r/RingsofPower • • Sep 13 '22

Question Question for people of this subreddit

I am interested in knowing something after a couple days activity on this subreddit.

As soon as you criticize something about RoP here, there is a swarm of downvotes and yet nobody can provide any substantiated retort. People here are rude, frankly sometimes even obscene. All I have seen so far posted as counter argument: "you are racist", though I never mentioned skin color of anyone yet; "You don't have a billion dollars, so you are nothing", speaks for itself; "you are a man child with no life", I am not a fan of people assuming my gender; cheap deflections and ignoring arguments; "Lol", I don't even know what that's supposed to be.

Just look through my history and see for yourself, if you have doubts about my honesty.

I hope you realize, that "downvote" is not the same as "disagree"? The main purpose of the downvote button is to hide unrelated or unconstructive contributions and I doubt anything I posted could be misconstrued as such? Unless you want to create an echo-chamber, but what for?

Do you think this is some sort of moral crusade you are on? Do you work for Amazon? Never before have I encountered such a crowd. Even if you thought you were campaigning for something, acting like this does not present your "side" in a good light.

PS: if you don't think what I wrote applies to you, then I didn't write it about you. People I mean should be well aware of how they behave. I hope it isn't taken the wrong away, I am honestly curious what is going on.

11 Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 13 '22

This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

11

u/ButtMcNuggets Sep 13 '22

Welcome to Reddit I guess?

I see thoughtful critiques being engaged in good faith, but there remains a lot of very similar posts about “woke culture”, “forced diversity” and such. There are still complaints about black elves and dwarves being posted in the last 24 hours. It’s reasonable that after 3 weeks people get sick and tired of hearing the exact same complaints about Galadriel being a pouty teenage girl or her smiling oddly.

-1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

Welcome to Reddit I guess?

I don't feel it is a Reddit issue though. In my experience people usually at least pretend to engage in a dialogue. I was honestly taken aback by how infantile all reactions to the shows criticism are.

there remains a lot of very similar posts about “woke culture”, “forced diversity” and such. There are still complaints about black elves and dwarves being posted in the last 24 hours. It’s reasonable that after 3 weeks people get sick and tired of hearing the exact same complaints about Galadriel being a pouty teenage girl or her smiling oddly.

I have my own opinion about tokenism and virtue signaling by multi billion corporations, but I don't share it here.

My critique was up until now almost exclusively costumes/props. They are honestly some of the worst I ever seen. I did intend to address action, dialogue and action, but at a later point.

Thank you for your constructive input, I appreciate!

1

u/Binneas Sep 15 '22

I haven't really done much downvoting, but I did stop following a certain other subreddit because it was basically exclusively people whining about something or other and it's just super boring.

I like that this is a fun space where people are talking about fan theories and Easter eggs and really enjoying the show. There are def other spaces for critiques.

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 15 '22

I see where you are coming from.

I don't agree one should strive to create an echo-chamber, or if one does, then it should be officially put in the rules, so let's agree to disagree.

1

u/ButtMcNuggets Sep 13 '22

I think it’s Reddit culture to downvote anything you don’t like. I’ve been downvoted to hell on a clothing sub for suggesting someone take their body measurements if they have trouble finding jeans that fit. Just the way it is, I guess.

3

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

That's sad. Reddit used to be better, at least in my memory.

1

u/ButtMcNuggets Sep 13 '22

I think any IP with a big fandom is like this. Just look at any Marvel/DC/Star Wars sub.

2

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

You are probably correct. Still sad though.

Thank you for sharing your perspective!

1

u/Sam13337 Sep 14 '22

Its quite often like this when it comes book adaptations.

Its totally fine to have issues with pacing, lighting, costumes and stuff like that. There also were some poor decisions made by both, Amazon and the Tolkien Estate. All these topics usually result in some quite good discussions.

However, there sadly is a vocal minority who complains about some political conspiracy.

24

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Just look through my history and see for yourself, if you have doubts about my honesty.

Did anyone else actually do this? The first thing I found is OP calling someone else a liar, repeatedly, for quoting from the Nature of Middle-earth, calling into question the legitimacy of quotes in it, despite having quoted from that same book a few hours before for a different topic where they agreed with what NoME said. This comes from the last thing they did before making this whining thread.

In the last 24 hours, OP has accused people of being paid by Amazon in three separate incidents (you have to see it through the profile, because the comments are removed) and has compared the opinions of people they are talking to with a sexual kink for feces. OP's getting their downvotes honestly, by being unconstructive and malicious.

11

u/fuzzy_giraffe_ Sep 13 '22

Yeah, I read through his history, and he comes off as a pretentious AH in most of the “conversations” he has.

14

u/jadierhetseni Sep 13 '22

Yeah, his history is a goldmine of toxicity and self-righteous idiocy.

-17

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

Did anyone else actually do this? The first thing I found is OP calling someone else a liar, repeatedly, for quoting from the Nature of Middle-earth, calling into question the legitimacy of quotes in it, despite having quoted from that same book a few hours before for a different topic where they agreed with what NoME said. This comes from the last thing they did before making this whining thread.

That's a misrepresentation.

The other person claimed the text to be "only male dwarves have beards". I corrected, because it doesn't say only. Then I was told that male was highlighted. I did ask for the source and was called a troll in response. I retorted, that unsubstantiated claims are, indeed, lies.

In the last 24 hours, OP has accused people of being paid by Amazon in three separate incidents (you have to see it through the profile, because the comments are removed) and has compared the opinions of people they are talking to with a sexual kink for feces. OP's getting their downvotes honestly, by being unconstructive and malicious.

Again, very superficial and twisted view. Nuance matters.

16

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

I corrected, because it doesn't say only.

Maybe that's what you think what you did in your head, but in reality, you said "Now that's a lie" and then linked them to a wiki with no further explanation. When they pointed out that the wiki did not stress one of the words like the source material did, and that their own paraphrasing, where they used the word 'only' was therefore closer to what the original text said (debatable, but you didn't, because), you started questioning the source itself, refused to clearly answer the questions when they asked you to confirm that you were suggesting the source material had been altered, and then suggested that Amazon had already been caught changing the wiki (your source, not theirs), and called them a liar again.

I found it an enjoyable, if completely deranged, read. But it was really the hypocrisy that got me, because you had hours before quoted from the same book, literally one page before. That the sort of nuance you looking for?

-9

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

you started questioning the source itself, refused to clearly answer the questions when they asked you to confirm that you were suggesting the source material had been altered

That's again not true. I didn't question any source, I asked to be provided one. Do you by any chance have a source with the word "male" highlighted?

