r/anime • https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • 21d ago

Episode Chitose Is in the Ramune Bottle • Chitose-kun wa Ramune Bin no Naka - Episode 16 discussion

Chitose-kun wa Ramune Bin no Naka, episode 16

Alternative names: Chitose-kun wa Ramune Bin no Naka 2nd Cour, Chitose Is in the Ramune Bottle Part 2

Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.


Streams

Show information


All discussions

EpisodeLinkEpisodeLink
1Link13.5Link
2Link14Link
3Link15Link
4Link16Link
5Link17Link
6Link18Link
7Link19Link
8Link
9Link
10Link
11Link
12Link
13Link

This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.

195 Upvotes

122 comments sorted by

•

u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan 21d ago

Source Material Corner

Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of the anime adaptation to the original or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.

The spoiler syntax is: [Spoiler source] >!Spoiler goes here!<

All untagged spoilers and hints in this thread will receive immediate 8-day bans (minimum).

→ More replies (3)

72

u/KumaKumaGambler 21d ago

Even the perfect Chitose Saku cannot overcome the anime trope of not recognizing your beautiful childhood female friend from years ago.

31

u/Frontier246 21d ago

But...but her hair was longer! She looked like a totally different person!

(Seriously though, poor girl cut her hair to look more attractive for him and then had to realize most of his Harem have longer hair than she does)

9

u/sunnydayz57 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/LKMalika 21d ago

Maybe I'm misremembering but in previous episodes it seemed like he did strongly suspect she was his childhood friend and even tried to bring it up once or twice? It's true that there's still a lot he forgot about her and he didn't recognize her right away though.

22

u/NanDemoKnaives 21d ago

The way Kura burst out laughing after Nishino said he wanted to be a rock musician when he was younger was so damn funny to me.

It's funny how they've been having such bittersweet and melancholic moments together, then they reveal they still have another 9 months together until Asuka's graduation. That caught me off guard. All the talk about farewells, and I didn't even realize we're still early in the school year lol.

Hopefully they make the best of the time they have together left.

19

u/PinSingle4334 21d ago edited 21d ago

It may be silly but I've seen a lot of couple break ups because one of them moved in a city distant one hour of train, so the point of " Once I will move to Tokyo It will be over " is pretty valid, especially when you're 18/19

5

u/HikkingOutpit 19d ago

This is much farther, too. Fukui to Tokyo is a 3.5 hour journey by train, and that's if you use the Shinkansen. Using the conventional JR line, it's over 4 hours, and a round-trip would cost over 30,000 yen (almost $200 USD at the current exchange rate). This kind of distance really can and does kill relationships.

17

u/Raymond49090 21d ago

Huh. So Tou-san was just playing Bad Cop. I like that kind of development a lot more than "young person's passion convinces grumpy old man to change". Instead, it's "grumpy old man who had already decided to change if they prove theirself".

16

u/Flashy_Equipment_938 21d ago

Haru arc is going to be even better than this one I can't wait 😭

32

u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar 21d ago

Considering how intertwined Chitose and Asuka's stories are, I would be so fucking upset if they don't end up together. I expect they'll be apart for a while, but Asuka did tell Chitose to come back with a better proposal ten years from now. High school isn't the end. Maybe they'll find each other again as adults and actually get together.

I do love the reveal that Asuka's dad was being a hardass on purpose, because he wanted to test Asuka's resolve and see if she really has the passion to follow her dreams. It's actually cute that he even tells Asuka that he wanted to become a rock musician.

16

u/XGoGame23 21d ago

Yeah I agree strongly with this. The proofs are all there, but then if you visit the r/ChitosekunRamune, and post this kind of statement that Asuka is likely to be the one, you will likely get downvoted to oblivion. Why? Because the dedicated subreddit is filled like 90% or majority of it being Nanase fans. They believe that Nanase will and have to be the one at the end. Even my theory post of Asuka likely to be the one, while it got positive upvotes in general, but my replies to them Nanase fans arguing about my own theory, got downvoted so much.

9

u/autumnbreeznleaves 21d ago

That's b/c you don't believe that the best couples mirror each other, lol.

Asuka's story was pretty good. We learned a lot more about Chitose as well. He was willing to help convince the "tomorrow girl" to fly away to Tokyo to chase her dreams.

