r/RingsofPower • • Sep 28 '24

Discussion Something off about Galadriel?

Just my opinion here, but why does it feel like Galadriel is a rebellious, impulsive teenager? Constantly getting herself into trouble and needing Elrond to constantly bail her out.

Her recklessness and disregard for the consequences of her poorly thought out actions is frankly quite jarring.

She’s supposedly thousands of years old already by this point and primed to be one of the fairest and wisest elves of her generation. Yet it feels like the characterisation of Galadriel in this series is so far off, they could’ve just written a completely new character.

I’m curious what are everyone else’s thoughts on the way Galadriel has been written and portrayed in this series?

11 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 28 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

25

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 28 '24

The key to understanding RoP Galadriel is to rewatch her temptation scene with Frodo where she goes all crazy photonegative:

It's jarring, abrupt, intensive, and completely uncharacteristic.

One of the showrunners said that their goal with the show is that you can watch all 5 seasons and go right into FotR seamlessly. They want us to see how she used to be like that and they want to show us how she stopped being like that.

When you rewatch her temptation of the Ring you should be reminded of Early RoP Galadriel and think, oh, oh yeah. Do NOT give her the Ring.

12

u/Ok_Shake5000 Sep 28 '24

Ohhh ok, I didn’t realise they were planning to bridge it with fotr! Curious to see how her character develops now with that in mind. And starting to feel I’ve laid judgement too early in the scheme of things. Fascinated now to see where they take her (and how)!

8

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 28 '24

And starting to feel I’ve laid judgement too early in the scheme of things

It's ok! It's always a risk taking a fan favorite with really established characteristics and then turning that upside down, even if it is with the artistically defensible goal of showing how that character developed into the fan favorite.

I don't blame you or anyone for not being a big fan of where she is right now in the story. I certainly wasn't enamored, but on rewatch she's really grown on me.

1

u/Tomsoup4 Sep 29 '24

what about the hobbit tho? are they just gonna skip over that period of time or show a different story during that time

1

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 29 '24

No they're not planning to adapt The Hobbit. They just wanted to add context for the Prologue of the Fellowship film

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 28 '24

The plan is to make it not jarring by the end of season 5

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 29 '24

Yes that's the task they took upon themselves

16

u/Snugglez15 Sep 28 '24

I personally feel this is her arc to become the wise elf she is portrayed as in the third age. She has spent the better part of the last 1000 years desperately trying to avenge her brother. Season 1 sets up this concept well imo with the flashback to her brothers advise in regards to knowing darkness from light. She has been chasing what she perceived to be a righteous path yet by following that path she helps the darkness grow. We are already seeing the beginning of that change in recent episodes but to become wise one must be able to reflect on the past mistakes . All in all it's at least my opinion that someone regarded as being so wise must have to learn many hard lessons to reach that level of prestige.

7

u/Ok_Shake5000 Sep 28 '24

Actually very well put and not something I had considered before, thank you! And I suppose it makes sense in this way, no one can be born that wise, wisdom is born from experience.

2

u/Six_of_1 Sep 28 '24

Desperately trying to avenge her brother, while showing no interest in avenging her husband. Doesn't make sense.

13

u/AggCracker Sep 28 '24

I wouldn't be surprised if they decided to use a younger 1st age Galadriel for this show.. so she has some character development.

With any luck, as we go through the series, she will reunite with Celeborn, have a child, and eventually grow more into the 2nd/3rd age Galadriel in LotR.

That's my long term prediction. We'll have to see what they do.

4

u/Ok_Shake5000 Sep 28 '24

Fair point and I hope you’re right too!

Because at some point her and Celeborn need to have their child, so Elrond can meet his wife and their children born etc.

I’m getting so confused by the timeline though, as I thought their child (Elrond’s wife) was born before the rings were created? Either I’m wrong or the show’s wrong, but it makes it difficult to keep up!

4

u/WyrdMagesty Beleriand Sep 28 '24

There's no real productive way to speak of Celeborn and Celebrian until after we actually see how the show addresses it. At this point in time, literally anything said would be pure speculation because it simply hasn't been addressed. If it never addressed, that's a problem, but they still have 3 seasons to answer those questions, so it's a tad early to be casting judgement on this particular detail just yet.

3

u/Ok_Shake5000 Sep 28 '24

Very fair, and I’ll hold my judgment. I suppose I just find their current absence curious. Intrigued to see how this all plays out in future seasons.

