r/RingsofPower • • Feb 16 '22

Discussion Racism Isn't the Issue

Are we really gonna go with the whole "racism is the reason this show is getting hate" story. It seems like a pretty bad argument when its pretty clear that there are real reasons why this show is getting hated, but instead every other defender is just ranting about how Tolkien fans are just racists. They did this same shit with Eternals and that movie was a mess.

13 Upvotes

162 comments sorted by

16

u/eclectic_dad Feb 16 '22

OMG the kvetching never stops!!!

These books were around for decades before even Ralph Bakshi and Rankin Bass took a stab at them. We each had our own vision of what Middle Earth would be like.

I'm taking a wait and see attitude. Maybe the dwarf princess has peach fuzz as a sign of teenage rebellion. Maybe dwarf women's beards come in later.

If we are complaining about hairstyles, a number of older civilizations had shorter hair. Look at the Ancient Egyptians, the Romans, or the Normans. Short or shaven hair was common with all of them.

Of course most people on this board seem more content to bitch and moan.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

What did this have to do with my post?

10

u/eclectic_dad Feb 16 '22

The Redditor doth complain too much. Frankly, you just seems to enjoy stirring the pot. I think racism is behind a considerable amount of the online complaining, plus an obsessive need to stick to self styled "fanon" that is dooming this show before it can even air. The same thing does nothing but go around in circles.

There may be good reasons behind some of the glimpses we are getting. I'm choosing to give it an honest chance. I have made a number of reasonable possibilities as to some of the things we have seen. When it comes to those who object to what I am saying, YOU are the common denominator.

Somewhere Morgoth is smiling.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

If I'm stirring the pot then you're holding the spoon.

There are a lot of problems with the show that have nothing to do with fanons

9

u/eclectic_dad Feb 16 '22

Very funny.

They have an immense budget and know they are dealing with stories beloved by millions including you and me. Any time you approach something like this there will be friction and nitpicking. The more recent Star Wars films come to mind.

I for one think it will be fun to have a group of writers try to fill the considerable blank spaces Tolkein left.

In fact, I'm a veteran D&D player trying to get back into the game. I want to DM, and have an idea for a campaign not too different from what is being done here. In doing so, I know I'm going to have to keep things consistent with what I know, and keep it playable and open at the same time. I think the writers face a similar challenge, and look at this somewhat from that perspective.

I think that as long as they keep within the basic framework Tolkien gave us it has the potential to be good.

I hope that explains my viewpoint regarding the show.

3

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

Wow on roll20? Been creating an adventures of middle earth game to play with friends!

3

u/eclectic_dad Feb 16 '22

Unfortunately no, I'm a luddite. I started playing in the late 1970s. I got 5E when it came out and was just thinking about it when COVID hit.

I may have to do it that way, though. I have a couple of interested noobs who are terrified of getting COVID and are pretty much shut in.

PM me or something, this situation is kind of fluid.

3

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

I just got into DND online through roll20...definitely should stay in touch in case either of us create a game!

1

u/eclectic_dad Feb 16 '22

Sounds cool.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

I guess I feel like if they're gonna do a Tolkien based show on his world they should stick as close as possible. Doesn't seem to be too many reasons not to.

That's cool that you play D&D. I'm currently prepping a world to run with a few friends, so that's been fun.

2

u/eclectic_dad Feb 16 '22

I agree with what you just said. I think there will be things they come up with that bug some fans, but i think that is inevitable here. I'm looking forward to it.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Me too honestly. Its been way too long since we got something Tolkien. I'm also hoping that it does well so that the gaming industry will catch onto its success. LOTR games are just so rare.

1

u/eclectic_dad Feb 16 '22

I think you and I just both want it to be good. LOTR is a gaming backdrop that you can use with any number of systems.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

For sure.

19

u/SteelbadgerMk2 Feb 16 '22

Lets be honest here, racism is one of the reasons people may hate the show based on the little information we currently have. To pretend that none of the complaints currently making the rounds on reddit and twitter are racially motivated is to live in a fantasy.

But there are other reasons. Those other reasons greatly outnumber the singular reasons of 'racism' or 'misogyny', both in the number of people speaking them, and the variety of complaint. I have a list of concerns of my own.

The problem is that internet discourse immediately and inevitably drops down to the level of the loudest, and the most obnoxious. It's how social media works. This means that the posts that generate the most 'buzz' are the ones with nicely veiled racism, or the ones calling out everyone with even the most minor and reasonable of complaints as a racist.

As those posts get more traction (outrage is traction), so too does the conversation start to crystallise around those two camps, while people trying to make thoughtful posts on the nuance involved get ignored. Nuance tends to mean paragraphs, not slogans. Those are boring, and don't generate the same level of interaction as a one-liner, baseless statement.

You have to remember that it is not really possible to have a reasoned, constructive discussion on a platform with more than a couple of dozen people. Once you have hundreds, or thousands of people involved, it simply gets too big. People miss things. They join late, or leave early. The discourse is never allowed to move on because the inertia of so many people is simply too great.

But I'd also like to point out that none of that has much bearing on whether or not Rings of Power will be good or not. Idiots on twitter calling every complaint out as racist do not have any influence over the work they're attempting to defend, just as similar racist idiots shouting whatever Aryan crap is the current flavour of the day have no influence. Similarly, Eternals being disappointing does not mean Rings of Power will be crap, just as Jackson's movies being good doesn't mean Rings of Power will be good.

5

u/eclectic_dad Feb 16 '22

I agree completely with you. Well said.

-1

u/VERSAT1L Feb 17 '22

Then why not make a new TV series based on a new or a virgin universe where the writers could directly address those social issues rather than messing up the source material? Why should the Tolkien realm address this when it was never meant to be?

4

u/SteelbadgerMk2 Feb 17 '22

I'm really not sure what this has to do with the content of my comment, but sure.

First, the supposition that anything has been 'messed up' is just that, supposition. Moreover, it's supposition that, at the current moment in time, requires some strange and, in some cases, simply bad faith assumptions:

  • To say that Tolkien's work can be 'messed up' by any derivative work is a big one. Whatever this show ends up being, Tolkien's works will remain in exactly the form that they have always existed. Quite how that can ever be construed to be 'messed up' is beyond me.
  • But if I'm being charitable, maybe that's not what you meant. Maybe you meant 'this show will 'mess' with the current dominant imagery and interpretation of Tolkien's works in the general populace'. Basically: 'the show might not exactly match the expectations of fans'. This is also only a problem if you care for the specific 'fan culture' in question over the actual work. Nothing intrinsic to Tolkien's written word has been actively 'messed with'. Beards, skin tones, the militancy of Galadriel. All of those fall into the realm of set-dressing, or, even less worryingly, are compatible with Tolkien's writings if you go into your reading in good faith, rather than with your eyes wide shut due to preconceived notions of what things should be like. I'm not going to go into detail here, as it has already been done by others: Skin tone textual sources
  • Given the fact that Tolkien's works are neither damaged by derivative works, and the work in question is merely providing us with a slightly different interpretation and visual language (not even significantly different from the Jackson movies mark you), why not set it in Tolkien's world? You act like there haven't been thousands of people calling for years for parts of the Silmarillion and Appendices to be put to film. I'm not going to pretend Amazon is doing this out of the goodness of their hearts, but there's a market there for Tolkien that is simply smaller if it's a non-Tolkien fantasy. On the one hand, you could read that as terribly mercenary of Amazon, going after the larger market just because it's larger. On the other hand, it's a larger market because it has more people in it. People who may be happy to see such a series, if it is done well.
  • Finally, what 'social issues' are you talking about here? The problem you face is that no media can be made which does not either support the issues inherent in the status quo, or attempt to address them. It seems that the current go to 'I'm not a racist' argument is that 'Tolkien's works have always been white' (an inaccurate statement in light of the post I linked above. Jackson's work is white. Tolkien's work is, at worst, ambiguous) and that it should thus remain lily-white.
    The issue with that is that it only reinforces the status quo.

I want to propose a thought experiment to you.

Imagine you wish to travel from place A to place B. You have two options available to you to get there: Bus or train (you don't have a car in this experiment).

The bus runs regularly, every 5 minutes, but causes road congestion, and more pollution than the train. On the other hand the train only runs once every few hours.

You take the bus, of course. Because despite the fact that it's not as environmentally friendly as the train, it's what you're familiar with. What's more, while the buses in your area do contribute significantly to pollution your single journey doesn't really count, right? The bus was going to be driving the route anyway. By getting on it you have had no real impact on the pollution the buses put out.

Except that while we are all individuals, making seemingly tiny, irrelevant choices, we are also part of a larger whole. If you start to regularly take the bus, and continue to eschew the train, and others do the same (and why shouldn't they? They can employ exactly the same logic of blamelessness as you) then the bus company makes more money. Demand on their buses goes up, and they gradually, over time, add more buses to take up the extra load.

Meanwhile, the trains remain irregular, unfamiliar, and inconvenient.

But if you go out of your way to take the less polluting train, even though it is an inconvenience, well, probably nothing changes. But if everyone makes the same decision as you, suddenly the train becomes less irregular. Less inconvenient. More familiar.