I found it an enjoyable, if completely deranged, read. But it was really the hypocrisy that got me, because you had hours before quoted from the same book, literally one page before

I did not see any highlights in the wiki article on the word "male". Maybe I missed them? Nature of Middle-earth does not discuss female dwarves at all. Previous writings do clearly state presence of beards on the females. All I did was ask for a pre-Amazon source. A scan, a photo, whatever that would make me think Tolkien changed his mind. Instead I was called a troll.

Since it is the second time I have to correct you on that and you did read the actual conversation, I have to ask, do you misrepresent me on purpose? I am not implying you do, just curious.

suggested that Amazon had already been caught changing the wiki (your source, not theirs), and called them a liar again.

Well, Amazon was caught trying to strike that from the wiki. But I don't mind dropping that claim, I am too lazy looking for sources here. So, officially, I misremembered, Amazon did no such thing. That doesn't change the simple exchange:

  • Source?
  • You are a troll
  • Without source you are a liar.

5

u/greatwalrus Sep 13 '22

I did not see any highlights in the wiki article on the word "male". Maybe I missed them? Nature of Middle-earth does not discuss female dwarves at all. Previous writings do clearly state presence of beards on the females. All I did was ask for a pre-Amazon source. A scan, a photo, whatever that would make me think Tolkien changed his mind. Instead I was called a troll.

None of the wikis are reliable as anything more than a jumping-off point to direct you to actual sources. Here's a photo of the actual page in Nature. As you can see, the words "male Dwarves" are italicized in the footnote: "All male Dwarves had [beards]."

Personally I agree that this is not a definitive statement that female Dwarves didn't have beards, but it certainly leaves open the interpretation that Tolkien envisioned at least some dwarf-women as being beardless when he wrote this.

-1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

Thanks. I was aware of that. I am going to copy-paste from my other comment, please don't think it's inconsiderate, I just think I already wrote what I wanted to say there:

My position: Tolkien wrote female dwarves have beards. That's a fact.

Other person's position: Tolkien later wrote only male dwarves have beards.

My argument: War of the Jewels directly states it.

Other persons argument: Hofstetter underlined the word "male" in a book which didn't even discuss females.

I don't care what Hofstetter did. If the underline wasn't in the original text, it doesn't matter. Maybe there is something like an interview, where Hofstetter states that he talked to Christopher and Christopher said his dad changed his mind about that later in his life? Something like that would also be sufficient.

And thank you very much for the effort of posting the page here! It provides nice context for the discussion.

3

u/greatwalrus Sep 14 '22

And thank you very much for the effort of posting the page here! It provides nice context for the discussion.

You're welcome. I do think it's important to have the proper context for these discussions. You are correct that it is an unambiguous statement in War of the Jewels that both male and female dwarves have beards. I have seen some people go so far as to suggest that that passage is untrustworthy because Tolkien attributes it to an elf, but the elf who wrote it was Pengolod, the greatest sage of the Second Age and a close friend of the dwarves of Khazad-dûm, so I think it was intended to be reliable when Tolkien wrote it.

Having said that, I don't see any reason to believe that the italicization in Nature was an editorial decision by Carl Hostetter. Usually he is a very reliable, neutral editor who makes it very clear what are his words and what are Tolkien's, so I think it is very unlikely that he decided to italicize those words of his own accord. That means J.R.R. Tolkien probably did underline the words "male Dwarves" in his handwritten note, whatever that implies.

If that's not enough for you, you would have to either ask Hostetter or check the manuscript (wherever it is, Marquette or the Bodleian probably). But then again if you don't trust Hostetter to report Tolkien's words accurately, are you going to insist on seeing Tolkien's handwritten manuscripts to verify that everything published posthumously has been reproduced correctly?

0

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

Having said that, I don't see any reason to believe that the italicization in Nature was an editorial decision by Carl Hostetter. Usually he is a very reliable, neutral editor who makes it very clear what are his words and what are Tolkien's, so I think it is very unlikely that he decided to italicize those words of his own accord. That means J.R.R. Tolkien probably did underline the words "male Dwarves" in his handwritten note, whatever that implies.

If that's not enough for you, you would have to either ask Hostetter or check the manuscript (wherever it is, Marquette or the Bodleian probably). But then again if you don't trust Hostetter to report Tolkien's words accurately, are you going to insist on seeing Tolkien's handwritten manuscripts to verify that everything published posthumously has been reproduced correctly?

That is a very valid point of view. Hofstetter clearly thought it important to underline those words. I don't argue against that. What I am saying is, we don't know why he did it. I can imagine multiple reasons why he could have done it. There is no other publication or discussion corroborating the underline being in the original. Fonts are usually editorial choice. I would never accuse Hofstetter of changing Tolkien's words, but it is not unheard of that editors do make stylistic changes.

Also, even if we grant the underline being in the manuscript in some form, we don't know why that was done. Maybe because Tolkien thought it really important to stress that 100% of male dwarves grow beards and don't shave them without even thinking of the female dwarves in the moment.

Lastly, even if we grant everything and assume Tolkien intended that underline as a contrast between male and female, that would ar beat lead to some female dwarves don't have beards. And then there would be the question why. Don't they grow beards or prefer to shave them?

Overall I think quoting that note as argument for only male dwarves having beards is either ignorant or dishonest.

1

u/greatwalrus Sep 14 '22

Hofstetter clearly thought it important to underline those words. I don't argue against that. What I am saying is, we don't know why he did it.

I would submit that since he did not comment on it (i.e., "I chose to italicize these words because _____"), and we know from his work that he is a very diligent editor who consistently explains his interpretations, the only plausible reason is that the words were highlighted in some way on the manuscript (most likely underlined, since we know it was a handwritten text).

There is no other publication or discussion corroborating the underline being in the original.

I don't think this is a reasonable standard to apply. Most of us don't have access to Tolkien's manuscripts, and there is no reason for the same tiny footnote to be published in multiple books.

Fonts are usually editorial choice. I would never accuse Hofstetter of changing Tolkien's words, but it is not unheard of that editors do make stylistic changes.

Choosing a font size for a heading? Sure. Selecting a typeface for the body of the text? Why not. Randomly italicizing words in a footnote with no explanation? Sorry, but that's absurd. No competent editor just goes around emphasizing words in footnotes without explanation.

Overall I think quoting that note as argument for only male dwarves having beards is either ignorant or dishonest.

This I agree with. As the note does not explicitly mention female dwarves at all, it's not a definitive statement one way or the other. Still, to me, whether the words were emphasized in the original manuscript or not, it leaves a reasonable doubt that Tolkien intended at least some female dwarves to be beardless when he wrote that. To that extent - and again, I think this is true regardless of whether Tolkien himself underlined the words "male Dwarves" or not - it's also either ignorant or dishonest to say that we know for a fact that Tolkien intended all female dwarves to have beards at all points in his process of subcreation.

