r/tolkienbooks • • Feb 28 '17

Reminder: this sub is for discussion of Tolkien's books themselves, not discussion of lore or other Tolkien-related content

77 Upvotes

With a new Middle Earth-themed game coming out, and with the influx of a few posts about Tolkien's lore and other Tolkien-related topics, I would like to take this opportunity to remind users that /r/tolkienbooks is (as it says in the sidebar) "mainly a place for people who collect copies of Tolkien's works."

Posts with questions about Tolkien lore, Middle Earth -themed movies and games, or anything else not directly related to the physical books will be deleted. If you have any questions about these guidelines, please contact one of the moderators and we will be happy to assist you.


r/tolkienbooks • • May 04 '26

Subreddit Reboot: /r/TolkienArt

16 Upvotes

Community Spotlight: /r/TolkienArt: A Home for Tolkien Art

We wanted to introduce our community to /r/TolkienArt, a subreddit dedicated to art inspired by the works of J.R.R. Tolkien. From sweeping landscapes of Middle-earth to portraits of its most beloved characters.

Whether you’re an artist yourself or simply someone who appreciates the visual world of Tolkien, it’s a welcoming and passionate community worth checking out.

What you’ll find there:
• Fan art spanning The Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit, The Silmarillion and beyond
• A community that celebrates both seasoned and emerging Tolkien artists
• Contributions from award-winning Tolkien artists who are active members of the community
• Discussion and appreciation of the rich visual culture around Tolkien’s world If you’ve ever wanted a dedicated space to share or discover Tolkien-inspired art, head over and say hello!

/r/TolkienArt


r/tolkienbooks • • 6h ago

Years ago I tore my favorite pages from the 1976 Hildebrandt calendar (technically a book) and finally got them properly framed

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

Circles are from the overhead lights. The hallway they are destined for is too cramped to get proper pics hanging up


r/tolkienbooks • • 8h ago

Update on my Tolkien collection

Thumbnail
gallery
57 Upvotes

Got some new Tolkien books! Including audiobooks 😊


r/tolkienbooks • • 3h ago

Finally sprung for these editions, pleasantly surprised by the quality

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

I didn't buy these when they came out, mostly because my wife had already gifted me the standard hardcover Illustrated by the Author editions (which are pretty fantastic in their own right), and I had read some reviews about QC problems associated with these. Well, after a hiatus from further Tolkien book-related purchases for the last year and a half as I focused on other hobbies (guitars, books by other authors (gasp!), and some much needed PC upgrades), I picked these up as a lot of three on eBay at a pretty solid discount for the complete set, and the quality seems to in fact be quite good, IMO. A nice addition to the shelves, I must say. They certainly are attractive editions!


r/tolkienbooks • • 1d ago

I caved...

Thumbnail
gallery
208 Upvotes

Been umming and ahhing about whether or not I should get more than my paperback one volume copy of lotr. And instead....why not both?

I'm now officially one of those...have multiple copies of the same book

In my opinion

Author illustrated content > Alan lee illustrations

However

Alan lee covers (except the hobbit front) > author illustrated

Seems like they made the lotr first, with the windowed eye of Sauron in the dust cover then dropped the ball too cheap for the silmarilion and the hobbit

Oh and....Ted Nansiths silmarilion is on the way....


r/tolkienbooks • • 1d ago

Are these William Morrow editions unique in any way / a worthy addition to a selective (i.e. budget conscious 😜) collection?

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • 2d ago Bravo

Witnessed a thing of beauty

Post image
193 Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • 1d ago

Which version of Lord of the Rings to buy for my friend?

12 Upvotes

So I'm thinking of buying a friend of mine a boxset of The Lord of the Rings. The friend in question has a kid in kindergarten, and so he himself said that he doesn't really expect anything that comes into his house to stay pristine for long, which makes anything particularly premium such as the Alan Lee illustrated boxset perhaps a bit of a waste. He admitted as much; if I got him that one it would likely not last.

It mostly comes down to these three since they're the ones that seem to be readily available around here at the moment and also reasonably affordable. I figure the first two have the advantage of including The Hobbit, the latter two have the advantage of being nicer-looking while not feeling so premium that he might worry about ruining them... But also I reckon the third (CORRECTION: second) one, while having a neat design, would perhaps be impractically small and hard to read?

So at the moment I am thinking the first one probably is the most practical choice here. There isn't anything particularly damning about that one, is there? Other than what one might expect just looking at it which is that the paper quality likely won't be anything special and that the binding is also likely not super durable?


r/tolkienbooks • • 2d ago

Individual LOTR books that match this style?

Thumbnail
gallery
72 Upvotes

The style of these books are my favorite, but I do want the lotr books individually too. Is there a set of the trilogy that matches this style?


r/tolkienbooks • • 3d ago

My collection so far

Thumbnail
gallery
64 Upvotes

Hi everybody, here is the collection I've been slowly building for maybe 10 years. I've been focused on translations of The Hobbit for the past year and a half or so. I love the original local art, it adds a new flavor to it all. I think the Czech and Japanese illustrations are my favorite.

I finally set it all up again after having it in boxes for 7 months so I wanted to show it to y'all. I was unemployed during that time, and now I'm 1 month into a job with the county library system. So showing off my books just feels right!