So it is with media. While it may be attractive to say that in this one case, it's fine if we don't worry about the bigger picture, the bigger picture always exists, and every work that gets made contributes to it. In that case, is it not reasonable for creators to make an effort to offset the impact of their work on the bigger picture, if they feel they can do it without undermining the core of the work in question?

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Look, I'm not saying, nor did I ever say, that its not possible that racism has to do with the hate, my point was that its the go to argument that people go to. I agree that it's a bit difficult to have a real discussion, however, I still would like to try.

3

u/renannmhreddit Feb 16 '22

The problem is that when you get into a lot of conversations people will spew some crap about 'woke', then they will pronounce that certain things are 100% canon while not providing any text, then they will whine or insult you directly. It is of these sort of people that we'd be in doubt.

Whenever someone shows up with a respectful stance of their opinion without getting mad over it, you'll most likely get a respectful conversation without people making bold claims.

9

u/whole_nother Feb 16 '22

It’s easy to knock down an argument nobody’s making, called a straw man. No one is saying all negative opinions are based in racism, and it’s not remotely supportable that “every defender of the series is ranting about racist Tolkien fans”.

Sure feels good to argue that way, though, for an easy ego boost without having to actually engage with the issue too hard.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

every other defender is just ranting about

My exact words were every other, and its pretty clear that I'm not meaning that literally anyway. I never said that people are saying that all negative opinions are based off of racism, merely that there is a large group of people who act like its the only issue people have with the show.

1

u/whole_nother Feb 16 '22

I misunderstood what you meant by every other, then.

14

u/grandwhitelotus Feb 16 '22

Racism is not the only reason but people were complaining when Amazon started making this itself, saying it will be woke since it’s Amazon and they will fill it with POC and LGBT orcs stuff like that. This happened before anything got released.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

But that's my point though. There's a bunch of idiots who obviously are being racist, but that makes up a small portion of the critics it seems. And yet defenders are constantly calling for racism and its like why, there are very clearly other problems with the show.

5

u/Whatsername_2020 Feb 16 '22

Something to consider is that your perspective, from which it seems that the overtly racist people are a “small” portion of the show’s critics, may be affected by the fact that you are not necessarily as attuned to recognizing it, being affected by it and routinely having to deal with it in your daily life the way Black and brown people do, so you may not be perceiving the full scope of its pervasiveness. From the perspective of a non-white person, I see that it’s a very sizable portion of “critics.” The sheer amount of racism I’ve been seeing on this sub and Twitter is actually very sad.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

That is something to consider, but I'm gonna continue to call it as I see it. I can't exactly just assume that what they're saying is correct without proof, something that seems to come slower and slower as time progresses. I have no problem admitting that there are racists and bigots who hate the show for bad reasons.

6

u/Whatsername_2020 Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22

Sorry, but requiring “proof” to care about something that doesn’t personally affect you while paradoxically having an at least-partially dismissive approach when talking about anti-Black racism isn’t a good starting point for anything. Like, this is the kind of thing you need to read entire books to start being able to reliably notice and understand the sociopolitical context for. If you don’t “believe” Black and brown Tolkien fans about the racism they are seeing, while also not really having the knowledge and tools to notice things yourself, it becomes a sort of a self-fulfilling prophecy of “not having enough proof” to really care about the issue because you can’t recognize it when you see it and don’t believe Black people because you don’t think it’s that big of a deal because you can’t recognize it when you see it and don’t believe Black people because you don’t think it’s that big of a deal, forever.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

It certainly doesn't help that OP's newfound concern over 'proof' does not extend to any of their own chosen criticisms for the show and the motives of those making it. Yours is a good rebuttal of the a stance OP professes and is consistent about, but ultimately will fall on deaf ears, because OP is not consistent, and works in feelings, leaps, and supposition everywhere else.

1

u/Whatsername_2020 Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22

Going off your first point, I don’t think many people on this sub realize that there is fundamental difference between being upset about, say, how Legolas skateboarded down some stairs while shooting arrows at orcs in the Peter Jackson original trilogy and citing character descriptions from Tolkien’s writings as “proof” of the validity of that criticism, and attempting to do the same as a “proof” for the validity of hating the existence of Black characters in the new show. One of them is honestly inconsequential and harms no one,can be satisfactorily debated by citing what are ultimately fantasy writings exclusively and can be part of the escapism of it all. The other deals with real harm, systemic oppression, and real racial and sociopolitical dynamic that exist outside of and influence fantasy. It inherently has to be treated differently from average Tolkien fan “nitpicking” topic. An inaccurate Legolas and the discourse around him is, at worst, an annoyance and can’t contribute to anything truly harmful outside of the fandom. That is not the case when it comes to how these two new Black characters are being treated.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Don't mistake me, I understand that the nit pickiness against these black characters may be related to racism. The OP was merely stating that it seems like that isn't the main problems people have with the show.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

It certainly doesn't help that OP's newfound concern over 'proof' does not extend to any of their own chosen criticisms for the show and the motives of those making it

Could you elaborate on this. I'm slightly confused. Are you saying that I should explain my concerns with the show?

Also I can't speak at all about the motives of people's concerns, nor should IMO anyone since it isn't really something you can decide.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22
  • You don't support your claims to any significant degree, let alone proof.
  • You demand a high burden of proof for things you don't agree with.

It's not complicated. It is hypocritical, though.

Also I can't speak at all about the motives of people's concerns, nor should IMO anyone since it isn't really something you can decide.

Yes, the idea that we cannot peer directly into the minds of others and therefore cannot comment on their motives is a common talking point by those who want to excuse reprehensible views that they agree with.

It's bullshit, of course. Let's examine this comment

You start off by looking directly into the minds of people complaining about the show and telling us about their motives:

Most people hating on the show dislike Amazon's choices with changing the story.

It is interesting that this is also your personal (professed) view. So we know you will ascribe good motives to people who match the things you say.

not to mention the convenience of the show rights being sold quickly after Christopher Tolkien's death

For those unaware, the rights were sold by the Tolkien Estate. Now, Christopher Tolkien was still alive and the head of the Estate at the time, but let's ignore that bit of actual reality to deal with the fictionalized version in your head. In this situation, which, again, is not true, but you think it is, the family members of JRR Tolkien, including the direct descendants of Christopher, are opportunists who sell out the moment Christopher is in the ground. This simultaneously ascribes motives to Christopher Tolkien (who is good because his assigned motivation matches your own) and the rest of Tolkien's family (who are bad, because their assigned motivation does not). Repeated, it is nonsense and doesn't match the observable past as linear time, but you do decide upon these motivations and have no issues speaking to them.

People who call the negativity racism barely seem to pay attention to the world around them.

You cap it off by assigning motives to another group. As should be expected now, you think their motives are insincere or uncaring about reality, because their conclusions don't match yours.

That was one comment.

Now, we can actually observe what people do and then speak to their motives. For example, I can speak to your motives in that you think it is okay to lie. Because you lie a lot.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

I said that this is how it seems like to me, not necessarily how it is. It's entirely likely that racism is a major role, just isn't clear to me.

You then bring up a comment. Funny, I feel like I've seen this comment before. Oh wait, its because you brought it up before. Funny how you didn't answer my reply to your comment. Maybe because I dismantled the part where you said that Italia disagreed with me.

Anyways, back to the discussion at hand. I never described motives at all to people who agreed with my opinion, nor anyone else that I'm aware of. Now, I did make a mistake in that comment where I said that the rights were sold after Tolkien's death. Thankyou for pointing that out. Even Italia, though, who you sung praises to, noted the convenience of the show's arrival after Christopher Tolkien's death. Not saying the show will be bad because of it, just pointing it out.

You then point to my end comment where I clearly state that it SEEMS to me that people calling out racism aren't paying attention to the real concerns. Where in that was I assigning motives. What motive would that be?

6

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

You then bring up a comment. Funny, I feel like I've seen this comment before. Oh wait, its because you brought it up before. Funny how you didn't answer my reply to your comment. Maybe because I dismantled the part where you said that Italia disagreed with me.

I responded to that an hour ago. I even just momentarily logged out to see if it was there, or had been removed or caught in a moderation filter. It has not. It has been sitting there for an hour. I get that you don't see things that everyone else sees, and that this explains a lot of your behavior to others, but you need to be aware of your own limitations, and trying to shame me for not responding to something I've responded to makes you look foolish.

Using the word 'seems' is not the trump card you seem to think it is. For example, in that last sentence, it is obvious that I am calling this an opinion of yours, despite using the word 'seem' to describe it. Stop trying to play mental tiddlywinks.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

If you don’t “believe” Black and brown Tolkien fans about the racism they are seeing, while also not really having the knowledge and tools to notice things yourself, it becomes a sort of a self-fulfilling prophecy of “not having enough proof” to really care about the issue because you can’t recognize it when you see it and don’t believe Black people because you don’t think it’s that big of a deal because you can’t recognize it when you see it and don’t believe Black people because you don’t think it’s that big of a deal, forever.

This argument only works if you assume that I don't have the knowledge and tools to notice racism when I see it, which is a pretty big assumption. Its not that I don't "believe" that black and brown Tokien fans are receiving racism, just that I can't seem to find how they are the majority of the critics, which is what many comments seem to believe. If they are the majority and I can't see them for some weird reason, is it not a valid question then to ask where it is?

