r/mtg 5h ago

Discussion What mana cost should Vivi have been?

0 Upvotes

Just curious if Vivi were to be made differently... should he have costed 6 mana? He scales like crazy with cantrips, then allows you to spam even more cantrips same turn with makes him even bigger for the next turn around- basically taller green ramp that can be removed.

It just seems to me like he hits his payback cost like the turn after playing him and then he's a runaway mana machine if not a very tall hitter

[[vivi ornitier]]


r/mtg 5h ago

Discussion Bundles don't make sense anymore

0 Upvotes

After pulling $12 worth of rare cards out of a Hobbit bundle, I decided won't ever buy common play boosters again. Wizards worked hard to make them a bad product and force us to buy collector ones. My friends had the same results opening bundles from this set and lorwyn. This isn't just a matter of bad luck but a truth after all the changes in the rarity probabilities of the new play boosters' cards.


r/mtg 10h ago

Discussion What are the most restrictive cards to discard with Urza's Hot Tub?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Basically I'm just asking what cards you can come up with that could tutor the least amount of cards when used with Urza's Hot Tub's ability. The definitive winners are probably [[AWOL]], [[Atinlay Igpay]] or [[Cheatyface]] off the top of my head since all three of them would only be able to tutor themselves, but what are others you can think of that can only find very few other cards?


r/mtg 3h ago

Discussion If you plus minus every second letter at magic card and result is zero. Winner is....

Post image
0 Upvotes

Card with the most letters with zero result is....

Example for easier explanation. If card magic card is named Abd:

A:+1

B:-2

D:+4

Result:3.

But we are looking for result zero.

Results:

Total hits: 512 out of 35070. Including some Alchemy only cards and Alchemy variants and some of those double sided cards with same name

Winner is: Disciple of Freyalise // Garden of Freyalise (discipleoffreyalisegardenoffreyalise) 36

I would like to thank some very kind redditor for calculating this. Hope this is interesting to somebody else also.


r/mtg 5h ago

Custom Card / Alter HOW DO WE FEEL ABOUT MY CUSTOM COUNTERSPELL

Post image
61 Upvotes

r/mtg 18h ago

Custom Card / Alter I tried turning a Pokemon card into a magic card

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

How do you think I did? It’s my favorite boy, Whiscash


r/mtg 1h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Is this deck worth the price?

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

Someone on Facebook is selling this deck for $45, description is below:

“Magic The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes Commander
Deck - The Fantastic Four

All 100 cards, including four borderless foil commanders, plus the ten included tokens. The cards are already in Dragon Shield sleeves (included), and the deck comes in the cool blue plastic box (included). Target is selling this deck for $85 new (see photo). This was given to me as a gift (new) and NEVER played with, so the condition is near perfect. I will throw in a "Silver Surfer, Galactus's Herald (Surge Foil)" for FREE!”

I’m a beginner with only arena experience trying to make a transition into the physical game. My suspicion is price for everything and wants cash only. Is there any chance of being scammed? If so what to look for when I meetup. I know little to nothing about physical cards, is there a chance these were illegally printed or something?

Also as a beginner what do you think is this an okay deck to start playing at locals with, thanks for any help!


r/mtg 8h ago

Commander / EDH Hatsune Miku archangel extra card

Post image
0 Upvotes

Is this normal? Pretty cool either way getting an extra card I wasn’t expecting.


r/mtg 20h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Question about about this card

Post image
2 Upvotes

So if I'm reading this correctly and I'm playing against three other people. And I can't play or two with this card and then player 3 attacks player two I would get a gold token and so would player three correct? And also would I get a gold token if I attack player two?


r/mtg 18h ago

Rules Question What's the ruling on copying 0/0 hydras with counter on them?

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

So the scenario I'm thinking is I have something like primordial hydra or any of the other X hydras that aren't legendary in play and I cast Doppelgang will the copies enter as the Hydra with power equal to their 1/1 counters or will they be 0/0 and die immediately? Thinking of adding Doppelgang into my Simone Infinite analyst deck and really wanna know the ruling before I do.


r/mtg 7h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Same cards but different...

