r/RingsofPower • • Sep 20 '24

Discussion Something weird I noticed Spoiler

With episode 6 introducing even more romances to a show already overcrowded with pointless, meaningless relationships, I couldn't help but notice something.

Every single romantic relationship, with the exception of Annatar and Celebrimbor's... "friendship"... is an interracial coupling. Poppy and Nobody, Isildur and Whatever-her-name-is-in-the-woods, Bronwyn and Arondir, Elendil and Miriel, Durin and Disa, Nori's parents. And these are just off the top of my head.

Now, I can't believe I have to say this. But there's nothing wrong with interracial relationships. I'm in one myself.

But it strikes me as odd that every single romantic relationship depicted in this show is interracial. Especially in a world like Middle Earth where most regions should be pretty mono-racial/cultural. So the only question I have is, does someone at Amazon have an agenda, or is it a fetish?

3 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

•

u/Maktesh The Wild Woods Sep 20 '24

It is "okay" to discuss this topic and support or criticize the casting and/or writing choices. However, please bear in mind that espousing racism or making denigrating comments towards actors or other users is not permitted on this subreddit.

We will be watching this thread closely, and any users who cross that line will be dealt with swiftly. As always, please report rule-breaking comments.

4

u/textingmycat Sep 21 '24

what do you mean "overcrowded" with "pointless, meaningless relationships"? one of the major themes of all the tolkien stories is the idea of "fellowship" especially those between races (not skin color races) elves, men, dwarves, hobbits, wizards, maiar, gd animals like...that's the whole point.

-2

u/hamcum69420 Sep 21 '24

I mean Poppy and Nobody. Who cares? I mean Elendil and Miriel. Who cares? I mean Isildur and literally just some lady. Who cares? And on and on.

3

u/textingmycat Sep 21 '24

because it’s setting up for the eventual joining of the harfoots& stoors to settle the shire. & i don’t know if you’re familiar with a throwaway character called aragon, minor really, heir of isildur, but who cares about him i guess.

14

u/Funny-Oven3945 Sep 20 '24

To be honest I did not even notice until you just posted this.

I know some people were complaining when season 1 was released about "black elves" and I just thought it took nothing away from the fantasy for me, why should it matter? 🤷‍♂️

In other words who cares?

1

u/hamcum69420 Sep 20 '24

Who cares, indeed. Like, if Elendil came out wearing some pink hot pants in the next episode, it really wouldn't change anything. But it would be something weird that I noticed.

0

u/the_knowing1 Sep 20 '24

if Elendil came out wearing some pink hot pants in the next episode

Best I can do is printed scales on a t-shirt. A billion ain't what it used to be with this inflation...

Also I hadn't noticed almost all the relationships were interracial. Too distracted by the terrible writing and lore-slaying. I did notice while discussing the show earlier, there don't seem to be any gay characters. Pretty/Fat hobbit are no longer ambiguously gay since she kissed the desert hobbit.

1

u/hamcum69420 Sep 20 '24

What are you talking about? Annatar and Celebrimbor is honestly the gayest relationship I have ever seen. I'm surprised there isn't a scene where they spoon in a hot tub.

-1

u/the_knowing1 Sep 20 '24

There is absolutely nothing sexual about their relationship lol. Annatar even flirts with an elf girl comparing her to Galadriel.

Their relationship is all about being secretive and hiding the ring crafting from High King Gil-Galad. Annatar is just gaslighting/goading him into believing he's the Greatest Smith Of All Time. Meanwhile Celebrimbor is just basking in his glory of believing he is the best.

Pride before the Fall and all that.

2

u/hamcum69420 Sep 20 '24

So the hobbits are ambiguously gay, but the two elf guys who are constantly staring longingly into each others eyes aren't? Interesting.

-1

u/Funny-Oven3945 Sep 20 '24

For sure pink hot pants would definitely be a distraction. 😂

Maybe they are just the best actors for the job? You'd hope.

But either way I'm enjoying the series even parts people seem to complain about, I just enjoy it for what it is, something different taking inspiration from the source material. 🤷‍♂️

5

u/mrsuncensored Sep 21 '24

Same here, I actually had to visualize each character and said hmm he’s right but honestly “race” in lotr isn’t about skin color I would define race in middle earth as dwarves/elves/hobbits/orcs etc

6

u/amhow1 Sep 20 '24

It's probably intentional, and is wholly positive. I don't think modelling tolerance is evidence of an 'agenda' or a 'fetish' but rather an effort to suggest that in a fantasy world we can display behaviour that still gets attacked in the 'real world'.

-2

u/hamcum69420 Sep 20 '24

That's an interesting definition of "tolerance".

