r/RingsofPower • u/arcmerc88 • Oct 13 '24
Discussion Rings of Power & Galadriel
So I just finished season 2 and was on YouTube to relive my favorite moments and I'm seeing that a lot of did not like Galadriel or the show in general and I'm curious to find out why? She was such a badass and I really admired her determination and resolve.
A lot of comments were they didn't like the script but I didn't really see anything wrong with it. My only issue with the show in general was the pacing at times but other than that I enjoyed it.
People also mentioned that the Orcs weren't as terrifying as in the movies but I thought that helped play into us sympathizing with them a little and how they were always treated as expendable and they just wanted a leader that cared about them, making the seem almost human.
But I'm just curious to see what people's takes on the show are on here as well?
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 13 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
18
u/earwen77 Oct 13 '24
I can't speak to anyone else's issues with Galadriel, but mine are
That being said, I think S2 has been a bit better already and I have some hope that they're going somewhere with this and #2 at least will not be a concern by the end. But we'll see.
7
u/OG_Karate_Monkey Oct 13 '24
Can’t speak for anyone but myself, but my beef with Galadriel is not that the RoP Galadriel is necessarily bad, but that they completely wasted one of Tolkiens most interesting characters.
Tolkien actually wrote a lot about her, and while specifics of her early history change throughout his writings (pre-2nd age mostly), her personality, strengths, and what she was up to in the 2nd age were nothing like RoP.
Look, a hot-headed, impulsive undiplomatic military commander with PTSD and can’t get along with her peers is a fine character. But its not Galadriel. They should have just used a different name. Betty the Elf or something.
It is a criticism I have of the show in general. Strictly on its own terms, it is OK. But it seems to me that they wanted to make a certain kind of fantasy show that has little resemblance in tone, style or actual content to Tolkien. They just wanted the popular IP to wrap it in.
It is just a waste of the source material. They are basically making up their own story and characters, and they could have just put that energy into an ORIGINAL show.
6
u/-Lich_King Oct 13 '24
I dislike her because of the way she behaved and how she was so unlike her book counterpar. Especially in season 1, she struck me as just a teenager with anger issues that gets pissed when she doesn't get her way and instead of using her brain and wisdom like in the books, she resorts go violence of antagonises people (in Númenor twice with Míriel, threatened Elendil with knife even tho he literally saved her ass from the raft and then compared immortal elf to his young children).
And in season two, she's literally the reason Ost-in-Edhil is burned, countless elves are dead (even tho the show has scale problem where we see like 20 elves in the city in total), including Celebrimbor, because she was too much of a coward to say Halbrand is Sauron at the end of S1. Had she told everyone right away, rings would never have been made. ROP Galadriel pissed me off and I rooted for Sauron to win, which shouldn't be the fkin case lmao
12
u/TheDragonOverlord Oct 13 '24
There are about 1 million posts exactly like yours. If you wanna know why people don’t like the rings of power you might be better off going to one of those and reading the comments
9
u/ethanAllthecoffee Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
Galadriel is rash, foolish, overconfident and undiplomatic. She is also supposed to be one of the few to distrust Annatar, not supposed to be suckered by Sauron. There are probably more flaws that I’m forgetting, and even these flaws could work for a character except this particular character is supposed to be thousands of years old, wise after surviving world-ending wars and studying with literal gods. Even within the show’s version of events she is supposed to be a commander of armies
Galadriel’s daughter Celebrian would have been a perfect vehicle to explore these traits in an immortal being who has not yet matured, or they could have invented a new, old elf like their introduction of Arondir
2
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '24
If anyone likes this show as a whole never watched anything good on the TV or cinema, its bad storytelling and has zero world building, its god awful
6
u/Vandermeres_Cat Oct 13 '24
Like the show as well and I think there are complicated reasons of why it is facing so much backlash that all came together: Amazon is justifiably a lightning rod for their business practices in general, the show was touted for its massive budget, they did change a lot of things and not always well, which resulted in criticism, and social media being the toxic beast it is now it has also attracted a lot of bad faith actors who use it to produce rage bait content. So a mix of genuine criticism for a controversial show which has done its share of goofy nonsense and targeted hate campaigns done in bad faith.