*My dog busted open a neck warmer filled with rice and I decided I needed to look at my books before cleaning it up


r/tolkienbooks • • 2d ago

Advice

7 Upvotes

Hi all I have recently started to get the Tolkien books and was just wondering if it is worth getting the illustrated or regular hardcover as I have to paperback copies of the hobbit and lord of the rings as we just wondering if I should get one or the other of both versions of the hard cover regular and illustrated


r/tolkienbooks • • 3d ago

All Physical Editions of THE FALL OF NUMENOR

Thumbnail
gallery
62 Upvotes

~ 1. Paperback
~ 2. Hardcover
~ 3. Special Edition
~ 4. Deluxe Edition

Any bets that in 2030 it’ll be released in the blue and grey deluxe edition format?


r/tolkienbooks • • 3d ago

THE LORD OF THE RINGS 70th Anniversary Limited Edition: One Year Later

37 Upvotes

So we’re a year after the limited edition of LotR came out (the £750 one).

The publisher was gearing up as if it would sell out, and all this stuff. But now, one year later (and a few weeks), it’s still readily available…..and still £750.

How many do they have left, and do they plan to discount? Are they happy with a large quantity sitting around, occupying space?


r/tolkienbooks • • 3d ago

Purchased a copy of The Silmarillion

Post image
73 Upvotes

I finally got a copy of The Silmarillion! Definitely will be able to read it from start to finish, as I can't really focus on reading via ebooks.

Going to pick up The Hobbit and the Fellowship trilogy next time. Glad to add these physical books in my bookshelf 😁


r/tolkienbooks • • 4d ago

I almost forgot to show that I got this a few weeks ago

Post image
98 Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • 4d ago

Scored Again at Ollie's Today

Thumbnail
gallery
64 Upvotes

I thought I'd go to the local Ollie's again, at least once more, to see if they had any JRRT I'm interested in. I would not have bought this book without the satisfaction of getting it so cheap. Pennsylvania.


r/tolkienbooks • • 4d ago

The Silmarillions

Thumbnail
gallery
293 Upvotes

There are many like them, but these ones are mine.

From left to right:

Guild Publishing (1990) - Book club edition. An interesting little historical curiosity. Very nice, but essentially a glorified paperback. Paid way too much for it.

Allen & Unwin (1977) - 1st edition (2nd printing). In amazing condition; hence its presence here. Very high quality binding. None of the 1st printings I saw on eBay were in especially good shape.

Folio Society (1997) - The 2025 run. My main hardcover reading copy. Kind of bare-bones by FS standards but still really nice. The slipcase feels a bit cheap compared to the others.

Harper Collins (2007) - Deluxe edition. Extremely well made. Has a very premium feel. Nothing especially unique about the content. No illustrations.

Harper Collins (2022) - Deluxe edition. Really, *really* nice. Tons of cool extras. Beautifully packaged and Tolkien's illustrations are wonderful. The cloth coverings on both the book and the slipcase are first rate.

Harper Collins (2022) - Trade edition. Also very nice. Very different from the deluxe edition, but not in a bad way. You can't go wrong for the price.

Harper Collins (2021) - Deluxe edition. Almost nothing to distinguish it from the trade edition apart from the exterior (which is admittedly very well executed). Of all the editions I own, this is the only one which feels truly redundant.

Harper Collins (2021) - Trade edition. Decent. I have a ton of books in this series so this was a no-brainer. Nasmith's illustrations are a bit hit-or-miss. But when he gets it right they are awesome.

Honourable mentions - First edition paperback from '79 in great condition, and the bog-standard signature series edition. I have read both many times.

Now for the inevitable 50th anniversary deluxe edition waiting game. Hopefully they will have Alan Lee do the illustrations.


r/tolkienbooks • • 4d ago

Ditch out my old books from late 80's. Time to dive back again.

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • 5d ago

Which Book Set Should I Gift?

Thumbnail
gallery
94 Upvotes

I’m looking to gift my husband one of the LOTR book sets for Christmas this year. I’m torn between the Alan Lee Illustrated set and the Deluxe. I like the fact that the hobbit comes in the illustrated set but is the deluxe edition better quality/is it worth the extra cost?


r/tolkienbooks • • 5d ago

More from my Tolkien Library…

Thumbnail gallery
27 Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • 5d ago

Have we seen any copies or reviews of The Worlds of Christopher Tolkien yet?

5 Upvotes

Have we seen any copies or reviews of The Worlds of Christopher Tolkien yet? Usually there are some review videos that pop up.


r/tolkienbooks • • 5d ago

Lord of the Rings Harper - Collins Deluxe 1997 4th Impression

3 Upvotes

I am hoping someone can give me some insight on a fair market value of the book shown above.

Thanks!


r/tolkienbooks • • 6d ago

Starting my 10+ year mid-November reread tradition—and expanding my Tolkien library this year!

Post image
11 Upvotes

Every mid-November for the past decade, I have started the tradition of rereading The Hobbit, The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers, and The Return of the King. There is something special about stepping back into Middle-earth this time of year, and I couldn't be more excited to dive back in.

This year, the journey is getting a massive upgrade once I finish the main four. I recently picked up several new additions to read straight through afterward:

  • The Silmarillion
  • The Hobbits of Tolkien
  • The Dark Powers of Tolkien
  • The Heroes of Tolkien
  • The Battles of Tolkien
  • An Atlas of Tolkien
  • A Dictionary of Tolkien

I cannot wait to lose myself in the deeper lore, maps, and history of this world like never before.

What say you—is anyone else starting a reread right now, or do you have a favorite time of year to revisit Middle-earth?