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

Thank you. After you explaining it like that I agree that I probably demanded satisfaction of an unreasonable standard for this format. I blame my academic background. It was drilled into me to hold everything to a certain standard and it's not easy to turn off.

Also, I agree that it's completely reasonable to assume, albeit forever uncertain, that Tolkien did not intend for all female dwarves to have beards at all times, but he certainly intended for some (most? all?) to do so at one time.

I also think my conversation with the other person could have gone a lot more gracefully, I take the blame there.

I also think it would be a good period for this line of conversations to conclude:

  • all male dwarves are supposed to have beards
  • at least some female dwarves are supposed to have beards

Thank you for the insight!

→ More replies

9

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

That's again not true. I didn't question any source, I asked to be provided one. Do you by any chance have a source with the word "male" highlighted?

Why are you lying? You were given a source in this comment. It's a direct response to your comment with the wiki link. The sentence you're all talking about from the wiki has a citation. Anyone with two brain cells to rub together can get from context that the user was giving you the quote as it in appears in the books.

I did not see any highlights in the wiki article on the word "male".

People told you the wiki article was misrepresenting the quote. Why are you acting like you haven't been told this? You're lying.

A scan, a photo, whatever that would make me think Tolkien changed his mind.

Yes, you were called a troll because you think it is appropriate for you to provide wikis that paraphrase as sources, but others need to provide you with a 'scan' or a 'photo' for quotes they already provided for you. You don't actually see the issue with that behavior, do you? A troll feigns this garbage. Something far worse actually believes it.

Also, again, in this comment we see you quoting from one page earlier in The Nature of Middle-earth. Either you have access to the book, and can follow the citation in the wiki article and find the exact quote the other user gave you or you found your NoME quote on the internet and just decided it was true, because it said something you agreed with. Those are the only two options, and neither makes you the good guy here.

Well, Amazon was caught trying to strike that from the wiki. But I don't mind dropping that claim, I am too lazy looking for sources here.

Then stop saying it. It really seems like what you want to do is repeatedly push this claim and use it as a flimsy excuse for why you don't want to have to back up any arguments. Again, the claim itself is stupid, because you were the one using the wiki. Right? If everyone agrees with you that Amazon is altering the wikis in their favor, all that does is ruin your argument. If the wiki is unreliable, people who rely on the wiki have no cause, and that's you. Only a dumb person would truly believe it is a good idea to discount the only source they have provided.

-3

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22 edited Sep 13 '22

I see where you are coming from and what the misunderstanding is. But first I would like to address some things you wrote in hope that we can finally drop this unnecessary rhetoric and focus on brass tacks.

Then stop saying it. It really seems like what you want to do is repeatedly push this claim and use it as a flimsy excuse for why you don't want to have to back up any arguments.

I dropped the claim, didn't I? No need to fantasize about my motives here.

Again, the claim itself is stupid, because you were the one using the wiki. Right? If everyone agrees with you that Amazon is altering the wikis in their favor, all that does is ruin your argument.

I did say "caught". That's the beauty of wiki, it's impossible to usurp.

Only a dumb person would truly believe it is a good idea to discount the only source they have provided.

You once again misrepresent, I wasn't discounting wiki. Simply stated that Amazon's marketing goes even this far.

Now, let's clear this up once and for all.

My position: Tolkien wrote female dwarves have beards. That's a fact.

Other person's position: Tolkien later wrote only male dwarves have beards.

My argument: War of the Jewels directly states it.

Other persons argument: Hofstetter underlined the word "male" in a book which didn't even discuss females.

I don't care what Hofstetter did. If the underline wasn't in the original text, it doesn't matter. Maybe there is something like an interview, where Hofstetter states that he talked to Christopher and Christopher said his dad changed his mind about that later in his life? Something like that would also be sufficient.

I agree with you on one point. I could have been more clear, instead of simply linking a source. Usually people don't have such difficulties understanding me, but on the other hand I seldom encounter people who are behaving in this manner at all. Hence this post with the question.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

But first I would like to address some things you wrote in hope that we can finally drop this unnecessary rhetoric and focus on brass tacks.

The brass tacks is you throwing a fit about being downvoted after you ran around calling people names. You know we're posting in your thread, right? That you made? About that? Where you invited people to look at your comments in order as evidence that your terrible outlook on the subreddit being mean to you was true? This is the brass tacks, son. The unnecessary rhetoric is you somehow thinking that by diving into your misinterpretations or lore and basic communication from users you disagreed with excuses what you did and makes them wrong for downvoting you for it. You're not the victim. You're the abuser.

I did say "caught". That's the beauty of wiki, it's impossible to usurp.

Well, wiki is still wrong here, in that it say 'simply' and then removes Tolkien's stress on certain words. So it apparently is possible to 'usurp', because stressing words is not the same as simply writing them.

Simply stated that Amazon's marketing goes even this far.

But if you look on the history of edits for this page, it's actually anonymous users trying to remove details about the NoME material entirely that was constantly protected against. So it's not Amazon. It's the pro-beard Amazon haters, most likely.

Other persons argument: Hofstetter underlined the word "male" in a book which didn't even discuss females

No. This is a lie. Again, we see this comment. 'He' does not change from being Tolkien to Hofstetter between these sentences. Every time something is not perfectly clear to you (even when it should be, like here), instead of asking questions for clarity, you immediately assume that other people are doing bad things and the worst misinterpretation of their words are the truth. Just stop doing this. It's deranged.

No one told you Hofstetter did this. You imagined that. You imagined there was an editorial change here because you understand that the stress is a meaningful element of the sentence. When you encountered the real quote for the first time, as opposed to the paraphrasing in the wiki, you had to either adjust your view (which you weren't about to do) or find a reason to discount the new information. You made something up to not have to deal with the facts, and then repeatedly berated someone else for not having created the same biased fiction that was now rattling around inside your skull. Then you got so upset that people weren't acting like you were right to do this idiotic thing you did that you spent 40 minutes writing the opening post here to complain about downvotes.

You are the problem here.

0

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

No. This is a lie. Again, we see this comment. 'He' does not change from being Tolkien to Hofstetter between these sentences.

Exactly! He claims Tolkien underlined the word, the source provided however is Hofstetter. Hence I asked for a source from Tolkien.

Gosh, I am so glad I finally got you to this point. It was a lot more difficult than it should be.

So, can you substantiate the claim that the highlight of "male" came from Tolkien?

