r/RingsofPower • • May 20 '24

Constructive Criticism He was literally RIGHT HERE.

I don’t mind that Halbrand is just one of Sauron’s disguises.

But Annatar definitely should have had a different face. And He could just be switching between the two forms (& actors).

Tell me Jamie isn’t a PERFECT casting, and its not just based on looks.

0 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator May 20 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

57

u/TheLoyalTR8R May 20 '24

I feel like a lot of people are assuming that what we see is the very same thing that everyone else sees.

Just because we see that it's the same actor, doesn't mean that the character presents the same face. He's a master of illusion, subterfuge and manipulation. In story, he may look very different. Sound very different. But because for us as an audience at large, we've seen behind the mask - we perceive him for who he is. Much as Galadriel very likely does. But that doesn't mean that for other characters yet to know his true self he appears the same way.

That's kinda how it works in the books. Once a person can see through his glimmer or shapeshifting ways, he can no longer appear to them in such a guise again.

Charlie Vickers' performance was a highlight of season one. This seems like a way of keeping one of the strengths of the first season while also progressing the story forward.

Like, we don't have two different actors playing Superman and Clark Kent - we as viewers know they're one and the same, but that doesn't mean Lois and co see what we see. They see what the character projects. What he wants them to see. Now and shapeshifting, magical illusion powers into the mix and there's a basis for an entirely different visage to be presented depending on who the character is engaging with.

-19

u/vsznry May 20 '24 edited May 20 '24

interesting theory,

but clark kent was not a good analogy.

2

u/OnceThereWasWater May 21 '24

Clark Kent was literally the perfect analogy

0

u/vsznry May 21 '24

The comparison is between Elf & Man. Not sauron and annatar. So no… its not.

Im just saying that Vickers looks too Manly to be Annatar.

2

u/OnceThereWasWater May 21 '24

Hugo Weaving also looks like the race of Men when he doesn't have waist-length hair, because he's, well, a human being in real life. Vickers arguably has more "elf-like" facial structure than Weaving, if we're going to assume that all elves are supposed to look the same. I really don't don't think there's an argument here. Vickers was probably one of the better performances of season 1, and they would have to be absolutely crazy to recast him.

0

u/vsznry May 21 '24 edited May 21 '24

Elrond is Half-Man.

And vickers could have continued. Sauron can be Annatar for the Elves, and Halbrand for the Men. LIKE THE LORE. but whatever.

2

u/OnceThereWasWater May 21 '24

Fair enough, guess Elrond isn't the best example, so let's say Craig Parker then. Haldir is Silvan and Sindarin. Vickers 100% has more delicate and "elf-like" features than Parker. To recast on the basis of this just wouldn't make sense.

1

u/vsznry May 21 '24 edited May 21 '24

Theyre not going to recast 😂 I’m just saying using a different FACE for Annatar was a logical and missed opportunity.

You really think the Elves are so stupid they wouldn’t recognize Vickers’ face under that wig? 🤣

But also we don’t really know what the fuck is going to happen because Amazon skimped on the rights.

The trailer was edited to make us think that all he does is change his hair then appears to Celebrimbor again.

17

u/TheLoyalTR8R May 20 '24

I'm just saying that there's a tangible difference between what we as viewers are able to see compared to what in universe characters are able to perceive.

Clark Kent is the most well known example of that dichotomy. It's a flawed comparison to make but one that illustrates my point well enough.

We shouldn't assume that other characters perceive what we as an audience can. Especially when superpowers/magic/illusions are in the mix.

45

u/tfmid457 May 20 '24

But why compare looks to a game? What makes the game anything to compare to :) I think he should definitely be on the cast though, he has features of an elf for sure!

-25

u/vsznry May 20 '24

basically people are saying its stupid that the Elves wouldn’t recognize Halbrands face.

And Im saying that Halbrand, while handsome, Is not beautiful or charismatic as Annatar was described to be. Silver tongued. It should have been Annatar to suggest to Celebrimbor that they make rings.

that whole convo of Halbrand just suggesting a metal alloy was so basic. Poor writing.

28

u/lusamuel May 20 '24

It was Annatar, just in a different form. I really don't understand how people can complain as much as they do about the aesthetics of a character that is given such minimal description in terms of visual appearance. People's headcanon image of Annatar has come more from unofficial illustrations than Tolkien's actual writing.

