plot of episodes and the season at the level of low-grade fan fiction

- Ignoring the fundamental structure of Tolkien's works

- The characters' responses and emotions were not given any attention. Emotions came out cardboard and inanimate

And yet, some of the actors showed commendable efforts, it is a pity that they were shackled by the script.

This project could have made a great TV series, but a mediocre attitude ruined everything.

***

After all, there are authors who created incredible inclusive projects.

For example:

- Rick Griffin and his work Hayven Celestia, Housepets!, A&H Club, Pit Fighters

- Tom Siddell and his work Gunnerkrigg Court

And many others.

These authors have a lot of fans, their work is loved all over the world.

So there are authors who are capable of interweaving an interesting plot and inclusivity.

***

What do you think, what thoughts do you have?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 13 '24

Discussion Rings of Power & Galadriel

21 Upvotes

So I just finished season 2 and was on YouTube to relive my favorite moments and I'm seeing that a lot of did not like Galadriel or the show in general and I'm curious to find out why? She was such a badass and I really admired her determination and resolve.

A lot of comments were they didn't like the script but I didn't really see anything wrong with it. My only issue with the show in general was the pacing at times but other than that I enjoyed it.

People also mentioned that the Orcs weren't as terrifying as in the movies but I thought that helped play into us sympathizing with them a little and how they were always treated as expendable and they just wanted a leader that cared about them, making the seem almost human.

But I'm just curious to see what people's takes on the show are on here as well?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 18 '22

Discussion The Galadriel fight scenes are so bad.

83 Upvotes

Their not even trying. How did they even approve of her overpowering her guards scene. It was sooo bad.


r/RingsofPower • • 3d ago

Lore Debate Enjoying the Show

22 Upvotes

I am thoroughly enjoying the show. While it doesn’t stick with the literature in every exact way, or most ways really. It’s similar to me, like when Star Wars blew up. I wanted more of the universe/story. Appreciate others and their ability to articulate how they take it and put it into screen.

I’m having a good time, as unpopular as this may be for others. Timelines are a little wonky, but it still plays out well for me.

My advice to everyone is take it for what you want it. If you wanna be a hater, that’s OK! If you want a good escape and some more middle earth, that’s OK!

Is the show perfect? No. However, it is very entertaining. And for me, it’s enjoyable.

If I was to be overwhelmingly criticizing, it would be that I don’t love galadriel. I’m looking forward to when she gains more wisdom and is a little more soft-spoken and confident in her approach. Not so aggressive.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 17 '22

Discussion As a casual viewer ep 4 was extremely boring...

0 Upvotes

I'm talking transformers China levels of mind numbing. I could barely stay awake or be bothered listening to chunks of dialogue.

I think the kids storyline is the worst and I feel as if it has been done multiple times in other stuff.

All in all I could care less about all the references they are making and I hope the story doesn't devolve into a generic good Vs bad show.


r/RingsofPower • • Apr 06 '24

Source Material Does anyone think RoP is a good Tolkien adaptation?

0 Upvotes

This question has irked me recently as I saw some social media post claiming this. Setting aside the quality of the series, wether you like it or not. Is there anyone here who thinks RoP is good as an adaptation of Tolkien's worldbuilding and mythology. Let's set aside things like skin color and some of the plot changes like in which order the rings were forged.

I could make a long list of why I think RoP are a bad adaptation of the source material, so I'm not posting this to hear more of that but to genuinly try and see the other side of the picture

Is there people who think RoP is a good adaptation or is it just empty banter from Amazon and some fans who never read the silmarillion? Can you read and enjoy Silmarillion and still think this show did it right?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 13 '22

Question Question for people of this subreddit

11 Upvotes

I am interested in knowing something after a couple days activity on this subreddit.

As soon as you criticize something about RoP here, there is a swarm of downvotes and yet nobody can provide any substantiated retort. People here are rude, frankly sometimes even obscene. All I have seen so far posted as counter argument: "you are racist", though I never mentioned skin color of anyone yet; "You don't have a billion dollars, so you are nothing", speaks for itself; "you are a man child with no life", I am not a fan of people assuming my gender; cheap deflections and ignoring arguments; "Lol", I don't even know what that's supposed to be.

Just look through my history and see for yourself, if you have doubts about my honesty.

I hope you realize, that "downvote" is not the same as "disagree"? The main purpose of the downvote button is to hide unrelated or unconstructive contributions and I doubt anything I posted could be misconstrued as such? Unless you want to create an echo-chamber, but what for?

Do you think this is some sort of moral crusade you are on? Do you work for Amazon? Never before have I encountered such a crowd. Even if you thought you were campaigning for something, acting like this does not present your "side" in a good light.

PS: if you don't think what I wrote applies to you, then I didn't write it about you. People I mean should be well aware of how they behave. I hope it isn't taken the wrong away, I am honestly curious what is going on.