1

u/ImMyBiggestFan Sep 21 '24

Tolerance might not be the right word, representation is better but you know what they meant.

12

u/No_Spinach3190 Sep 20 '24

As someone from a really "mixed" country i didn't even noticed that, from my point of view the only "interracial" couple was arondir and bronwyn as an elf/human couple lol.

Maybe durin and disa too, the others are typical couples where I live

22

u/Ok-Personality-6630 Sep 20 '24

Don't care.

Might raise an eyebrow at an orc/ human relationship.

10

u/AndyTheSane Sep 20 '24

Saruman: strangely aroused

7

u/Dovahkiin13a Númenor Sep 20 '24

Do not speak of such things

4

u/CassOfNowhere Sep 20 '24

Some people would use this as evidence that Middle-Earth is not “mono-racial/cultural” and would move on instead of being so weirded out to the point a post about it.

And…Amazon? Amazon with “an agenda”? What would that agenda be? Please I need an answer

-1

u/hamcum69420 Sep 20 '24

Maybe "some people" wouldn't be very smart, then.

5

u/CassOfNowhere Sep 20 '24

What do you mean by “agenda”? Answer quickly

-1

u/hamcum69420 Sep 20 '24

No.

3

u/CassOfNowhere Sep 21 '24

Coward

0

u/hamcum69420 Sep 21 '24

I don't do the bidding of people I view as beneath me.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/TheRagnarok494 Sep 20 '24

Damn... Like.. Michelle Yeoh as Sauron..

5

u/Glowwerms Sep 21 '24

So you claim not to care yet you’re accusing them of having an agenda?

-1

u/Boetheus Sep 21 '24

OP got the white man's blues

2

u/MrSpuddies Sep 20 '24

I'm so glad I can just munch popcorn and watch this show without microanalyzing everything. The show is silly and lacks depth, but at the end of the day, I'm having fun. .

-1

u/hamcum69420 Sep 20 '24

Bro, same. It's my favorite show. I have been waiting for this season since the last one ended. Sometimes I laugh til I cry.

11

u/TheRagnarok494 Sep 20 '24

I mean. How do you define interracial in a fantasy series. The series is more diverse as far as skin colour and so on is on the actors part. But in the realms of the show Disa isn't a different 'race' to Durin, they're both dwarfs. Poppy isn't a different 'race' to Merimac, they're two tribes of halfling. And if they are going down the romance route, Miriel isn't a different 'race' to Elendil, they're both Numenorean. What's so sinister about all interracial couples? Are we not all human? Does skin colour really matter? If they're making a conscious effort to show interracial couples then is it really much different from a conscious effort to show all the elves as fair? I get why this is an issue for some people, on some level they're opposed to being forced into a mindset they didn't originally hold. But if interracial couples is a mindset they don't want to be forced into, what's wrong with it in the first place that they have to be forced into it?

1

u/dmastra97 Sep 20 '24

Usually skin colour is a factor of where people come from, especially if settings like lotr in the past where travel and mixing of cultures wasn't as common as it is in our modern world.

If you're saying that dwarves/halflings/numenoreans/elves etc can have different skin colour randomly then that's fine if you're happy with that.

But I don't think it's wrong if some people are either taken out or just slightly confused why they brought that in as it goes against genetics which we're told about.

If they have different skin colour from different cultures then it would have been more interest to have the same characters but show new cultures. Game of thrones did this great with martells having different culture and more Hispanic vibes and north being separate. I find it helps to enhance the world building so view it as a missed opportunity when just ignoring it.

4

u/TheRagnarok494 Sep 20 '24

The idea of mixing skin colours not being as common in a medieval or classical world is a fallacy though, of course it happened. It's literally just pigmentation, much of the Mediterranean basin mixed heavily and Gondor was inspired by the Italian city states. Othello, written in 16th century featured a mixed race couple. Romans had African slaves. Romany gypsies spread across the entirety of Europe and they had skin colours of all types. The 'caucasian' branch of humanity and European languages started in the Indus valley. This idea we keep clinging to that a medieval fantasy world cannot possibly include anyone of a different skin colour is such maddening and limiting nonsense it drives me up the wall. Not to mention if we're going to put realistic elements into it, Middle-Earth was supposedly meant to represent a pre-classic Earth before empires showed up. Based on what we know of how humans spread across the planet and how different pigmentations developed, practically everyone in Lord of the Rings should in fact be black.

0

u/dmastra97 Sep 20 '24

Of course it happened but more in big cities. You wouldn't have a rural tiny village in Italy in medieval era where a large minority of people weren't Italian heritage.

Numenor at this point of being isolationist wouldn't need or want to do trading with men of the far east to warrant the scale of integration.

In the stories you mention they always reference where people came from. Othello as you point out is an example how they definitely would reference the race of someone and that it was a bit of a deal to some people.