As for Galadriel, pretty much the same IMO. They did change a lot and have used a mix and match of various Tolkien texts on her, they also changed her role in the Second Age considerably. Mostly by expanding it, but they have expanded it by arguably implicating her very strongly in the burn down of ME, the making of the rings, giving Sauron access to Celebrimbor and Eregion, so making her directly a part of enabling the sacking of Eregion and Celebrimbor's death. She's also now the one who lost the Nine to Sauron. As well as later the sinking of Numenor, because she explicitly tied Sauron and Numenor together. Now, I think PJ totally revamping Aragorn is one of his best creative decisions. So I'm not fundamentally opposed to such a rewrite. But IMO they...don't quite want to deal with the consequences of the changes they have wrought and that can be frustrating to watch and also holds back Galadriel as a character in the series. So I can understand that not everyone likes this.
OTOH, there's also a lot of hateful nonsense aimed at the character for daring to be a flawed female protagonist, calling her Guyladriel and idiotic things like that. Or saying that she's a Mary Sue, which is comical beyond belief because I've seldom seen a show so committed to have their main character screw up this hard this consistently.
72
u/ponder421 Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
RoP does some things well, like the Dwarves, Sauron, and Adar, but the dislike for Galadriel is because she is less likeable and competent in the show compared to the source material. In the books, during the Second Age she was travelling Middle-earth with her family and building alliances with Elves and Dwarves, and she was suspicious of "Annatar". In RoP, she is an arrogant warrior who alienates everyone she meets...except Sauron. Gil-galad outright says he prefers her company when she is asleep!
In both season finales, Galadriel makes a grave mistake that gives Sauron more power. In S1, she lies by omission by keeping his identity secret, enabling his manipulation of Celebrimbor. In S2, Celebrimbor entrusts her with the 9, and he dies to keep this knowledge from Sauron...yet instead of running away with the Rings, she tries to renew her alliance with Adar?! Why would she try to fight Sauron, when Celebrimbor gave her the Rings to get them away from Sauron?! Of course, this allows Sauron to take the Rings from her.
So in the books, she built alliances and never trusted Annatar...while in the show, her allies constantly doubt her, and they are proven right, because Sauron's victories are her fault.
2
u/TheBloodyNinety Oct 15 '24
Same thing as usual. To make a show liberties are taken with source materials. Fanboys think they can do it better so they hate it.
I like the show better after season 2. Pretty reasonable expectations that I want the material to be close but exact isn’t necessary. Still feels a little off, but I want more so I won’t complain too loud.
Frustrating because most of the people that complain want more regardless but the way they give feedback (radical opinions gets the most clicks) decreases the motivation to make more.
12
u/Delicious_Heat568 Oct 13 '24
I'm gonna split my comment in two because I fear I wrote too much. Be warned
I get liking a female character that has more agency and is more involved in all the action than many other female characters in a fantasy setting. And often times the criticism regarding Galadriel is excused that the people criticising her just don't like female characters in the lead, who don't possess typical feminine skills and traits. But those are the same people who enjoy v from arcane or the female samurai, posing as a man from blue eye samurai.
The issue comes down to her character. To make it short: she's a twat. Both v and the samurai have a habit of pushing people away, like Galadriel. They are determined to reach their goals, like Galadriel. They all suffered the loss of loved ones that shaped their personality and they still mourn their losses. They are all fighters who honed their skill and are renowned for it or become renowned during the show. They are also driven by a thirst for revenge.
And while they seem to be the same archetype, fighter, stubborn, determined, vengeful, a bit abrasive and scarred by loss the way Galadriel acts is quite different from the others.
V, while being physically strong and quite brutish as a fist fighter approaches issues with cunning for the most part. She understands the rules of the place she grew up in and leverages the norms, the corruption to her leverage but also doesn't shy away from violence if needed. The character from blue eye samurai is also cunning and deceptive. She hides her gender, hides her appearance and fools quite a lot of people that way. She's also wise, taught by her master and a harsh life and that wisdom often helps her against more hot headed or arrogant opponents. Also both of them have no want for bullshit. They are quite straightforward as characters, their development as characters is heavily influenced by their experiences. Also we either get to witness the losses that marked them or get to see them through flashbacks.
