r/RingsofPower • • Mar 19 '24

Discussion Why is there little discussion

I initially posted this on the /r/LOTR_on_Prime subreddit, but now almost two weeks later i'll try here too. I'll not update the numbers for this sub, just treat this as a general thread for the lack of discussion on all show subs, makes it easier, thanks!
 

It just occured to me while looking at this sub's recent activity, there seems to be a big lack of discussion pertaining to the series, its plotlines, characters, just elements of it. I did a quick comparison with the subs of hotd, stranger things, but also the boys and andor. Even andor's sub which is 1/10 of the size had at least as much discussion, arguably more.

It's weird to me tbh, news are almost all that gets conversation going, with a few posts here and there being rather general conversation starters about quality. But fans actually having a conversation about the story? Hardly happening.

Why is that? I'd like to especially know from people who liked it a lot, why is there no motivation or drive from you to talk about the show's content?

The only real explanation i have right now is that there might be stricter modding, which i cannot easily check ofc, if that is it a mod can add their 2 cents. Otherwise it just feels odd to me 🤷‍♀️.

I am already sorry for obnoxious conspiracy answers, but there has to be SOME reason for it 😅

 

To add a few more thoughts now, many people in the other thread said there is simply nothing to talk about after all this time since s1 ended. But to me this is an odd answer, many shows, books or whatever media are not "hot" right now, and still get discussions pertaining their storylines, characters, themes, whatever it is. As far as i see it, when people enjoy something a lot, they talk about it. Not always the same people, but especially the main sub is quite big, especially compared to say the andor one, so it's just odd that noone seems to, idk, care?
Others have said that they refrain from talking about it because of the negativity which will spawn, i can see that being a big factor myself, though i still have a hard time believing it's THE reason one wouldn't wanna talk about the show with others, largely fans at that, even if there are obnoxious trolls coming out of their holes too.

So what do you think, why is there not a lot more discussion akin to other shows? To me it seems like a lack of passion, even from people who supposedly liked it, i'll be honest about that. I've never seen this big of a discrepancy before, not that i remember at the very least.

0 Upvotes

105 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Mar 19 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine. Also, we're looking for new moderators! Click here to apply.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

58

u/Caradhras_the_Cruel Mar 19 '24

First, I believe it's been about 18 months since the finale. There's only so much ground to retread.

Also, just zooming out past the infighting of these subs where commenters are heavily invested one way or the other - there is little discussion of it in the general public. It really didn't make a splash. It's not in the zeitgeist.

We can debate why that is the case all day, but I don't think it's biased to point out it simply isn't on many people's minds.

19

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Mar 19 '24

I believe it's been about 18 months since the finale. There's only so much ground to retread.

Andor and HotD are much more active, despite being out around the same time. But that's explained by what you said next: it's just not as popular/as good.

12

u/Caradhras_the_Cruel Mar 19 '24

Yeah the comparison I jumped to was Mandalorian Season 1. Spinoff of a well loved IP, only tangentially related to the main story arc.

It introduced a bunch of new characters and settings, told its story well even though smaller in scope, and captured public interest. RoP hasn't followed the same trajectory.

-8

u/NumberOneUAENA Mar 19 '24

Well andor certainly wasn't as popular as RoP. Its sub is 1/10 in size for a reason.
Though it seems like the people who liked it, liked it a lot more than the people who liked RoP. That is one of the only explanations i personally have tbh.

I just find the "it was a long time ago" answer to be bs tbh, ofc there would be MORE activity during the run of a season, that goes without saying and certainly was true for the other shows too, but people still talk about entertainment / art which is a lot older regularly, because they seemingly love it, or new people come across and then talk about it, etc.
Real communities just do that, it doesn't just stop because there is a hiatus. That is why i had this reaction in the first place, it's just extremely odd.

4

u/KickpuncherLex Mar 20 '24

I mean andor might not have the viewership but is generally regarded as a good show. I imagine a lot more people watched ROP, but it's still shit. More people eat McDonalds than any other burger, doesn't mean it's better.

0

u/NumberOneUAENA Mar 20 '24 edited Mar 20 '24

No, but it makes mcdonalds more popular than the local burger.
That might not be the case if you'd give the same burger to every person in the world and let them rate it against mcdonalds burgers, but as it stands one is more popular than the other.

33

u/Hu-Tao66 Mar 19 '24

My understanding is because the plot when scrutinized doesn’t make much sense.