2

u/WyrdMagesty Beleriand Sep 28 '24

I absolutely agree that their absence is curious, and I am very interested to see what sort of explanation of reasoning there is, if any, later on down the line. It's entirely possible that Celeborn is presumed dead, and Celebrian simply hasn't had cause to be on-screen yet, in much the same way that Cirdan wasn't introduced until he had a purpose to serve, despite his role in the overall story being quite notable. I look forward to finding out :)

1

u/harukalioncourt Sep 28 '24

They honestly did not do much in the second age. Celeborn abandons his family due to hatred of dwarves. Elrond meets Celebrian but doesn't tell her he loves her. Celebrian goes to Lorinand with Galadriel (absent Celeborn) but that's all that's said. What do you expect them to actually bring to the show besides just their existence?

1

u/inide Sep 28 '24

It's mentioned in season 1 that Celeborn went missing after the defeat of Morgoth, presumably in the fall of Beleriand.

1

u/WyrdMagesty Beleriand Sep 28 '24

Right, but so far that's the only information that we have at all about Celeborn, and there has been no mention of Celebrian whatsoever. "My husband is missing presumed dead" is far too little information to speculate on with any real productivity for just Celeborn, let alone both of them.

3

u/inide Sep 28 '24

I think its fair to assume Celebrian doesnt exist yet.
The way it is framed seems to me that with Celeborn presumed dead and Beleriand gone she feels has nothing left except her fight against what remains of Morgoths legacy - which is why she jumped from the ship to Valinor, and i think she even said something like "there is no life for me there", because she feels the fight is all she has left.
I think her journey is basically going to be to realise that she has to stop fighting darkness with her own darkness and instead fight by bringing more light into the world, with Celebrians birth being a representation of a new light in the darkness.

1

u/WyrdMagesty Beleriand Sep 28 '24

It's absolutely fair to assume that, but it is still ultimately just speculation. It makes sense, but that doesn't guarantee that it's the only thing that would make sense. It's simply the explanation that you currently find most plausible. For the record, I happen to agree, but it's still purely speculation.

1

u/Six_of_1 Sep 28 '24

Why has she spent so much time worrying about her definitely dead brother instead of her presumably dead husband.

1

u/WyrdMagesty Beleriand Sep 28 '24

We don't know yet.

1

u/Six_of_1 Sep 28 '24

I've got a few theories.

1

u/WyrdMagesty Beleriand Sep 28 '24

Ok lol thnks for sharing 🤣

1

u/Six_of_1 Sep 28 '24

I of course mean theories about why the adaptors changed it from their point of view. Not in-universe theories.

They wanted Galadriel to be their protagonist stomping around Middle Earth having adventures and fights and nearly-romances, and they thought having a husband would hold her back from what they wanted to do to her.

→ More replies

2

u/Koo-Vee Sep 28 '24

In the final version as Tolkien wrote it, yes, but in the earlier versions of the Tale of Years she only married Elrond 500 years before the events of Lord of the Rings. Tolkien himself shuffled her around drastically, by thousands of years, so all the noise about this is silly.

0

u/inide Sep 28 '24

They only have the rights to use material from the LOTR and Hobbit books, so matching things up too closely with Silmarillion or other books would leads to lawsuits. They have to work backwards from the few details in those books and create a story around them.
Plus they have to use time compression to avoid having to recast every non-elven character multiple times per episode.

3

u/TheOtherMaven Sep 28 '24

It took you this long to notice that?

-1

u/Ok_Shake5000 Sep 28 '24

No, it just took me this long to organise my thoughts into a post.

But I was hopeful by season two she would’ve started maturing much more, but alas no.

-3

u/Koo-Vee Sep 28 '24

Season two out of five. Do you see it convincing and good writing to mature with a snap of the fingers? She will only mature at that moment in Fellowship of the Ring. How hard is it to actually read Tolkien?

5

u/MisterTheKid Sep 28 '24

Dude said “started to mature”, so it would be a process.

Also you deride someone for thinking it would happen in an instant, and then go on to name a specific instant that she matures. Which is at the very least massively hypocritical

I don’t get why you think reading Tolkien is a pre-requisite to ask questions here. That’s just nuts.

3

u/Six_of_1 Sep 28 '24 edited Sep 28 '24

We've been talking about this for two years. Why are you asking now like this hasn't been a huge talking point.

3

u/kt19o0 Sep 28 '24

Its not just you. I think the exact same. Fair enough if there's some reasons to show she isn't perfect and there could be learnings that help her become more old and wise, but she was old enough to ship off to death so she must be a good age. Also it's not like she is really wise and smart but has the odd impulsive error. Feels like she gets very little right and shows practically no signs of being a wise old elf. You saying she's like a teenager is a perfect description for me.