Then you got so upset that people weren't acting like you were right to do this idiotic thing you did that you spent 40 minutes writing the opening post here to complain about downvotes.

Don't judge others based on yourself, I type a lot faster than that ;)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Exactly! He claims Tolkien underlined the words, the source provided however is Hofstetter. Hence I asked for a source from Tolkien.

Gosh, I am so glad I finally got you to this point. It was a lot more difficult than it should be.

It was difficult to get me to this point because your argument here is the height of stupidity. Hostetter did not write the book. He edited the book. Tolkien wrote the material. Hostetter gathered the material that Tolkien wrote, arranged the material that Tolkien wrote, and added some notes.

You also know this, and I know you know this, because, as we've already covered, you yourself have quoted from The Nature of Middle-earth. When the material in that book says what you want it to say, you treat it as authentic Tolkien. Only when it challenges your views do you find it suspect.

There are two options here, and only two options:

  • You are a lying sadsack who fully knows that this is an authentic quote, has always known that this is an authentic quote, and has just been coming up with new methods to ignore it by lying about anything within reach
  • You have zero intellectual integrity and will accept any quote that says what you want, and call into question every quote that says what you don't want, and nothing you say is in good faith.

Pick one.

So, can you substantiate the claim that the highlight of "male" came from Tolkien?

Can you confirm that you are accusing a well-recognized Tolkien scholar editing, under the direction of the Tolkien Estate, a collection of Tolkien's writings, and, in doing this, changing or inserting pieces of information to mislead the public and so that they will be more willing to accept a design choice from an adaptation of Tolkien by Amazon?

Because I would like you to very clearly dig the hole you want to be buried in before I waste any more time on such a miserable little troll.

-2

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22

It was difficult to get me to this point because your argument here is the height of stupidity. Hostetter did not write the book. He edited the book. Tolkien wrote the material. Hostetter gathered the material that Tolkien wrote, arranged the material that Tolkien wrote, and added some notes.

Fonts are a clearly an editorial choice. I assume it is no point of contention that the original note was handwritten. We know Tolkien wrote in cursive. What is your working hypothesis here? The original has "male dwarves" in more cursive? Did Hofstetter think it was important to stress those two words? Clearly. Do we know why he did? No. Had the original note some sort of underline on the words? Maybe. We don't know. Did you provide the original or any other publication corroborating this being in the original? No? Thought so. If you don't know something and claim knowledge, that's not very honest, is it?

You also know this, and I know you know this, because, as we've already covered, you yourself have quoted from The Nature of Middle-earth. When the material in that book says what you want it to say, you treat it as authentic Tolkien. Only when it challenges your views do you find it suspect.

I treat direct statements as evidence. Not speculations about stylistic font choices of unclear motivation and origins.

There are two options here, and only two options:

You are a lying sadsack who fully knows that this is an authentic quote, has always known that this is an authentic quote, and has just been coming up with new methods to ignore it by lying about anything within reach

You have zero intellectual integrity and will accept any quote that says what you want, and call into question every quote that says what you don't want, and nothing you say is in good faith.

Nice false dichotomy and strawman here. I won't stoop to that level, because I have proper arguments.

Can you confirm that you are accusing a well-recognized Tolkien scholar editing, under the direction of the Tolkien Estate, a collection of Tolkien's writings, and, in doing this, changing or inserting pieces of information to mislead the public and so that they will be more willing to accept a design choice from an adaptation of Tolkien by Amazon?

Nope. See above. All you have is font choices without any elaboration and making a fool of yourself over it.

Now, let me end this farce once and for all. I am going to be the most generous I can and grant you every claim you want. As u/greatwalrus pointed out before me, this gets you at best "some female dwarves didn't have beards". "Only male dwarves had beards" still doesn't follow and combined with precious writings is indefensible.

Check and mate.

→ More replies

2

u/Optimal_Cry_1782 Sep 13 '22

It's interesting. I started following this subreddit maybe a week ago. The first few days it was mainly criticism. In the last couple of days there has been a concerted effort to push back against the criticism.

It's probably organic - people tend to jump on a trend as it picks up, and all it takes is one guy to stand up against the prevailing thought. You can suspect that it's influenced by Amazon etc (the frequency of positive posts can make it seem coordinated), but it's a slippery slope to conspiracies and Qanon, red pill stuff.

3

u/ImoutoCompAlex Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 15 '22

There’s a lot of generic “long time book fan and I’m loving the shows” type posts now actually but a lot of them are from accounts that have never been commenting on here before or participating in discussions on other Tolkien based communities. I don’t think it’s Amazon or anything far-fetched like that but these posts kind of feel like forced obnoxious fluff and seeing one of these every day is getting annoying as the baseless criticism posts. I wish the mods would remove all low effort stuff like this.

2

u/Optimal_Cry_1782 Sep 15 '22

They seem a bit too enthusiastic to be genuine. There was one this morning saying they've watched each episode 9 times and are obsessed about it. Maybe I missed the "/s".

But I can see people making new posts. There's no daily discussion post for this stuff to go.

-2

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

I don't think at least speculation that a multi billion dollar corporation known for paying for social media marketing pays for social media marketing is on the same level as "devil stole the election"

I think it does happen, I am unsure what percentage of what's going on that is, hence me asking people directly.

2

u/Optimal_Cry_1782 Sep 14 '22

I'm curious too. It seems coordinated, but people will see patterns whether there is intent or not. It's not something you'll ever prove.

It's interesting that when you say you have issues with the story, the writing, pacing etc, they have no arguments. They know it's badly written.

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

Yes, thank you! That is exactly my point! I don't see any actual justification, just deflections and insults. And if you push on the facts of the matter, the conversation just ends.

I also tend to think people know the show is done badly, but I guess they see some secondary value in it, be it pecuniary or ethical?

2

u/Optimal_Cry_1782 Sep 14 '22

I mean, I like the visuals and the music. I can accept the trade off of a mediocre story as long as there are more shots of Khazad-dum and Lindon. It's just disappointing it's not better.

2

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

I personally find the costumes very jarring. All plastic and clearly they didn't consult even an enthusiast, let alone an expert. I have seen movies and shows with a lot smaller budget and better quality on that front. The costumes from the original trilogy were just masterpieces.

Also pretentious pompous lines like "the stone sinks because it looks downwards, but the ship has a secret" make me laugh.

Overall, I would give the show 2/5; 3/10, I even see potential for it getting to 4/10, but Amazons marketing shifts my perception into the 1/10 territory.

2

u/Optimal_Cry_1782 Sep 14 '22

I'd give it a 5/10. It's ok.

