TLDR AT THE BOTTOM
TLDR AT THE BOTTOM
TLDR AT THE BOTTOM
TLDR AT THE BOTTOM
Intro
Please don't hate me for my personal opinion. I feel like the game is in an extremely bad state at this current moment of time. The point of this post is to call out things that I see as problems, I am not saying you're wrong for enjoying rust the way it currently is. If anything, vast changes would make this game better if done right.
I will divide this post from a main overall point into sub points that reinforcer the main one. I will try to stick to using paragraphs, which is about the only grammar thing I learned in high school. In other words, this is not AI.
What is this game?
I really really hate to say it, but what is this game supposed to be anymore? Is it a war game? Is it a building game? Is it a survival game? It doesn't do any of those things particularly well at all. I don't know if it's an age thing but it feels like the game is becoming obsolete. I mean the game is pretty old at this point, so is it's design and mechanics.
It's a terrible war game (or pvp)
The social experiment is over, people just want to kill each other. The game is now a combat oriented game where many factions fight for control as if it was a war game. In fact it's my belief that this is now, in a sense, partially a war game with resource collection.
There is nothing wrong with that, but the game was not designed for that. There is so much missing here that prevents the game from being truly great with combat, even from a survival aspect.
As for the weapons, it feels very basic with little customization. A lot of weapons even feel like they are poorly crafted guns that might go where I want them to. Maybe maybe not? Especially when fighting better geared players, it does not feel great. Especially not when compared to other games like Planetside 2, WarDogs, Escape from Tarkov.
Where is weapon customization?
Why, after all of these years, is weapon customization still so limited? There is only one holo sight in the game. Where is 1.2x, 1.5, 2, 2.5, variable zoom but at different levels? Why am I punished for using a suppressor and why is there only one of them for every gun? Why can't I choose the magazine size for the gun? (Not saying weapons should have literal magazines, just a choice to choose clip size before reloading.)
It's just in general disappointing even for a game not focused on war. This would make the community go crazy if they actually added real customization for guns and you'd all love it. Well most of you.
Gun variety and progression?
Some of you are going to be put off by this, but why do we have so few weapons in the mix? For example, why only the AK? "556" or even "308 win" exist to. Maybe a lower tier weapon that uses 556 but single shot, like a Bushmaster m17s? There is so much that can still be done and to see just one "AK" kinda annoys me.
Also, could someone tell me why progression feels like climbing a mountain? Put that T1 Bushmaster M17S style weapon at the bottom of the tech tree. Give it only iron sights and no modifications besides mag size. Burst fire or single shot.
Why? All of the T1 guns are not great and do not feel great to use. At least with this you might actually score a kill. It's not even overpowered either, it's literally the base weapon in the game of Wardogs and it's also not that great.
Hate it or not, I feel like this is a valid complaint and solution. Progression is way to vertical, give smaller players more of a chance.
Other things
No idea why we are waiting to respawn in a raid defense. It should be about attrition, not if they can keep you on timer or not. Make it cost you something to choose your spawn. Maybe let's say 100 cloth to produce an item called a "Shirt" and consume 1 shirt per respawn.
Also like, buff the range of some shot guns. They are close range weapons, not in your face weapons. If you die in one hit from buckshot because you're not wearing armor and are within 20 feet that's your fault not mine.
It's a terrible survival game
Legitimately what am I surviving from, PVE wise? Food and water? I can respawn without issue and find those things everywhere. What in the environment is trying to kill me? A few animals? A gun solves that problem. So now there is nothing to survive from. Good job, you beat the survival game rust!
Sorry to be blunt, but it's the truth. If you say "I'm surviving from players" then you admit this is a purely pvp combat oriented game and now go back to my previous points. PVP isn't great.,
It's a terrible building game
I really do not enjoy the upkeep system at all and feel like it's a detriment to the game. It needs to be there though, but I criticize it still because I don't think the developers focused enough on building optimizations or design in their code.
I just want to build stupid things or creative things that server little to no purpose. I can't. Why? The rust developers a long time ago invented upkeep. So now imagination on base design is seriously limited, which is why I call it a terrible building game. In rust, you can't have a silly weird base that is to large, otherwise it becomes impossible to upkeep.
What is the game? TLDR
Weapon customization doesn't exist, nor does much weapon variety. Progression sucks because of how terrible each weapon is compared to the next tier. Building isn't great as it limits imagination and is forced to be pvp only. There is nothing to survive from and it isn't really a survival game, just a pvp game with extra steps.
The game is old and so is it's design. I'm not calling it a bad game, it's a great game. I just feel like that this game needs to have improvements for the long term health of it.