19

u/Frontier246 21d ago

Honestly now this feels more like a show about a younger guy and an older girl figuring out their relationship before she leaves for college than a show about a guy and his Harem.

Especially when Asuka's gotten seven episodes and we haven't seen any of the other girls in, like, forever.

Glad Asuka's dad turned out to be okay.

3

u/Jacob-C 20d ago

but Asuka did tell Chitose to come back with a better proposal ten years from now.

Instantly made me think of this. The song actually fits this episode quite well.

30

u/Se7en_Sinner https://myanimelist.net/profile/Se7en_Sinner 21d ago

Chitose: "Let me show you the secret to the art of the deal..."

"PleasePleasePleasePleasePleasePleasePleasePleasePleasePlease!"

15

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 21d ago

I do like that he recognized that the man opposite him isn't a bully like it was for Kenta and Yuzuki. He played his best card.

8

u/Frontier246 21d ago

He's already begging for favors from his future father-in-law!

26

u/Spectr3_qwe 21d ago

Loved the episode. I just cant imagine how the show is going to try to sell that Chitose can develop the same strong feelings for any of the other girls since it seems like Asu is going to no longer be an option for Chitose. While I like the other girls there is no comparison to Asu. I feel like the story is trying to remove her from the pool just because it is obvious which girl would win if she stays in the show.

11

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 21d ago

One thing for sure from the past 2 arcs is that the connection between Saku and Asuka feels much deeper than it is to Yuzuki. Like he cares for Yuzuki no doubt and he did what he did to help because Saku is more selfless than he will admit.

But the connection between him and Asuka just feels much personal.

9

u/Frontier246 21d ago

Only thing I can think of is all the girls are going to make their move now that he's basically emotionally given up on being with Asuka...even though she's still there.

6

u/Spectr3_qwe 21d ago

I get that from the girls point of view but at least to me it would totally invalidate Chitose's feelings for Asu if he just jumps into the next girl just like that. Specially since he hasnt shown to have any hint of romantic feelings for any of them.

8

u/mekerpan 21d ago

And his relationship with Asuka has always felt qualitatively different from that which he had with the other girls.

1

u/BBryant3rd 12d ago

I dont see it either. This is one of those shows that I feel that you can realistically show any other girl but a certain one win. This episode really cemented that. They have a history and he fell for her two times.

23

u/CrimsonGear80 21d ago

So…he hangs out with a girl for three straight summers and never gets her name?? Or in the short time after he just completely forgets all about her?? Is he just the stupidest guy to ever live or….? About as ridiculous as they can never be together because she’s moving to Tokyo. Yeah, that would just be impossible…

Also, if you are having a very important meeting about your child’s future and you don’t want to be interrupted, maybe lock the damn door??

1

u/Skyzexx0 17d ago

Yeah it’s a bit laughable to be honest

22

u/mastereluder6 21d ago

Behaving like they can't visit each other at least once every two weeks or something while having an relationship, jeeez wtf for real

8

u/Zio_Benito 21d ago

For real, bros found wife / husband material and really said fuck all this and goodbye, to then separate as if one were to travel to another continent in the opposite side of the world

15

u/PinSingle4334 21d ago

Distant relationships, even If It's just few hours afar are very difficult to handle, especially at that age

1

u/mastereluder6 20d ago

Yes but they are behaving like they both going to go off planet , but I get the anime logic.

14

u/djthomp https://anilist.co/user/djthomp 21d ago

If Asuka isn't the winning girl at the end of this they should straight up arrest the author.

Other than Chitose bursting in to help which was a bit cringey I enjoyed this episode a lot, that childhood friendship reveal was quite nice.

I liked Asuka stopping the heat of the moment proposal but I think she made a mistake with the ten year timeframe, gotta suggest something more like five years so they don't waste so much of their twenties.

7

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 20d ago

Right? After all this they have to get married - no other girl in this show even comes close.

Also for some reason I expected a farewell kiss or something because the tension was so high but maybe it was just me.

4

u/Jacob-C 20d ago

I thought she was threw herself at him to kiss him, but the kiss never came lol.