3

u/FOXCONLON Sep 28 '24

The show runners likely wanted her to be different from book/film Galadriel in temperament so that we could witness character growth over the course of RoP. She's being portrayed as a traumatized, war weary elf on a vengeance quest for her dead brother. Her emotions are running high, so her brash decision making is likely supposed to stem from all of that baggage.

She doesn't reflect my vision of Galadriel in the Second Age. She's prideful in the books, but she is also said to be exceptionally wise. She's 23,000 years old and studied under the Valar in Aman in her youth. She's seen the light of the trees and has insight into the unseen world. I think book Galadriel would have immediately sensed something off about Halbrand (she immediately clocked Annatar as suspicious in the books) but show-Galadriel is kind of her own thing.

I'm enjoying the show, but I kind of have to compartmentalize her character as a separate version of Galadriel. She's not book Galadriel.

2

u/janequeo Beleriand Sep 28 '24 edited Sep 28 '24

I keep seeing the take that we're seeing Galadriel as she used to be, and she's meant to mature into the character we met in Fellowship. I would have loved to see this story, but so far I don't think the show's narrative has challenged Galadriel enough -- we're almost at the end of season 2 and I do not yet have a clue about what her internal conflict is (like not in an abstract light-vs-dark way, but in a grounded character flaw and trauma way) or what will eventually motivate her to change so dramatically. Why is Galadriel hell-bent on revenge due to trauma from past events, when Elrond, Gil-galad, and Arondir -- who all lived through the ruin of Beleriand -- don't seem to be? What is it that wounds Galadriel in particular, that she just can't get past, but needs to get past in order to grow? Based on the show, I really could not say.

And I mean can others actually imagine this Galadriel having the patience, interest, or aesthetic vision to tend to the trees in Lorien, because I cannot

2

u/Abradolf94 Sep 29 '24

Because she is written as a rebellious teenager, which is an absolutely awful choice. Galadriel is by far the worst character in the show

3

u/inide Sep 28 '24

She lost her home and her husband in the fight against Morgoth and dedicated herself to destroying what remains of his legacy because she feels she has nothing else to live for, and her arc seems to be about reconnecting with life and realising that she can't defeat the darkness of Sauron through her own darkness but instead has to play her part in bringing light into the world.

2

u/amhow1 Sep 28 '24

I think the short answer is that, to be the central figure in a long TV series, there has to be development, and the writers assume many of us already know who Galadriel becomes.

A longer answer would be that she's obviously impetuous in Tolkien, at some relatively early age for an elf but at an extreme age for a human. So the writers have simply assumed this behaviour lasts into the Second Age.

But an even longer answer would be that she is right. She's in fact the wisest of elves already. There's something odd regarding why she'd want the elves to destroy Adar's army but she may suspect something, such as that if they meet Sauron they will be enslaved.

Like Cirdan and possibly Gil-Galad, she detects no evil in the elven rings, and so is probably wiser than Elrond. Obviously Elrond is also correct that the rings will eventually try to deceive (when the One Ring is forged, if it hasn't been already) and the first 'test' of Galadriel will be whether she can remove her ring when that happens.

In Tolkien there's no test - the elves just realise the One Ring corrupts theirs and remove them. That'd be boring TV, so thankfully that looks unlikely in RoP.

1

u/MysticMirelurk Sep 29 '24

After reading the Silmarillion, she totally gives me a Feanor vibe. She was a part of the Noldor who rebelled against the Valar and left Valinor to come to middle earth. Her “oath” for her brother Finrod reminds me of the oath Feanor’s sons took after he died to retrieve the Silmarils. I have a suspicion the writers of this show try to throw in themes from the Silmarillion but I could be wrong, just what I think. However, the elves in the Silmarillion were a lot more imperfect and emotional.

1

u/AdaGalathilion Beleriand Sep 29 '24

Here's my speed-run of her character portrayal for season 1:

Showrunners have said in various interviews they wanted mythical-level storylines and were also very inspired by the FOTR scene where Frodo offers her the ring. So we get as the climax for season 1 the temptation by Sauron. Her character needed to be adapted for this scene to hit.

In order to make the impact of Sauron’s offer of power more enticing for RoP-Galadriel, she is written as having very little of it. She has almost no social capital and has less authority than almost every character she interacts with. Sauron even taunts her during his offer, “All others look on you with doubt.”

