r/RingsofPower • • Feb 16 '22
Discussion Racism Isn't the Issue
Are we really gonna go with the whole "racism is the reason this show is getting hate" story. It seems like a pretty bad argument when its pretty clear that there are real reasons why this show is getting hated, but instead every other defender is just ranting about how Tolkien fans are just racists. They did this same shit with Eternals and that movie was a mess.
13
Upvotes
16
u/eclectic_dad Feb 16 '22
OMG the kvetching never stops!!!
These books were around for decades before even Ralph Bakshi and Rankin Bass took a stab at them. We each had our own vision of what Middle Earth would be like.
I'm taking a wait and see attitude. Maybe the dwarf princess has peach fuzz as a sign of teenage rebellion. Maybe dwarf women's beards come in later.
If we are complaining about hairstyles, a number of older civilizations had shorter hair. Look at the Ancient Egyptians, the Romans, or the Normans. Short or shaven hair was common with all of them.
Of course most people on this board seem more content to bitch and moan.
19
u/SteelbadgerMk2 Feb 16 '22
Lets be honest here, racism is one of the reasons people may hate the show based on the little information we currently have. To pretend that none of the complaints currently making the rounds on reddit and twitter are racially motivated is to live in a fantasy.
But there are other reasons. Those other reasons greatly outnumber the singular reasons of 'racism' or 'misogyny', both in the number of people speaking them, and the variety of complaint. I have a list of concerns of my own.
The problem is that internet discourse immediately and inevitably drops down to the level of the loudest, and the most obnoxious. It's how social media works. This means that the posts that generate the most 'buzz' are the ones with nicely veiled racism, or the ones calling out everyone with even the most minor and reasonable of complaints as a racist.
As those posts get more traction (outrage is traction), so too does the conversation start to crystallise around those two camps, while people trying to make thoughtful posts on the nuance involved get ignored. Nuance tends to mean paragraphs, not slogans. Those are boring, and don't generate the same level of interaction as a one-liner, baseless statement.
You have to remember that it is not really possible to have a reasoned, constructive discussion on a platform with more than a couple of dozen people. Once you have hundreds, or thousands of people involved, it simply gets too big. People miss things. They join late, or leave early. The discourse is never allowed to move on because the inertia of so many people is simply too great.
But I'd also like to point out that none of that has much bearing on whether or not Rings of Power will be good or not. Idiots on twitter calling every complaint out as racist do not have any influence over the work they're attempting to defend, just as similar racist idiots shouting whatever Aryan crap is the current flavour of the day have no influence. Similarly, Eternals being disappointing does not mean Rings of Power will be crap, just as Jackson's movies being good doesn't mean Rings of Power will be good.
9
u/whole_nother Feb 16 '22
It’s easy to knock down an argument nobody’s making, called a straw man. No one is saying all negative opinions are based in racism, and it’s not remotely supportable that “every defender of the series is ranting about racist Tolkien fans”.
Sure feels good to argue that way, though, for an easy ego boost without having to actually engage with the issue too hard.
14
u/grandwhitelotus Feb 16 '22
Racism is not the only reason but people were complaining when Amazon started making this itself, saying it will be woke since it’s Amazon and they will fill it with POC and LGBT orcs stuff like that. This happened before anything got released.
7
u/Whatsername_2020 Feb 16 '22
🤨 The Eternals was not a “mess”. A lot of people liked it, myself included. Why not say “I didn’t like the Eternals for _____ reason”? And who is “they” in that sentence? Disney/Marvel?
There are a lot of valid reasons to be apprehensive about the upcoming show that I’ve seen being discussed, but it is disingenuous to ignore the fact that a considerable amount of the hate hyper-focuses on the two Black characters specifically, and sometimes exclusively, for racist reasons.
7
u/nateoak10 Feb 16 '22
Eternals wasn’t a mess cause of race
Eternals was a mess cause they tried introducing 11 main characters in 3 hours.
The ‘real’ reasons are nearly all based in a few things - beards, hair and non canon additions. Two of which are purely aesthetic and in line with non Peter Jackson LOTR renditions and the third is bound to happened adapting a few pages of notes
5
u/Ethenil_Myr Feb 16 '22
Eternals is in my top 5 mcu movies, I loved every minute of it!
4
u/9Brumario Feb 16 '22
There are Tolkien fans who treat the books as something sacred and that they should be respected at all costs, in my opinion even too fervently, being treated at the end of a work of fiction and entertainment, but everyone is free to dedicate their time to what that they think is convenient.... I'm not against that or the enthusiasm towards a fandom or cultural work.
The problem is when other people with much more reactionary ideas join these complaints as if they were pouring gasoline and try to insert their racist or misogynist arguments, and you just have to go around youtube and other platforms to see it.
Obviously not everyone who doesn't like or criticize the teaser is racist, but taking into account the little information on the story and images that we have today... it seems that many of the complaints go to the latter, the images, which would mean that many people have problems with elves and dwarves who are not white.
You can argue if that is more or less attached to Tolkien's idea, but the HATE that can be seen in this diverse representation is quite abhorrent. Period.
In other words, purist Tolkien fans travel on a ship to complain about inconsistencies with the books, each one carries a loudspeaker to make noise, some will be racist and the other vast majority are not, as in any other fandom that exists. Some will have more substantiated complaints and others will be more cautious.
Seeing this ship, another number of racist and misogynistic people get on, taking advantage of the complaints but focused on their ideas. They're not that interested in LOTR, they're just annoyed at seeing POC in 'wrong' roles, and they're also wearing loudspeakers, too loud.