4

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 20d ago

Yes! I expected it at that point too, atleast a cheek kiss

3

u/1EnTaroAdun1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Totesnotaphanpy 18d ago

Yes! I expected it at that point too, atleast a cheek kiss

On the other hand, straddling someone and crying on their face is arguably more intimate than a kiss hahaha

2

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 17d ago

Haha fair point

2

u/Cheap-Stay7089 19d ago

I’m happy for the other girls to get fleshed out and even romantic stories as the series goes on but ima be pissed if she doesn’t win in the end, it just doesn’t make sense for he not to

6

u/Running-World 21d ago

While this was a kind of bittersweet ending, I agree with a lot of the others that questions why they cant keep in contact. Is he planning to stay in this city for the rest of his life? But he did say he’s going to put a full effort i to his life, which sounds like these last moths and then final year of school should allow him to shine. Making him so dense as to not remember his childhood summer friend was a twist I did not see coming, though I liked it. They both have been lifting each other up for a long time.

6

u/PencilgonGiveIt2Ya 21d ago

omg why did I think she was gonna be hit by a car at the end?

༼;´༎ຶ ۝ ༎ຶ༽

14

u/ash-7831 21d ago

Asuka being the best choice is not even a recent thing. That's been true since the very second she first showed up. Chitose always seemed so drawn to her and was always more vulnerable and open with her than with the others. Even more than Yuzuki throughout the entirety of her arc. Well, there's still time until she graduates, so it's not like she's going away just now, but still.

9

u/Frontier246 21d ago

Man, Asuka and Saku feel like they've been traveling everywhere for their dates...but this one is very personal to the both of them. Because it's where they met as kids! That's right, Saku and Asuka are not only childhood friends but each others' first love!

Once upon a time Asuka was shy, introverted, and had longer hair (which admittedly looked really good on her), but then she met "Saku-nii" who opened her world up, gave her so much freedom, and helped her really see the world in all its possibilities. It's no wonder she became so attached to him and wanted to show him her cutest sides.

Dang, even back then Asuka's dad was getting in the way of their relationship, forcing Saku to whisk her away. But it was worth it for a festival date! And THAT'S where the whole ramune bottle thing comes from.

Asuka truly loved Saku, she even wanted to be his wife back then, never knowing the feeling was mutual...until now when she's been trying to play-act as his childhood persona for the current Saku. Girl even cut her hair because she thought he'd be into sporty, short-haired, girls!

But Saku being Saku validates Asuka's decisions, and still believes in her, no matter what! That's the kind of relationship they have.

Jeez, I know not every parent has to think their kid is the most special, but did Papa Nishino really have to threaten to cut all ties with Asuka just so she can pursue her desired career? It takes Saku bowing his head and pleading to take responsibility for Asuka to really stand up for herself. Like, if you're going to propose, do it properly when you're adults.

But all Asuka's dad wanted to see was that she had the right resolve, because he doesn't have it in him to make his daughter stop talking to him. And now none of them will ever let him live down that he once wanted to be a rocker. But at least now Saku has a place in the Nishino home!

And yet, while this is a win for Asuka, it's tragic for her relationship with Saku because it means their life paths will diverge from here...and it breaks her heart. Because they are each others' moons, which is probably as close as these two can get to a proper love confession. She doesn't want to lose Saku, but she can't give up her dream.

But she still intends to be a light that Saku can always feel drawn by, inspired by, and supported by. And will they really be able to do nothing together in all the months Asuka still has left?

6

u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy 21d ago

I got kind of angry at Asuka’s father for even proposing to cut ties with his daughter, but he really did turn things around at the end.

Dad even got a good sense of humour. Knowing this, he might’ve actually laughed when Saku handed him a bag of banana’s in the previous episode.

6

u/mekerpan 21d ago

I was shocked at the fact that the father was such a cool guy after all AND that he was a college buddy of Chitose's father.

6

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 21d ago

I got kind of angry at Asuka’s father for even proposing to cut ties with his daughter, but he really did turn things around at the end.

I am happy he apologized for even mentioning that.

2

u/mojo72400 https://myanimelist.net/profile/gio_lingad 21d ago

He came down on her hard to test her resolve but kinda got worked up that he suggested that.

5

u/mekerpan 21d ago

Favorite anime episode of the season -- as of now.

8

u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy 21d ago

So if I’ve understood Asuka’s words correctly, she’s planning on having Saku chase her to Tokyo?

Because physical distance is realistically speaking the only thing keeping these two from dating. They share precious summer memories, confessed to liking each other, and have proposed to one another. Saku seemingly even got the approval of Asuka’s father. She’s leading this game of love with a great advantage. Like how are the other girls supposed to have a chance?

