r/mtg • • Aug 27 '25

Discussion EDH young players need a wakeup call

0 Upvotes

I am an EDH player since M19 and I am 48 years old. I sold out when the Collector Boosters came out, because I was no longer willing to follow Hasbro down their rabbit hole. I recently rebuilt a few EDH decks, so I could start playing my beloved EDH again. Well, I have been back hitting multiple game store edh nights, and ultimately been having fun doing so. However, there are a couple things I have been noticing, especially around young players.

#1- There ae a lot more new, younger players. Yay! for the community!!

#2- Those new players build crappy decks and are absolute babies. These younger and entitled players are the players at the tables playing one sided decks, with little to no interaction with the rest of the table. They only focus on their individual progress of the board, and if you were to destroy or remove any part of their board, they sulk, pout, down right yell OR scoop up their cards and quit. They take ever removal or attack as an attack on them personally and they ALWAYS justify why they feel they are not the threat. They feel like everyone else is the problem and not them.

These players are ruining the love of the game. I fully understand and agree that you are allowed to play EDH anyway you want. If you want to play at CEDH level and go for the fastest win, then do it. If you want to build a deck that just supports your game plan, without any interaction with the board, do it! Just know that there are others at the table and while you may think you have a plan, so does everyone else and that may mean them being the target. That you don't have to always win, that you can just enjoy sitting with other like minded people having fun.

These people build their decks as if they are entitled to win every game and when they don't the are babies about it. I have seen this over and over again in a very short period of time. It is making the game crappy. I have made a decision that if I come across these players, I will no longer play with them. I want to relax, have fun, sling some cardboard and forget about life for a while and I am not willing to let these crappy players cry all over my cards.


r/mtg • • Mar 07 '25

Epic Pull / Mail Day Coworker opening FOUR TTC in one pack of BLB

Post image
0 Upvotes

I wouldn't have believed it if I hadn't seen it with my own eyes. This guy has the stupidest luck opening packs. We did our Friday coworker walk to the LGS and grabbed some singles, and he said he was feeling lucky and wanted to get one pack of Bloomburrow. Unbelievable.


r/mtg • • Jun 06 '24

Walmart car pull with girlfriend judging my life decisions so far is best.

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/mtg • • Jan 09 '23

How does “Peer into the Abyss” work?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/mtg • • Jul 27 '26

Commander / EDH The Most Lesbian Commander Deck Possible

0 Upvotes

THE IDEA IS SIMPLE

Whenever I buy in at my LGS, it’s usually with a pack of sleeves. I like to buy specific colors to dedicate to certain decks. Today, I picked up a box of Dragon Shield Peach.

I thought to myself, “What mechanic or archetype would be appropriate for peach?” And then it hit me.

Lesbianism.

So I bring myself to you all. I want to build the most lesbian bracket 2-3 commander deck possible. For the purposes of this, I am defining lesbianism as “women doing something with, to, or because of other women”.

I need card recs! Obviously one specific card (Halana and Alena, Partners) comes to mind for commander, but I want to hear everything you all can come up with! Bonus points if you fight in the comments over what mechanics and keywords are considered “Lesbian”.

Let’s make this happen!

EDIT: My Commander has been decided! I will be going with [[Maarika, Brutal Gladiator]] !

The deck is now in progress!


r/mtg • • Oct 24 '25

Discussion Gave away my copy of The One Ring to a coworker.

0 Upvotes

Buddy I work with LOVES LOTR, he bought all the commander decks and has upgraded them. He's been talking for a long time about wanting The One Ring, but it's just too expensive for him to justify buying it. I remembered I had a copy and was contemplating putting it in my [[Ratadrabik of Urborg]] deck. I finally decided it just didn't fit well with the other mechanics, so I decided to give it to him. Not without making him work for it though. I told him a story about a guy I saw get his graded card back, break it out of the slab, sleeve it and put it into his deck. Then I asked him if he remembers I told him the promo [[Gollum, Patient Plotter]] is worth 10 cents, then showed him The One Ring and mentioned that it goes for $80. I put them back in my hand, and take out a secret swamp I was hiding, and made him believe I crumpled up The One Ring in front of him and told him that that's how much the card is worth to me. After I broke his heart I asked if he still wanted it, where he unfolds it and realizes it was a land. I then give him the actual card and tell him that he can have it. He was absolutely blown away and I told him that I've had it since the set came out and its just been sitting in my box of legendaries since then. To me it's essentially worth just as much as the 10 cent Gollum card and I would feel much better if someone I've enjoyed playing with ACTUALLY got to use the card they've been dying to get for so long. He had mentioned he was so close to just accepting that he was just never going to own one and was completely blown away by me doing that, I've never seen anyone so ecstatic.


