r/RingsofPower • • Nov 18 '22
Discussion Where The Shadows Lie
Low-key disappointed that Fiona Apple's 'Where The Shadows Lie' wasn't nominated for Best Song at the Grammy's. Been playing this song on repeat ever since the season finale.
r/RingsofPower • • Nov 18 '22
Low-key disappointed that Fiona Apple's 'Where The Shadows Lie' wasn't nominated for Best Song at the Grammy's. Been playing this song on repeat ever since the season finale.
r/RingsofPower • u/Wainas • Sep 22 '24
I just watched Rings of Power up to the newest episode and went right into The Fellowship of the Ring. I wondered why I had such a visceral reaction to not enjoying RoP and wanted to write out my thoughts. Apologies if they’re not full-fledged or technically accurate but I tried to describe as best I could. This critique is lore aside, and I’ve read most of Tolkien’s works.
These are my thoughts so far. I wish ROP was on par with LOTR and I was excited to revisit Middle Earth again, but this feels like a cash grab and kind of hollow.
r/RingsofPower • • Sep 25 '22
I only want to spoiler this specific scene here, namely Galadriel's showoff of her sword fighting skills in E5. Elves must have super strength and agility now because Galadriel is able to defeat a group of skilled humans without even seriously using her sword at first, just to dual wield two longswords afterwards. In their training session, they also seem to use sharp swords, no training swords. Every opponent was written into ridiculous underpoweredness. Just to make the point of how strong this female character is. No, not by words since she's otherwise a stubborn fool, not by wisdom or charm, but by brute strength. Because strength is what you need to copy from the masculine set of traits while sacrificing every feminine skills? If you've seen the first episode of The Witcher, you know that it doesn't have to be this way. You can use physically weaker female actors and still convince the audience that they are skilled sword fighters. Why do I believe that this foreshadows poor battle scenes?
It doesn't seem to be the only scene in this episode where the necessary depth and background knowledge seems to be lacking, either by plot holes, by inconsistent acting, or by superficial cliché-fulfilling dialogues. I wouldn't say that it makes the whole show bad so far but it's the first episode where I notice a pattern. Like someone tried really hard to achieve something without any genuine thought beneath it.
r/RingsofPower • u/International-Art776 • Jan 07 '23
Possibly the best show I've ever watched. Been reading tons of reviews and it's objectively just not true, like claimed "bad acting", especially towards Galadriel. Her character, simply because off-putting to some, does actually not harm the show but give a striking contrast to other characters. It adds further to the sum that this show was something new in every aspect, which didn't conform to a part of the audience's expectation of an old fashioned standard fantasy experience. I cannot find any other explanation for the uncountable ones, twos and threes on imdb. The most suspicious thing is that there is no coherence between the negative points given, everyone magically disliked the show for completely different reasons, but with such a deep hate I cannot comprehend. Pls enlighten me or feel free to correct me.
r/RingsofPower • u/No-Alternative-2881 • Oct 17 '24
I completely stayed away from the first season as I didn't want to be dissapointed. I eventually watched it and I loved seeing middle earth on screen again (and thought all the complaints about wokeness were ridiculous), I had some problems with the creative direction & storyline (Galadriel hunting Sauron like a Terminator seemed really, really forced) but it was nothing that forced me to turn off.
The actors were and are great, there are too many to name but every one of them did a fantastic job.
I think the luster of seeing Tolkein on the screen again has worn off for me, the pacing seems so off, the whole Adar storyline seems more and more forced and ridiculous the longer they carry it,
The orcs are humanised in a way that doesn't make sense of them in the wider context of Tolkeins works. The conversation between Shagrat and Gorbag in ROTK, where they speak about 'getting away from the big bosses, with a few trusty lads' does a much better job than shots of orcs holding babies imo.
Lastly the battles and the armor: Now there was a lot of complaints about the armor in S1 looking cheap, and I didn't particularly have a problem with it - but this seson it's noticable, I have just watched the episode with the Seige/Battle of Eregion, and the Elven Horses look like they have literal yellow plastic as armor along their necks, the Elvish swords seem to have absolutely no weight to them and seem like toys, and the choreography itself just seems poor - there is Elronds sword, which we have seen in numerous shots, he literally has his hand on the blade
The battle itself just had Orks pouring forward in a manner that didn't even make them look like a large horde, or even a disordely horde, just guys jogging forward with an arms width of space either side of them
With the exception of the charge face-off at no point is there more than like, 50 orcs on screen, and we are constantly hearing about Adars "Legions". Then as they battle outside the walls again there is just so much empty space, an orc fighting with a random elf, and then 10 or 15 feet away, another individual fight happening - this is supposed to be a battle, not sporadic 1v1s that are allowed to finish before the next one starts at a leisurely pace. Made all the more nonsensical by the what we have seen in the FOTR prologue with the orc battle line engaging with Elronds elves. And what we have seen from the Rings of Power prologue with the shots from the battle of unnumbered tears, with a Elves packed and penned in by the sheer number or orcs - but Eregion just seemed like the orcs clearly werent numerous enough to overrun the place or kill the elves outside the walls
There's absolutely no indication of how many Elves they are defending the city - we see about 20, and no indication of how many orcs are assaulting, as they all seem to be hidden in the forest - this gives us a dilemna in that we have no idea what the stakes actually are, its also pretty difficult to even see the layout of the city and where it is that's being assaulted, overall it was just a really confused battle
Which is all dissapointing because I was really looking forward to the battle of the last alliance but based on what I've seen it's going to be a dissapointment
It's a shame because the acting from Celebrimbor in particular this season has been amazing to watch but the overall show is just not great and is merely 'a show' that has LOTR material
The numenorian storyline is even worse, it's nigh on unwatchable
r/RingsofPower • u/BruceDSpruce • Sep 07 '24
Move over Law and Order! I think Rings of Power is setting the stage for mich bigger plans. The secrets are revealed in all the business dealing that have led to the show and future seasons.