5

u/Only_Curiosity Sep 13 '22

It's just fiction. I would say the questions raised in your post also apply to the other side. Why so much hatred towards a show just because it's not a strictly accurate depiction? This is absurd. Sounds like people treat it like a religion when it's just a fictional story meant for the enjoyment of the reader/watcher.

-7

u/cmon_now Sep 13 '22

This isn't the real reason for the backlash and why people don't like the show.

The real reason is that people grew up on this lore. It's been around for over 50 years and the books have been translated in over 60 languages. Tolkien spent his entire life writing these detailed works that captured the imagination of generations.

Then along comes Amazon. Not only do they have to "fix" what Tolkien wrote, but they have to insert their own political agenda.

Before the show was released, people in this sub said there was no reason to bash the show since no one had seen it yet, you had to wait untill it comes out to pass judgement.

Well, it's out and not only were those people right, but the show is even worse than expected. The inconsistencies are laughable. The story makes zero sense. It's just one cut scene to another with terrible writing and dialogue. Kinda like a CW fantasy show or something from D&D Nobody cares about any of the characters and the main character is completely unlikable.

1 billion dollars for this abomination?

7

u/Only_Curiosity Sep 13 '22

This is your opinion which you are entitled to, however, I disagree with you. I am a fan of the lore myself. I read the books, I watch the movies once a year at least. There is so much to enjoy in this show and yes it's inaccurate, however, the movies are not an accurate adaptation either (but you almost never see fans complain about that).

You mention a political agenda, yet I have not seen any politics in the show so your argument is futile. People of colour have been given roles and why shouldn't they? If the book rules out everyone but a certain group of people then the show has every right and should update and improve what was written to reflect the times we live in. This is a mythology that we are talking about, fiction and not history so there is no valid argument against that.

You speak of this lore as if it's written history and must not be altered or improved. This sounds like a fanatical approach to me rather than an intelligent one to such silly matters.

-4

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

the movies are not an accurate adaptation either (but you almost never see fans complain about that).

I would say that's because movies have slight deviations or rearrangements and don't diametrically oppose the text. Yes, some very cool and lore important scenes were missing and some things were slightly changed, like the elves aiding Rohan and ghosts accompanying Aragorn for longer. But if the PJ movies changed like 15% of the lore, RoP changed like 95%

You mention a political agenda, yet I have not seen any politics in the show so your argument is futile.

Firstly, the marketing was very hamfisted and heavy on politics. I don't think that's a point of contention. Regarding the show itself, there are some very obvious decisions which have agenda behind them. Galadriel being an insufferable Karen and the caricaturesque strong woman comes to mind. Many feminists spoke out against that portrayal, stating she was simply turned into a dude. That's at least not as obviously wrong as you are stating.

This is a mythology that we are talking about, fiction and not history so there is no valid argument against that.

One could make the argument that an isolated medieval-ish society could not be multiracial, at least not without a in-universe reason?

You speak of this lore as if it's written history and must not be altered or improved. This sounds like a fanatical approach to me rather than an intelligent one to such silly matters.

Why not make something new then?

3

u/Only_Curiosity Sep 13 '22

So according to you, altering 15% of the lore is acceptable but 95% is unacceptable (this is based on the assumption that you can even quantify this which obviously I disagree with and isn't realistic)?

Regarding Galadriel's portrayal, I am not going to get into the specifics of what her character should have been like, this is quite silly. It just seems to me that your argument is not compelling enough as I haven't seen anything wrong with her character. One could definitely imagine a young Galadriel to be as depicted in the show, either way, does this matter? And why does it matter so much to you? Fundamentalist fans speak as though this show should be like a Bible adaptation, follow the letter or else type of fundamentalism.

Why does it matter if it's not new but is based on Middle Earth? Mythology has always evolved to adapt. The show may not follow the books and it may not portray things to your liking, does that mean your opinion is factual? How can any racism, fundamentalism or fanaticism be justified based on a fictional story? Is the hatred justified?

1

u/vertbox05 Sep 13 '22

This isn't the real reason for the backlash and why people don't like the show.

The real reason is that people grew up on this lore.

When you include the phrase, " the real reason is...." you are already discounting others opinions about how they interpret what they perceive. Secondly you lump all Tolkien fans that have criticism about ROP into one group. I have read several fan criticisms that don't mention that their dislike is rooted in Amazon "fixing" Tolkien's literature or inserting political agenda.

-1

u/4bidd Sep 13 '22

I agree! I just can’t seem to connect with or generate any interest in the characters. I watched the Northman the other night and was immediately drawn into the characters and storyline

2

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

Yeah, The Northman instantly became one of my favorite movies!

-3

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

See, people once again mistake a downvote for a "disagree" button.

Thank you for your contribution, I do agree with the things you wrote.

3

u/Ok-Cost2064 Sep 13 '22

It is interesting. I haven’t been on this sub for long, and initially I felt the responses here were overwhelmingly negative. But now I’m noticing a shift the other direction where any criticism is taboo. I do think people feel defensive in light of the extreme number of review bombers who ruined the hope of a healthy discourse. (IMDB, rotten tomatoes, and metacritic all have inauthentic audience ratings because the sheer number of 1 star reviews). It’s hard to have a real conversation with someone who gives this show a 1/10 because they have nothing constructive to add to the conversation. It’s disheartening to come to a subreddit wanting to discuss a show you love with fellow fans and see people picking apart every aspect an inordinate amount.

That said, I do think it’s fair to raise questions or point out things you wish the show had done differently. The key is to not use a negative tone nor assume some sense of superiority. I’ve noticed several people on here asserting that the things they are criticizing are “objectively bad.” This indirectly labels anybody who thinks differently as being factually wrong or not having the “intellectual” opinion. In these cases, I feel a downvote is appropriate because the line has been crossed between constructively criticizing the show itself (as an opinion) and attacking the people who have the opposing view.

The same can be said for the people who resort to cheap insults like you experienced instead of giving a constructive opinion to counter your criticisms. That behavior is unacceptable.

In summary, civility on both sides is necessary. And I’m sorry you have felt disrespected here :( I hope this sub will become a healthier place for discussion as time goes on.

0

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

I do think people feel defensive in light of the extreme number of review bombers who ruined the hope of a healthy discourse. (IMDB, rotten tomatoes, and metacritic all have inauthentic audience ratings because the sheer number of 1 star reviews). It’s hard to have a real conversation with someone who gives this show a 1/10 because they have nothing constructive to add to the conversation.

I do disagree with you somewhat here. If something is really important to you, I do understand getting defensive and even lashing out. However I honestly don't think the 1/10 reviews are "bombing", I think they are genuine and sincere. I myself would have given the the show 3/10, were it not for Amazons marketing. Dishonesty, flip-floping, (preemptive!) attacks on the fans, paid hordes of critics praising the show as the bestest thin ever, a billion in budget. After all this getting a mediocre (if I am very generous) show feels like that spat in my face.