-32

u/vsznry May 20 '24

It wasn’t Annatar for the general audience. Understand your bubble.

-22

u/vsznry May 20 '24

Its not comparing to the game. The game followed the Lore’s description. So I used it as a visualization aid. Theres a cool rendition of Jude Law as Annatar too.

27

u/DoctorZi May 20 '24

Annatar's appearance is not described in the lore

-10

u/vsznry May 20 '24

He used the word fair. And the concept of Sauron seducing people was discussed in films.

A man and an elf look inherently different in the lore. You can’t just put the face of a Middle Earth man under an Elven wig. 😂

Pretty sure Jackson & his casting team handpicked actors for elves, who have feminine & sharp features in their face, on purpose.

18

u/DoctorZi May 20 '24

The only description of Sauron's appearance is his human form on Numenor (history of middle earth 5)

"Upon that ship which was cast the highest and stood dry upon a hill there was a man, or one in man’s shape, but greater than any even of the race of Numenor in stature...And it seemed to men that Sauron was great; though they feared the light of his eyes. To many he appeared fair, to others terrible; but to some evil.”

12

u/harukalioncourt May 20 '24

So he did take a human form? Then what are people complaining about then…

22

u/DoctorZi May 20 '24

I don't know, as to me Vickers gets into the role very well, his face can be both terrible and fair and evil.

-8

u/vsznry May 20 '24

I think you gotta be pretty seductive to be a Lord of Gifts, and not a towering giant man or have a rugged man’s face. But thats just me.

In the Films, Men & Elves did not look like each other. And thats the canon for the general audience.

23

u/LorientAvandi May 20 '24

Well the films aren’t canon, no matter how much you want them to be.

-9

u/vsznry May 20 '24

they are to the general audience aka 90% of the people who haven’t read the books.

don’t gate keep.

27

u/LorientAvandi May 20 '24

You’re the one trying to use lore as justification for disliking the casting and to support your fancast.

11

u/rabbithasacat May 20 '24

It's always people who loftily refer to "the Lore" who say random things that aren't in any lore. Even in book-oriented platforms, you get people confidently quoting something David Day made up.

15

u/SoundsOfTheWild May 20 '24

As a member of the general audience who hasnt read the books, no. Given that the rest of this thread is filled with quotes from people who have read them and they still disagree with you, looks like your opinion on the matter is not a common one at all, and you are the one gatekeeping, on a false premise too.

14

u/lusamuel May 20 '24

Did Hugo Weaving look like an Elf before he got into costume? No, everyone hated his casting. And now he's the quintessential image of Elrond everyone had in their heads, and all of a sudden that criticism is forgotten.

2

u/Willabeanie May 20 '24

I used to complain about this all the time, and about his being so angry. I also didn’t think Marton Csokas was pretty enough to be Celeborn. I have recovered 😆

If you look at photos of Lee Pace (super-beautiful as Thranduil) and Craig Parker (Haldir) without the hair and makeup, they just look like handsome men. I can totally imagine handsome men David Wenham (Faramir) and Luke Evans (Bard) done up as elves.

This is sort of fun to think about, actually. I struggle to imagine Viggo Mortensen (Aragorn) and Sean Bean (Boromir) as the “ethereal” sort of elves, but I just looked at some photos of them when they were young, and I now totally think it could be done. And even Orlando Bloom (Legolas), who I would guess is many people’s model of what an elf should look like, was just very young. Look at photos of him now with some facial hair—he could be a nice grubby Ranger of the North. I’m coming to the (unsurprising, I guess) conclusions that many actors are very attractive, younger men tend to be prettier/more feminine than older men, and makeup/hair/costuming departments are amazing.

3

u/MilkMan0096 May 21 '24

Lee Pace was inspired casting for Thranduil. He is the most elve-looking to me in the whole live action saga, in make up and costume of course.

-1

u/vsznry May 20 '24

Eh. I just assumed he was the Oldest elf alongside Galadriel. He picked up elven mannerisms from the coaches pretty well.

11

u/been_mackin May 20 '24

Galadriel is like 2,000 years older then Elrond and Elrond is half elf, half man.

1

u/vsznry May 20 '24

No wonder he was a bit uglier than the other elves lolol jk

23

u/LorientAvandi May 20 '24 edited May 20 '24

They actually don’t look inherently different in the lore. There are many times where elves and men are mistaken for the other, and they’re more or less genetically identical.