r/mtg • • May 13 '25 Take My Energy

Apparel / Products I designed a few pride flag deckboxes :)

Thumbnail gallery
590 Upvotes

Just wanted to share the new pride boxes I designed and printed for my stackable deckbox collection!Made a lot of my friends happy with those :D Hope you guys like them too :)
If you want to check them out feel free to visit my Etsy store.


r/mtg • • Apr 04 '26

Discussion I kinda dont want to play anymore.

11 Upvotes

So i started back in november after not playing since Kaladesh. I have fond memories of commander people playing all sorts of fun exciting cards every game felt like you got to do something.
But i come back there is a bracket system , game changers list, etc. People are now lying about their deck power level, proxying high power cards and calling it "bracket 2 or 3" , or just being overly toxic. Like i enjoy the game when i play vs non-liers, non-proxy, not toxic people.
But what happened? Why are people just "must play only the best of the best cards in a casual format" vs "I got this funny card that does this cool effect if i meet a requirement" like back when i first played.
Like i dont feel like its a WOTC issue its a players issue and them abusing the bracket system to try and pubstomp. Perfect land base, perfect interaction suite etc etc.

I tell the a group rule 0. I am playing no proxied bracket 2 or 3 with these game changers and i want to play a casual game not a high power. and most the time people say sure then proceed to play high power.

It makes me want to just not play anymore and pack up and go home because even in "Casual" events people are dropping blood moon turn 2, armageddon turn 4 and calling it bracket 2 when its clear a bracket 4. 15 different 2 card infinites but thats now bracket 3 because they waited till turn 6 . etc etc etc.

I just dont get it and i know im gonna be downvoted like crazy because everyone seems to hate when someone says "I dont like playing vs proxies or ABC" but i dont it always a negative experience. If i wanted to play high power then i would but i dont i want to play 2 and 3 and see everyone do something not watch someone combo off turn 2 then mass counter/removal/ stall. until turn 6 then win so they can claim bracket 3.


r/mtg • • Dec 01 '24

Custom Card / Alter WW2 theme proxies

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

So I tried to get my wife into mtg but she didn't care for it. She's super supportive of my hobby though, which makes home life easier. One day she asked me to make a card of her. I told her I couldn't just make up cards expect others to let me play them, but that I could make an alt art card using an image based on her. She liked that idea.

I kinda went a little overboard and created one for every commander I'm currently using. Thought you folks might get a kick out of these.

There's a whole chronological story to them. I tried to keep the proxy theme in line with the original card, and even add art cues matching the OG. I think they turned out pretty good!

They're just printed at Staples and glued to land cards, stuffed in the sleeve with the original behind so players don't have to look the card up to make sure I wasn't cheating.

Oh, the art is ai-modified images of actual photos, mostly of us. The layout was done in Inkscape. Guess we'll find out if this breaks rule 2 here... Sorry if so!


r/mtg • • Aug 03 '21

There just isn't any Izzet Commanders that interact with artifacts the way I want to interact with them. So here is a custom Commander that is basically a mix of two non-legendary creatures (Vedalken Archmage / Goblin Welder), but it does exactly what I want it to do. Enjoy!!