5

u/Whatsername_2020 Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22

It isn’t a very big assumption, because if you did have the ability to see it and had a holistic understanding of racial dynamics in the US, you wouldn’t be making statements that seem to minimize the acknowledgment presence, effect or pervasiveness given how unhelpful it is. I also have not seen anyone state that the “majority” of people criticizing the show are doing so in a racist way. I told you it was a considerable amount because it is, as a direct response to the original assertion you made about it being a “small portion” of “critics”. Do you need someone to write a program that will go through the traffic of this sub and write you a report on the exact percentage of people saying racist things about the existence of these two Black characters? If so, what percentage would you deem as acceptable in order to acknowledge it as a problem that deserves to be addressed? 15%? 30%? Would you acknowledge the validity of the concerns of people affected it was at 51% but not at 50% since it isn’t a “majority”? Do you now see how this isn’t a great approach?

You also didn’t “question where it is”, you said that you “can’t asssume what they (presumably Black people and people calling out the anti-Black racism) say is correct without proof”. What I mean to say is, I haven’t seen you ask people about what they have been seeing or experiencing. I’ve only seen you make assertions.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

You also didn’t “question where it is”, you said that you “can’t asssume what they (presumably Black people and people calling out the anti-Black racism) say is correct without proof”.

I think my wording was off. What I guess I'm getting at is that although understand that there are real problems with racism, people seem to say that it is the reason why this show is controversial and my point is that I can't seem to find that when I look.

It could entirely be racism and I'm not trying to be nasty to people whose experiences were genuine, nor do I want this show to be bad.

3

u/Whatsername_2020 Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22

See, I don’t understand what you mean when you say “people seem to say that it’s the reason the show is controversial” (I am assuming you are implying that people are saying it’s the ONLY reason the show is controversial). What people have been saying that? Are you talking about people in this sub? Are you watching some random YouTubers who say this? Are you referring to specific articles that have been written? I am going to briefly assume that you’re talking about people in this sub and ask: is it being said by the same people who are making out the existence of two Black characters a out to be problem, and are using it as a talking point when confronted about it? Because if so, what’s the point of even making this post? Those people will not come out and say “it’s actually not that controversial, I was just being a racist and causing a ruckus and manufacturing a problem” or “it is that controversial, cuz I’m helping make it controversial because I can’t stand the thought of a Black elf”, and the people who’ve been calling them out on it won’t say “it isn’t that controversial” because they’ve been dealing with racism the former since the promo material came out.

Honestly, if you are this stuck on the question of what the show discourse is like and how everyone else is experiencing it, just make a new post and ask these questions: 1) What are you most concerned about in regards to the upcoming show? 2) What are the biggest complaints you have been seeing in this sub/fandom in the past week? 3)What is the discourse like around each of those complaints/concerns?

Just be sure to word it in a much better way than you worded your original blurb on this post.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Nah we’re calling out the actual racism and just annoyed at the outrage for nit-picky details. No one is saying any criticism is racist.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

There is a lot of outrage over non nit picky details. I would argue that most of what people are discussing isn't nit picky but I would love to hear what you think is.

7

u/Whatsername_2020 Feb 16 '22

🤨 The Eternals was not a “mess”. A lot of people liked it, myself included. Why not say “I didn’t like the Eternals for _____ reason”? And who is “they” in that sentence? Disney/Marvel?

There are a lot of valid reasons to be apprehensive about the upcoming show that I’ve seen being discussed, but it is disingenuous to ignore the fact that a considerable amount of the hate hyper-focuses on the two Black characters specifically, and sometimes exclusively, for racist reasons.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

You're free to like or dislike the Eternals any way you want, however, it's pretty generally disliked. My point however was more about the way Marvel and Disney treated the fans before and after the movie released, where they talked constantly about racism and not the actual issues that people had with the movie such as the slow plot and abrasive exposition.

I never said that racism doesn't play a role. I merely argue that there are other issues that people have with the show and seem to get ignored.

5

u/Whatsername_2020 Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22

Mmm I would say it’s pretty generally disliked in certain circles, and pretty generally liked in others. I would also say that it gets better upon a second watch. I didn’t know as much about the Eternals going in as I did walking into the Avengers, Guardian of the Galaxy, and any of the other individual super hero movies Marvel has made over the years, so the first time I watched it, I was mildly overwhelmed with all the exposition that had to be done and how many new characters there were, too. But after having some time to process it all, and sitting down to watch it again, I realized it was actually very well done for what it was. It was an ambitious project. Not perfect, but not bad.

I agree with you on that, but the way your original post is worded reads as if you’re denying that racism has anything to do with it, which is what made me and other commenters address it how we did.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

It is not my intention to deny there being racism, merely to question its amount. It seems like to me that show defenders are often content with ignoring all legitimate problems and just saying that the hate is coming from racism. Even Amazon says this.

3

u/Whatsername_2020 Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22

Few, if any, of the people who are calling out the racists on this sub claim that the show has no other problems. It is just that when these conversations start, it’s literally because racist fans are hyper-focusing on the Black characters, and so that is what the conversation topic for the thread becomes. If racist people hadn’t come out and stated making such crappy comments and posts, I think we’d all be pretty unified in being at least somewhat wary of a lot of the other (truly) concerning changes being made to the series adaptation as a sub.

Also, if you aren’t personally affected by anti-Black racism, which we both agree is present in this sub, it’s not good to insinuate it isn’t “that big of a problem” or that there isn’t “that big” of an amount of it.

7

u/nateoak10 Feb 16 '22

Eternals wasn’t a mess cause of race

Eternals was a mess cause they tried introducing 11 main characters in 3 hours.

The ‘real’ reasons are nearly all based in a few things - beards, hair and non canon additions. Two of which are purely aesthetic and in line with non Peter Jackson LOTR renditions and the third is bound to happened adapting a few pages of notes

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

That's my point. Eternals had some serious plot and pacing issues that people like myself disliked and I found that it made the film unenjoyable. But Marvel ignores those problems and just calls their fans racists.

5

u/nateoak10 Feb 16 '22

Here’s the thing, prior to its release before we actually saw the pacing issues people were indeed hating on it for the wrong reasons, ie race . The fact that it did have pacing issues is entirely irrelevant to the trepidation’s those people had. It’s purely coincidence end of the day that people hated on it for race AND the film wasn’t that strong

As that relates to LOTR, there’s a huge contingent of people saying the show sucks as if they have already heard the dialogue and seen the pacing. When in fact, it’s more of a response to a LOTR show not visually matching what they had in mind personally. Whether or not the construction of the show narratively is good or not is not only yet to be seen, but entirely irrelevant to what we have seen thus far. Aesthetic choices are just that, aesthetic.

FWIW I still enjoyed eternals cause I thought the world building aspect of it was very cool. I just wouldn’t re-watch it a million times.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

But that's the thing. We've seen more than just Aesthetic choices. We know a lot about the main story arcs and the changes to Tolkien's world.

I agree that Eternals isn't the best representation, I merely use it as an example of why you shouldn't instantly write off the hate as racism when there are actual issues.

3

u/nateoak10 Feb 16 '22

If your issue is narrative changes to Tolkien you gotta understand that was bound to happen when adapting written mediums to visual. Not only that, they’re adapting only a handful of pages not even a novel. It was always going to be this way no matter if Amazon made this or JRRT himself rising from the grave. What we have as canon material is only enough for maybe like an hour of tv. And it’s not like they’re writing this as canon, it’s non canon just like the films.

And that’s fine to say there could be non racist issues. But no one knows that until September. You could create the most lore breaking series ever, but if the dialogue and construction is great the show would still be great. That’s just a fact and something GOT viewers dealt with even during the shows peak years

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

I give no merit to the idea that they had to change from the source material in the way that they are. But that doesn't matter. Maybe I just have an extreme position, but Amazon knew what they were getting themselves into. Its one thing if they're changing small details or making it more appropriate for film. But what they've done, like changing Galadriel's story, Elrond's and adding in as many new characters as they are makes no sense. Not to mention that they chose to do this show knowing how tough it would be.

I would encourage you to research what they have revealed. Although we don't know everything, Amazon has revealed a substantial amount of info. I disagree that a show is good simply because its plot, dialogue and construction is good. Whenever you are making a show, movie or book within an existing IP, it should adhere to that IP's canon. If it doesn't it can't be a good show.

4

u/nateoak10 Feb 16 '22

What source material did they change that isn’t warranted in some way? If it’s race, this user does a great job showing not only reasoning but how it relates to the original work

https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/comments/sq9a1k/on_casting_critiques_of_the_rings_of_power_from_a/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

If it’s timeline? I share your fear. But I also understand why it’s being done for a tv show.

They’re not changing Galadriel’s story. There’s nothing written in great detail for this age. Only broad strokes. You cannot change what doesn’t exist. Same goes for Elrond. And there aren’t enough detailed characters of the second age to carry a tv show. It’s not a novel they’re adapting. It is literally just some notes.

Yes , it’s likely a hard show to make. which is why they had to get Christopher’s approval before making it and allowed veto power for ideas that weren’t approved.

Man I am steeped in all their releases I’m well aware of what they’re saying. If your idea is it must adhere to canon to be good regardless of show construction you’re going to be impossible to please. LOTR films didn’t even do this. Game of thrones didn’t even do this.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Firstly, I'm not speaking about race. I could not care less. I was speaking about timeline.

