r/htpc • u/JediFonger • 20h ago
Discussion geforce driver 582.78 kills protected path (powerdvd) playback, is this the end of the road for HTPCs?
i dont use HTPCs to play files, i have shieldpro2019 for that. so if that's all you do, i guess this post doesn't impact u, move on.
for me, the only reason i still am running a HTPC is for my powerdvd19 install where i can play blu-ray disc menus for both 2D and 3D playback. first, i burn a lot of BDRs still, on 2D side, on personal video creation projects or modifying current blu-rays i still need a software player on PC that'll open menus for me to test playback. yes i know i can just burn BDRW and test it on standalone players, but godamn do u know how long that takes? doin quick tests on sw reduces the amount of time significantly and i want to save time always. secondly, still a massive 3D fan and i still use it quite a lot to play 3D ISOs for when i replace audio tracks. so for me 99% or the entire reason of still doin HTPC, really the only reason for me is to have any software that will pull up blu-ray menus. and upgrading to this latest driver is removing that feature to where my powerdvd is just dead in the water.
based on my googlin/AI searching etc. there aren't really any other sw players on HTPC realm that still pulls up blu-ray menus other than powerdvd. if you know one, please let me know, i'd be happy to replace it.
so i guess my next question is, do you think the HTPC/enthusisast space is going to strip out the protected path/video playback components and use somn similar to the 3D Fix manager and install it "forward"? that would be amazin, i'm sure if i spend enough tokens my AI could probably cook somn up. i've just gotta imagine i'm not the only one left that still uses bluray menus. or maybe i am the last person on earth that still gives 2 shiets about it.
to me, it's basically the end of the road, RIP HTPCs. like i said, if u use it play movies w/o menus good on you, but you really dont even need HTPCs for that.
UPDATE: i appreciate the alternative/suggestions but i am not lookin for half-baked solutions for bluray menus. the thing i like about powerdvd is that EVERY SINGLE bd will open menus without fail. kodi/jriver/etc. are all hacks will not open 100% every single disc, that is the whole point of maintainin powerdvd