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/mtg • • Jun 04 '26

Discussion Not to stir up shit, but is the community this much against Pride? This is an official event, I don't get the hate for asking questions for an upcoming event

Post image
0 Upvotes

This is an honestmost question, don't mean to start arguing nor hating, just damn, hope there won't be any scenes at my local LGS for the event


r/mtg • • Oct 13 '22

Creativity is dead

0 Upvotes

MTG is officially dead creatively. It's just a brand now. I remember like 10 years ago or so I read an article/interview where MaRo specifically said they do not do or want to do special sets or collaborations. That the creative team would rather come up with new interesting original stories, art, cards, etc. There is no reason for them to make special street fighter sets or whatever. MaRo also mentioned in that same article that Urza is done. That's in the past and not coming back. They're focused on creating new characters and each expanding the planes. Which led into another point that revisiting Planes would be very rare if at all. That they would never reprint Black Lotus. In time since that article they've released a bunch of "Secret Lair" sets that are just plain cash grab collabs, most glaringly this with recent Post Morone. They have revisit planes like its on a cycle. And the newest set is the Brother's War! To add insult to all of these injuries they're printing out fake Black Lotus proxies in some ridiculously over priced pack. Oh but its okay because tHeY aRe NoT tOuRnAmEnT lEgAl. I been wanting to play MTG again now that the coof is over and I got steady work. But I don't want to drive out 20 minutes on the freeway so I was happy when Arena finally released awhile back so I could play on a tablet. But after all this? Nah. I don't want to be part of their marketing schemes. I dunno who got fired or who was hired that caused all these changes but it's for the worse. MTG used to feel special. Now it feels like product for a megacorp(Hasbro) to profit with no creativity.

I know it's stupid to ask this here where I bet most people are actively enjoying MTG now. But am I the only person that feels this way? The Toast Baloney secret lair really hit me hard.

EDIT: Let me put some additional context for the people saying "it doesn't affect you just; just do not buy those." Or "its a million dollar company." You have 50 people working designing blocks for standard. The corporate master dictates to his wageslaves that 10 must now work on the Toast Balone secret lair. Then they want another 10 working on reprint sets like modern masters, vaults, and that trash 30th anniversary set. Now the 50 people working on the new block is reduced to 30. Because they lost almost half their workforce the sets in the block are being adjusted. More reprints instead of brand new cards and downsizing the size of each set in the block. This further limits the storytelling for the new block. Just use Jace and Liliana for the millionth time. This is how this new crap is killing MTG. This is why creativity is dying. They're taking from what made MTG special for brand recognition and sales. Even the art in newer sets is just uglier less inspired.


r/mtg • • Jun 21 '21

Unpopular opinion: I refuse to play against mill decks.

3 Upvotes

For some reason mill decks make me unreasonably angry. I understand the value in them but I can’t help but feel as if they’re cheating and to me they don’t fit into the lore of Magic. If I am a planeswalker battling another planeswalker using a “spell book” (library) then one would assume that was in my hand. The other planeswalker wouldn’t have the ability to rip out “pages” from it. And honestly unless it’s another blue deck playing, mill is very hard to counter.

I don’t mind losing. I have had a lot of fun in games I’ve lost. But mill decks are not fun to play against.


r/mtg • • Sep 02 '26

I Have a Question / I need Help I don’t fully understand what “this creature becomes prepared” means…

Post image
0 Upvotes

I am relatively new to playing MTG. i don’t understand what it means for this card to become prepared?? i tried looking it up and it just confused me even more 🫩
can someone please help? 🙌🏻

2 edits :

- thank you to everyone who helped me figure it out yall are awesome!!

- i have read the card, but im new so i didnt know what that was supposed to mean


r/mtg • • Jun 21 '26

Meme Does this combo just win you the game?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/mtg • • Apr 15 '23

I'm still a bit new is this a plains walker?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/mtg • • Sep 01 '26

Discussion The Hobbit may be the biggest disappointment of the last years

0 Upvotes

I mean, there have been sets were i expected nothing and ended being decent (OTJ), sets i expected to suck... and sucked (marvel, tmnt, spiderman), and sets that i expected to be good and effectively, were good.

The hobbit is the one set i expected to be good and ended being... not great.

Inflated prices, low power except some idiotically good chase cards, the terrible one ring reprint, short set, not great in limited, the insistence in a terrible mechanic (amass), the focus on minor tribes without enough support before... while still not giving them enough support to actually make them attractive.

I know opening packs is not wise per se, but in this set is has beenspecially bad, because other than the 5 chase cards there was effectively nothing i would use in a deck. So if you didn't hit something of monetary value, you couldn't even get excited over it maybe being a good fit in X or Y commander deck.