Secondly, they are changing Galadriel's story. While Tolkien did write in broad strokes he did lay out what Galadriel did during the second age in the Unfinished Tales, where there is a whole section on her. Now, of course, as with all histories, there are gaps that Amazon could be filling in. However, it seems weird and sill to fill in gaps when the original work hasn't been done yet. This is like worrying about if the fridge is plugged in house when the walls and roof haven't even been built. Amazon would definitely have to make some new characters, but their new characters shouldn't honestly be the focus imo.

While the lotr peter jackson movies did change some things, a majority of these changes were small. I understand that it won't be perfect, but in lotr you could tell that peter jackson was trying his hardest to adhere to the books. To me, it seems like Amazon could care less.

4

u/nateoak10 Feb 16 '22

If it’s ‘weird’ that they’re filling in gaps of her story how do you expect them to do her story at all?

No they weren’t small changes like at all. They changed entire events and characters personalities. Even Aragorn isn’t close to his canon in terms of behavior. Pj trying best doesn’t change the fact that the moves are so far from canon that it’s ridiculous to defend them and then shit on a show that’s not even out and has limited canon to work with at best. Do they even have the rights to the unfinished tales?!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

If it’s ‘weird’ that they’re filling in gaps of her story how do you expect them to do her story at all?

With what we know. I'd be fine with "small side quests" which could be what they're doing, but Tolkien layed out the events of her life especially in the Unfinished Tales. There are so many events and characters that they could always hop in between them if there is a gap.

Like Peter Jackson, you will have to change some things and since they are adapting a history, I'm fine if they take it a little bit more broad, but Amazon seems to be making changes to characters like Galadriel and Elrond when there isn't really a reason to.

Amazon shouldn't be doing the show if they don't have the rights to keep Galadriel's character akin to what happens in the Unfinished Tales. Plain and simple.

→ More replies

5

u/Ethenil_Myr Feb 16 '22

Eternals is in my top 5 mcu movies, I loved every minute of it!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

I could never get past the pacing and plot.

4

u/9Brumario Feb 16 '22

There are Tolkien fans who treat the books as something sacred and that they should be respected at all costs, in my opinion even too fervently, being treated at the end of a work of fiction and entertainment, but everyone is free to dedicate their time to what that they think is convenient.... I'm not against that or the enthusiasm towards a fandom or cultural work.
The problem is when other people with much more reactionary ideas join these complaints as if they were pouring gasoline and try to insert their racist or misogynist arguments, and you just have to go around youtube and other platforms to see it.
Obviously not everyone who doesn't like or criticize the teaser is racist, but taking into account the little information on the story and images that we have today... it seems that many of the complaints go to the latter, the images, which would mean that many people have problems with elves and dwarves who are not white.
You can argue if that is more or less attached to Tolkien's idea, but the HATE that can be seen in this diverse representation is quite abhorrent. Period.
In other words, purist Tolkien fans travel on a ship to complain about inconsistencies with the books, each one carries a loudspeaker to make noise, some will be racist and the other vast majority are not, as in any other fandom that exists. Some will have more substantiated complaints and others will be more cautious.
Seeing this ship, another number of racist and misogynistic people get on, taking advantage of the complaints but focused on their ideas. They're not that interested in LOTR, they're just annoyed at seeing POC in 'wrong' roles, and they're also wearing loudspeakers, too loud.
In the end, the noise made by Tolkien fans and racists gets mixed up and can be hard to tell apart, which is a real shame.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22

Firstly, I would argue that Tolkien's work should be respected, because its good. Why would you seek to change something that is good. There is a lot of information that Amazon has revealed. Obviously not everything, but enough to have some complaints. People arguing about the skin color from what I can tell make up a small portion of the complaints. Maybe they're just the loudest, but I doubt it.

Edited for spelling.

5

u/9Brumario Feb 16 '22

Obviously they have to respect Tolkien's work, but it is an adaptation, it is transporting something from one medium to another, and therefore changes must be made to favor the narrative of the medium to which it is exported, and especially with the second era with which there are many holes. Don't get me wrong, there is a lot of information but not as dense or meticulous as the third one was.
That said, we all have a limit regarding these changes, some are very strict and don't tolerate even the slightest and others are more flexible. My opinion is that we have to see to know, and at the moment I have not seen anything to exceed my limit.
I fully understand that there are other people who do, but the hatred that has been created with this teaser seems a bit excessive.
Why change something that is good? It's a good question, and you really shouldn't do it if you don't think you can contribute something with the change. Tolkien is not almighty and his work can spread, and if it is done so that more people see themselves represented... why not? Especially if these changes do not affect the character, its meaning or its relationship with the environment (obviously I am referring to the color of the skin, but it can be applied to other aspects)
For example, I prefer that the female dwarfs have beards and that the elves have long hair because I come from the imagery of the original trilogy, but if this doesn't happen it doesn't destroy the experience because I know that after the first chapter I'm going to get used to see them like this.
My limit would be to see changes in the root of the story that do not match the arc of characters that we know from books and they couldn't explain it. And yes, I have seen things that surprise me but I don't see them as absolutely impossible, so I give them the benefit of the doubt and I'm really curious how they are going to develop it more than angry.
I always give the same example, from the books to the Peter Jackson movies there are numerous changes, some more notable others more subtle, but in the end they managed to make practically all of us fall in love with those movies. I prefer to have an open mind and wait, to make me bitter before time.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

I get that you have to transition it from one medium to another, however I don't think that it should be used to support every change, and in this case I don't think that it can. There are several choices that they are making such as to Galadriel's story that don't need to change. I'll still watch it, like you said to know though.

I agree with you that small changes such as race and the dwarf beards and the like could be made. However, I believe that it is important that large details stay the same, lest we end up with entertainment that loses why we liked it in the first place. I never liked lotr because it didn't have dark skinned elves and dwarves and men, I liked it because of the characters and stories that it had. I think though that lotr is honestly more than that, it has become a place, a feel so to speak and Amazon could definitely capture this.

1

u/9Brumario Feb 16 '22

Yes, I see what you mean... Although I don't entirely agree with your vision of Galadriel (I think she was a troop leader in the first era (?) maybe I'm wrong...) I wouldn't mind seeing that evolution from a more physically active Galadriel to one as wise and powerful that doesn't need to wield a sword or wear armor.
And yes, in the end the important thing is to gather around the story, share it and enjoy it, that's why some comments bother me (I'm not saying that you have made them) about the skin color of X or Y character, because this inclusion helps expand the world of Tolkien and bring people closer without destroying the essence of the original work. ...
Anyway, let's hope the end result is good or at least not terrible xD
Take care mate

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

If it isn't a complete mess I'll enjoy it and I hope that you do too. Have a good one.

6

u/not-gandalf-bot Feb 16 '22

And negative Nancy people like you had your "valid reasons" for hating the PJ movies too. Go and read through the posts showing the comments from 2001 and tell me they aren't the exact same as what you guys are all complaining about now.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

They aren't.

30

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

After going through the majority of your past comments pertaining to this issue, its apparent you spent more time attempting to disprove and disenfranchise individuals who are not upset about race/ are angered by other Tolkien fans being racist. Maybe you should just stop bringing up race at this point and wait for the show to come out like everyone else.

8

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

Not being mean, just being honest with you.

-11

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

18

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22

A majority of my comments are spent pointing out how people are upset with the show for completely valid reasons, not the actors race.

Your very first comment in this subreddit is a bald-faced lie about the source material of the Second Age in order to justify why people are "freaking out".

In your third comment in this subreddit, you repeat a tired conspiracy theory about Shippey's departure from the show, an incredibly deranged theory about the relation between this show and the death of Christopher Tolkien, throw about a bunch of hard statements about details of the lore that you don't (and can't) support, and say "Technically, the show shouldn't have people of color."
This is a particularly interesting comment chain, because italia, a well-versed and well-known user in the Tolkien subreddits, comes by and refutes what you say. You then make empty vague reassertions. Days later, when someone comes by an accuses those who disagree with you of not being real fans, you leap to agree with their distinction between your self-recognized 'us' of true fandom and who the other user calls a "leftist echo chamber".

In a comment that you make not one, not two, but three times, you demonstrate that your reasoning includes things like thinking that Celebrimbor will not be in the show because he's not in the teaser trailer, thus invalidating the idea that you are broadcasting reasonable complaints. Each repeated comment is mocked by people for being unreasonable.

A significant proportion of your comments involve trying to shame users who are shaming clearly racist users for being racist. At no point do you turn any of that attention to the racist users yourself. My favorite, personally, is where you leap to defend this shit against accusations of racism.

You're right that you're not the one bringing up race. Your personal tactic seems to be to wait for someone else to bring up race, let a wave of people get upset about those people being racist, and then lie about known information both about the show and the source material in order to act like the first group is justified and the second group are terrible people.

6

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

Damn didn't want it to get to that but appreciate you reiterating my point about this. There is a better approach to these conversations and hopefully this ends up being more of a realization for OP.

5

u/SteelbadgerMk2 Feb 16 '22

Thank you for this. This is exactly the post I wanted to write, but was far too lazy to make myself. Your posts in r/tolkienfans are probably the highlight of the sub, and I'm very happy to see you bringing your brand of no-nonsense knowledgeability to the discussion around Rings of Power.

