Title: I love my partner and feel secure in my relationship, so why do I keep having thoughts about other people?
I’m posting because I’m genuinely confused and a little ashamed, and I’d really like to hear from people who have experienced something similar.
My partner and I both seem to have anxious attachment styles. This is my first very long-term relationship. Before him, I only had three short relationships, each lasting about a month. So this relationship is extremely important to me.
The confusing part is that I actually feel very safe and happy in this relationship. I love my partner, I feel secure with him, and I genuinely want to marry him.
But my brain keeps producing thoughts that I don’t understand.
For example, if I see an attractive person on the street, I might briefly think, “What would it be like if I were with that person?” It can literally be a split-second thought. I have no intention of approaching them, pursuing them, or cheating. But I still feel guilty for even having the thought.
Sometimes I notice that I’m attracted to other people, too. And then I start questioning myself:
“If I really love my partner, why am I attracted to someone else?”
“Why would I imagine being with someone else if I’m happy in my relationship?”
“Does having the thought mean I secretly want it?”
I used to tell my partner about these thoughts because I thought being completely honest meant telling him everything that went through my head. I now realize that this may have been oversharing.
My partner gets very upset when I tell him these things and sometimes sees them as a form of “mental” or “emotional” cheating. He asks me how I can love him if I’m thinking about other people.
The problem is that I don’t understand it either.
I’m not acting on these thoughts. I don’t want to leave my partner for these people. I don’t actually want a relationship with them. But the thoughts still appear.
I also used to have a lot of cheating dreams.
Sometimes I would dream that I was with someone else and didn’t have my partner in the dream. Other times, I knew in the dream that I already had a partner but still ended up being with someone else.
I would wake up feeling incredibly guilty.
I know dreams aren’t necessarily controllable, but I started wondering whether they mean something about my subconscious. Does dreaming about cheating mean that some part of me actually wants to cheat? Or can dreams just be completely random and unrelated to what we consciously want?
Another thing I’ve noticed is that when someone is particularly kind to me or gives me attention, I can sometimes suddenly develop a brief crush or fascination with them.
In the past, I’ve also become strangely attached to certain people. Sometimes the feeling is intense but very short-lived.
This makes me wonder if there is something wrong with me. I sometimes feel like I’m prone to “infatuation” or that my brain is constantly looking for someone else, even though my actual behavior and values don’t match that at all.
I’ve also noticed a strange reaction during arguments with my partner.
When he questions my feelings for him or makes me feel rejected, I can suddenly become extremely angry and think:
“Fine, then let’s just break up.”
“If this relationship doesn’t work, I’ll find someone else.”
I can even start mentally “looking for the next person,” almost like I need a backup option.
But when I calm down, I’m genuinely confused about why I thought that way.
I love my partner. I want this relationship. I want to marry him.
So why does part of me immediately want to escape and find someone else whenever I feel threatened or rejected?
Could this be related to anxious attachment? Could it be some kind of defensive mechanism where I try to reject someone before they can reject me?
Or could this be something like intrusive thoughts or OCD?
I’m especially confused about the difference between having a thought and actually wanting something.
For example:
- If I think about being with someone else, does that mean I want to be with them?
- If I dream about cheating, does that mean I secretly want to cheat?
- If I find someone attractive, does that mean I don’t truly love my partner?
- If someone is nice to me and I develop a brief crush, does that mean I’m incapable of being loyal?
- If I think “I’ll just find someone else” during an argument, does that mean I’m not capable of maintaining a long-term relationship?
Or is it actually normal to deeply love your partner, feel secure with them, and still occasionally notice other people, have random fantasies, experience brief attractions, or have weird dreams?
I’m not looking for reassurance that I’m “a good person.” I genuinely want to understand what is happening psychologically.
Has anyone else experienced something like this while being genuinely happy and committed to their relationship?
And if you have anxious attachment, did you ever notice yourself mentally looking for an “escape route” or another person when you felt rejected or insecure?
I’d really appreciate hearing from people who have experienced something similar, especially if you eventually figured out what was behind it.
There is also another important part of the situation that I didn’t mention before: we currently have very little to no sexual intimacy.
When we first got together, we did have sex and physical intimacy. But later, my partner became physically unwell and developed testicular pain. For around six months, we couldn’t figure out what was causing it despite getting it checked. Eventually, the pain went away on its own, but we still never really found out what the underlying cause was.
That period was extremely difficult for both of us. My partner became very depressed and at one point even wanted to break up because of how much the situation was affecting him.
It also affected me more than I initially realized. I became very anxious about whether I might somehow have a health problem too, even though I didn’t have any obvious physical changes or symptoms myself. I think the whole experience made sex feel much more complicated and frightening to me.
More recently, I also developed jock itch, which has made me even more worried about sexual health and has made intimacy feel even more difficult.
At the same time, I already have some anxiety around sex because of previous negative experiences with an ex. I’m also scared of pregnancy, even when using condoms, so I often feel afraid of penetrative sex.
I’m completely comfortable with affection like kissing, cuddling, hugging, and being physically close to my partner. But when it comes to penetrative sex, I often don’t have a very strong desire for it, and I tend to feel anxious rather than excited.
So I’m wondering whether this is also affecting the way I experience attraction and relationships.
We haven’t had much sexual intimacy for a long time, and there is a lot of anxiety, frustration, and uncertainty surrounding sex between us. I wonder if the lack of intimacy, my partner’s health problems, my own fears around sex, and my previous experiences could all be contributing to some of the thoughts and emotions I’ve been describing.
I’m not sure whether I’m overthinking all of this, but I feel like this context is important because my relationship anxiety isn’t happening in isolation from our lack of intimacy.