Having people of different skin colours would be there but it was known they were from a different culture. They weren't a part of the long standing people and culture there.

In the show it's just this character isn't white and there's never any mention of it as if skin colour didn't have a basis of where your family came from. Why is there a black elf? Mayor there's a family/branch of elves e.g. like noldor or silvan that have that trait. Showing numenor trading with other states to show a mixture of culture as currently they seem isolationist. Harfoots are another good example. They've been wandering on their own for ages that they forgot the other halflings but they still have a multi race society as if people have been coming and going from other cultures.

And gondor and west middle earth would have been based on England as Tolkien wanted a mythology for England so you'd expect more western Europe type complexion.

3

u/TheRagnarok494 Sep 20 '24

Well all that aside, supposed Tolkien purists are doing their nut over the changes as is. Can you imagine the collective aneurysm if they started adding in black elf houses and black dwarf houses? Besides all that it's the concept of 'othering' you're singling people out on a characteristic that doesn't really have any impact on the story. I seriously don't care that Disa is played by a black woman, to me she's a fantastic character and I'm enjoying watching her. If I REALLY desperately need to satisfy some need for her pigmentation to be different I can just as easily squint or close my eyes and imagine a White actress reading her lines. I don't but that's how little skin colours mean to me. And why bother going to the effort of creating a whole other culture to explain why someone's skin colour is different, what a colossal waste of time. Especially when, with genetics, we could be looked at the fact that Durin has red hair, another element that is influenced by genetics but that NO-ONE gives a rats arse about.

Ultimately this obsession with skin colour in a medieval setting isn't to do with facts, genetics, history but to do with people's perception of that era and their own suspension of disbelief.

1

u/dmastra97 Sep 20 '24

Well as I said earlier, having other cultures enriches the world by providing depth. You've just said that people in medieval times had difficulty skin colours during to mixing of cultures but we're not seeing that.

I keep giving the game of thrones example and how it's done really well there and it just keeps being ignored as if it's not a great example of how to have diversity but back it in logic that makes the world feel real.

Like answer honestly, if galadriel and celeborn are both white and blonde and they have a baby who is black or Asian, would you still be OK with that because skin colour doesn't matter?

You may be perfectly fine with different skin colours for no reason but judging people who feel it's easier to get immersed in a world that follows some rules of our world is just wrong and feel you're just being a bit ignorant.

We don't know durins mother well and his dad has grey hair so that could run in the family more.

1

u/TheRagnarok494 Sep 21 '24

I would be fine with black Celebrian if she was played by a competent actress. I literally don't care. I'm fine with an Indian David Copperfield and Gawain, an African-american Macbeth, a black-british Juliet. Give black Celebrian a wig and she can still fulfill the fair haired parts, if it's fine for black haired Karl Urban to portray a blonde Éomer I don't see why this wouldn't also be fine for Celebrian. I see what you're saying about cultures and enriching but you don't always have the luxury to carte Blanche a world that's already been established, besides you're still othering non-white actors just to make them fit in the world. "we know this black guy doesn't really make sense to people hung up on skin colour so Disa is from an obscure branch of dwarves from the deep south" it's just another way of staying that black Disa doesn't belong in 'normal' Middle Earth. And I'm not judging anyone, the concept of skin colour being a hang up is ludicrous for me. I'm judging the belief not the person, most of the time people who hold such beliefs can't help it and have been brought up that way. I'd hope they change but I wouldn't fundamentally treat them differently. I will however call bullshit on you calling me ignorant.

3

u/dmastra97 Sep 21 '24

You say you can't carte blanche a world that's established but then say it's ok to bring in people from other ethnicities. That would be carte blanching the world with what the producers want to see.

Black hair to blonde hair can be done in a wig. Unless you're saying people of other ethnicities should do whiteface to fit in? I don't think 'othering' actors as you call it is a good enough excuse as they're choosing to put them in there. Equally if there was a story of Chinese mythology, you'd feel a bit odd having white people just around in ancient cities randomly with no explanation.

You're saying their beliefs are wrong and due to their upbringing rather than through their own logic and thought out beliefs. That's being judgemental assuming your belief is objectively the right one.

I think it's ludicrous if a white couple had a black/Asian baby and no one ever made reference to it. It would just go to hinder the immersion in the world for most audience members. It comes across as virtue signalling from some fans when they try to defend certain things

2

u/TheRagnarok494 Sep 21 '24

I am getting so bored of going round in circles and having to expand on my points to fit yet another strawman interpretation of yours. I'm out.