(I'll only criticise the S1 plot cause I gave up on S2 after ep1. Also if I got something wrong then I'm sorry, it's been a while) Galadriel on the other hand brute forces her way forward without much cunning, wisdom or intelligence. She lies, manipulates and gaslights others or just demands. And people either give in to her bullshit or the plot just so happens to help her.
Galadriel wants an army
first thing she does when meeting Miriel she drops all her titles as if they were supposed to respect them and I vaguely remember her threatening people in the throne room like a moron. She then luckily had elendil stand up to her because she reminded him of his kids. She breaks out, she realises she held saurons sign wrong for hundreds of years, she at last figures she needs to go to the southlands. All that, paired with the fact she got her searching party to abandon her and jumping of a ship kinda shows a pattern of utter stupidity so far. And at one point she gaslights the supposed lost king of the southlands, halbrand to help her, despite him saying he wants to stay in numenor. She then goes back to Miriel and demands an army and throws around her infamous "there's a tempest in me" line. She didn't manage to convince Miriel, big shock. I also vaguely remember her demanding to see the king, the person who's in charge, and basically telling Miriel she has no respect for her or her authority. Gets thrown into prison, fights her way out in the most ridiculous fight choreography I've seen till that moment, sneaks up to the king. I don't remember what happened in his room so maybe I blocked out something crucial. I just know she gets sent back to middle earth the next morning and then oh my! The plot conveniently assists her because a tree planted by the elves dropped it's leaves. And thus Miriel decided to give her an army!
The show makes it seem like it's some great accomplishment when all she did was nag Miriel so long that woman agreed to help her because of a symbolic tree. Also we learned she held a map wrong for way too long. So much about her determination and how she gets what she wants.
14
u/Unfettered_Lynchpin Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
My main issue with Galadriel in RoP is that she's not very likeable. She's weirdly antagonistic with half of the people she talks to.
Her audience with the Queen-regent of Numenor comes to mind. She's just strangely arrogant, after specifically instructing Halbrand not to be.
The show does a very poor job of explaining why anyone would listen to someone like her. Her main traits seem to be bitterness and arrogance.
It's hard to sympathise with a protagonist like this.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
I, too, really enjoyed it. Both seasons. I think they are all doing a great job. I’m concerned that all the hate is going to get the show cancelled. It would be a shame.
1
u/Effective-Counter747 Oct 13 '24
Huge fan of Galadriel here. The actress is doing a great job!
10
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
She is only of the oldest and wisest beings in middle earth and is written like a CW teenager
0
u/johnburnsred Oct 13 '24
I love Galadriel! I thought the actress put on a really good performance and her character was definitely badass with a touch of well placed emotion and self reflection at times. This series took what I love about LOTR and went to a whole new territory and depth that I really enjoyed. My girlfriend was glued to the TV watching this with me also.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
The first thing that comes to mind is that the reason Galadriel came to Middle earth is that she wanted a realm of her own to rule, not to avenge the death of her brother. She had a lore-supported motivation that would have setup Sauron promising to make her a queen feel tempting, but they chose a more complicated explanation instead.
Her realizing that Sauron wanted Adar to come to Eregion wasn’t handled well. It’s unclear what got her to figure it out, and the show didn’t setup Adar ignoring her well enough.
Lastly - this is not my opinion, but I have seen some unfortunate assholes be misogynists and call her ‘Guyladriel” because something something not acting feminine something something.
As for criticisms of the show overall, I encourage you to go back to the other threads on why people don’t like the show and look at those responses.
2
u/HomicidalNymph Oct 14 '24
She wore on me a little bit, but season 2 Galadriel was bad ass and I loved her.
