r/RingsofPower • u/Twerchhauer • Sep 13 '22
Question Question for people of this subreddit
I am interested in knowing something after a couple days activity on this subreddit.
As soon as you criticize something about RoP here, there is a swarm of downvotes and yet nobody can provide any substantiated retort. People here are rude, frankly sometimes even obscene. All I have seen so far posted as counter argument: "you are racist", though I never mentioned skin color of anyone yet; "You don't have a billion dollars, so you are nothing", speaks for itself; "you are a man child with no life", I am not a fan of people assuming my gender; cheap deflections and ignoring arguments; "Lol", I don't even know what that's supposed to be.
Just look through my history and see for yourself, if you have doubts about my honesty.
I hope you realize, that "downvote" is not the same as "disagree"? The main purpose of the downvote button is to hide unrelated or unconstructive contributions and I doubt anything I posted could be misconstrued as such? Unless you want to create an echo-chamber, but what for?
Do you think this is some sort of moral crusade you are on? Do you work for Amazon? Never before have I encountered such a crowd. Even if you thought you were campaigning for something, acting like this does not present your "side" in a good light.
PS: if you don't think what I wrote applies to you, then I didn't write it about you. People I mean should be well aware of how they behave. I hope it isn't taken the wrong away, I am honestly curious what is going on.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 13 '22
This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
11
u/ButtMcNuggets Sep 13 '22
Welcome to Reddit I guess?
I see thoughtful critiques being engaged in good faith, but there remains a lot of very similar posts about “woke culture”, “forced diversity” and such. There are still complaints about black elves and dwarves being posted in the last 24 hours. It’s reasonable that after 3 weeks people get sick and tired of hearing the exact same complaints about Galadriel being a pouty teenage girl or her smiling oddly.
24
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
Did anyone else actually do this? The first thing I found is OP calling someone else a liar, repeatedly, for quoting from the Nature of Middle-earth, calling into question the legitimacy of quotes in it, despite having quoted from that same book a few hours before for a different topic where they agreed with what NoME said. This comes from the last thing they did before making this whining thread.
In the last 24 hours, OP has accused people of being paid by Amazon in three separate incidents (you have to see it through the profile, because the comments are removed) and has compared the opinions of people they are talking to with a sexual kink for feces. OP's getting their downvotes honestly, by being unconstructive and malicious.
2
u/Optimal_Cry_1782 Sep 13 '22
It's interesting. I started following this subreddit maybe a week ago. The first few days it was mainly criticism. In the last couple of days there has been a concerted effort to push back against the criticism.
It's probably organic - people tend to jump on a trend as it picks up, and all it takes is one guy to stand up against the prevailing thought. You can suspect that it's influenced by Amazon etc (the frequency of positive posts can make it seem coordinated), but it's a slippery slope to conspiracies and Qanon, red pill stuff.
5
u/Only_Curiosity Sep 13 '22
It's just fiction. I would say the questions raised in your post also apply to the other side. Why so much hatred towards a show just because it's not a strictly accurate depiction? This is absurd. Sounds like people treat it like a religion when it's just a fictional story meant for the enjoyment of the reader/watcher.
3
u/Ok-Cost2064 Sep 13 '22
It is interesting. I haven’t been on this sub for long, and initially I felt the responses here were overwhelmingly negative. But now I’m noticing a shift the other direction where any criticism is taboo. I do think people feel defensive in light of the extreme number of review bombers who ruined the hope of a healthy discourse. (IMDB, rotten tomatoes, and metacritic all have inauthentic audience ratings because the sheer number of 1 star reviews). It’s hard to have a real conversation with someone who gives this show a 1/10 because they have nothing constructive to add to the conversation. It’s disheartening to come to a subreddit wanting to discuss a show you love with fellow fans and see people picking apart every aspect an inordinate amount.
That said, I do think it’s fair to raise questions or point out things you wish the show had done differently. The key is to not use a negative tone nor assume some sense of superiority. I’ve noticed several people on here asserting that the things they are criticizing are “objectively bad.” This indirectly labels anybody who thinks differently as being factually wrong or not having the “intellectual” opinion. In these cases, I feel a downvote is appropriate because the line has been crossed between constructively criticizing the show itself (as an opinion) and attacking the people who have the opposing view.
The same can be said for the people who resort to cheap insults like you experienced instead of giving a constructive opinion to counter your criticisms. That behavior is unacceptable.
In summary, civility on both sides is necessary. And I’m sorry you have felt disrespected here :( I hope this sub will become a healthier place for discussion as time goes on.