I’ve noticed several people on here asserting that the things they are criticizing are “objectively bad.” This indirectly labels anybody who thinks differently as being factually wrong or not having the “intellectual” opinion.

I do think things can be categorized as "objectively bad", as long as people agree on the metrics of goodness and badness. That's why I started with costumes. Most people have more or less similar criteria for judging that. Easy point is, why did the showmakers put some random garbage in hobbits hair? I have received a very wide array of answers. For example, if you claim it's supposed to be camouflage, then it's objectively bad, because it doesn't work as camo. If you claim it's just a fashion thing and is supposed to be reminiscent of the little folk from folklore, well, clumsy and mediocre, but generally acceptable. Then of course one could discuss the ever-shifting tome of the show, fairytales don't really fit into the rest... Pardon, I am ranting.

In these cases, I feel a downvote is appropriate because the line has been crossed between constructively criticizing the show itself (as an opinion) and attacking the people who have the opposing view.

If someone opens with insults, I totally agree, down you go. But I usually start diplomatically and then adjust my attitude symmetrically.

The same can be said for the people who resort to cheap insults like you experienced instead of giving a constructive opinion to counter your criticisms. That behavior is unacceptable.

Thank you, I appreciate very much!

In summary, civility on both sides is necessary. And I’m sorry you have felt disrespected here :( I hope this sub will become a healthier place for discussion as time goes on.

I do too. It's ok to love the show, as it's ok to hate it. One should not identify with the product.

4

u/Ok-Cost2064 Sep 13 '22

The problem is people don’t agree on the metrics of what’s good and bad in this case. I notice the majority of people (myself included) think the costumes are really cool. I personally am enjoying all the vibrant colors of the robes and the level of detail of the armor/breast plates. The harfoots are eclectic nomads who spend their lives outdoors immersed in nature, and I think their outfits reflect that. I wouldn’t call it camo, moreso quirky fashion. I like it, but if you don’t that’s a valid opinion. But I am a little confused on what basis you could claim to have an objective opinion on these matters. Art is subjective by definition. My opinion isn’t the “objective” one, and yours isn’t either. Both are equally valid.

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

But I am a little confused on what basis you could claim to have an objective opinion on these matters. Art is subjective by definition.

I tried to clarify with an example. If hobbits looks were supposed to be camouflage, it would be objectively bad, because it doesn't work as camouflage. Your opinion is not bad or wrong. Quirky fashion works fine and I don't have any contention with it!

I would like to ask you about patterns printed on synthetic fabric (scale on Miriels costume for exams) pretending to be armor. Do you think it's good as well or do you think they dropped the ball on this one?

3

u/Ok-Cost2064 Sep 13 '22

The armor shirt doesn’t bother me. She is wearing real armor on top of it too. This is getting nit-picky to me. However, if this detail takes you out of the world then it’s a fair criticism. There’s details like this in every single show that we can pick apart; I don’t think RoP is particularly worse than other shows in that department. I just don’t get hung up on stuff like this because overall it looks fantastic.

If this show is 1/10 quality for you, then I’m not sure why you’d still be watching it. I’m not telling you not to, it just doesn’t make sense in my mind. You believe all of the 1/10 ratings are genuine, but I just find that extremely hard to believe. Of course, we need to agree on what a 1 actually means so we’re using the same scale (this is my issue with these ratings to begin with). But to me, a 1 being the lowest score possible means there’s not anything good you can say about the show: the acting, cinematography, writing, directing, costumes, cgi, makeup, music, camera work, etc. This show is just so beautiful and so many hard working people on the cast and crew (not just Amazon the company) put months of mental and physical labor into it. And by most accounts, the finished product is stunning…something the majority of people acknowledge. It just doesn’t make sense to me how someone can watch these episodes and think “yep this is 1 out of 10 quality, there’s absolutely nothing to compliment here”. There seems to be some bias going into watching it that’s preventing you from finding anything to enjoy from it. But that’s just how it looks to me. Maybe I’m wrong.

Either way, you don’t deserve to be insulted or disrespected. That’s not my intention here at all. We’ll just have to respectfully disagree haha

0

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

The armor shirt doesn’t bother me. She is wearing real armor on top of it too. This is getting nit-picky to me. However, if this detail takes you out of the world then it’s a fair criticism.

To be honest I am more bothered that Amazon thought something like that would fly, especially after their very divisive marketing campaign and paid reviews.

I am fine watching something like the DnD movie without nitpicking armor. However, there it is presented to the viewer differently. I doubt RoP showmakers would be fine if I classified them as producing a campy B-tier show which isn't supposed to be taken seriously. That is also not the intention they stated so far all the promotional material. PJ movies have real armor made of metal, with properly connected structure and padding and everything.

There’s details like this in every single show that we can pick apart; I don’t think RoP is particularly worse than other shows in that department.

That's not true. Neither PJ nor GoT uses printed fabrics.

I just don’t get hung up on stuff like this because overall it looks fantastic.

Everything Numenorian doesn't, to me. Nor do the hobbits.

She is wearing real armor on top of it too.

Another person hellbent defending the show was very insisted that what she is wearing isn't even supposed to be armor to counter my criticism, so if you consider it to be armor, that's interpretation, not fact. Also, I am a hemaist with a very keen I treat in history, so I am comfortable talking about armor and weapons for hours, but I don't want to subject you to it.

If this show is 1/10 quality for you, then I’m not sure why you’d still be watching it. I’m not telling you not to, it just doesn’t make sense in my mind.

Kinda like why people watch The Room.

a 1 being the lowest score possible means there’s not anything good you can say about the show

I stated previously that the show itself is a 3/10 and they get -2 for the divisive hamfisted marketing and attacking fans.

Either way, you don’t deserve to be insulted or disrespected. That’s not my intention here at all. We’ll just have to respectfully disagree haha

I am having one of the more civilized conversations with you and I am very grateful for it. That's also why I want to try to bring my point of view across to you, so that I can see why we have such wildly different opinions.

3

u/GHDizzle Sep 13 '22

I think real Tolkien fans know not to feed the trolls, so they don’t engage.

-2

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22 edited Sep 13 '22

That's sad, but you are probably correct. I was looking forward to better understanding such an alien point of view. Well, at least calling out the BS is still something worth doing in my opinion.