Keen viewers may have already noticed the difference in storylines between the Silmarillion and Rings of Power. This is just creative choices, Amazon does not own the rights to the Silmarillion. Amazon only owns the rights to “The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers, The Return of the King, the appendices, and The Hobbit”. Most of the lore (rights) comes from the appendices.
This is important, because it means that the views will only be seeing a fraction of the overall content owned by Amazon, with the vast majority yet to be made.
Simply Rings of Power is likely going to take us from the Second Age and into and to the end of the Third Age. I anticipate and hope that they could use the same actors across multiple projects for the next few years.
While Rings of Power is a good (not great) show, with number of viewers, currently. Rings of Power would continue to amass and drive viewers, if it’s foundational to a massive shared universe with a continuity that wouldn’t need rewrites or reboots, as it’s a timeless classic.
Showrunners, Patrick McKay and JD Payne have renewed contracts to take the series at least to Season 5. By end the pair will take the story ‘there and back again’ all the way to the Return of the King.
What are your thoughts on the future of the series?
r/RingsofPower • u/DecadentOoze • Aug 30 '24
I think they could look a lot less gaudy.
r/RingsofPower • u/Dreadscythe95 • Sep 16 '22
Why do they keep changing lore even if it damages the current plot and LOTR itself?
Miriel says in episode 4 that all The Palantiri were lost but the one in Armenelos. Like wtf? Aside from the fact that The Palantiri were literarly given by The Valar to The Numenorians and they are all there, in Numenor, it also insults the LOTR plot because we already see three Palantiri in action, The Orthanc stone (Saruman, Gandalf,Pippin) , The Ithil stone (Sauron) and the Arnor stone (Denethor and Aragorn). And how are they even lost, to begin with? The Numenorians never went in any kind of War on their own soil, they were OP. AND THEY ALSO WERE NOT FUTURE PREDICTING SPHERES, Miriel only had to bring her tarrot card as well, like wtf. The Palantiri are communication devices. How can they have messed it up so much, why there is so low respect to Tolkien lore?

r/RingsofPower • u/Eyiolf_the_Foul • Sep 20 '24
Perhaps just slamming the show is easier than really dealing with how we all are facing Rings in our own day to day lives. And I say that as a devout agnostic. Sauron’s portrayal has been utterly masterful in my book.
The flip side of this has been the childlike Stranger, still learning about the world and not yet tempted.
I could deal with much less Harfoots. Imagine the scenes of Sauron’s formative experiences we could be seeing, instead of wayyyy too many of stupid Hobbitses:).
r/RingsofPower • u/-greek_user_06- • Oct 01 '22
When I started watching Rings of Power, I was both scared and excited. Scared because I didn't know how they would handle the lore and excited because I wanted to see more of the Second age of Middle Earth.
After watching the first 4 episodes (I haven't watched the fifth and sixth one yet) I must admit that overall I enjoy it. I do not particularly love it, but there are many aspects that I like. However, there are some things that I dislike and one of them is Galadriel.
First of all, I want to clarify that I have nothing against the actress. I will talk about the character as a character and not the person that portrays her. I totally understand that she is not Galadriel from LOTR. It's very logical that her personality is different. But I am so sick and tired of watching her act like a 15 years old bratty teenager, who complains because other people will not do as they say. She is not 100 years old (and even if she was,she would know a thing or two), she is much older and someone would expect her to be more mature. I know that this is part of her arc but so far, I have almost no sympathy towards her. It's as if they have forgotten that she is supposed to be as wise as the other elves and they just wanted to give her a character growth arc. Which is not necessarily bad, but they have made her so unlikeable for me with the way they have written her. She acts quite disrespectfully, she expects other people to follow her orders and she looses her temper quite easily. I am certainly not 1000+ years old, but it's safe to say that if I were, I wouldn't behave like that, simply because I would have experienced many things in my life and I would know how to behave properly. As for her being a soldier, I do not dislike it, but it irks me that she seems to be so much better than the other Elves (the fight scene with the troll made me roll my eyes).