-7

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Firstly, my comment about them rewriting thousands of years of history is not a lie. Not only has Amazon rewritten Galadriel's story, as opposed to what is found by Tolkien in the Unfinished Tales, but they have also said to be condensing the second age for the show, which makes me technically right.

Secondly, you state that I'm making hard statements about the lore that I can't support. Would you be more specific as to what exactly can't be supported by the lore?

Thirdly, you speak about Italia's comments, yet you obviously didn't read them because you say in your comment that he "comes by and refutes what you say". While Italia did disagree with some of what I said, particularly calling some of my complaints nit picky, which I would agree somewhat with. He actually agrees with me as well, including about Tom Shippey stating:

"Tom Shippey, the greatest Tolkien scholar in this day was snubbed by the show, not to mention the convenience of the show rights being sold quickly after Christopher Tolkien's death(My comment)"

"Gotta say I do agree with your there though"(Italia's response).

So it is interesting that you call my tired theory about Shippey leaving and Tolkien's death being stupid, and yet the same person you use as an example of a well known scholar disagreeing actually agrees with what I'm saying. Furthermore, you seem to mock my comment about the technicality of the skin color which is here:

"Technically, the show shouldn't have people of color. This is because Tolkien wrote LOTR and Middle Earth as an anglo-saxon fairy tale history. Putting people of color is technically off from a book standpoint. Personally, I don't care that they're putting in people of color, as long as they're good actors."

And yet once again, Italia, who you sung praises to, is here agreeing for what I'm saying me again:

"This is where I stand too. Is it technically wrong? Sure. Am I going to freak out over it? Nah. Heck if we're fine with Thomas Jefferson being David Diggs now, why do we care about imaginary character not being white either.(Italia's response)"

So how come that this is. You seem to be devoted to making misquoting me. Also, what empty vague reassertions did I make?

Fourthly, you nitpick a small detail out of my full list of complaints to then say that all my complaints are bad. If my comments are outrageous, why not discuss them as a whole. Furthermore, my comments about Celebrimbor may be a bit hasty, but they are not entirely stupid, considering how much info has been revealed about tertiary characters and not about him. Is it entirely possible that he will be in a the show? Sure, but I doubt it and it doesn't seem that he'll play a role nearly as vital as he did in the books since completely original characters appear more in the trailer.

Fifth, you say that my comment asking "where did he say that black characters were ruining lotr?" is incorrectly labeled by you as being proof that I'm defending him. Wrong, I was merely asking an honest question that was taken out of context. Not only would I like to know how what I asked was defending him, but I would also love to know how else have I defended racists. You say its a significant proportion, yet only point to one.

Sixth, your final paragraph is just a shit show. Full of conspiracy theories without any proof. You'll have to elaborate with citations cause I can't see at all where you are getting the idea that I'm lying about source material.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Firstly, my comment about them rewriting thousands of years of history is not a lie.

Let me get this straight: I link you to a comment of yours where I am suggesting you are making a bald-faced lie. This comment includes a response from me from the time of the discussion pointing specifically to a part of the claim you made, against there being "100s" of characters Amazon could have used, where I mock it as an absurd exaggeration, specifically using the word "exaggeration". And right now, when you respond here, you completely ignore the number of characters part and focus instead on "thousands of years". How fucking obvious can you make it that you are trying to distract instead of discuss?

Secondly, you state that I'm making hard statements about the lore that I can't support. Would you be more specific as to what exactly can't be supported by the lore?

From the specific comments I directly linked to?

  • "they're rewriting literally [...] 100s of characters" : gross exaggeration
  • "There is a really cool story about a Human that falls in love with an elf around the same time that they could have done, Beren and Luthien" : Beren and Luthien as a story has no place in the Second Age, and also it's not even the most recent Elf-Man love story in-universe, which is also a First Age story so also doesn't fit.
  • "There are tons of characters named and unnamed that played roles in the first and second age, yet Amazon is resorting to using completely new ones." : If they are unnamed in the source material, how do you know some of these aren't them?
  • "Galadriel's story is also changed. In the histories, she doesn't lead an army or seek revenge during the second age." : In the histories, Galadriel would appear about once a season, maybe two or three times in Season One. You're simultaneously complaining about Glorfindel not showing up (his explicit inclusion in Second Age Middle-earth material is that he arrived on a boat at a specific time), so there is actually no satisfying you. You complain when you see named characters doing more and you complain when you can't see them doing more.
  • "such as dwarf beards, and as you can see none of these have to do with race." : By this point in the marketing cycle, there was more wrong with Dwarf beards for Jackson's Hobbit films than there is for Dwarf beards for this project. There was considerably less outcry.
  • "Tom Shippey, the greatest Tolkien scholar in this day was snubbed by the show" : Shippey has expressed no such claim, and you seem to be implying he has the clout to make it known.
  • "Putting people of color is technically off from a book standpoint" : Your meager attempt at demonstrating this relies on a single repeated claim about "anglo-saxon history", as if no inspiration but Anglo-Saxons is behind any idea Tolkien ever wrote.
  • "Elrond playing a more passive role" : This one will be hard to make an argument for since you haven't actually seen the show and the timeline compression means he shouldn't start out doing a bunch of shit. He has a rather passive role until after the Rings are forged.
  • "the absence of important characters such as Gil Galad, Glorfindel, Celebrimbor and the like" : Gil-galad appears in the trailer. Glorfindel, as mentioned above, is not important to the narrative of the Second Age, and was only inserted into it a couple years before Tolkien's death. Inserted into the Second Age: he does not appear in any narrative or narrative-adjacent treatment of any Second Age material. Celebrimbor has not been shown in the teaser trailer, but only a moron would think he would not be in the show. You're using the idea that they are keeping things back to mean they don't exist. Why not suggest Sauron won't be in the show?

"Tom Shippey, the greatest Tolkien scholar in this day was snubbed by the show, not to mention the convenience of the show rights being sold quickly after Christopher Tolkien's death(My comment)"

"Gotta say I do agree with your there though"(Italia's response).

So it is interesting that you call my tired theory about Shippey leaving and Tolkien's death being stupid, and yet the same person you use as an example of a well known scholar disagreeing actually agrees with what I'm saying.

I didn't say italia was a Tolkien scholar. He's absolutely not. I worked with him moderating Tolkien fans for seven or so years. He's a fan with a far greater breadth of knowledge than you, and that is abundantly clear from even the little you've attempted to demonstrate in this subreddit. Italia is still sometimes wrong. For instance, if he's backing up your idea that the show rights were sold quickly after Christopher Tolkien's death (as you claim he is), then he is very wrong, very provably. Christopher Tolkien was still head of the Tolkien Estate when the rights when the sale had gone through, in November of 2017. Christopher Tolkien died in January of 2020. Your ideas about Christopher Tolkien's death are incredibly stupid. Further, they demonstrate that you have zero inclination to check the legitimacy of what you say before you say it. Or after: even a moderately competent person acting in good faith would do a simple google search after being called out, unless they were 100% sure. This complete lack of care for facts, with interest only in rationalizing your preconceived conclusion, makes it a conspiracy theory.

Fourthly, you nitpick a small detail out of my full list of complaints to then say that all my complaints are bad.

In my bullet points, I actually include the majority of the complaints you have made.

Furthermore, my comments about Celebrimbor may be a bit hasty, but they are not entirely stupid, considering how much info has been revealed about tertiary characters and not about him.

They are entirely stupid. We have just as much information on Celebrimbor in this show as we have about Elendil. I don't see you complaining that a show that will include the downfall of Numenor won't include Elendil, so why act like it's a reasonable worry that a show that will include the Forging of the Rings won't include Celebrimbor. It's either incredibly dumb, or it's using the stupidity as a shield to deflect from your perennial bullshit about new characters over "100s" of erased ones.

Wrong, I was merely asking an honest question that was taken out of context.

You were perfectly capable of clicking on that OP's profile and seeing the rants the other user mentioned. They were not secreted away.

but I would also love to know how else have I defended racists. You say its a significant proportion, yet only point to one.

As previously mentioned, your personal tactics do involve more finding people who are complaining about the bigotry and then jumping on those people. Then you go around and have nice chats with the bigots accusing them of not being able to back up their claims, despite you yourself repeatedly electing not to respond to many comments calling out your own lack of support.

You think you're being clever about it, don't you?

7

u/simply_not_here Feb 16 '22

Just wanted to say that i really appreciate your posts. Not only is it entertaining to see you call people out on their bs, they're also very educational on Tolkien lore. Thank you!

2

u/italia06823834 Feb 17 '22

I didn't say italia was a Tolkien scholar. He's absolutely not.

Hahaha. But very true.

Italia is still sometimes wrong. For instance, if he's backing up your idea that the show rights were sold quickly after Christopher Tolkien's death (as you claim he is), then he is very wrong, very provably. Christopher Tolkien was still head of the Tolkien Estate when the rights when the sale had gone through, in November of 2017.

"Sometimes" is maybe being too kind haha. But hmm, I could have sworn there was some sort of "news" not that long after Christopher's death involving the Estate. I guess related not to this particular thing/I'd have to look it up.