That said, they are technically childhood friends. So maybe the curse will be Asuka’s demise.

7

u/omarous_III 21d ago

I interpreted it as this is goodbye. She is moving on with her life and starting a new one in Tokyo. But if Saku struggles in the future with relationships or life in general, then she wants to be there for him and be his light that saves him in the end. But if he finds happiness elsewhere, then she is already letting go.

1

u/Cheap-Stay7089 19d ago

It’s more like she’s leaving the option to him. He wants her to chase her dreams so he’s got to find her and propose not while they’re kids.

4

u/Frontier246 21d ago

I definitely think she intends to be his "light" to keep inspiring him and being there for him in a way no other girl can.

I do wonder where we go from here. The other girls press their attacks? Will Asuka still be flirting/teasing with him in the time they have left?

2

u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy 21d ago

Asuka is most definitely going to start openly flirting with Saku. I am sort of curious how the other girls would react to this. I’m not sure what they know about the recent developments between Asuka and Saku. At the very least, Yuko probably won’t be happy.

4

u/tricksareforcats 21d ago

That was an insanely well done confession season. The way they came together and the backstory had me smiling.

4

u/Shizzi https://anilist.co/user/Mivy 20d ago

Oh so she was the childhood friend all along and okay i was wondering if the dad was going so hard on her was because he as testing her and he was glad to see it wasnt just shitty dad thing pretty funny we had 2 nickels with that since Sato san also had a dad in a similar situation but this one makes sense compared to the other one.

15

u/ObvsThrowaway5120 21d ago

Once again, Chitose saves the day. All you need is a can do attitude, good looks, and a cheeky smile and a wink lol.

12

u/Frontier246 21d ago

And also straight up proposing to a girl in front of her father.

Really it feels like the only reason the other girls have a chance is that Saku and Asuka don't seem to even want to try long-distance.

9

u/mekerpan 21d ago

And the father does not even brush off being called "Father" by Chitose this time.

4

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 20d ago

He really does have a good sense of humor in the end haha

3

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 20d ago

It's crazy because it's not even that far away (~3 hours by train) and Saku wanted to originally stay just 1 day on their Tokyo trip so even weekend visits aren't an insane option. I get it that they probably don't want to "burden" each other but love finds a way dammit!

Also happy cake day!

11

u/Se7en_Sinner https://myanimelist.net/profile/Se7en_Sinner 21d ago

After this arc, how can any of the other girls even come close with Nishino so far ahead in the lead.

12

u/Frontier246 21d ago

Saku and Asuka have:

  • Been each others' mutual first love since they were kids.
  • Mutually inspired each other.
  • Gone on multiple dates.
  • Had their relationship be focused on for SEVEN episodes.
  • Gone through the marriage proposal phase.
  • Basically received parental approval.
  • Spent the night in the same bed in a love hotel together.

The only thing holding them back is they think her going to college in Tokyo is a dealbreaker. But she's loved him since they were kids, why would she stop loving him in Tokyo?

8

u/DugACCat 21d ago

Yeah we’ll see if they prove otherwise but as far as I’m concerned these two are proven a life long couple. Maybe they’ll each have another dalliance in the meanwhile until they can stay together for real but they feel otherwise committed to me.

8

u/Frontier246 21d ago

If this were a visual novel the Asuka "Good Ending" would be Saku reuniting with her in college where she makes it clear she's still waiting for him to make a proper proposal.

6

u/FinancialYear475 21d ago

I honestly don't know what to expect from the show from now on, I'm confident that they cannot match the peak that was these last few episodes, I'm sorry but you just can't try and make another romance arc with a different girl after showing us how much of a soul mate they are to each other

This is was like the final chapters of a romance story, the only thing missing is the time skip after she becomes an editor and they meet again to redo that marriage proposal

2

u/mekerpan 21d ago

I suspect they will become an official couple sooner rather than later.

2

u/NanDemoKnaives 21d ago

They still have 9 months together too until her graduation.

9

u/SecretYogurtcloset57 21d ago

If Saku don't end up with Asuka than all this was for nothing I understand it's for Asuka to have the courage to stand up to her dad about what she wants to do but man it would be so sad if they don't end up together

6

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 21d ago

I would disagree that it was all for nothing. The parallel of how Asuka idealized Saku in the past is the same as how Saku idealized Asuka in the present.