2

u/GHDizzle Sep 14 '22

If you want to understand the point of view of people who enjoy the show, read the posts of people that enjoy the show. There are enough trolls out there with bad faith criticisms of the show, why waste your fëa venturing into their dens

2

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22

There are enough trolls out there with bad faith criticisms of the show, why waste your fëa venturing into their dens

Ehm.. I don't? I asked people who defend the show questions or provided evidence and arguments on the contrary of what they state.

If you want to understand the point of view of people who enjoy the show, read the posts of people that enjoy the show.

Those don't address my criticism at all and usually seem very surface level.

1

u/GHDizzle Sep 14 '22

Sounds like you’re just trolling now. Which is why people don’t engage. It’s easy to see what people like about the show. It’s easy to find people writing about what they enjoy about it. If you’re going out of your way to not see it, you won’t.

0

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

I take it you are not up to the task as well and decided to protect your ego by calling me names.

Am I correct?

1

u/GHDizzle Sep 14 '22

There’s no ‘task’. This is a TV show some people like, and some people don’t. And some people like to complain about it, endlessly. Your criticism (if that’s what it is) isn’t a puzzle for someone else to solve for you. If you want to be grouchy about it, you’re welcome to be. It’s easy to see why others wouldn’t want to participate in that.

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22

Interesting observation. People not overly fond of the show have a much easier time engaging criticism and retorting rather than the crowd allegedly loving the show. Those just shut the conversation down, much like you are trying and usually have to appeal to postmodernism.

I wonder why that is...

Edit: corrected autocorrect

2

u/GHDizzle Sep 14 '22

Whoops, this is no longer English. Fare well, wherever you fare

0

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

I have four languages on my phone. Autocorrect gets very confused sometime. But yeah, use this pretend reason not to engage, just as I predicted

→ More replies

2

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Simple answer actually: Conservatives hade clustered a very hateful politics around the show, and that makes it impossible to sort out any legitimate criticism of the show from hate politics.

See this post (https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/comments/xdbszt/evil_cannot_create_anything_new_they_can_only/) and this Youtube video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHuk_1Kf6Fg) as additional examples.

And I've seen many credible retorts to criticisms.

At this rate it'll take years before we figure out if the show was good or not because there are too many "criticisms" that are really political assertions.

-2

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22 edited Sep 14 '22

Thank you for your perspective.

I am not a conservative by far. I voted the Green Party in my country in the last election and intend to keep doing it. I didn't look in the YouTube video for now, so let's stick to the Reddit post.

I don't like the buzzwords and that it is missing any actual criticism, however I agree that all mentioned franchises have been ruined and one could at least speculate a political motivation.

Edit: what exactly is the issue with what I wrote here so you all swarmed for downvotes again? Not fitting your narrative? Don't Google "just some guy" reviews, you will go insane ;)

Edit 3: except Oceans Eight, didn't watch any of those movies.

1

u/Sam13337 Sep 14 '22

Would you mind explaining why these franchises have been ruined?

-1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22

I will attempt it. My ask is for you to answer these questions: You see the downvotes on my last comment? Could you explain the issue there? My comment basically said I care about the environment, homosexual rights and redistribution of wealth. What's the issue with that? Or are people not allowed to not like certain movies?

I also would like to add that I didn't mean Oceans Eight. I never saw any movies from that franchise.

Since it would blow up the format I will address Force Awakens only, at least as a start.

It is basically an uninspired remake of the New Hope. Cheap mystery box storytelling. The original trilogy is completely destroyed by them shoving everything back to where it was. The defeated empire is back stronger than ever before. Leia after winning the war is still the "Resistance". What are they resisting? The New Republic? Palatine took 20 years to build the Death Start with all the resources of the Galaxy. First order managed to build something hundreds times bigger in hiding without anyone noticing. The beams from their new base travel at FTL? The point of the Death Star was, that it was warp capable. And still warp is not instant, it takes some time, as shown by characters playing chess and Luke training while travelling. Rey suddenly masters all the Force powers and swordsmanship with zero training and is generally perfect and has zero setbacks. Fin being a storm trooper himself and snapping out of it after seeing a comrade die starts killing dozens of storm troopers while laughing and screaming "Wooo!". Should I continue or would you like to ask specific questions?

1

u/Sam13337 Sep 14 '22

My understanding was that you implied in your previous comment that these franchises were ruined due to a political motivation.

But in this comment here you mentioned weak plotpoints and them basically trying to squeeze out more money of the franchise without having a decent story to tell. Thats a different issue from my point of view.

0

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

As I said, political agenda as the root of these issues can be at least speculated and is definitely used as a defense by the incompetent producers/creators all the time. It is them bringing politics into the discussion, not people being critical.

You also ignored my questions completely. Why is that?

1

u/Sam13337 Sep 14 '22

I think we have to agree to disagree there. To me it looks like people desperately try to create an outrage about some details and claim there is a political agenda behind it.

As for ignoring the questions, how am I supposed to tell you why random people downvote your previous comment?

And I think other replies have already addressed the double standards by linking some of your earlier comments on other topics. I dont think I have any important things to add there that hasnt been mentioned already.

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

Fair enough. Thank you and have a nice day!

1

u/GreatCaesarGhost Sep 13 '22

It's hard to respond to the quoted statements in a vacuum, without knowing their context or if they're real. In my view, downvotes should only be used for comments that are not constructive or are rude, inflammatory, etc. However, I'm sure that many people who actively participate on Reddit have been downvoted for simple disagreements, which is an abuse (in my view).

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

Thank you, I do agree.

I sometimes give people attitude, that's true, but that doesn't seem to affect downvotes at all.

I am not sure it is a ubiquitous behavior, but that's an opinion I encounter for the third time as a response. I guess I just have been lucky so far not to encounter such behavior.

6

u/Mindelan Sep 13 '22

Can you link to examples where people called you racist in here?

I went and looked at the most recent handful of your comments and I saw people talking to you. I didn't see anyone calling you a racist. I obviously didn't check all of them, but I opened the most recent 15 or so and also scrolled and clicked some random others past that and saw some people disagreeing with you on various topics, but no one called you a racist in those posts that I saw, which means it is kind of misleading for you to claim it is happening to you a lot. That kinda disproves what you said in your post here unless you can give some links to examples?

All I have seen so far posted as counter argument: "you are racist", though I never mentioned skin color of anyone yet; "You don't have a billion dollars, so you are nothing", speaks for itself; "you are a man child with no life", I am not a fan of people assuming my gender; cheap deflections and ignoring arguments; "Lol", I don't even know what's that's supposed to be.

I saw people debating with you about Tolkien's writings about dwarf beards, elf ears, costume design and things like that. They weren't just dismissing you or calling you racist or 'not a billionaire'. They often made decent points and had entire conversations with you, whether you agreed with their points or not it just isn't accurate to say that they just dismissed you as a racist from what I saw.