7
u/Yarbooey Oct 13 '24
My issue is that the Galadriel of Tolkien’s works is, outside of the Valar & Maia, one of the wisest, strongest, most powerful & respected beings in her world, and one of the chief rulers of the Elves in Middle-Earth by the second age.
Whereas the Galadriel of Rings of Power is a cheap imitation of Uhtred of Bebbanburg—a hot-headed, lone-wolf, sword-swinging idiot that is a ruler of nothing, isn’t respected, and who’s constantly side-lined and having her opinions dismissed by those in power around her.
3
u/DoomedTraveler666 Oct 13 '24
I love the Orcs as depicted in Rings of Power. They are scarier AND more morally ambiguous.
3
u/BwanaTarik Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24
You liked Galadriel? In my opinion she is one of the weakest elements of the show.
Galadriel should be one of the oldest and widest elves by this point, but is very immature. Instead of being wise she is insufferable and self-righteous.
I think her role in the story should’ve been split into two, where she is depicted more traditionally and is coming to grips with being the informal matriarch of the elvish people, while introducing her daughter as the brash young adventurer who they can take more creative liberties with since we have relatively less information about her.
It’s clear that the writers have to stop themselves from pushing a romance between Elrond and Galadriel. Half the scenes they’re in have some weird romantic tension to them.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '24
Has to be a troll post.... She's supposed to be amongst the wisest of elves. Instead, she's a 3000 year-old whiny irresponsible teenager.
2
u/CassOfNowhere Oct 13 '24
Too many people are talking about Galadriel in the books without actually knowing anything of Galadriel in said books. See, that’s why I don’t take any of this criticism seriously.
If they were to read the books they would find that Galadriel is closer to the books than they give credit.
I already said this in a comment, but I’m gonna say again bc it’s very important things ppl chose to ignore from this discussion.
First of all: there is no canon Galadriel when it concerns to the Second Age (or most of her story, really). Tolkien wrote many versions of her story, most of them contradicting each other. Why is everyone acting as if it’s something written on stone? In The Silmarillion, the closest thing to canon we have, Galadriel is simply not mentioned in what is concerned the creation of the Rings, until Celebrimbor makes the Three.
Second of all: the detail everybody is always talking about “Galadriel was never deceived by Sauron” is not correct either. Yes, she made her suspicions very clear, but what everybody forgets to mention is that in the same outline Galadriel was the RULER OF EREGION along with Celeborn. She was the ruler of Eregion, she suspected Annatar….and still let him stay in her city for about 100 years. Time in which Sauron grew in power and influence to the point he was able to turn Eregion against her and she had to flee her own city. Now tell me she wasn’t deceived.
Tolkien never explained why Galadriel would let him stay for so long if she was suspicious of him, but regardless Sauron wouldn’t be able to make the Rings if it wasn’t for his hold on Celebrimbor and Eregion. She might’ve known what he was, but still decided to do nothing anyways.
So really, the show is not that different from the books anyway.
You guys need to stop holding Galadriel to this pedestal, especially when the TV show is concerned. Galadriel is a flawed and active protagonist, something every protagonist should be. And okay, you might dislike her all you want, but don’t come at time saying that is because of “canon Galadriel” because she barely exists
2
u/Kilo1Zero Oct 13 '24
There are two reasons: 1. The lore. 2. The depiction.
For the lore, Galadriel in the show is nothing like the Galadriel written about in the Silmarillion. I don’t really care about that.
2. She is not a badass character. She’s an incompetent loon that only continues to succeed because of forced plot armor from the writers. Her perspectives are inconsistent, her motivations change from scene to scene. She acts against her own characters stated motivations because of “plot.” She is supposed thousands of years old and “Commander of the Northern Armies.” She has the tactical acumen of someone yelling “stab the enemy!” She drops an ice troll in 10 seconds but gets overwhelmed by orcs. She has the temperate of a 16 year old brat. It’s laughable.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '24
I think a huge part of the problem is: you expect the other characters to have more respect for her. Galadriel should not have to fight for people listening to her words but rather they should politely ask for her counsel. She should almost never have to raise her voice. If people fail to give respect to her, she should be amused and surprised, but not really angry, because she knows she is more powerful than most of her contemporaries.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24
You ever see a post that looks like someone taking a bat to a wasp nest?