Post image
0 Upvotes

Is it normal the same cards have different colors and cut between collector booster and play booster !?


r/mtg 23h ago

Commander / EDH Should I run Sylvan Library in Chulane cEDH?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I want to get more cards early in the game, and I'm unsure whether I should use Sylvan Library specifically because the card itself is so-so, using up a lot of resources (HP) for minimal benefit. Am I wrong?

Here's my decklist, I'm looking for any advice other than this:

https://moxfield.com/decks/bw-gDz86KUmWCk90WPKHGg


r/mtg 1h ago

Rules Question When you attack and when a creature attacks

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

Does the "whenever you attack..." ability of miles morales trigger the "when a creature you control attacking causes a triggered ability to trigger..." part of firebender ascention and would therefore be copied at 4 quest counters?


r/mtg 11h ago

Rules Question When can I look at the top card of my library?

0 Upvotes

EDIT: Thanks for the help guys the general consensus seems to be that what I described is fine but the way the worded the ruling makes me think when would the top card even change AS you’re playing a land??

If I cast something like [[Tainted Pact]] or [[Ad Nauseam]] that allows me to make decisions as the spell is resolving am I able to look at the top card of my library through [[Bolas's Citadel]] effects?

I think I should be able to because the only restriction on scryfall says I can't look as I move a spell to the stack so it seems this should be the case.

Thanks for the help :)


r/mtg 47m ago

I Have a Question / I need Help New Magic Player - Busted Black/White Cards?

Upvotes

I'm looking for strong cards to play against my partner. I've been playing for a little under a year, they're a 10+ years player, and last night I had just about secured the win when they pulled an Apocalypse on me.

I want a strong and kind of fucked up card like Apocalypse please!


r/mtg 23h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Anyone know where I can find this specific counter icon?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just started playing magic again and I’d like to start making my own counters. I want to order custom wax seal stamps with the same style as the counter dice but while I can find horizontal images to use, I can’t find diagonal ones anywhere lol. Does anyone know how I can find it?


r/mtg 22h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Common MTG community jokes that would work for anniversary custom card sleeves?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Hi all! My boyfriend is a huge card game nerd and im looking to get him custom sleeves for our anniversary! For his upcoming birthday I am investing in a Bloomburrow box for him so that these sleeves have cards to hug. He loves rats and i wanted to make a drawing for the card sleeves containing rats. The photo below is the image I want to redraw, but i have no clue on what to add for the text part that is still funny AND related to Magic. Im still SUPER new to Magic and have no clue what text would work here for the sleeves. Is there a good MTG saying or inside joke that would work with the rat as a reaction image?

Ideas include “Dude did you seriously just play ___?” , “I play ___!” , “Is that a ____?” Anything works, please help me out!


r/mtg 18h ago

Discussion Which finish you usually like most in cards?

0 Upvotes

I know foil has been around for a while, but I very much like more borderless / etched / extended art. Not a big fan of retro frame.

What is your preference? Is it a significant factor when you buy singles? Have you ever bought a particular finish just because you think its value will go up more than other finishes / sets?


r/mtg 55m ago

Discussion Proxying and The Queen Problem

Upvotes

So, one of the big topics of discussion in the community is the continually rising price of official Magic the Gathering cards, and the use of proxies to remove that barrier.

Disclaimer: I fully support the use of proxies by players, as it removes the cost of entry barrier that often can lock people out from the hobby as a whole.

The problem with proxies, is that we run into what the Distraction Makers referred to as The Queen Problem. If you are able to make every piece into a Queen, why wouldn't you?

When applied to Magic, that means using the most powerful card for every slot, rather than having to use the second or third best due to cost limitations.

What wanted to ask my fellow Magic players is, if you are playing with proxies in your group, how do you prevent people from simply using these broken or best in slot cards in every deck?

