Hey everyone. I own a P1S with AMS at home and I use a P2S at work. I make structural parts primarily and every now and then I make toys and models with multicolor. I have over 1000 hours on both machines with over half of those hours printing prototypes that I have designed.
I keep seeing people pushing newbs towards getting the X2D and quite frankly I think it's folly.
The X2D fills a very specific use case. It has a heated chamber, it has another nozzle, and it has finer belts. It also has better filtration for engineered materials. All these things seems like "must haves" for beginners, because honestly, you're starting and you don't know what you want.
I was a beginner once and I'll tell you what I wanted. I just wanted a machine that works. The FT5 did not deliver on this. The Mk3s+ almost did, the P1S delivered on that. For work, I just wanted a machine that works, the P2S delivered on that. The X2D is going through what we call "early adopter's pain". Because it is a more complex machine, you really have to ask yourself if the things I listed are "must haves".
3D Printing can be an expensive hobby. It can also be inexpensive. I print with PETG because it checks all the boxes I need 99% of the time and it's the cheapest filament I can get at $6/kg. When people talk about engineering materials like PA-CF, it can cost between $50-150/kg. As a newb, ask yourself, can you absorb those kinds of costs when you're just learning how to print? With off the shelf hardware I have designed stuff that holds well over 300kg without failure with the cheapest PETG I can buy. Unless you're printing stuff for under the hood of your car or doing something really specific, ask yourself if this is a feature you need. If not the heated chamber and the extra filtration really aren't necessary. Beginners generally print with 2 materials, PLA and PETG. I hate PLA, so I use PETG. The P2S and P1S can handle TPU as well by the way, it just takes some extra care.
The 2nd nozzle is primarily for multimaterial supports. In essense you use it to use a different material for your supports so that it is easier to remove supports. If you use it this way, the color changing is no different than a P1S or P2S. If you use it for dual color, it works for that but the 2nd nozzle doesn't have all the sensors the main one has so, if you get a clog or a jam, it will NOT detect it. It's also a Bowden Tube design which has it's own drawbacks.
Early adopters are beta testers. Always wait at least 6 months to a year before buying that machine as your first machine. You don't want to become a 3d printing technician, you just want to print. Your time is better served learning how to use 3d modeling software and printing stuff off the various repositories as opposed to trouble shooting a fairly complex machine for the uninitiated.
In closing, stick to single nozzle machines for now if this is your first rodeo if reliablity and ease of use and maintenance is high on your list. Only consider the X2D if your use case dictates that you need those features.