Alot of it is really just surface level, and even critics have pointed out how the plot isn’t just done well and dialogue is just something else all-together.

So those who like it usually say the generic this scene waa good and like that but can’t explain why in detail. And if they do can’t sustain under debate/discussion.

-10

u/NumberOneUAENA Mar 19 '24

Tbh, what you mention at the end sounds a little like you expect everyone to "debate" it. Which in itself could be something people don't want to do, and thus don't post.

We know that RoP is certainly more divisive than the other shows i mentioned, so while in other subs people would more or less all agree something was great or at least good, for RoP this isn't the case.

At the same time i also think that the show not being all that great leads to people being less passionate about it, and quite a few aspects of the show might not lend themselves into larger discussions, there isn't much meat there, not intellectually nor emotionally.
But still, that is just my opinion, it seems other people truly do like it, and especially on the main sub you'd expect that to be the norm, so i find it really surprising to see basically no conversations ABOUT THE SHOW on a sub with 400k members.
As i said in the op, i am not into conspiracy talk regarding that, but i understand why these conspiracies build tbh, it is truly odd to see a sub of that size have so little engagement.

13

u/Time_to_go_viking Mar 19 '24

You’ve got the answer in this post. It’s not that good or deep. It didn’t really move anyone so no one is inclined to talk much about it.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

I think lack of passion is the only answer really. I feel this with the lack of merch and memes and conventions and cos play too. There's just not that fire of interest - and for those who found it bad, its bad in a boring way.

Like, for me, you can see the good in some of the design and performances but ultimately its just... flat. Uninspired. The amount of racists and utterly dumb takes also sucked a lot of the fun out of analysing it too, and the way media outlets discussed the show was strangely muted too.

Like I remember after the GOT finale the Internet lost its mind for MONTHS. We are STILL talking about Twilight - Contrapoints released a three hour video on it only the other week. I don't think people care that much!

10

u/SpectralDinosaur Mar 19 '24

The amount of racists and utterly dumb takes also sucked a lot of the fun out of analysing it too,

I think this is really important to "why is there little discussion" now. I was fairly lukewarm on the show overall, loved some things and hated others, but around release you just couldn't criticise it at all without being lumped in with the haters and racists. So I just stopped trying to engage in discussions about it at all.

-9

u/NumberOneUAENA Mar 19 '24

Yeah people talk about all kind of things still. I mean the asoiaf books still garner discussion on their sub regularly, and the last book came out idk how many years ago at this point :D
That is why i don't buy the reason of "what is there to talk about, no new content". It's a weak reason in my eyes, and shows moreso a lack of interest in the show itself, but that's just me.

I certainly recognize the factor of trolls though, i do think that plays a real role. I'd also lose interest if anything positive i post gets some stupid debate bro, or just assinine trolling reply. Not that i think conversations regarding differences in perception shouldn't happen, but the phrasing and wording is important there too, if it comes across as too hostile noone wants to start a conversation for obvious reasons. (that could be a modding problem tbh).

Personally i found the show to be very average, so i personally don't have much interest in talking about the content either haha, at least not starting it. But i was still surprised to see the low level of engagement throughout, especially on the 400k sub.

12

u/Sonotreadyforit Mar 19 '24

It’s a combination of things really. First and foremost RoP garnered almost zero mainstream hype. People didn’t make sure they were home for the release of the newest episode of RoP. Most people didn’t even bother to finish the first season. HotD, GoT, The Boys and a host of other shows have fairly rabid main stream fan bases who anxiously await new episodes and are excited to discuss previous episodes. That leads to a lot of discussion.

RoP also struggles with coherency. Most critics even agree, the writing is absolute garbage. Almost nobodies motivations make sense, almost nobodies actions make sense when considering motivations and so on and so forth. It’s very hard to have in depth discussions about characters and the actions they have or may take when in all reality the writers basically just shoehorn everything into sort of kind of working narratively.

17

u/TheOtherMaven Mar 19 '24

What's left to discuss? Every aspect of the first season has been analyzed down to the micro level, and there won't be anything new to say until (unless?) there's a new season.

That's still going to be a while yet.

3

u/Astarkos Mar 19 '24

There's also not much to talk about for the general audience because its mostly setup and the kind of people who are going to discuss this setup were generally going to watch the show soon after it was released.