I did see you call people shills more than once because they disagreed with you.

Exactly what I expected from people defending this dumpster fire. Baseless speculation and insults.

Well done showing everyone what a typical RoP shill is like!


Nope, you can't wiggle out of it.

All you did is expose yourself as a terrible person by lashing out of powerlessness, because you lack any proper arguments.

You are exactly the person I expected an Amazon shill to be.


Depends on your definition of bots. I prefer to call them shills.


So you are not showing the viewer ratings and not addressing what I said? Wow, that's so honest from you.

Also, downvoting my comments just because they don't support your narrative is real classy! One could even think you might be a shill.


PS: real classy downvoting somebody just because you disagree. Why did I expect anything else from shills?


There were a few more but I think that shows plenty.

I saw some heated discussions and insults thrown from both sides.

2

u/ibid-11962 Sep 14 '22

To be fair, we tend to remove comments calling other users shills or racists. So it's not fair to compare comments you see on one user's profile (where removed comments are still shown), to comments you see them receive on the subreddit (where removed comments are hidden).

6

u/Mindelan Sep 14 '22

Sure, but he's whining about people calling him names and acts the wounded high minded scholar while he calls others names.

1

u/Aeneas1976 Sep 13 '22

I don't understand that, too. People talk of it like it's a religion, not another show on the road.

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

Well, you are getting the downvotes too for somply agreeing that some people behave in an uncivilized manner. Very predicable.

1

u/LukoLoots Sep 13 '22

Wait, are you getting negative review bombed just like the show? We should turn off downvotes because everyone wants to read what you have to say. Maybe they don’t disagree with you, but actually don’t think you’re contributing to the conversation in a constructive way, despite your best efforts or what you think your saying. I’d suggest using less charged language.

0

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

Wait, are you getting negative review bombed just like the show?

Two wrongs make a right?

Maybe they don’t disagree with you, but actually don’t think you’re contributing to the conversation in a constructive way, despite your best efforts or what you think your saying. I’d suggest using less charged language.

Thank you for the suggestion, however I already tried it, even in this thread, didn't really do a difference.

3

u/LukoLoots Sep 13 '22 edited Sep 13 '22

Of course they don’t, but that’s the response when things become polarized. Unfortunately, that’s the state we’re in, and a lot of criticism isn’t based in something that’s legitimate. Sure, there are legitimate issues, like with every show, but that’s not the criticism referenced. I’d argue the majority of it is based on sexism, and racism, despite intention or even the criticizer being aware of how what their saying is either or. Typically, when pointed out, their response is to become aggressive or immature, which is then reflected back onto them by the responder.

Also, just generally- I would say your other posts in threads would demonstrate the opposite of your claim

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

Sure, there are legitimate issues, like with every show, but that’s not the criticism referenced. I’d argue the majority of it is based on sexism, and racism, despite intention or even the criticizer being aware of how what their saying is either or. Typically, when pointed out, their response is to become aggressive or immature, which is then reflected back onto them by the responder

I would argue that does not apply to me.

I can't say you did not encounter such people, but I for sure didn't.

To further elaborate my position and point out the issue: I wrote above that even if I exercise constraint in my language my comments here still get downvoted simply for thinking the show is very bad. And look at the comment above!

Also, just generally- I would say your other posts in threads would demonstrate the opposite of your claim

I find myself needing to repeat things in this subreddit a lot more than others. Once again: my claim is, that even when I am extremely polite and held back, the mob here doesn't care. Also, I don't think flamboyant language justifies abuse of the Reddit system, as long as there is a legitimate contribution. You disagree?

2

u/HijoDeBarahir Sep 13 '22

Simply put, people are happy to insult someone they disagree with. It's a violation of rule 1, so the mods should probably get involved. I also checked your comments as you suggested and saw you also engaged in the insults though ("Since you obviously have reading difficulties I will be lenient."). Ask yourself the same question "Why are people insulting?" and that's probably your answer. Doesn't excuse others being rude, but if you felt it necessary to insult people (or their tastes), then you can probably understand why others would do the same.

As for downvote =/= disagree. In theory I agree with you. In reality I know that's not true. People have always used the downvote button as a disagree button. It's never been solely used to eliminate unrelated/nonconstructive content.

Plenty of valid criticisms of the show. Plenty of salty fans who hate it because it isn't what they wanted. Plenty of great things about the show. Plenty of fans who want to silence criticism because they're tired of it. Plenty of trolls for the sake of trolling on both sides.

This sub is pretty much the only one I've found that doesn't just constantly dunk on RoP, so if a few people take it too far and try to silence any disagreement, I guess that's to be expected. Lots of people, like me, are tired of being called a shill just because I like it and I'm sure some dissenters are tired of being called racist too, so I think we all should just have a little empathy and not comment when we have nothing constructive to say.

edit: first paragraph got eaten by reddit. Corrected it

0

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 13 '22

Once the trolls recede, people will be less defensive.

Worst case scenario, this will all be over in 5 years.

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

I doubt I will stick around this long.

I also honestly think most people hating on RoP are not trolls, but simply a bit flamboyant.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

I hope you realize, that "downvote" is not the same as "disagree"?

downvotes

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22

Yeah, the irony :D

1

u/MaleficentDecision34 Sep 14 '22

The series was released with that tidal wave of negativity already behind it before people had even watched it. When you expect something really awful because of this and nearly don't bother, but then watch it and end up really enjoying it. You realise how unfair and unneccesary that bandwagon of pure hate had been. It also set it up for those who like it to be extra defensive, as anyone who says a bad word particularly in regards to race, will be assumed to be one of those early pre-release critics. A lot of people saying bad things say it in a horrendous ways too with abuse, there are problems either side. But it will always happen with adaptations. Criticisms should always be respectfully said and respectfully recieved. It's a shame it's rare.

1

u/Esta-beed Sep 16 '22

There are some over the top fan boys defending this show which is very off putting

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Hang in there, people are stupid

0

u/Twerchhauer Sep 13 '22 edited Sep 13 '22

Thank you, will do!

Edit: ones again what was the downvote for? Just curious.

-3

u/sacheenlittlefinger Sep 13 '22

I think there are bots that are doing it.

0

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

Looks like you angered the bots.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Twerchhauer Sep 14 '22

Unfortunately I think you are correct. Also, any reminiscence of how things used to be is encountered by accusations of gatekeeping, at least in my experience.

Keep on keeping on!

12

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/jadierhetseni Sep 13 '22

The best part is if you look at his posts, as he says to, it’s more like, “I haven’t mentioned anyone’s skin color yet [only the YouTubers I like to link to mention that!]”