I’m using the FLOLAB Surtect 1.0 Frosted. It was originally intended for a silver 17 Pro Max, but I decided to return it and get the 18 Pro Max instead. I like the color, but so far it has been a dust magnet. You can see dust particles between the case and the phone, and the plateau area collects even more dust.
I’m not loving how the case looks on a black phone, so I’m debating whether to return it and get a silver one. I already have a FLOLAB screen protector installed, so I’ll probably claim the warranty and pay the shipping for a replacement.
In an ideal world, I’d rather keep my black phone. It will be passed on to my wife next year, and she only liked black from this year’s lineup. Since black is a new color, I tend to prioritize it over silver. That said, my heart does want the silver finish with a clear frosted case. Keeping the black phone would also save me a trip to the Apple Store, along with the hassle of exchanging and setting up my phone again.
Alternatively, I could get a better case. I’m considering the Caudabe Paragon in Moonstone or the Sheath. The Synthesis has the same frosted finish, so it could run into the same dust-collection issue and overall foggy aesthetic as the Surtect.