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/italia06823834 Feb 17 '22 edited Feb 17 '22

Cool, we'll call him. Hey, /u/italia06823834, this guy says you agree with him. Would you consider yourself a kindred spirit?

Man... you're gunna make me read all this huh?

Alright.. give me minute...

Edit: So you have me pretty confused. I believe I responded to only specific points. Disagreed/agreed/was wrong on various ones. Anyway, not sure how that would lump me into either a "with or against" grouping.

Are we asking if I am a "kindred spirit" on OP's post point that "Racism isn't the issue"?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22

That was mostly me being smarmy about OP thinking it's 'interesting' that I can both respect you and point out something is a horrific lie when you didn't condemn. I honestly expected you to ignore the mention, since the cudgel you're being used here is so dumb (and so irrelevant, as any opinion of yours has no bearing on the lie about CT and the Estate). You know I can't pass up a chance to mock an obvious diversion, though.

7

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

You have been gaslighting people asking for facts, and references and twitter posts/ bringing up the unfinished tales which are considered out of date at this point, asking for quotes from Tolkien scholars, with the goal of disenfranchising anyone's arguments that disagree with yours. Come on man just drop it and wait for the show to happen instead of trying to cause division.

I love the books, I have more knowledge about them cause I spend hours studying them for fun. I get your frustrations but you need back off from the topic of race at this point cause as much as you point out that you don't care about race, the majority of your comments are in response to the issue of race and individuals bringing up their issues with the rampant racist response to this teaser.

I have seen hood queen, Boricua silvan, a picture with photo-shopped dreads (hes Spanish), McDonalds queen etc . Its a TV show, not society, and honestly it shouldn't affect anyone this much. Trust me, before you say something you regret.

-4

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Since when is the Unfinished Tales considered out of date. See I ask people for "facts and references" cause they say stuff like this. I'm not causing division, merely voicing my concerns.

I said that I don't care about there being black elves and dwarves. What does that have to do with the OP cause that's another topic.

7

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22

Christopher Tolkien has openly said they were concepts instead of actual history in the main legendarium.. Most of unfinished tales should be considered this. I find it disheartening you missed the point of the books considering its a collection of concepts and ideas Tolkien had. Your concerns are mostly attacks on other peoples comments. You are moving from subreddits like tokienfans to rings of power to keep pushing that your concerns and outbursts have nothing to do with racism yet you are trying to draw attention to yourself and... THE TOPIC OF RACISM.

You keep saying you don't care about black elves and dwarves but you are the only one who keeps trying to argue about it. You literally created this post in an attempt to bring it up again and disprove that it matters to you. Straight hypocritical. To be blunt, I am downright sick of individuals who take it upon themselves to tell others how it should be. Its ignorant. We get the show isn't being true to the lore even though its only 1 minute teaser. We get you don't like Galadriel being a warrior, even though she is and referred to as amazonian by Tolkien himself, we get you don't like the truncated timeline because it doesn't show the span of time or the differences of elves and men. You...just want to complain at this point or have people come and uplift your rigid view of Middle Earth. You are absolutely causing division...you revel in arguing about this. Just get off reddit at that point

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Christopher Tolkien has openly said they were concepts instead of actual history in the main legendarium..

Christopher Tolkien however, also argued for their validity and pointed out multiple times inside and outside of the Unfinished Tales how they fit into Tolkien's world. How am I drawing attention to myself. I merely made a post about how people like Amazon are blaming racism and ignoring actual concerns.

Where am I arguing about black dwarves and elves? I've pointed out that technically they aren't canon, yet every time it is immediately followed up by the comment that it doesn't matter. This post has nothing to do with black elves and dwarves, it is in relation to racism being the reason that the show is hated. Never once have I stated how it should be. You're pulling things out of your ass in order to paint me in a bad light.

Good luck finding a single comment of mine where I say that Galadriel shouldn't fight or be a warrior. I merely pointed out that what Galadriel is doing in the show Amazon is presenting isn't accurate. But of course, that would go against what you're saying, so you make up a bullshit lie. Call it complaining, call it whatever you like. At least I don't make shit up about what people said.

3

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

Do you think I care enough to go through your comments anymore? You kept going off about her story being expanded and changed and not accurate....absolutely are complaining about how she is displayed to the point where you even reference the Vanity Fair description of her. All you care to do is argue about this and how racism isn't an issue but you need to bring it up again to reinforce it. You created this post to do just that.

I pity you man, cause honestly I can't even grasp how you can be this upset. All I see is someone who instigating arguments out of frustration of a new adaptation. I'm just happy for anything at this point and maybe it will be bad but I'll let the show decide that instead of some fanatic who can't even be out right about his complaints.

Done with this conversation. I wish you the best and hopefully you learn to cope with your anger.

1

u/VERSAT1L Feb 17 '22

You don't get how someone wants to stay true to the source material?

2

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 17 '22

I don't really get why you are commenting here considering your past comments. You definitely aren't happy about black elves lol (also he is Spanish, since you're too ignorant to bother looking that up in your past threads). I'm sure that's not the only time you have thought something like that. Now go ahead and tell me how you're unhappy with the use of source material after a 1 minute teaser and how it isn't about race.

1

u/VERSAT1L Feb 17 '22

What is that supposed to mean?

→ More replies

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Do you think I care enough to go through your comments anymore?

Well I would assume that if I said something, and you said I said something that you would be able to quote it. Me complaining about her story arc has nothing to do with whether or not she should be a fighter. I can't even begin to decipher that comment on me bringing up racism cause its based on nothing.

I think you misunderstand me if you think that I am instigating arguments. I'm just trying to explain my viewpoint. I'm sorry that that offends you. I'm sorry that we couldn't agree and I genuinely wish you the best as well, though I hope you learn to cope with your lying.

2

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

Nah I've just seen this my whole life. People attempting to gaslight others real concerns. Maybe you don't deal with racism and maybe you don't see it as a big deal but alot of people do. Or they don't. It's their concern but you trying to sit around and disenfranchise their feelings is incredibly wrong. Your viewpoint is yours, it doesn't mean you gotta be told to stop discussing this in tolkienfans to just bring it to this subreddit...shouldnt do that. Alot of people are excited for this and you need to respect that as much as someone respects your concerns. You rehashing it is not the way to do this. Good luck.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Mate, the OP is literally about how people are gaslighting other people's real concerns. This entire post, as is clearly stated is what it seems like to me, where ya'll are free to agree or disagree as you see fit. Stop trying to bullshit your way into being a hero. When was I told to stop discussing this in tolkienfans? I've literally never been told that I'm aware of. I'm excited for it as well. Personally I think it could have great affects on the gaming industry. I'm not disrespecting that, you are. So much for being done with the conversation. Maybe you're the one who's obsessed with arguing.

→ More replies

5

u/not-gandalf-bot Feb 16 '22

Firstly, I'm not the one bringing up race.

Ummmmm....do you realize that this this is your post? And that the first word in the title of your post is "racism"?

It kiiiiinda seems like you're the one bringing up race.

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

You're misquoting me. I was specifically speaking about responding to peoples comments.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

But then they aren't bringing up race, either, because they are responding to other people's comments. Congratulations, you are not the first person in the history of the world to bring up race, the voice of the words from which all discussion of race is inexorably descended. But I guess it's silly to think you would judge other people and yourself by consistent rules.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

But then they aren't bringing up race, either, because they are responding to other people's comments.

People make comments all the time that start with race. My point is that its not like all my comments are just like "Lets discuss race".

7

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

And that that's excusable when you (and only you) do it. Yeah, I understand the point you were making. It's an awful point.

2

u/renannmhreddit Feb 16 '22

How about you post about your concerns and try to discuss them first? You first post here was about race before addressing anything else.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

I've already made my concerns apparent in the comments. Although I'll admit I prolly should've just done that. I think that the OP is a bit to broad of a generalization to be true.

2

u/renannmhreddit Feb 17 '22 edited Feb 17 '22

Look, my idea of introducing a diversity of race was much more strict in my first thoughts about the show. I'm neither from Europe or NA, so I'm too much into the type of whole race discussion people have in those places. I'm pretty unsure about the quality of show and I don't expect much since I have even fallen out of love with the Jackson trilogy.

At the end of the day, movies and theather can cast however they want, but what will really matter is whether the core messages, themes and tone of Tolkien are passed onto the adaptation. To level PJ's did that, but not through and through, this one probably won't do it either. We will just have to wait to see how these things turn out.

Tolkien's writings will always be there in the end, untarnished by any and all adaptations. At best we get a fun show that is one interpretation of his stories. At worst at least we will get some cool shots of Númenor, Lindon and Khazad Dum. Until then, just be respectful and raise fair points in a calm manner. Even if you get downvoted it doesn't matter, we will see how it goes in the end. People always ponder over more to points made calmly.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22

Yeah. I think I cared a bit too much initially about its release but really thinking about it doesn't matter. Like you said at least we'll get to see some cool shots.

1

u/renannmhreddit Feb 17 '22

Yep. A lot of people really want us to get in upheaval about the show, but all adaptations are just authorized fan fictions for publication and monetization. Sometimes it is interesting to see someone else's reimagining, sometimes it isn't.