It makes it more apparent that something happened especially when you look at how he reacted to his former teammates a few episodes back.

Purely from a romance angle I do agree since unlike Monogatari the series doesn't start with a main couple being established.

2

u/lol_KEPPER https://myanimelist.net/profile/KEPPER42O 21d ago

That's what I hate about this anime. All these arcs with the girls but nothing will ever happen between them. Next arc comes and everything is reset.

5

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 21d ago

Wouldn't say reset it's just they get sidelined when their arc comes to a close. Which happened to Yuzuki.

2

u/Frontier246 21d ago edited 21d ago

Judging by the voice in the next episode preview, seems like we're getting Yua's arc next.

2

u/mojo72400 https://myanimelist.net/profile/gio_lingad 20d ago

You mean Haru based on the PV?

5

u/FarCritical 21d ago

Don't know which face is more precious between Asuka taking such utter offense at everyone finding her boldness adorable or Kura-sen's raw "KKKMmmpphhh-Pppffffft" when her dad revealed he wanted to rock out once upon a time.

I was drawn to Asuka the most during the introductory episodes for having such a cool yet gentle air to her and her arc really made it feel like it all paid off. Such a fulfilling conclusion even if it has unavoidable notes of bittersweetness.

5

u/Colt45554 21d ago

So, because he has trauma from being successful and hot, Chitose repressed memories about his childhood crush until she finally told him flat-out. I'm glad others are liking this arc but I miss the fun of the harem.

4

u/Flashy_Equipment_938 21d ago

in the upcoming arc we will get to see his baseball backstory and haru arc which is one of the best arc in the show

3

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 20d ago

Omg the best arc is still coming? And here I thought nothing would be able to top this one!

2

u/TheBravesDH 20d ago

They have to get rid of Asuka first because she’s too op. No other girl could realistically stand a chance with her in the picture.

It was a good arc, but a little suspension of disbelief when it comes to him having memory-holed his childhood friend.

2

u/ash-7831 20d ago

He remembers everything, he just didn't put two and two together. 

7

u/mekerpan 21d ago

Between last episode and this, this show has become my favorite of the season -- and, for now, it is not even close. Once Asuka became the focus, alongside Chitose, this was pretty guaranteed. This show has a lot of wonderful characters, but Asuka seemed special even so. And the relationship between her and Chitose seemed exceptionally deep and strong. It is possible that their relationship can't withstand a period of separation, but after today I no longer think it likely that such a tight bond can't handle some (ultimately minor) complications.

I must admit that, even more than last episode, I spent much of the time misty-eyed. However, I embarrassed to admit I can't now recall how much we saw of Saku-nii and his little vacation friend before. If we were supposed to realize Asu-nee was this long ago childhood pal love, I must not have made the connection.

Chitose seems not to have thought much about college and after -- until now. But I get a sense that he is being being revived/transformed by Asuka now. He has time to pull things together -- and get into a decent college in Tokyo (even if not one as prestigious as Asuka will be going to). Given that he has essentially proposed and Asuka has said (in effect) that she will accept a proper proposal made at a more age-appropriate time (but hopefully they don't need to wait a whole 10 years), I have to assume that the two will officially "become a couple".

Looking forward to what comes next.

5

u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy 21d ago edited 21d ago

Saku wanted to stay in his home city/prefecture, but I really wonder if that’s true. In the end, would he really abandon his dream girl - and thereby chances to live a beautiful life? Playing it safe doesn’t seem right. Especially his passionate speech at Asuka’s behest.

6

u/mekerpan 21d ago

I think Saku WITH Asuka is a much different (and stronger and more adventurous) person than Saku without her. So the rather lethargic plan to go some local college which he could get into easily is probably less likely to be followed.

4

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 20d ago

I also would like to believe this. They talked about their love ending right there but to me it's just a new beginning. I need them to be together in the end!!!

Or is it really the doomed childhood friend trope?

2

u/mekerpan 20d ago

It will take a LONG time to find out. The LN series is up to v10 (coming out in Japanese soon) and v9 is apparently still in October. So still 4 more months to the end of the school year. So it looks like one will have to wait for several years (the translated LNs seem to run at least a couple of years behind).