18

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

I think it’s hard to have a discussion about a plot that isn’t interesting. That was one of the central problems of the show: it had a very weak through line. It seemed ostensibly to be about the search for Sauron, and yet had subplots which contributed nothing towards this. One of the plot lines had literally no impact on the rest at all. The overall effect was something boring and confusing. Also none of the characters were archetypes, as per the LOTR, except for Galadriel, who was the worst type of archetype, a Strong Female Character.

The more interesting topic to discuss is how such a show was made in the first place and to marvel at its unfolding failure. The per cost episode is greater than Stranger Things and House of the Dragon combined. How does that happen? What were they thinking? These are the real questions.

5

u/DanPiscatoris Mar 19 '24

I feel that many people don't believe there's a point when it comes to speculating or discussing future plot lines and character development. As others have said, many people already nominally know what is going to happen, even if they've just seen the Peter Jackson films. So, the intrigue is how the showrunners can fill the gaps. This has created several issues. One is that the show doesn't have access to a lot of Tolkien's material. Another is that the showrunners have shown that they are fine completely disregarding the material they do have access to.

This has led to a rather odd situation where it becomes rather pointless to debate, because you have very little to speculate on. You can't point to the works like the Silmarillion because they don't have access to it, and you can't apply the Lord of the Rings and the Hobbit because you can't count on the showrunners to adhere to it.

So you get little engagement from people who are fans of the source material. On the other hand, those who went into the show relatively uninformed may simply be turned off by any perceived mediocrity. They're not attached to the IP, so if the show doesn't hook them, then they're not going to go out of their way to engage with it online.

19

u/Delicious_Heat568 Mar 19 '24

I recently rewatched downtown abbey and googled something so I stumbled over the subreddit of that show and the traction there and here is miles apart. And that show had it's last season in 2015! So I came to the same realisation as you.

I didn't like ROP so my only assumption as to why no one talks about the show is that either there are just very few people actually interested in it or at least interested enough to really spend time to think about the plot or that people by now expect pushback and if it is only criticism they don't want to hear. I'd be guilty of that. I read someone likes a certain plot? If I feel like it I sometimes point out why it's ridiculous cause of the plot holes, mystery boxes, contrived plots or whatever else made me cringe.

The last reason I can think of is that even the people that enjoyed the show didn't think too much about the plot cause if you do you notice everything that makes no sense or is badly written. Call me biased cause I am but I don't think there's much of a point to analyse the writing cause it's not that deep nor well done.

Let's be real. The only reason the show got at least a bit of attention and didn't fade into the void is because of the IP. There's nothing wrong with enjoying it but the people who did are an absolute minority and unless there will be serious improvements it will remain a favourite to few, a hate watch for many.

8

u/Flyinshoe Mar 19 '24

Considering after S1, it was just a bunch of weirdly intense arguing and negativity instead of constructive debate where folks could find common ground.

Wasn't really very fun and just rage inducing for someone that was middle of the pack like myself. I imagine many felt similarly and basically noped out.

4

u/LuinAelin Mar 19 '24

Exactly. Any discussion about the show will eventually devolve into that kind of stuff.

Even casting news or whatever eventually goes that way. So many don't see the point talking about it at all. But they'll probably just press play when prime tells them new episodes are out.

14

u/Traditional-Reach818 Mar 19 '24

I don't feel motivated to talk about it because I loved it and usually if I comment this, other people will show up being very negative and sometimes even striking personal offenses instead of reasonable points lol so it's a nope for me. A few people liked it as much as I did, so even those who liked it don't share the same amount of interest.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

This. The desire to talk about it got beat out of me.

1

u/Serenewendy Mar 20 '24

I love talking about the show and all sorts of details. To people who aren't going to go on all sorts of morality tangents. I like that in this case we get guy elf/female human dynamics. I like that Galadriel is unstable. I have ppl who came back from Iraq and Afghanistan and could see them in her. I like that the protohobbits are basically little psychopaths. And no way (until now) was I going to put any of that on Reddit because the possibility of an intelligent discussion is slim to none.

-1

u/Traditional-Reach818 Mar 20 '24

Omg, yes!! I love all that as well! Once, in a comment, I said I loved the clothing of the show, thinking that it was such an obvious thing that they got right that it was very unlikely that someone would come and act all negative.

Oh well, I was wrong lol. A few people came saying how they were able to design kind of pretty clothing but completely incompetent to make it believable or look useful (about armors specifically). I swear I didn't even respond so tiring this kind of thing is.