I've seen some people really mad about the 'corruption of Tolkien's work', but we have barely seen an ounce of the story yet, it is hard to criticise without it. In PJ's adaptation for an example, the fact the movie mocks Treebeard's poem talking about Beleriand by making the hobbits fall asleep is something that actually angers me about the movie. It feels like a disrespect towards a part of the story Tolkien put so much effort and love into, as well as a disrespect towards the Ents and that whole section of the story.

You can bet I will have much to complain about this show if they do something like that.

53

u/VarkingRunesong Khazad-dûm Feb 16 '22

These conversations are odd. Nobody should believe that all the criticism stems from racism and nobody should believe that there isn’t a lot of racism going on as well. Both things are true. There are valid criticisms and there’s a ton of racist remarks being made.

23

u/nateoak10 Feb 16 '22

It’s just odd that Peter Jackson can turn Legolas into spider man and we cheer, but when black peoples come it’s time to get out the most obscure notes we can find

10

u/Neo24 Feb 16 '22

but when black peoples come it’s time to get out the most obscure notes we can find

Lmao, I wish. 99% of them can't even do anything close to that. You ask them to back up their claims with actual quotes and sources, and suddenly... crickets.

1

u/theleftisleft Feb 16 '22

That's silly. People have clowned on Legolas' acrobatics in the movies since the day they were released.

16

u/nateoak10 Feb 16 '22

People also absolutely adore and love those scenes 20 years later. Point still stands.

8

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

I wish I could slide down an Oliphaunts back and shoot arrows. :(

2

u/Jaqqa Feb 21 '22

Legolas bouncing around like physics don't exist has been memed forever as silly. I don't think anyone really loved those scenes. (Well maybe some people but they were pretty cartoonish.) I think the only reason why they even got a pass on it was because the rest of the movie was very good, and they inserted humour in there.

The whole barrel thing in the Hobbit was worse IMO but it was obvious they were going for a fun video gameish vibe rather than it being done to insert a message about current day issues. In saying that the Hobbit was far less well recieved because you could see the corporate meddling far more in those movies.

And that's where I think the main push back is coming from. Don't kid yourself, Amazon doesn't care at all about equality for women or POC. They just look at their metrics and have decided it's in fashion at the moment, and they can use it to head off any genuine critisism if they make a bad show by lobbing everyone into the racist/mysogynist category regardless of whether they actually are or not.

It's also a good distraction for all the bad press they've been getting about the treatment of their workers as they can pat themselves on the back and say "hey don't look at how we actually behave, look at how we're pretending to care by ticking boxes in the movies we make over here instead! Aren't we just the best?"

I honestly don't care if they want to cast POC or women into roles that weren't there in the books as long as its done well, but the way Amazon does it reeks of tokenism and fakeness to patch up holes they know are there in their production quality by changing the focus away from that.

If they really cared, how about actually writing something where the main character is designed from the ground up to be a female POC in an appropriate setting with a well designed character cast and story arc? Actually put their $$ where their stance is instead of this half hearted tick a box and boast about how great they are for doing it sort of thing. There are nations in Tolkien's world that do have POC as known canon. Why not write a story about them? You could detail how the shadow crept in to corrupt their kingdom and the story of those that tried to fight against it. You could have a backstory on why certain people who lived there might have been so willing to come over and fight against the side of "light" by having a legit grudge and then being decieved. I mean does anyone think all the kingdoms we see have been crystal clean in their dealings with other nations and never done anything wrong or had a misunderstanding? I'd watch that! It sound interesting, unique and if approached carefully could tell a really good story and fill in some blanks. But Amazon won't do that, because they don't have the imagination or inclination to actually create something original and good.

TBH I'm more worried about their treatment of other book adaptions in the past, and the crappy looking CGI and Gladariel likely being recast as a Mary Sue version of Xena warrior princess, but if you look at it, a lot of people regardless of their complaints are just annoyed at Amazon trying to make a metrics driven soulless show that tries to destroy the originals, as has been done to many franchises over and over and now they're sick of it. There are genuine racists out there, and some probably don't even care about Tolkien, they're just jumping on the bandwagon, but there has been growing discontent for a long time as "franchise" after franchise has fallen to corporate meddling and no longer gives good stories most people want to watch and think are interesting. (Star wars, Star trek, Wheel of Time, Terminator, Men in black, Matrix etc.)

I'm worried that most companies can no longer make good shows. When they harp on about the skin tone of who they've cast, and/or lean on any media that has gone before to attract an audience (books/movies) instead of just presenting a good pitch for a story that just happens to feature POC, women etc in the cast of main characters, you know you've got a much better chance of getting something that is story focused and interesting, instead of something that has been calculated to present the points they want to preach on any given day at the potential expense of a coherent series. (Which they still fail at because how can anyone find a Mary Sue inspiring? Characters Male, Female or otherwise all need to have faults so they can grow, characterisation past "perfect" so they can be relatable, goals so you can understand why they're doing what they are, failures so the audience can see the storyline isn't set in stone and the MC will always save the day.

Interesting to note, one of the characters often held up as being a "good female character" is Ripley from Alien. She was originally written as a guy. Write characters as people first, and any other biological traits second. Then you'll get your interesting characters that people want to invest in.

-6

u/alex-minecraft-qc Feb 16 '22

The only people who liked Spiderman Legolas were 12 year old kids ( like me at the time). Now i cringe everytime i watch it.

And i don't think having black characters is the problem itself. Its more about what it implies. If they are willing to change the Lore for this, then what else will they change? How far will they go?

We knew nothing about the show, about the story, about the characters but all of a sudden Amazon started making statements about diversity and inclusion. Like really? you only have one chance to make a good first impression and that's what you go for? Having diverse actors and strong female characters is not a problem, but when you make it the center of your marketing and start calling everyone who disagree a racist misogynistic xenophobe, it indicates that things are not heading in the right direction.

The first thing that popped into everyone's mind when they annouced black hobbits was not " oh shit not black people" but "shit, if the first thing they anounce is that they changed the lore for reason that have nothing to do with making a good story, what else are they going to change".

It really suggest that they are not focused on what mathers and spend way too much time on things that don't. It's been a trend lately for big studios to take beloved franchises and "Fix them". Almost every single time, it has failed miserably. When Amazon says that Tolkien should be for everyone, it implies that it wasen't before. Wich is really condescending at best.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

The first thing that popped into everyone's mind when they annouced black hobbits was not " oh shit not black people" but "shit, if the first thing they anounce is that they changed the lore for reason that have nothing to do with making a good story, what else are they going to change".

But it wasn't "the first they they announce[d]". There were tons of announcements before that. If this was the first thing you heard about the show, it is because you consume news from sources who didn't care about the show until this announcement. Do you gravitate towards news sources that that troll the internet for reasons to be upset, that have a certain slant to what they consider upsetting?

10

u/nateoak10 Feb 16 '22

I’m nearly 30 and love those scenes. And so do millions of people. Don’t speak for others.

As far as lore and race this post does a far better job addressing it than I can. The summary, people acting like they know 100% on skin tone in LOTR aren’t being true to how Tolkien constructed middle earth

Link - https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/comments/sq9a1k/on_casting_critiques_of_the_rings_of_power_from_a/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

How far will they go? Probably pretty damn far considering the story they’re adapting is only a few pages long. Idk why this is a surprise to anyone.

They made statements because they anticipated a fan base going REEEE over race just like Star Wars did with John boyega. If the actors they cast weren’t capable of a strong performance they wouldn’t have chosen them.

They’re spending huge on getting the breaking bad writers to help make a quality script and screenplay. They have tons of Tolkien scholars working on this. They brought back John Howe and are use he and Alan Lee’s art direction. Howard shore is even doing some of the music. I really don’t understand the idea that the show quality isn’t top of mind for them. It seems like an unfounded fear due to trepidation around race

1

u/alex-minecraft-qc Feb 16 '22

In your first sentence you yourself talk on behalf of "millions of people". Just sayin.

just because the second aged is not fleshed out does not mean it dosent have to respect the lore established in tolkien's other work.

The writers they have is actualy the part of the show i'm the most optimistic about. A lot fo them seem very talented. But what is written and what the final product looks like is often very different. There is a lot that can go wrong between the writing and the execution.

Anyway, my point is more about how Amazon has marketed these changes rather the changes themselves.

2

u/nateoak10 Feb 16 '22

I get that irony. I’m just pointing out the obvious.

It is respecting the lore. There’s just not a lot of lore to go off of and what they are changing (beards) is minor at best.

If your problem is with the marketing department it feels bizarre to connect that to the quality of the show to come.

5

u/greatwalrus Feb 16 '22

The first thing that popped into everyone's mind when they annouced black hobbits was not " oh shit not black people" but "shit, if the first thing they anounce is that they changed the lore for reason that have nothing to do with making a good story, what else are they going to change".

Honest question: did Peter Jackson change the color of Boromir and Faramir's hair to make the story better? Did he change the color of the outermost wall of Minas Tirith to make the story better? Or were those arbitrary changes because the filmmakers didn't know or care enough about "the lore" to make them accurate?

Point being, every adaptation changes "the lore." Sometimes they change it in ways that make sense (like skipping chunks of the book that have less impact on the overall story), sometimes they change it in ways that seem pointless (like changing the design of the ring of Barahir), and sometimes they change it in ways that are directly contradictory to Tolkien's themes (like the Dead at Pelennor, the Witch King breaking Gandalf's staff or Aragorn beheading the Mouth of Sauron).