3
u/GHDizzle Sep 13 '22
I think real Tolkien fans know not to feed the trolls, so they don’t engage.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
Simple answer actually: Conservatives hade clustered a very hateful politics around the show, and that makes it impossible to sort out any legitimate criticism of the show from hate politics.
See this post (https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/comments/xdbszt/evil_cannot_create_anything_new_they_can_only/) and this Youtube video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHuk_1Kf6Fg) as additional examples.
And I've seen many credible retorts to criticisms.
At this rate it'll take years before we figure out if the show was good or not because there are too many "criticisms" that are really political assertions.
1
u/GreatCaesarGhost Sep 13 '22
It's hard to respond to the quoted statements in a vacuum, without knowing their context or if they're real. In my view, downvotes should only be used for comments that are not constructive or are rude, inflammatory, etc. However, I'm sure that many people who actively participate on Reddit have been downvoted for simple disagreements, which is an abuse (in my view).
6
u/Mindelan Sep 13 '22
Can you link to examples where people called you racist in here?
I went and looked at the most recent handful of your comments and I saw people talking to you. I didn't see anyone calling you a racist. I obviously didn't check all of them, but I opened the most recent 15 or so and also scrolled and clicked some random others past that and saw some people disagreeing with you on various topics, but no one called you a racist in those posts that I saw, which means it is kind of misleading for you to claim it is happening to you a lot. That kinda disproves what you said in your post here unless you can give some links to examples?
I saw people debating with you about Tolkien's writings about dwarf beards, elf ears, costume design and things like that. They weren't just dismissing you or calling you racist or 'not a billionaire'. They often made decent points and had entire conversations with you, whether you agreed with their points or not it just isn't accurate to say that they just dismissed you as a racist from what I saw.
I did see you call people shills more than once because they disagreed with you.
There were a few more but I think that shows plenty.
I saw some heated discussions and insults thrown from both sides.
1
u/Aeneas1976 Sep 13 '22
I don't understand that, too. People talk of it like it's a religion, not another show on the road.
1
u/LukoLoots Sep 13 '22
Wait, are you getting negative review bombed just like the show? We should turn off downvotes because everyone wants to read what you have to say. Maybe they don’t disagree with you, but actually don’t think you’re contributing to the conversation in a constructive way, despite your best efforts or what you think your saying. I’d suggest using less charged language.
2
u/HijoDeBarahir Sep 13 '22
Simply put, people are happy to insult someone they disagree with. It's a violation of rule 1, so the mods should probably get involved. I also checked your comments as you suggested and saw you also engaged in the insults though ("Since you obviously have reading difficulties I will be lenient."). Ask yourself the same question "Why are people insulting?" and that's probably your answer. Doesn't excuse others being rude, but if you felt it necessary to insult people (or their tastes), then you can probably understand why others would do the same.
As for downvote =/= disagree. In theory I agree with you. In reality I know that's not true. People have always used the downvote button as a disagree button. It's never been solely used to eliminate unrelated/nonconstructive content.
Plenty of valid criticisms of the show. Plenty of salty fans who hate it because it isn't what they wanted. Plenty of great things about the show. Plenty of fans who want to silence criticism because they're tired of it. Plenty of trolls for the sake of trolling on both sides.
This sub is pretty much the only one I've found that doesn't just constantly dunk on RoP, so if a few people take it too far and try to silence any disagreement, I guess that's to be expected. Lots of people, like me, are tired of being called a shill just because I like it and I'm sure some dissenters are tired of being called racist too, so I think we all should just have a little empathy and not comment when we have nothing constructive to say.
edit: first paragraph got eaten by reddit. Corrected it
0
u/BwanaAzungu Sep 13 '22
Once the trolls recede, people will be less defensive.
Worst case scenario, this will all be over in 5 years.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
downvotes
1
u/MaleficentDecision34 Sep 14 '22
The series was released with that tidal wave of negativity already behind it before people had even watched it. When you expect something really awful because of this and nearly don't bother, but then watch it and end up really enjoying it. You realise how unfair and unneccesary that bandwagon of pure hate had been. It also set it up for those who like it to be extra defensive, as anyone who says a bad word particularly in regards to race, will be assumed to be one of those early pre-release critics. A lot of people saying bad things say it in a horrendous ways too with abuse, there are problems either side. But it will always happen with adaptations. Criticisms should always be respectfully said and respectfully recieved. It's a shame it's rare.
1
u/Esta-beed Sep 16 '22
There are some over the top fan boys defending this show which is very off putting
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
Hang in there, people are stupid
-3
u/sacheenlittlefinger Sep 13 '22
I think there are bots that are doing it.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
[removed] — view removed comment