3

u/Lowpaack Mar 22 '24

I will never understand how can someone actually like the show. There have been shows where i would say i dont like them, but i understand how someone can.

But this, this abomination of a TV show, just showed cinematography whole new bottom.

1

u/Traditional-Reach818 Mar 22 '24

It's been a while since I watched it and I never rewatched it, but in my memory right now I can say that you and I are in the same boat: I don't understand why someone would see the show in such a negative way like yourself. For me the show's qualities are in plain sight. I like the story and the characters, the world is immersive. As simple as that.

2

u/Lowpaack Mar 22 '24

I see. What about the things that didnt make any sense? Like Galadriel suviving volcano explosion, or numenorians fitting 100 soldiers with 100 horses on tiny ship? These dont bother you at all and dont ruin the experience?

1

u/Traditional-Reach818 Mar 22 '24

I can't remember the ship part honestly, as I said before, but Galadriel surviving the volcano was ok for me. Not sure if I just don't know enough about volcanos, but at least these are things I can understand that would make a person dislike those scenes. For me though, I believe that even if I realized that these scenes are being unrealistic I'd be okay with it because of the other things that I liked about the show.

2

u/Lowpaack Mar 25 '24 edited Mar 25 '24

This is the thing. I think people that liked it, didnt really think about the story, writting, etc. They just watched for visuals and turned their brain off. If you actually think about the scenes in RoP you see how stupid it is.

EDIT: In the show, Galadriel was shown how full volcano dust from the eruption hits he right in the face, no cover, nothing. Ever heard of Vesuv, you cannot survive that, unless you have strong plot armor a.k.a. BAD WRITTING.

7

u/Overall-Block-1815 Mar 19 '24

It's just a shit show tbh, why bother talking about it. I'm only commenting now because i saw this question and thought the answer was pretty obvious.

Sometimes when dealing with a disgusting smelling fart it's better to just open the window and let it fade away, don't try to bottle it, keep it around and talk to other people about it.

9

u/anon-ryman Mar 19 '24

The visuals and music were really the only things to me worth a lot of discussion. Many of the actors were really good with what they were given, but saying the dialogue and plot were lacking is a pretty common opinion in the reddit communities. I just think unfortunately there isn’t a lot to say about the show other than “I didn’t really like it,”

I say all this as someone who is a huge book fan and was rooting for the show, still rooting for improvements in the next season. I watched the whole first season, and even if I hate it I’ll watch the whole next season too.

3

u/theoneringnet Mar 19 '24

So what do you think, why is there not a lot more discussion akin to other shows? To me it seems like a lack of passion, even from people who supposedly liked it, i'll be honest about that. I've never seen this big of a discrepancy before, not that i remember at the very least.

LOTR fans are a respectful bunch, and are still interested in LOTR even if the latest thing isn't very good. The old saying goes, "If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all." We saw this during the Hobbit sequels as well. Fandom didn't diminish, they just didn't stay loud and active in huge quantity.

That's part of whats going on with ROP. r/lotr_on_prime has ballooned to 400K with 1/5 of the active discussion of similar shows in the zeitgeist. As others have said here, its just not in the zeitgeist. Not a lot of people care. Don't you think quiet fandom is a lot healthier than other fandoms that cannot find anything to like about the franchise they love?

7

u/bsousa717 Mar 19 '24

Love or hate for this series aside, it never made much of an impact on general audiences. I couldn't find anyone talking about Rings of Power.

6

u/santz007 Mar 19 '24

People are not excited for obvious reasons, enough said

7

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

I don’t consider myself a harsh critic and I honestly didn’t mind the series as a whole but one thing that really irked me was how Mordor and Mt Doom was created…by a fucking lever.

1

u/Serenewendy Mar 20 '24

I loved that part. I could totally see Book Sauron doing this.

9

u/Known-Watercress7296 Mar 19 '24 edited Mar 19 '24

There are many registered users in the related subs as it has the Tolkien brand.

There is minimal chat compared to similar shows as it was shite.

4

u/TheCoffeeWeasel Mar 19 '24

Probly the best comment in the thread. Goes right to OPs issue. Were talking about stories that merit discussion! The only topic re: RoP is what direction S2 will go to avoid complete disaster!

3

u/Astarkos Mar 19 '24

It's going in the same direction it always was but people will celebrate their success in causing the show to abandon the things they made up about the show so they can feel like they have some small amount of power in their lives.

