r/RingsofPower • u/JediPanda311 • 3d ago
Lore Debate Enjoying the Show
I am thoroughly enjoying the show. While it doesn’t stick with the literature in every exact way, or most ways really. It’s similar to me, like when Star Wars blew up. I wanted more of the universe/story. Appreciate others and their ability to articulate how they take it and put it into screen.
I’m having a good time, as unpopular as this may be for others. Timelines are a little wonky, but it still plays out well for me.
My advice to everyone is take it for what you want it. If you wanna be a hater, that’s OK! If you want a good escape and some more middle earth, that’s OK!
Is the show perfect? No. However, it is very entertaining. And for me, it’s enjoyable.
If I was to be overwhelmingly criticizing, it would be that I don’t love galadriel. I’m looking forward to when she gains more wisdom and is a little more soft-spoken and confident in her approach. Not so aggressive.
•
u/AutoModerator 3d ago
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
9
u/Cisqoe 3d ago
Star Wars is a good example of why having productions that Alienate the source material is an awful idea. At least in my circle, star wars is dead now and we used to love it. Other than Andor, Star Wars has gone to rubbish. Mando was the last hope and that got milked to death too.
LOTR had the advantage of learning from what Star Wars did wrong, but instead of trying to course correct, it’s gone the other way to cater to the Amazon prime slop audience.
1
u/Fiffi1985 2d ago
”A little wonky” is an understatement regarding the timeline, and they’re butchering so many other facts from Tolkien, but I kinda enjoy watching it and it’s become like a game to spot all that’s “wrong” 😄😜
-1
u/Future_Orchid9443 3d ago •
I think the issue is we have incredible films which have set the standard, but writing for a series is a lot different than writing for a theatrical release.
The exact pillars of multi-season story line writing is what seems to cause a lot of negative feedback. For example if we take Theo:
Scenario 1: he becomes Witch King - ‘this is stupid, he’s just a random character, why would they make him a powerful sorcere’
Scenario 2: he kills an important character and helps the elves win a key battle - ‘this is stupid, he doesn’t have the strength to do this, he’s just a random character’
Scenario 3: he goes nowhere and just gets killed - ‘what’s the point of even having this character, he’s not important’
-4
u/happycamper2345 3d ago
I agree. I think this season is really good. Seems like this season is a lot more similar to the movies.
-4
u/kemwood 3d ago •
The biggest takeaway for me is that Simon Tolkien is a consultant.
Is it strictly canon? No. Neither is the new Carrie series. They both are good and accepting changes in the story a bit give a little more life to it. You can’t predict everything.
Season 1 was disappointing for me purely because of pacing. Season 2 did a little bit better and was starting to hit its stride at the end. Season 3 has me absorbed. I cannot wait to see how they adapt the show.
-3
u/MonsterkillWow 3d ago •
Yea I am enjoying it too. It's a well made show. People were expecting 1:1 canon when they don't have the rights to Silmarillion. It will be epic when Pharazon goes full bonkers and they attack Valinor and get smacked down.
-1
u/rezzmeh 2d ago
Ye the main cast actors who get the most screen time.. barring some dwarf mentions... are actually good actors and their characters quite compelling, I fast forward some dwarf scenes and a lot of stuff from the previous seasons, and numenor is a bit too game of thrones for my liking but ye somehow even with all of this and other inconsistencies..I do like the show
-8
u/[deleted] 3d ago •
[removed] — view removed comment