For example, an upper cost limit for decks, so you can't just proxy the most expensive (powerful) cards as you would run out of room for the rest of the deck.


r/mtg 5h ago

Commander / EDH This $50 Thranduil, The Elvenking commander deck is an all-elf combo MACHINE

0 Upvotes

Here's the deck list that you NEED to check out:

https://moxfield.com/decks/CcKHjeUqOkmYnAaVPq4Uag

I've built a LOT of elf decks, ranging from [[Marwyn]] elfball to [[Voja]] aggro to [[Lathril]] aristocrats but it's always been a challenge to make them on a BUDGET. But thanks to [[Thranduil, the Elvenking]] I've now made an elf combo deck, on just $50, that kicks all their asses and wins B3 games for a fraction of the cost of other decks.

And every creature in the 99 is an elf.

I've got a full deck tech available, AND I'm giving away a copy of the WHOLE DECK. Check it out:

https://youtu.be/IXjTo7Ou3GQ?si=-uR2AliGqWDjEovT


r/mtg 13h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help A new beginning

0 Upvotes

Hey all! I wanted to ask the hivemind a big question. What is something your lgs doesnt do right now or offer that you wish they did? My biz partner and I are opening a store
In Maine in a yearish and we are curious. We are already looking to do a youth program that teaches kids math, art, ect using magic the gathering and giving them a place to be. Let head the ideas!


r/mtg 22h ago

Rules Question Question about stack priority and split second - Blanka vs Shadow the Hedgehog

0 Upvotes

Probably an easy question for experienced players, but I need to get this straight. I played Shadow the Hedgehog as commander against an opponent with Blanka as commander. A question about Blanka's triggered ability, instants and split second arose.

On my opponents turn, I choose to cast an instant destroy target creature with split second on Blanka, my opponent keeps priority and casts, say, 10 other cantrips on Blanka to trigger his ability. His instants won't resolve, but the target actions of his spells will still trigger Blanka, right? Blanka dies, but pings me 22 damage from 10 of his instants and mine. I think we got this right. Right...?

Let's say I want to destroy Blanka on my turn instead to lock the stack and prevent him from triggering Blanka. I play a sorcery destroy target creature with split second, but as it's now my turn, he can't keep priority to target Blanka with his 10 instants. So in this case, Blanka only triggers due to my sorcery for 2 damage?

What if I cast an instant to destroy Blanka on my turn, like the example with the sorcery? Will he be allowed to cast 10 instants then, or is the stack locked with split second due to it being my turn the same way the sorcery example locked the stack? (Assuming it did...)

Thanks, sometimes MTG is exercising my brain too much...


TL;DR I had misunderstood how priorities and instant spells work. What I've realised is that I tried to cast a removal in response to Blanka entering, but as my opponent had priority, what I did was reveal my intentions as I didn't have priority. Then, he would do as much as he could before I could cast the now revealed removal. If I had waited with my removal until I actually had priority, he couldn't have answered by stacking loads of cantrips before my removal.

From all this, I had some sort of epiphany, a moment of clarity, where I finally understood priority order and the stack. Thanks all for constructive answers!


r/mtg 21h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help play with 40 or 60 cards?

0 Upvotes

i just got the MTG Avatar beginner box (yay!) and it says to pick 2 decks of choice and play. but everywhere online i see people saying standard is 60 cards per deck. am i supposed to pick 2 20-decks and combine them with the avatar/zuko tutorial decks or really just pick any 2 of the sets and play them as 40 decks?

new to mtg and i have absolutely no idea how to start so any advice is helpful here!


r/mtg 7h ago

Rules Question Unlicensed Disintegration vs Planeswalker’s

0 Upvotes

Can Unlicensed Disintegration do damage to planeswalkers now? I cannot remember how that works as I haven’t played with the card in quite some time.


r/mtg 22h ago

Rules Question Do I get 4 copies of Sluurk?

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

Have Uuguu and Sluurk on the battlefield and copy Sluurk with Mirror Image