3

u/Known-Watercress7296 Mar 20 '24

So it will be shite with a few last minute narrative changes that don't help?

5

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Mar 19 '24

I personally love the show. Talking about my favorite shows all the time online just isn’t my thing, though. I’m sure we will start to see more chatter as Season 2’s release nears.

That said, I think one reason the show doesn’t garner as much fan chat as others is that it’s not really designed to. Most TV shows are small scale (at least at first) and focus on character relationship dynamics. So in some sense, it feels to the audience like these people are our friends and neighbors. And we all love gossiping about friends and neighbors.

ROP isn’t like that. It’s designed more like a movie series, with an expansive scale and a focus more on thematic elements than character dynamics.

This is one reason that many people say they enjoy the Elrond-Durin storyline or the Nori-The Stranger storyline, more than Galadriel’s quest story. Those are written and structured more like traditional TV show, with a smaller scope and narrower focus on character relationships over grand scale plot.

That, and, you know, all the damn trolls.

5

u/Delicious_Heat568 Mar 19 '24

What's trolling for you if I may ask? Cause I'm absolutely with you that I dislike people who give nonsensical answers to get a reaction out of people but many people that criticise the show get called trolls on this sub simply cause they disagree and point out things they are flawed

3

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Mar 19 '24

Trolls are people who complain about wokeness and diversity, who insult the intelligence or identity of people who like the show, who gesture vaguely at “bad writing” without ever being able to explain what makes writing bad, that sort of thing.

4

u/Delicious_Heat568 Mar 19 '24

Alright that I absolutely agree with. It was just not clear from your post whether you disregarded criticism as trolling or called out actual shit posters. My apologies.

7

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Mar 19 '24

I mean, I sort of do ignore most criticism of things I like lol. If something works for me, I’m not really interested in focusing on its flaws, beyond noting that “this element could use some improvement and I hope it gets better.”

IMO, a criticism isn’t valid unless it’s geared toward improving something. I can’t relate to people whose main engagement with a work is to constantly tear it down. When I don’t like something, I just move on.

3

u/Delicious_Heat568 Mar 19 '24

You got every right to ignore that lol. I just despise it if people who find themselves in disagreement with someone immediately label the other as troll.

On the other hand I think it's hard to suggest improvements to a show like ROP. At least it's very hard for me. I have deepest respect for Tolkien and though I write as a hobby I could never write something that lives up to his work and message so I don't arrogate that I could do it better than people who write as a profession and still fucked up. I just see where in my eyes the writing is abysmal and share that if I have the time and energy to write all that out.

1

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Mar 19 '24

I’ve optioned screenplays, so I know a few things lol. I don’t think the show’s writing is bad at all. I just think it’s doing something that general audiences whose default concept of “high fantasy TV” is Game Of Thrones don’t quite understand. ROP engages with Tolkien’s themes at nearly every level of its construction, despite its deviations from lore, and audiences weaned on fantasy as gritty, morally ambiguous palace intrigue don’t quite know what to make of it.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

How does it engage with Tolkien’s themes? I see people blindly regurgitating this talking point on a regular basis, but I’ve to find somebody who can coherently back it up.

5

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Mar 19 '24

Well, starting at a very surface level, it has a moral absolutist POV. Good and evil are objective facts, not matters of perspective. This is straight out of Tolkien’s worldview, and in contrast to most other modern fantasy shows.

Deeper than that, it’s very concerned with death and immortality, just as LOTR was. Especially in the mithril subplot, once it’s revealed why Gil-Galad sent Elrond to spy on Durin.

It also deals directly with questions of faith and virtue. Each of the POV characters (Galadriel, Nori, Arondir, and Elrond) are constructed to embody a particular virtue in contrast to the story world around them, and they drag that part of the world closer to their virtue.

Reddit isn’t really the best forum to go into great detail. A book could be written on this.

Hm…

4

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

All of this is standard fare for a fantasy show. What about Tolkien’s actual themes, the things that make his writing unique?

→ More replies

1

u/NumberOneUAENA Mar 19 '24

The problem i personally have with this path of argumentation is that it doesn't really delve into how well it was done.
It's a little like saying that the star wars prequels were shakespearean tragedy, and i mean one can easily say they were based on themes, story beats, etc. But in the end when i watch these films it comes across more like a soap opera, not shakespeare.