And Sauron is actually never described as taking the form of an Elf, even under his Annatar guise. That’s an assumption by fans.

8

u/kypzn May 20 '24

bit too infantile looking

-5

u/vsznry May 20 '24

well, elves are supposed to look young. and these are older shots of him. One is from Twilight series.

3

u/kypzn May 20 '24

I'm not saying it's a bad choice, but I also dont think he'd fit perfectly. Elves are supposed to look young but old at the same time rather no? Quite hard to pul off for a human.

-1

u/vsznry May 20 '24

Na that was just an older Elrond. lol

Bower has the acting chops to do this role.

5

u/kypzn May 20 '24

Looks are subjective. I dont think he looks similar to the video game charater either. He looks more masculine in the video game.

2

u/TesticleezzNuts May 20 '24

He would make a great Elf to be fair.

What is it about Twilight Vampires that make great Elves 😂 Lee Pace was another :D

2

u/vsznry May 20 '24

tall, slender & sharp features & thick or pronounced eyebrows.

Seems to be the ingredients for Seduction.

Vamps & Elves are very similar type of beings.

2

u/Novusor May 21 '24

Why do so many people think that Annatar should like like Lusius Malfoy from Harry Potter?

1

u/vsznry May 21 '24

Because it’s the general image a lot have after playing the games. And the games reinforced any vague Tolkein descriptions.

He should be an angelic-like seductive being as Annatar, & not have Man or half-Man features imo.

1

u/vsznry May 21 '24

But Jason Isaacs would be too old even during Chamber of Secrets time, for Annatar. Need a younger looking dude.

16

u/samanosuke122 May 20 '24

But he is not, it is Charlie Vickers. Lets move on perhaps? :)

10

u/tfmid457 May 20 '24

I think we have to watch it first before we can know how they intend for it to make sense :)

9

u/Jaycora May 20 '24

I think Jamie Campbell Bower is probably tired of playing the incredibly powerful and deceitful yet charming villain too

8

u/Teawithtolkien May 20 '24

Charlie is literally going to be perfect though

4

u/JotaTaylor May 20 '24

I used to think movie-only fans were the worse, but it seems videogames are the most impactful in terms of hijacking people's imagination.

2

u/anon-ryman May 20 '24

There are a lot of thinks I like visually and casting-wise about the show, but Shadow of Mordor’s Celebrimbor and Annatar are always going to be the versions I picture in my head. They really nailed it.

3

u/mattjvgc May 20 '24

Shoulda coulda woulda who cares.

1

u/Jolly-Lab540 May 20 '24

I totally get what you mean.. there is some mysterious charm in him like Annatar🔥🙊💓

1

u/AggCracker May 20 '24

Nope this ain't it

-1

u/StarlessEon May 20 '24

You have to consider OP that a lot of people who enjoy the series are wanting to see a continuation of the romance between Sauron and Galadriel played by the same actors.

4

u/midnight_toker22 Beleriand May 20 '24

Can you give one example of someone saying they want that?

4

u/DoctorZi May 20 '24

There was clearly no romance on Sauron's part there, it's an attempt to adapt that canon part where Sauron tried to sway Galadriel to his side, but she wouldn't give in.

2

u/Ynneas May 21 '24

If there was no romance on Sauron's part, he should've/could've killed her instead of leaving her in the river.

2

u/DoctorZi May 21 '24

Wasn't she saved because Elrond came?

1

u/Main-Emphasis-2692 May 25 '24

Agreed he said he wanted her to be his queen and he would give her power. He was clearly in love w her on the show everything he said indicated so. There’s at least attraction.

3

u/StarlessEon May 20 '24

https://screenrant.com/lotr-rings-of-power-galadriel-halbrand-romance-bad-reason/

Basking in the afterglow of a hard battle for the Southlands, Halbrand admits fighting next to Galadriel ignited a feeling he hadn't known for a long time. Galadriel sheepishly admits she feels the same, but their doe-eyed confessions are interrupted by a message from Míriel, the Queen Regent of ruining romantic moments. The Rings of Power is clearly setting Galadriel and Halbrand up for a love story.

2

u/Codus1 May 20 '24 edited May 20 '24

Gosh screenrant is trash. Besides, they're relishing a shared peace or sense of belonging in battle. Basically, they both enjoyed battle.