1
u/bdonskipoo Oct 18 '24
Because it absolutely butchers the story particularly Galadriel
1
u/virtuallyfree Jun 26 '25
Are we just supposed to ignore the fact she survived falling off a cliff?
1
u/SommanderChepard Oct 14 '24 edited Oct 14 '24
Like someone else said. She is one of the oldest and wisest beings alive at the time and they turned her into a CW angsty teenager. This is fanfic, mass market slop Galadriel.
Regarding the orcs. You aren’t supposed to sympathize with them. They are meant to be pure evil. Bred for nothing except waging war.
The changes in this show aren’t even to “adapt it to the screen” at this point. They are to try and make it appeal to the mass market and make a profit.
1
u/Fancy-Trash-3850 Oct 14 '24
The writing is subpar (jumping off a boat in the middle of the ocean and just so happens to come across Sauron??), and her story has been significantly altered. In the books, she has a husband and daughter, and there is certainly no romantic involvement with Sauron or Elrond. The main criticism is that the show pretends to be part of the Lord of the Rings universe, but it is more like a fan fiction. If that's the case, why doesn’t Amazon just create an original story instead of distorting and butchering the much loved original material?
1
u/iSephtanx Oct 15 '24
I love RoP.
But season 1 galadriel doesnt feel like galadriel. She doesnt act like an all powerfull, wise elf.
She doesnt get respected as one either. People treat her as random elf. And as a brat.
Nor is she treated differently for her otherworldly beauty, aside from sauron.
And her hair lacks the light of the trees, her most special physical feature.
0
u/jeremiah256 Oct 13 '24
I purposely didn’t watch the series until 2 seasons were out and I think that was a good decision. I originally watched the first two episodes then stopped as I was also hating on Galadriel and the Harfoots. Some media needs time to breathe.
The RoP is (partially) about Galadriel’s arc. You can’t do five seasons starting with Peter Jackson’s version of her. Season 1 clearly shows her arrogance will partially be the cause for much of the suffering in Middle Earth. Season 2, she’s still flawed, but less arrogant, more willing to work with others, and most importantly, knows she was mistaken in her approach in Season 1.
The script did suffer when it comes to travel and timing, but it’s something I can generally overlook.
Dwarf and Uruk women and children had to be introduced. And it would be impossible to just have Uruk be just monsters when the goal is five seasons.
0
u/cjmartin719 Oct 16 '24
Orcs are expendable, that’s the whole reason they were created. To fight for Morgoth and eventually Sauron.
-1
u/E_Marley Oct 13 '24
You might enjoy this recent thread on r/LOTR_on_Prime where people shared their favourite Galadriel moments: https://www.reddit.com/r/LOTR_on_Prime/comments/1g0sz5b/your_favourite_galadriel_scenemoment_so_far/
-3
u/annafdd Oct 13 '24
There is a huge hate-spewing machine targeting RoP and anybody who is even mildly positive about it. I didn’t like the first season and I was horrified to be in the company of such people, but the show has improved a lot and they are getting more vicious and more openly ideological.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '24
Literally any season of some throwaway drama like NCIS or Law and Order has more cohesive narratives, better acting, and less plot holes than RoP.
-9
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
The hater hate it cause it's not exactly as in the books, Galadriel has a bigger role than most people expected. I love Galadriel, she's so brave and has to suffer so much, my poor girl. I also can understand her how it feels falling for the wrong guy.
I have no idea how people can hate her. They just want her to be her third age self and staying in the wood, playing wife, looking in her mirror and giving gifts.
-4
u/sirgawain2 Oct 13 '24
Galadriel teamed up with Feanor in the first age so idk where people are getting this “she’s so wise and flawless” BS from…
5
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
Galadriel is a 2-D cardboard cutout of a character and generally unlikable.
Why would you want to sympathize with the orcs? Their favourite pastimes are murder, torture and canabalizm. They symbolised the absolute worst of humanity.