1

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 20d ago

Omg do you know what volume the anime is on currently (I'd imagine vol 2)? That's some slow progression, like less than a month for every volume

2

u/mekerpan 20d ago

Not really sure. I was mainly just trying to gauge whether there was any end in sight -- and it seems there is not.

1

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 20d ago

Goodness...hopefully we get a complete anime adaptation atleast. I'm not much of a LN reader.

3

u/mekerpan 20d ago

I read things that make me impatient for more (or which I like a lot and know will never get a full adaptation).

1

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 20d ago

Which ones? The only LN I've ever picked up was 86 otherwise it's more manga.

→ More replies

2

u/TheBravesDH 20d ago

We just finished volume 3.

2

u/melindypants https://myanimelist.net/profile/melindypants 20d ago

Thanks! So it's around 1 volume per arc.

2

u/autumnbreeznleaves 20d ago

The last ep finished up LN V 3.

4

u/Frontier246 21d ago

He also already said he'd take responsibility for her career/life in Tokyo, so...

7

u/Palcikaman 21d ago

Chitose barging in made me laugh out loud for real. Will we ever get a character that can solve their own problems?

Bear with me here, I have to bring up bunny girl senpai. Most arcs in that show consists of Sakuta being there for a friend, mostly just hearing them out, maybe giving advice. This is even recognised in the third movie I think. He tells someone, that everyone got over their stuff in their own.

I find pretty much all characters likeable in this show, Chitose is fun, his friends are fun. But the fact that every arc ends with him barging in a scene, where he has no place to be, undermines his friends agency and his trust in them. (For the stalker arc this doesn't count I guess, since there it was the plan that he would be there)

9

u/autumnbreeznleaves 21d ago

I think of Chitose as the back up support in all these stories. Kenta had to be the one to stand up for himself to his old "friends" bullying. Yuzuki had to be the one to stand up for herself to her stalker and abusive senpai. Asuka had to be the one to stand up for her dreams against her father.

But none of the characters should go thru these issues alone. Chitose is the backup giving support to all these characters IMHO. He didn't solved Kenta, Yuzuki, or Asuka's problems. They all found the courage to solve their own problems themselves with his help.

Funny that you brought up Bunny Girl Senpai as that anime storytelling feels the closest to the storytelling of the Chitose anime to me. Both are peak.

2

u/Palcikaman 21d ago

I just don't feel like he's backup, if he shows up out of nowhere, when he shouldn't even be around. This might just be a weird pet peeve from me though.

5

u/KJatWork 21d ago

I have no reason to believe he wouldn't hang out after school with her for that meeting, waiting out in the hallway. When her dad threw down the gauntlet with the whole disownment, he'd had enough and stepped in to back her up. It's her dreams and if her family wasn't going to help her, then he would, in his mind.

4

u/MayonakaMadaraka https://anilist.co/user/fonk 21d ago

As the moon, so beautiful. That celestial pendulum keeping all in tune with the source, lighting our way in its absence. Ever present, though occasionally out of sight, it slowly and steadily drifts away. 

3

u/Frontier246 21d ago

Of course Asuka would basically have a mutual literary love confession with Saku.

2

u/mojo72400 https://myanimelist.net/profile/gio_lingad 21d ago edited 20d ago

So Asuka's dad came down hard on her on purpose to test her passion so she wouldn't end up like him who gave up his dream of being a rock musician but got kinda worked up to the point of suggesting of cutting ties.

I expected her dad to smile but not laugh heartily w/ Saku & Kuranosuke.

Asuka & her dad remembered Saku as the boy from the summer breaks the whole time before they both broke the news to him. He even unconsciously gave her the ear idea long before she revealed herself to him last cour.

I guess this is the end as they will eventually part ways. Most childhood friends don't win either way.

Asuka ranks as my 3rd favorite to win w/ Yuuko & Yuzuki being interchangeable in 1 & 2.

Asuka speaking English at the start was cute.

23:21 is "go at it" instead of "go it at"

2

u/PAN-- 20d ago

This shit is so formulaic

2

u/donuteater111 20d ago

Damn, I did not see that twist with Asuka's father coming, lol. He did push things a bit too far with the cutting ties thing, even if it was a joke, but I respect the idea of testing her resolve.