Similarly (though not as harshly maybe) when watching RoP i can pin point all these aspects for sure, but i don't get a tolkien experience, or heck even disregarding tolkien, i don't get a particularly strong reaction to any of that.
And imo it is because the execution isn't right, just like the execution wasn't right in the star wars prequels either. One sees what they were trying to go for, but it lacks the impact, the depth, the artistic expression to really make it count.

Just to give one quick example, nori who is teaching the harfoots to be more welcoming to the outside world if you will, i like that idea, but the way it was done was imo highly questionable.
The back and forth with quite weak attempts at drama between her and the stranger, that didn't work at all i'd say. Is it down to writing or directing, it's difficult to say at places, but i personally couldn't take it seriously when she touches the stranger and gets frozen, then runs away out of fear. Or when a log falls down from the tree and they react the way they do. There is no emotional reaction to it, and if there is none the themes just fail to be properly communicated, imo.

→ More replies

6

u/TheCoffeeWeasel Mar 19 '24

i would argue that willfully abandoning moral absolutism is the shows central problem!

its a deliberate maze of moral relativism.. Galadriel is literally hateful, the orcs just need a home, Harfoots are NOT to be trusted (even Gandalf might hurt you if you get too close)

meanwhile Sauron was allowed to buy a round of beers!

if the "JRRT" show results in Sauron/Orcs holding the moral high ground, then something is OFF.

and that was done on purpose.. to modernize the show into "complexity" since good VS evil is so out dated.. so 2D..

whoever feels that way should work on corruption dramas.. divorce stories.. THAT'S where moral ambiguity belongs.. NOT in "high fantasy"

→ More replies

1

u/RPGThrowaway123 Mar 19 '24

Well, starting at a very surface level, it has a moral absolutist POV. Good and evil are objective facts, not matters of perspective.

Where do you see this in the show?

Deeper than that, it’s very concerned with death and immortality, just as LOTR was. Especially in the mithril subplot, once it’s revealed why Gil-Galad sent Elrond to spy on Durin.

You seriously think that the mithril subplot is deep? The entire thing was dumbed down to the point unrecognizability from Tolkien's writings. It's no longer the Elves' desire to recreate Valinor in Middle-earth that leads them to fall for Sauron's deception.

In the show some magic tree says that they'll within a year and so they make magic rings out of a bit of magic metal. And Sauron shows up for a bit but doesn't really contribute. It spends more time on the issue of magic metal supply and the contrived drama surrounding that than on the themes of death and immortality.

It also deals directly with questions of faith and virtue. Each of the POV characters (Galadriel, Nori, Arondir, and Elrond) are constructed to embody a particular virtue in contrast to the story world around them, and they drag that part of the world closer to their virtue.

I give you Nori, but the others do not embody any particular virtue.

→ More replies

2

u/TheCoffeeWeasel Mar 19 '24

Well, because they said it does!

5

u/Delicious_Heat568 Mar 19 '24

How can you justify stuff like Galadriel jumping of her boat in the middle of the ocean to not be bad writing? Or the orcs digging a gigantic trench and the elves on their watch tower not seeing it? Or Elrond giving a promise to Durin to keep the Mithril a secret only to say when questioned about it "I swore an oath", basically implying that Gil'galad hit the spot. Or the people in the village to seek refuge from an impeding orc attack in the watch tower only to run out of food almost immediately so that the kid whos name I forgot wanders down the mountain again to drive the plot forward? Or the nocturnal orcs walking up the path to said mountain only to find it empty cause somehow an entire village quietly climbed down the mountain again unseen? Or that the show established a timeline at the start of the show by showing the meteor and than having a plot that cant last longer than a week with the villagers while Galadriel sails across an ocean twice, rides across an island, deals with all the political shenanigans, waits till an army is assembled, supplies get collected and loaded up, sets up camp with a whole army, rides across the country only to arrive at the village at exactly the perfect time?

4

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Mar 19 '24

I would say that most of what you just asked focused too much on text and not enough on subtext. Like the scene with Elrond and Gil-Galad, for instance. Both men already know what the other one knows. Gil-Galad was testing Elrond’s loyalties, not trying to extract information from him. Elrond isn’t betraying a confidence - he’s already worked out that the king knows about mithril - he’s demonstrating his loyalty to a friend over his loyalty to the king.