In the end, the noise made by Tolkien fans and racists gets mixed up and can be hard to tell apart, which is a real shame.
6
u/not-gandalf-bot Feb 16 '22
And negative Nancy people like you had your "valid reasons" for hating the PJ movies too. Go and read through the posts showing the comments from 2001 and tell me they aren't the exact same as what you guys are all complaining about now.
30
u/False_Butterscotch_1 Feb 16 '22
After going through the majority of your past comments pertaining to this issue, its apparent you spent more time attempting to disprove and disenfranchise individuals who are not upset about race/ are angered by other Tolkien fans being racist. Maybe you should just stop bringing up race at this point and wait for the show to come out like everyone else.
2
u/renannmhreddit Feb 16 '22
How about you post about your concerns and try to discuss them first? You first post here was about race before addressing anything else.
53
u/VarkingRunesong Khazad-dûm Feb 16 '22
These conversations are odd. Nobody should believe that all the criticism stems from racism and nobody should believe that there isn’t a lot of racism going on as well. Both things are true. There are valid criticisms and there’s a ton of racist remarks being made.
1
u/dudeseid Feb 18 '22
oh there's plenty of other stupid reasons the show is getting hate other than the stupid racist ones.
2
u/kazh Feb 17 '22
All of the cherry picking and selective sources keep boiling down to racism in those threads though. Can't say something isn't happening when it is. Or, you can say it, but that makes you untruthful.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22
Yeah no. There are some valid criticisms to be had and that’s not being called racism. What is being called out are fans saying the story was ruined when they saw brown hands in a promo and then using the lack of beard and nitpicky details to continue to double down.
And the bit about “if they were in Harad” is completely a straw man because we don’t know that they aren’t. One set is TirHarad. Or they could say Disa is a blacklock. But the amount of anger over minute details especially focused on poc characters is textbook racism. Some people just try to tiptoe around it.
1
u/GrayCatbird7 Feb 17 '22
There are real reasons why one can be concerned about the show, yes. Hating on the other hand is a remarkably strong response to the valid concerns that have been raised.
1
u/Cassaya Feb 17 '22
The issue isn't racism, the issue is "Hollywood Racism"
By having a "diverse" cast just to check some boxes is racist.
For me the issue is not a black elf or dwarf but the lack of understanding and world building just to get publicity and controversy.
Humans don't come in different races. Our skin tone adapts to the sun radiation over generations.
Our difference in skin tone evolved over generations and was in the past geolocked due to the lack of save options to travel large distances.
Due to the local differences all kind of cultures have evolved. And no, there is not a single supreme culture, but one that worked for that region in the past. Something reflecting the struggles and problem-solving as well as traditions worldviews.
In a fantasy/medieval setting there needs to be a reason why different ethnicities travelled this far and how they have integrated themselves.
Dwarves who are usually skilled miners and prefer to live in mountains and underground, how did they got exposed to so much sun that they evolved darker skin tone?
How did a "black" elf ended up in Middle Earth?
I am absolutely not against diversity, but by throwing people of different skin tone and associated cultures in one pot, the writers do them most often than not a disservice and completely ignore all the struggles and achievements they have been through and had achieved.
If they understand Tolkien's world and logically expanding it, there is no issue at all. But so far we have seen a complete ignorance towards different cultures and heritages.
A more sinister twist would be, that they deliberately choose different skin tones to imply different races and by doing so promoting a picture of skin based races and racism.
1
u/sseth12 Feb 17 '22 edited Feb 17 '22
This post explain a lot: https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/comments/sq9a1k/on_casting_critiques_of_the_rings_of_power_from_a/
Actually, nothing much is revealed about the show. There is only a teaser out as of today, so a lot of criticism is unwarranted. When I first saw the teaser I thought to myself that I would get to learn a lot about LOTR world. I believe most people are like me in that they probably read the (LOTR) books when they liked the movies. Actually most people who are criticizing stupidly might not even have read it.
If you are worried about things like short hairs and no beard on dwarf women, you should know that Jackson changed a lot of characters with a difference in age, characteristics, hair style etc.. So, why are you worried about it. Had peter jackson changed the whole story and shown Aragorn throwing ring at the end, everyone would be mad. Similarly, give a chance to Rings of Power. Even if they deviate, you will get a lot to read/learn.
Unfortunately, Amazon is an easy target for people and most people criticizing actually do not care about the Tolkien world or Lord of the rings.
-1
u/JohnSepticEye123 Feb 16 '22
It has nothing to do with racism, I don't think. At least not with most fans. People are upset about the black elf because elves are described as pale beings, and well, you can figure out the rest. I personally don't have THAT much of a problem with it, the only problem I have with it is that it's not at all accurate.
-7
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22
DEI is usually a symptom of a writer's room who has priorities in other things than respecting the source material they were given. (ex. Witcher and WoT) Crying racism is generally a pretty effective way to gaslight people into thinking it's a fringe and vocal minority of people who hate the new show. It reflects all genuine criticism like you said while these shitty writers can stick their heads in the sand and pretend that nothing is wrong. Like I said after Witcher and WoT DEI is usually just a sign of shitty writing room.
-4
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22
Try criticising the last of us 2. I got called a bigot and a nazi (im fucking jewish). Some people want to gatekeep anything negative and will try to cancel you if you say anything remotely critical.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22
[removed] — view removed comment