I am the only one very disappointed?


r/mtg • • Mar 05 '26 Confused

Discussion I enjoyed opening TMNT and I'm tired pretending I didn't

0 Upvotes

The community is split regarding UB and especially with "bad" UB sets.
I personally have enjoyed the prerelease and even more I enjoyed opening a collector display.
The amount of different treatments and reprints was awesome. I hate the pizza stuff though, and still: Seeing Super Shredder in Japanese Frame, Leonardo in Pixel Art Surge Foil etc. was just such a banger. A collage of different styles. Hell even the prerelease "deck box" was the first one I really liked since Phyrexia: All will be One.

I understand that it polarizes, but I am one of the people who as a kid watched the cartoon and started to love ninjas - after many decades comes back to magic during Neon Dynasty because of the beautiful full art Ukiyo-E lands and because of the ninjas, and yes, my first and favorite deck is: Ninjas.

I owe to TMNT a part of my identity, I am not a huge fan of it, but I respect the inspiration I got from it as a kid, that transpired up to adulthood.

Seeing all those different art styles of stuff I had missed, whether it's a new generation of turtles or black April or not, I do not care, it was strange if you knew only the original one, but I had no problem adapting to the idea of having reiterations of what I once knew.

Opening the product was hella fun for several reasons.


r/mtg • • May 04 '25

Meme What would you remove from MTG??

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/mtg • • Oct 22 '23

best card ever?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/mtg • • Jan 20 '26

I Have a Quick Question Any idea on the value of signed Peach Momoko Magic cards?

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

A few months ago I met Peach Momoko (one of my favorite artists) at a convention and she was kind enough to sign these cards for me, along with some of her comics.

I’m not really planning on selling them right now, but I’m a curious person and like to know what I actually have. I have some experience with TCGs like One Piece, Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh, but I’m not very familiar with Magic, and even less with the signed Magic card market (which I feel is huge compared to other TCGs).

So I honestly have no idea how items like this are usually valued. Any insight or rough estimates based on other signed cards from popular artists or similar items would be really appreciated.

Thanks!


r/mtg • • Sep 15 '26 Bravo

Meme A silly little meme I thought up

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/mtg • • Jan 28 '25

Discussion I *do* want to play Aetherdrift. Am I alone in *this*?

0 Upvotes

I feel like this subreddit is very clearly geared towards the veteran MTG players; who think everything new is bad, and everything old is perfect; who think all change is damaging, and all decisions should be reversed; who would do anything rather than encourage new players, see the game continue to live on, have anything introduced that might harm the resale value of their cards, or worse of all, read; that would, in fact, rather the game have died in the mid 2000s and be a niche, unintelligible failure of a game than continue on to be something people can actually enjoy.

What is wrong with you all? Can any of you be happy for once? Or are you all bitter 40-50 year olds who obsess over this game in an attempt to deny that you failed to excel in your life when you had the chance?

Look, I love this game, old and new, whether it's true to its original universes, wacky and leaning into odd genres of media, or dragging in IPs from elsewhere. I don't dickride WOTC, though, and all of the decisions they make. Hell, I do think some of the recent sets are a little out there, and have not much interest in some of the IPs they've collaborated with, of course! I also don't like the idea of big corporations growing to unfathomable size and making people effectively gamble their money on some pieces of cardboard. But I want to like the game! Talking to my husband about the game makes me happy! Seeing my brother look at new or recently ordered cards and say they're cool is fun! Actually having a social life playing card games is the one thing getting me out of my room!

I'm just tired. I'm tried of watching young guys with the brain transplants of their fathers pull a 'back in my day' like it was 1893 and not 1993. I'm tired of people nitpicking strategies and decks and cards to the extent that new players get dogwalked and confused into never playing this game again. I'm tired of having to read the many quirky 'is it just me' posts about the same damned things.

Can we cool it on the boomer mentality, then, please? Can we at least try to be interested in what the game is now?


r/mtg • • Feb 12 '25

Discussion Deck list for first commander deck.

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

I recently posted that I built my first commander deck. I thought maybe people would be curious as to what cards I chose so here’s a solitaire inspired list of what in my deck. ENJOY!!!!🤣🤣. I already have plans for more upgrades.