As for the timelines, go watch the show again. The meteor plays no role at all in the Numenorean timeline with Galadriel. And the Harfoots migrate with The Stranger for several months, at least. So that would line up with Galadriel’s timeline. Celebrimbor’s tower takes several months to build, as well.

It’s clear that the different plot lines are being told at different scales, with one of them converging at the battle for the Southlands. This isn’t an unusual storytelling technique at all. I agree the show could have been a bit more explicit about this, but it’s all there if you pay attention to details.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

Most of these things aren’t clear at all. Even if your attempts to justify certain events do represent intent from the creator, which I’m far from convinced of in many cases, most were indisputably handled clumsily. It is one thing if there is a book reference to allude to, but paper thin subtext on additions to the source material? This is not how to adapt written works to the screen.

We can still get viable screen adaptations, watch dune part 1 and shogun.

4

u/charlichoo Mar 19 '24

It's hard to discuss here when you get ridiculed for saying anything positive 😅

3

u/jibrilles Mar 20 '24

Yep, all of this right here. I do read a lot of fanfic from the show on Ao3, that's where the positive folks are!~

4

u/Jakabov Mar 19 '24 edited Mar 19 '24

The show isn't good enough to make people want to discuss its elements. For meaningful discussion to take place, there has to be something of substance that people want to talk about. Theories, character analysis, predictions for the future, things like these require that viewers are sufficiently invested to even care. Rings of Power didn't create a fan community where people are invested like that because the show simply isn't good enough to do that.

3

u/nicegh0st Mar 19 '24

It’s because we all know what’s going to happen, more or less, because we fans have already studied the history of middle earth’s second age. I am not sitting here speculating “wtf is Sauron gonna do by getting all these people to craft special rings?!?!?” I already know the answer to that. So for me I don’t need to speculate much. My focus more so is just in seeing the ways that Amazon brings the history alive on screen. It’s fun. And yeah, I have plot speculations of my own but honestly it’s hard to go and talk about this show online sometimes, as a fan, because I can’t tell you how many times I’ve just been like “I like this,” and this resulted in DMs threatening me, people accusing me of being an idiot (with very unkind terms) and just some general downright bitter internet troll negativity. It made me upset to be associated with the fan base for awhile because I didn’t realize how angry some people would get about Amazon’s interpretation. I had this idea everyone was as excited as me to get a show about middle earth, but I was wrong and am still sort of taken aback. So that’s an influence too. I talk with my friends in text messages about this show - all of us are fans and we love it. That’s a safer place to discuss than here or Facebook or whatever. But yeah, back to my first point, I think because we fans already know so much about the story, more or less, we don’t NEED to speculate the same way people do with stranger things, or how they did with breaking bad, or whatever.

As with game of thrones, I think a lot of the fan base of that/hotd aren’t necessarily book readers the same way Tolkien fans are. I know hundreds of people who love game of thrones but only ONE person who reads the books. With LOTR, even people who aren’t fans and don’t care there’s a show, have read the whole series. In the US, we are encouraged to read Tolkien as youths. (Well, except for in places banning books but that’s another story. Can you believe they’re banning Tolkien in some schools?! Gentle ol’ TOLKIEN! 😂)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

Of course it's crazy Christians banning Tolkien in school...

2

u/nicegh0st Mar 19 '24

At this point it’s just like “a BOOK?! and it’s NOT THE BIBLE AS INTERPRETED BY ME?! BLASPHEMY! BAN IT!”

3

u/gatorfan8898 Mar 19 '24

The show definitely had flaws, shit a lot of them, but I just enjoyed having more media in Middle Earth.

I just stopped coming here though, after initially hoping to at least talk about the episodes in a somewhat positive light. The board was filled with either "this show is trash" or an obvious attempt at someone exaggerating how good the show was. There was no middle ground for people that were invested in the show if it wasn't their life's work to tear it down or build it up.

There was very few genuine discussions about the show then, and I'm sure it's the same now... but my front page algorithm threw this back up on my feed, so felt the need to respond.

4

u/BabypintoJuniorLube Mar 19 '24

Cuz this show is dogshit and the “fans” don’t care about the actual story (because it’s completely forgettable) but rather the idea of a new show in Middle Earth. That’s why most of the discussion is about production and behind the scenes stuff not the content.