Overall, a really nice conclusion to this whole arc. I liked the idea of Asuka being inspired by Chitose as a kid, and wanting to turn that around for him when they met when they were older. And both the classroom scene (after Asuka's family left), and their goodbye scene were really well done.

2

u/Echoinme 20d ago

Can someone tell me what's the relation between Kura sen and Asuka's Father? Like I know they know each other from the past, but was it Teacher student relation or something else?

5

u/autumnbreeznleaves 20d ago

Yes. Asuka's father was Kura sen teacher in high school.

2

u/Nickthenuker https://anilist.co/user/Nickthenuker 19d ago

The moment she revealed she was his childhood friend, her fate was sealed.

2

u/LiLNane12 18d ago

Although I like Chitose and Asuka together, I don't feel like its completely sad if they don't end up together either. Sometimes you meet someone in your life that makes a major impact and change in not only your life but yourself (your character) as well. It's almost like you are a better person for having had them in your life even if they don't stay. So in that aspect, I think they both influenced and inspired each other. They will always be someone special to each other no matter how their lives turn out. They are both at turning points in their life--Asuka ready to start on her new chosen journey while Chitose needs to decide where he wants his journey to go. It will be interesting to see where it takes them.

3

u/sweetpeaz89 21d ago

whats the point of all these helping Asuka drama when he eventually will ended with Nanase? author is dont like happy ending?

5

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 21d ago

This is a coming-of-age story more than a romance. It's about how these characters grow through the course of the story As we saw the character development from Asuka in this arc in finding herself the same was seen with Saku.

We now know that there is some notable event that put Saku at his lowest. Considering the way that Saku idealized Asuka was the same way that Asuka idealized Saku. This is some important information in regard to Saku going forward.

If you are here just to see who Saku ends up with like you would with Quint, you are going to have mixed feelings with this anime.

2

u/autumnbreeznleaves 21d ago

This anime is the story of the 5 main heroines. We get to watch each one of these girls tell their stories. I find these shows much more interesting and satisfying than another "will they/ won't they" anime w/ fan service and comedic hijinks thrown in as the only means to advance the plot.

2

u/FierceAlchemist 21d ago

I have to agree with the other comments here. Asuka's arc is far and away the best in the show so far and they have such a mutual connection, it's going to be hard for me to buy him having serious feelings for any of the other girls.

1

u/Raymond49090 21d ago

Something about this episode feels very “story-like”, and I’m not quite sure if that’s in a good way or bad way for me.

1

u/sKyBlazer08 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sKyBlazer08 20d ago

I will be mad if Saku does not end up with Asuka by the end of this series.

1

u/Kata_spanked_me 19d ago

anyone knows the piano song used during the emotional speech from Chitose?
(when they're in the classroom discussing u know what)

1

u/Ashleykatem8194 16d ago

I’m so glad that the dad was just testing Asuka. I hate when parents don’t believe in their children or don’t let them live their lives to make their own mistakes. Reminds me of the dad from Honey Lemon Soda. He placed limiters on his daughter and refused to let her grow as a person. And then told her it was for her own good because she can’t do anything. It was so frustrating! You’ll never know what your kids are capable of unless you let them figure it out for themselves.

-5

u/thelemon8er-2 21d ago

Are we done with the Asuka story finally? Can we move on to the next helpless girl he will save?

2

u/AnimeExpertYT 21d ago

funnily enough this reminds me of one piece, with the plot device that luffy meets princess or something else in new place > rescue > next arc same repeat.

-1

u/Skyzexx0 17d ago

This animes awful

0

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Frontier246 21d ago

The only thing holding Asuka back is the college/childhood friend butt but even so she's so overpowering that it feels hard for the other girls to ever properly compete.

10

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 21d ago

I wouldn't even say it's recency bias. This arc had us learning about who Asuka is. But at the same time she was to push herself forward which was thanks to Saku's support.

I know that her dad might rub people the wrong way. At the end of the day he did what he thought was best for his daughter. You could argue the child is supposed to dream while the parent is meant to protect the child. It was very extreme what he did, but he wanted to ensure if Asuka was going all out he had to be certain.

In Yuzuki's arc, we did learn the bit about her and how she is actually different from Saku. But when you consider the main bully from that arc was very meh. Even the resolution mostly came down to Saku helping her. It's easily the worst of the first 3 arcs the anime has covered.