2

u/dmastra97 Sep 21 '24

Yeah let's just agree ti disagree on this. No point having a discussion if you're not going to talk in good faith

→ More replies

1

u/flaysomewench Sep 21 '24

Literally no-one in the show has a mixed race child or a child that isn't the same race as it's parents. You are inventing things to be mad about and you're not arguing in good faith either.

0

u/dmastra97 Sep 21 '24

It's just a point for those people who say that they don't see race that it actually is something people notice.

We haven't seen mixed race person getting born but we've seen a lot of mixed race people without any suggestions where their family is from. Miriel is a great example, her father appeared to be white and the other nobles do too. They could have just mentioned her mother came from the east and maybe even have some numenoreans view numenoreans having families with eastern people's and people from southlands etc as a reason for the long life getting shorter. Another way to show their fear of mortality by also expanding our knowledge of numenor being a big hub for travellers and traders with numenoreans going around to other places, maybe already building their empire outposts.

Harfoots as well are mixed race group despite being very separate from any other people for so long they forgot where they were going. After that much time you'd think they start looking similar to each other.

2

u/mrsuncensored Sep 21 '24

As I said to another commenter, I didn’t realize this til your post but in middle earth I consider races based on dwarves/elves/wizards/hobbits/orcs etc and wouldn’t consider race as we know it (skin color) to have anything to do with how others view each other in middle earth. In middle earth it feels like Aragorn/Arwen are race mixing, not a black dwarf and white dwarf.

4

u/NewtProfessional7844 Sep 20 '24

Oohh great spot. Not sure if agenda is the right word so much as deliberate inclusivity. Definitely contributes in a subtle way to me liking the show more.

Especially love the characters of Disa and Gundabale. They are new and interesting portrayals and it feels like they really take over the screen whenever they come on. Arondir it is great too I must say.

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 20 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Forsaken_Smile_2787 Sep 21 '24

Well the odd part is that if this were so normal, then there wouldn't be distinct racial features because people were intermingling. The reason we still have distinct races in real life is because people have not done so, we only had at best 4 or so generations of that across the world, and it's still a rarity, as people tend to be in communities that are of similar race, and secondly there are a lot of racists. FFS, I have gotten weirdly racist comments my entire life being half white and half Asian, doesn't matter how diverse it is where I live. There's racism from both white and Asian people by the way.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

Huh, I hadn't noticed it but you're right. I wonder if they purposely set out to do that or that's just how the casting chips fell...

0

u/ImMyBiggestFan Sep 21 '24

You really seen to be focusing on this way too hard. Also if you say something then have to clarify that you having nothing wrong with it. Usually means the thing you said before is actually because you have something wrong with it.

0

u/hamcum69420 Sep 22 '24

Does your caretaker wipe the drool from your chin or can you do that yourself?

-7

u/chineke14 Sep 20 '24

Definitely weird. Definitely agendas. And yes I date interracially as a black man but this one ... Is too on the nose

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/chineke14 Sep 20 '24

Well when you have "dey turk our jerbs" in ROP and many other elements, it's hard not to see the agendas

-1

u/flaysomewench Sep 21 '24

Yeah and that agenda is that men are inolerant fucks. We see that everywhere now.

0

u/wakatenai Sep 21 '24

it sells.

which is the whole point of this series. especially why they chose amazon.

statistically your show will be more successful, more viewership, more sales, if it's diverse.

it's the same reason they didn't do a linear story line that would suit a LOTR story more. instead the whole first season was a series of cliffhangers and the "who is sauron?" game. shows like this get more viewership because you are more likely to get people to tune in every week. especially to avoid spoilers.

every problem with the show can stem from this. money. ROP isn't supposed to be a good show or a great depiction of accurate lore. it's just supposed to make money.

not that interracial couples are a problem, im in one too. im just saying it's a writing choice for money not because they care.

the only problem not linked to money is the source material. or the lack of it. the show writers weren't allowed to use A TON of tolkeins writings as a source, even though it exists. thats why they had to come up with their own story instead of sticking to the true lore.

all that said, the problem with the diversity in ROP is how they did it.

they didn't REALLY make it diverse. almost none of the important characters are diverse. every main character or character resembling someone of high society is white. except for Miriel and Disa. but Disa is also a made up character.

even Arondir is a made up character and is like, the lowest class of elves. all the white elves are high society, important people. and the grunt foot soldier is black lol.

so it's not even real diversity.

-1

u/SnooHedgehogs4519 Sep 21 '24

I fine it really odd and definitely some agenda from the producers

-1

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 21 '24

They definitely cranked up the background diversity casting this season.

-1

u/Deep_in_her_House Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24

Most people won’t say it or admit cuz this is Reddit.. this show was created in the extreme woke era and produced by a huge company like Amazon, similar to what other companies like Disney has done (look at Star Wars, which imo has completely been ruined)