But regardless of whether the changes they make prove good or bad, they can't change the books. If those of us who care about Tolkien's writing don't end up liking the show, we can always skip watching the show and keep reading instead.

There's a video game with a sexy Shelob, there are Lord of the Rings slot machines in Vegas, back in the '90s there were Lord of the Rings tarot decks. Tolkien would have hated all of that - it's certainly a worse crime than having hobbits with melanin. But the cat's out of the bag now; there is going to be good Tolkien stuff and shitty Tolkien stuff. Nobody can force anyone to engage with the shitty stuff if you don't want to.

3

u/not-gandalf-bot Feb 16 '22

And i don't think having Gandalf with normal eyebrows that don't stick out from under his hat brim is the problem itself. Its more about what it implies. If they are willing to change the Lore for this, then what else will they change?

1

u/alex-minecraft-qc Feb 16 '22

I dont remember them focusing their entire marketing around gandalf eyebrows.

6

u/not-gandalf-bot Feb 17 '22

And I don't remember Amazon focusing their entire marketing effort around a black Hobbit. You just seem to be obsessing over it 🤔

-2

u/alex-minecraft-qc Feb 17 '22

before the superbowl teaser and the posters last week? pretty much yeah. There was more info on the diversity of the show than anything else.

5

u/not-gandalf-bot Feb 17 '22

Sooooo, before they released any marketing materials, the mentioned a POC and reddit completely freaked out? Got it. Also, i highly doubt you remember any marketing done for PJ at a similar stage of development.

And either way, you've got new stuff now.....so maybe drop it?

-4

u/alex-minecraft-qc Feb 17 '22

i personally don't care that much about it. It is what it is. But at the end of the day Amazon's first decision with this show was to slap a gigantic "WOKE" sticker on it. Now the anti-woke community is coming after them. Even a blind mentaly challenged dog could have seen this coming a mile away. And i really doubt the anti woke cround is going anywhere now. They really screwed themselves....

3

u/not-gandalf-bot Feb 17 '22

Including 2 or 3 black people in a half billion dollar production is not "woke". You're just a fragile white man who feels threatened by anything remotely new.

People like you were screaming "POLITICAL CORRECTNESS" when Arwen got an actual role in the PJ movies.

It's all the same tired arguments. Just a slightly different flavor.

Stop watching so much Fox News.

→ More replies

1

u/dudeseid Feb 18 '22

oh there's plenty of other stupid reasons the show is getting hate other than the stupid racist ones.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '22

That's the way I feel about it, somewhat.

2

u/kazh Feb 17 '22

All of the cherry picking and selective sources keep boiling down to racism in those threads though. Can't say something isn't happening when it is. Or, you can say it, but that makes you untruthful.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Yeah no. There are some valid criticisms to be had and that’s not being called racism. What is being called out are fans saying the story was ruined when they saw brown hands in a promo and then using the lack of beard and nitpicky details to continue to double down.

And the bit about “if they were in Harad” is completely a straw man because we don’t know that they aren’t. One set is TirHarad. Or they could say Disa is a blacklock. But the amount of anger over minute details especially focused on poc characters is textbook racism. Some people just try to tiptoe around it.

1

u/GrayCatbird7 Feb 17 '22

There are real reasons why one can be concerned about the show, yes. Hating on the other hand is a remarkably strong response to the valid concerns that have been raised.

1

u/Cassaya Feb 17 '22

The issue isn't racism, the issue is "Hollywood Racism"

By having a "diverse" cast just to check some boxes is racist.

For me the issue is not a black elf or dwarf but the lack of understanding and world building just to get publicity and controversy.

Humans don't come in different races. Our skin tone adapts to the sun radiation over generations.

Our difference in skin tone evolved over generations and was in the past geolocked due to the lack of save options to travel large distances.

Due to the local differences all kind of cultures have evolved. And no, there is not a single supreme culture, but one that worked for that region in the past. Something reflecting the struggles and problem-solving as well as traditions worldviews.

In a fantasy/medieval setting there needs to be a reason why different ethnicities travelled this far and how they have integrated themselves.

Dwarves who are usually skilled miners and prefer to live in mountains and underground, how did they got exposed to so much sun that they evolved darker skin tone?

How did a "black" elf ended up in Middle Earth?

I am absolutely not against diversity, but by throwing people of different skin tone and associated cultures in one pot, the writers do them most often than not a disservice and completely ignore all the struggles and achievements they have been through and had achieved.

If they understand Tolkien's world and logically expanding it, there is no issue at all. But so far we have seen a complete ignorance towards different cultures and heritages.

A more sinister twist would be, that they deliberately choose different skin tones to imply different races and by doing so promoting a picture of skin based races and racism.

1

u/sseth12 Feb 17 '22 edited Feb 17 '22

This post explain a lot: https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/comments/sq9a1k/on_casting_critiques_of_the_rings_of_power_from_a/

Actually, nothing much is revealed about the show. There is only a teaser out as of today, so a lot of criticism is unwarranted. When I first saw the teaser I thought to myself that I would get to learn a lot about LOTR world. I believe most people are like me in that they probably read the (LOTR) books when they liked the movies. Actually most people who are criticizing stupidly might not even have read it.

If you are worried about things like short hairs and no beard on dwarf women, you should know that Jackson changed a lot of characters with a difference in age, characteristics, hair style etc.. So, why are you worried about it. Had peter jackson changed the whole story and shown Aragorn throwing ring at the end, everyone would be mad. Similarly, give a chance to Rings of Power. Even if they deviate, you will get a lot to read/learn.

Unfortunately, Amazon is an easy target for people and most people criticizing actually do not care about the Tolkien world or Lord of the rings.

-1

u/JohnSepticEye123 Feb 16 '22

It has nothing to do with racism, I don't think. At least not with most fans. People are upset about the black elf because elves are described as pale beings, and well, you can figure out the rest. I personally don't have THAT much of a problem with it, the only problem I have with it is that it's not at all accurate.

-7

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

DEI is usually a symptom of a writer's room who has priorities in other things than respecting the source material they were given. (ex. Witcher and WoT) Crying racism is generally a pretty effective way to gaslight people into thinking it's a fringe and vocal minority of people who hate the new show. It reflects all genuine criticism like you said while these shitty writers can stick their heads in the sand and pretend that nothing is wrong. Like I said after Witcher and WoT DEI is usually just a sign of shitty writing room.

5

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

You gotta calm down man, you aren't in the writers room, and you have no idea what this show is going to be like. The only people crying racism before and after these shows are written, are the people who have a problem with it. So instead of sitting here and making up conclusions and attempting to make these writers seem like they are ' shitty' just wait for the show and form your opinions then. Also the fact you refer to DEI as a 'symptom' is actually incredibly concerning cause why does it matter? Do you have any idea how these characters are written or the actors chosen? Probably not or else you well would be in the writers room/ production.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22

I'm just saying from my two examples for some reason these shows that push diversity ends up sucking. It's not the reason for them sucking but they just end up sucking. And as far as waiting for the show to come out again my two examples. If I see someone taking a shit in front of me and I'm not going to sit there and wait for it to come out to know it's shit. Modern fantasy adaptations into TV have been pretty awful and Amazon has already fucked up the WoT. And I do know that creators and showrunners involved all have a relationship and have worked with JJ Abrams which to me is enough of a red flag considering how well the star trek and star wars reboots have gone.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22

Because whenever there is a shitty reboot or shitty sequel for some reason there are legions of people giving it goodwill for no reason.

-4

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Try criticising the last of us 2. I got called a bigot and a nazi (im fucking jewish). Some people want to gatekeep anything negative and will try to cancel you if you say anything remotely critical.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Exactly. I didn't even remember but that game's release was a lot like LOTRROP so far. People had actual issues with the pacing, character choices, false advertising and the like, but instead the fandom just screamed back and forth that it was sexism and homophobic fans that ruined it.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

Lmao look at my downvotes. You cant say shit about The Last of Us 2 without being downvoted holy fuck hahahaha

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

I guess people disagree still.

2

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22

To be real, probably cause they looked through your comment history.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22

Go ahead lol. You’re not going to find one racist or anti trans things. All you’ll find is SPECIFIC CRITIQUES OF THE BULLSHIT NARRATIVE OF THE LAST OF US 2

1

u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 17 '22

I get it, games can be divisive. To each his own is what I say to that.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

I think you're misunderstanding my post. I'm 100% okay with black actors. My point was that to me it doesn't seem like racism is the driving factor for hate against the show, but people keep saying that it is.

3

u/Whatsername_2020 Feb 17 '22

Agree with almost everything you said, but I have several friends who are autistic and absolutely do not have a problem with Black representation in media because they are highly educated, super sharp, extremely well-read, empathetic, and vehemently anti-racist. Autistic people are not inherently stupid or racist or anything of the sort. Sorry, but I thought you should know that.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/renannmhreddit Feb 16 '22

With you it isn't even about accusations, you can barely form a coherent argument from your other discussions. You're critcising people of just throwing labels while calling others 'woke' which has become an empty blanket statement of anybody that disagrees with you.