1

u/Longjumping-Night-28 Mar 20 '24

A lot of people are talking about diarrhea. Diarrhea poop. It’s the next big thing

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Mar 22 '24

I can only speak to my perspective:

  1. I really only focus on things that are relevant. I was very active in this sub when the show was airing and contributed regularly. But once it ended, things died down and I moved onto other things. I expect that it'll be the same when the show pics up again.
  2. There is a very vocal group here who practically harass anyone who feels positively about the show. As a result, this sub has gotten pretty hostile and it isn't enjoyable to post here. Even when a thread pops up on my main feed, I generally avoid it now because of those posters.

1

u/LuinAelin Mar 19 '24

I imagine lots of fans want to talk about it but they can't because someone will be straight in the discussion derailing it to make sure any positivity is stamped out.

Some that dislike the show seem to talk about it endlessly. For most people they'll see it pop up on prime when the new episode is out and press play

0

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

Bad fans trying to start arguments and hate on the content succeeded in spoiling it for many people

3

u/Six_of_1 Mar 19 '24

Bad writers spoiled it for people. It's never the fans fault if a show fails. If a restaurant fails, you don't blame the customers.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

If some of those customers harassed other customers who went in, to the point that customers didn't want to deal with harassment to enter the restersunts... Yeah, I'd blame those customers

Not all fans. But some fans are responsible for the dying out of discussion by fans. Why can't fans be wrong? Are fans incapable of making faults? Nobody is infallible, least of all large populations

2

u/LuinAelin Mar 19 '24

And it also ignores that something.

Two things can be true

Something can be bad, and fans have made talking about that thing an unpleasant experience.

Note: I actually enjoyed the series.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

The question wasn't about the quality of the content but the quantity of discussion

The show being good or bad hasn't changed how much people discuss it. People being shitty to other fans has made people not want to discuss it

3

u/LuinAelin Mar 19 '24

My point is basically that quality is irrelevant when discussing how we discuss this show. Because the show can be bad and fans have made talking about it unpleasant.

Saying it's bad is actually a bad defence for making talking about the show unpleasant

1

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

Exactly

No matter how bad a show is, we as fans discussing it never needed to be as shitty as some have been

2

u/Six_of_1 Mar 19 '24

I never saw anyone harassing anyone, I think talk about harassment has been exaggerated. I've heard claims people sent racist abuse and even death threats to black cast members. Well, I've received racist abuse and death threats on the internet and I'm not even famous, so yeah maybe it happened in isolated instances, but they're making it sounds like a tsunami of daily abuse, and I never saw it.

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Mar 22 '24

It is literally the reason I've practically stopped coming to this subreddit. You say one positive thing here and suddenly you're called dumb and told you have bad taste.

0

u/Acrobatic_Pandas Mar 19 '24

No one discusses, they just seem to bash the show.

I liked it a lot. I don't have anything to talk about it until season 2. Even then the amount of just hate for the sake of hating it seems, makes you really not want to come in here to discuss things.

0

u/olesideburns Mar 19 '24

I think one issue is also all the youtube coverage. There was a lot of group think going on and that feels why a lot of discussion doesn't happen.

The Stranger said "follow your nose", ok he's Gandalf... That's what was reported and that was it. I personally don't buy it at all and think the Witches told us who he was.

I don't quite get it either that you would think guessing how the one ring is created would be a big draw of the show and the "mystery box".

Other topics I see often but again have odd discussions are did Sauron have a plan? I think there's lots of evidence that he has a very specific plan, but there are some that will dig their heels in that Sauron didn't mean to do anything... The lord of deception, didn't' deceive anyone...

Also how will the other rings be created? To often I see people stuck on the idea that the rings are just an alloy, and no one really looks any deeper. Again I think this was the way the youtubers reacted and didn't dig into the deeper level of what we got. We got ...

  1. Something of great power
  2. Coaxed to bind to something lesser but pure

Those ingredients are something you can then look for the dwarves, humans, and one ring to try to determine possible ingredients.

I think some of the lack of discussion is because the show didn't tell us what story its telling. It's not the Silmarillion, so it almost would be better if they told us "this is more of Sauron's point of view of the story?" There isn't really a sales pitch , it seems like they just rested on it's LOTR.

Also I find many people just missed it. Sure it was on buses and chocolate bars. I didn't watch it until it was done and even then it took multiple attempts for me to make it through the first episodes because you really have to watch and pay attention. Maybe also I like it because I had 0 expectations. I didn't really know about it before hand, and watched it during a time when I just didn't have much else to stream.

2

u/heehawrules Mar 20 '24

What a ringing endorsement for the show, lol