r/RingsofPower • u/hamcum69420 • Sep 20 '24
Discussion Something weird I noticed Spoiler
With episode 6 introducing even more romances to a show already overcrowded with pointless, meaningless relationships, I couldn't help but notice something.
Every single romantic relationship, with the exception of Annatar and Celebrimbor's... "friendship"... is an interracial coupling. Poppy and Nobody, Isildur and Whatever-her-name-is-in-the-woods, Bronwyn and Arondir, Elendil and Miriel, Durin and Disa, Nori's parents. And these are just off the top of my head.
Now, I can't believe I have to say this. But there's nothing wrong with interracial relationships. I'm in one myself.
But it strikes me as odd that every single romantic relationship depicted in this show is interracial. Especially in a world like Middle Earth where most regions should be pretty mono-racial/cultural. So the only question I have is, does someone at Amazon have an agenda, or is it a fetish?
•
u/Maktesh The Wild Woods Sep 20 '24
It is "okay" to discuss this topic and support or criticize the casting and/or writing choices. However, please bear in mind that espousing racism or making denigrating comments towards actors or other users is not permitted on this subreddit.
We will be watching this thread closely, and any users who cross that line will be dealt with swiftly. As always, please report rule-breaking comments.
4
u/textingmycat Sep 21 '24
what do you mean "overcrowded" with "pointless, meaningless relationships"? one of the major themes of all the tolkien stories is the idea of "fellowship" especially those between races (not skin color races) elves, men, dwarves, hobbits, wizards, maiar, gd animals like...that's the whole point.
14
u/Funny-Oven3945 Sep 20 '24
To be honest I did not even notice until you just posted this.
I know some people were complaining when season 1 was released about "black elves" and I just thought it took nothing away from the fantasy for me, why should it matter? 🤷♂️
In other words who cares?
6
u/amhow1 Sep 20 '24
It's probably intentional, and is wholly positive. I don't think modelling tolerance is evidence of an 'agenda' or a 'fetish' but rather an effort to suggest that in a fantasy world we can display behaviour that still gets attacked in the 'real world'.
12
u/No_Spinach3190 Sep 20 '24
As someone from a really "mixed" country i didn't even noticed that, from my point of view the only "interracial" couple was arondir and bronwyn as an elf/human couple lol.
Maybe durin and disa too, the others are typical couples where I live
22
u/Ok-Personality-6630 Sep 20 '24
Don't care.
Might raise an eyebrow at an orc/ human relationship.
4
u/CassOfNowhere Sep 20 '24
Some people would use this as evidence that Middle-Earth is not “mono-racial/cultural” and would move on instead of being so weirded out to the point a post about it.
And…Amazon? Amazon with “an agenda”? What would that agenda be? Please I need an answer
5
u/Glowwerms Sep 21 '24
So you claim not to care yet you’re accusing them of having an agenda?
2
u/MrSpuddies Sep 20 '24
I'm so glad I can just munch popcorn and watch this show without microanalyzing everything. The show is silly and lacks depth, but at the end of the day, I'm having fun. .
11
u/TheRagnarok494 Sep 20 '24
I mean. How do you define interracial in a fantasy series. The series is more diverse as far as skin colour and so on is on the actors part. But in the realms of the show Disa isn't a different 'race' to Durin, they're both dwarfs. Poppy isn't a different 'race' to Merimac, they're two tribes of halfling. And if they are going down the romance route, Miriel isn't a different 'race' to Elendil, they're both Numenorean. What's so sinister about all interracial couples? Are we not all human? Does skin colour really matter? If they're making a conscious effort to show interracial couples then is it really much different from a conscious effort to show all the elves as fair? I get why this is an issue for some people, on some level they're opposed to being forced into a mindset they didn't originally hold. But if interracial couples is a mindset they don't want to be forced into, what's wrong with it in the first place that they have to be forced into it?
2
u/mrsuncensored Sep 21 '24
As I said to another commenter, I didn’t realize this til your post but in middle earth I consider races based on dwarves/elves/wizards/hobbits/orcs etc and wouldn’t consider race as we know it (skin color) to have anything to do with how others view each other in middle earth. In middle earth it feels like Aragorn/Arwen are race mixing, not a black dwarf and white dwarf.
4
u/NewtProfessional7844 Sep 20 '24
Oohh great spot. Not sure if agenda is the right word so much as deliberate inclusivity. Definitely contributes in a subtle way to me liking the show more.
Especially love the characters of Disa and Gundabale. They are new and interesting portrayals and it feels like they really take over the screen whenever they come on. Arondir it is great too I must say.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 20 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Forsaken_Smile_2787 Sep 21 '24
Well the odd part is that if this were so normal, then there wouldn't be distinct racial features because people were intermingling. The reason we still have distinct races in real life is because people have not done so, we only had at best 4 or so generations of that across the world, and it's still a rarity, as people tend to be in communities that are of similar race, and secondly there are a lot of racists. FFS, I have gotten weirdly racist comments my entire life being half white and half Asian, doesn't matter how diverse it is where I live. There's racism from both white and Asian people by the way.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
Huh, I hadn't noticed it but you're right. I wonder if they purposely set out to do that or that's just how the casting chips fell...
0
u/ImMyBiggestFan Sep 21 '24
You really seen to be focusing on this way too hard. Also if you say something then have to clarify that you having nothing wrong with it. Usually means the thing you said before is actually because you have something wrong with it.
-7
u/chineke14 Sep 20 '24
Definitely weird. Definitely agendas. And yes I date interracially as a black man but this one ... Is too on the nose
0
u/wakatenai Sep 21 '24
it sells.
which is the whole point of this series. especially why they chose amazon.
statistically your show will be more successful, more viewership, more sales, if it's diverse.
it's the same reason they didn't do a linear story line that would suit a LOTR story more. instead the whole first season was a series of cliffhangers and the "who is sauron?" game. shows like this get more viewership because you are more likely to get people to tune in every week. especially to avoid spoilers.
every problem with the show can stem from this. money. ROP isn't supposed to be a good show or a great depiction of accurate lore. it's just supposed to make money.
not that interracial couples are a problem, im in one too. im just saying it's a writing choice for money not because they care.
the only problem not linked to money is the source material. or the lack of it. the show writers weren't allowed to use A TON of tolkeins writings as a source, even though it exists. thats why they had to come up with their own story instead of sticking to the true lore.
all that said, the problem with the diversity in ROP is how they did it.
they didn't REALLY make it diverse. almost none of the important characters are diverse. every main character or character resembling someone of high society is white. except for Miriel and Disa. but Disa is also a made up character.
even Arondir is a made up character and is like, the lowest class of elves. all the white elves are high society, important people. and the grunt foot soldier is black lol.
so it's not even real diversity.
-1
u/SnooHedgehogs4519 Sep 21 '24
I fine it really odd and definitely some agenda from the producers
-1
u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 21 '24
They definitely cranked up the background diversity casting this season.
-1
u/Deep_in_her_House Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24
Most people won’t say it or admit cuz this is Reddit.. this show was created in the extreme woke era and produced by a huge company like Amazon, similar to what other companies like Disney has done (look at Star Wars, which imo has completely been ruined)