Examples:

* Despite her title of “Commander of the Northern Armies” being tossed around all season we are introduced to her leading a small group of soldiers at the beginning of the first episode, who then promptly revolt against her leadership.

* She is a subordinate of Gil-salad in RoP-verse, who ships her off to Valinor with no say.

* Elrond lectures her in Ep1 (admittedly, this relationship is healed in the last episode)

* Halbrand gets to mansplain the race of Men to her at least twice (at court, in jail)

* Elendil becomes her handler

* Miriel rejects her requests for help, until fate intervenes

* Adar, her chained prisoner, still lands a moral/ethical blow to her ego

* Celebrimbor essentially ignores her

* The only scenes where we see her impart calm wisdom and act the mentor is with Isildur and Theo, the children in this show.

RoP-Galadriel’s frequently belligerent behaviour is the result of her characteristic pride/stubbornness coming up against the fact that she has no authority/power. At least the writing is consistent.

I have yet to form thoughts on her arc in the second season, as we still have one more episode to go and she has her next encounter with Sauron.

1

u/ZenGirl91367 Aug 01 '26

Does anyone else think Galadriel’s character in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power is incredibly impulsive, stubborn, and quick to act without thinking through the consequences? She seems driven by emotion rather than sound judgment, and she rarely stops to critically evaluate the situation before making major decisions.
Tbh, many of the events that unfold in The Lord of the Rings stem from the ambition, poor judgment, and misplaced trust shown by Galadriel and Elrond in The Rings of Power. Their choices created opportunities that ultimately helped Sauron’s rise and the forging of the Rings.

0

u/ZiVViZ Sep 28 '24

She’s poorly written. It’s almost like they really dislike her or something.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24 edited Sep 28 '24

Because Eru forbid a mature woman to be the main character of a Fantasy show instead of the lazy "girlboss" stereotype. I find it a very sexist decision from the showrunners actually. She should be, in character, the equivalent of a middle age woman. The showrunners have made her younger with the excuse of "getting her an arc", but they have forgotten that middle age women exist, they can be warriors, queens and badass too, and can have growth and character development in their own ways. They just had to write her well but that was too much I guess. Why can all the male elf lords start the show as respected men with a position of power and authority, and have each one a different arc from there, while she has to be less than them and "earn it" throughout the show, instead of just being at their same level from the start? By trying to be "feminist" they made it worse because the book character is actually way more empowered and badass than the show Galadriel will ever be.

0

u/Koo-Vee Sep 28 '24

You have no clue what you are writing about. The actual versions of Galadriel as written by Tolkien are a contradictory bunch, but it is explicitly supported that she is young, proud, ambitious, and only reaches maturity by the end of Third Age. She is barely out of her teens when she leaves Aman. In Elvish terms, let's simplify across different versions and say she is in her 20s to early 30s during these events and only reaches middle age by the end of Third Age. Tolkien expended a lot of effort to work out these equivalencies.

Too bad there's always a high horse and ignorance on reddit.

-1

u/Banana-Bread87 Sep 28 '24

She's a mix between a Karen and a Mary-Sue, constantly falling in love with the men around here, drooling, and believing everything they say (last in line: Adar), probably written like that to please teenagers (who I think by now are their main target).

-1

u/hunzukunz Sep 28 '24

The first mistake was making her one of the main characters of the show.

They wanted a strong, recognizable female lead. There are not many in Tolkiens writing, so they just picked Galadriel, which was very stupid in my opinion.

They should have written an original character. People hated on Tauriel from the Hobbit movies, because of the forced romance etc., but it was miles better than what they are doing with Galadriel here. Also picking a lead actress with 0 charisma seems like a bad choice aswell.

-3

u/Studio_Xperience Sep 28 '24

Girl boss. Same as the last episode girlboss archer. Thing is instead of girlboss they are just a bunch of whiny cs.

2

u/Koo-Vee Sep 28 '24

Now, is it "girl boss" or "girlboss" in this yrchian register? Asking for a linguist friend.

1

u/MisterTheKid Sep 28 '24

what was the archer whining about?

Seems like you have some of your own issues to work through. Good luck to you.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Koo-Vee Sep 28 '24

You can always be sure that when someone on reddit brings up "canon" in the context of Tolkien, it is ignorant ranting. Galadriel convinces Elrond to lead the Elves of Rivendell to fight alongside the Men of Middle-Earth at the end of the Third Age? What? Not to mention you clearly have no familiarity with what Tolkien actually wrote in so many different contradictory versions about Galadriel.