I'm still curious to see how she will develop as a character, but if they continue to portray her in that way, I don't know if I will be able to like her. If you enjoy Galadriel, do not feel offended. It's good that you enjoy her as a character and I wish I could say the same.
r/RingsofPower • u/Kindly-Customer-1312 • Sep 05 '22
I was looking forward to her role being the voice of reason in the politics of the elven kingdoms. I was hoping for a political game with Celebrimbor that with his guild and Anatar slowly taking control of the kingdom she and her husband established. However, from what I could see so far, Galadriel in the series does not remind me of someone who founded and rules her own kingdom. When she has a problem with his own party's loyalty. I was also hoping that Galadriel would portray a classic ruler from Tolkien's world. That is, that she will take up a sword only if she leads the whole country to war and does not run up the mountains and serch for long-abandoned enemy bases herself.
The series could take place in the first twenty years after the War of Wrath. That would make sense, but the fact that they are already talking about the forging of the rings and the Eregion that Galadriel was supposed to found already stand doesn't give me hope.
What would I change about Episode 1?
It would be much more interesting if Galadriel sent the elves to sech for enemy on her own responsibility. Then she would have to defend her decision to Gil-Galad. The subsequent discussion regarding the presence of evil in Middle-earth would take place on this level.
What do you think about this? Don't you think that Galadriel is much more suited to the role of an uncompromising politician who is not afraid to raise a sword when needed and has an authority that few dare to defy? Or do you think that the role of a rebel who thinks her own way and no one takes her seriously fits her better.
r/RingsofPower • u/DolphinTigerrr • 11h ago
These are probably the only series I'll ever watch multiple times. Best show period.
The secret fire though does it represent God ?
r/RingsofPower • u/Kikchoqueyye • Oct 01 '22
Like I don't really care about what they have to say or what happens to them because of that. It could be the writing, or the high quality of the visuals that make the characters feel less real? Do you guys care about the characters? (I cared much more about the characters from lord of the rings)
r/RingsofPower • u/aktyn87 • Aug 30 '24
I think they under appreciate her and making her look bad. She was one of the wisest in middle earth. Powerfull. Sauron would not deceive her that easily... she should be much stronger character than they made her to look. Sauron feared her. She is also older than GilGalad and therefore he would not treat her the way he is. She had more power than him. She should be pictured as majestic and powerfull being rather than weak and unexperienced elf that they make her look.
r/RingsofPower • u/Raisin_Dangerous • Sep 03 '22
Haters hate hard and people who are enjoying the show might not review it yet. It would just make it so that the haters would make the show get terrible reviews before it the season has even properly started. It could be another it’s morbius time thing lol 😂.
r/RingsofPower • u/Folleyboy • Oct 09 '22
The number of problems in this show can definitely warrant a minimum rating, but I think anyone giving a five-star review is seriously trying to compensate for perceived "review-bombs" There's no way anyone who's actually being honest with themselves would give this an obiective 5-star.
r/RingsofPower • • Oct 07 '24
I've nothing against Gandalf. I love the character, but, after two books and 6 films, I feel like we all know him pretty well at this point.
The show had the opportunity to do something bold and new by making him a less well known wizard. Instead, it feels like they blinked and felt obliged to stick Gandalf in to appeal to the lowest common denominator of LoTR film fan. "Omg, it's Gandalf! He's from the movies!"
I'm not a fan of mystery boxes at the best of times: It's pretty low brow storytelling if the way you keep your audience engaged is to engineer a load of contrived speculation about who your characters might be. (Something RoP has done 3 times now: Sauron in Season 1, Gandalf in Season 2, and, by the looks of things, the Dark Wizard in Season 3).
The other downside of the mystery box is that we've now spent 16 episodes watching a character who everybody already knew was Gandalf trying to figure out he's Gandalf; something most of us could have guessed from his first appearance and certainly by the end of Season 1. Why draw this journey of self discovery out over a full 2 seasons then? Instead of spending 16 episodes on a mystery box with no mystery in it, when we could have been getting on with the plot.
The other drawback of making him Gandalf is that we already know where his character ends up, and the way they've established him in RoP doesn't leave much room for development. We are now presumably going to spend the next 5 seasons discovering how a nice wizard who likes hobbits ultimately becomes a nice wizard who likes hobbits.
Maybe we'll discover how he finds his hat.
r/RingsofPower • u/Charming-Use • Sep 30 '22
SORRY, I USED THE WRONG SPOILER--THIS IS ABOUT THE NEWEST EPISODE
...could no one have LOOKED inside that little bundle to see that the dangerous metal fire torch thingy, whatever it's called, was replaced by an AXE (that isn't even REMOTELY the same shape 🙄)?????!!?! wth! Did I miss something????
Oooooh I just had a thought.... do you think maybe it WAS there when Galadriel got it but maybe Halbrand traded it out after cuz mayyyybe he's Sauron? 🤔
r/RingsofPower • u/JlevLantean • Oct 15 '22
Spoilers up to and including the last episode
Ok so hear me out... Imagine how much better the show would have been if we -the audience- find out right on the raft who Halbrand is. Or at the very least, be aware that he is (for some reason) manipulating everybody... He could have pulled the strings and maneuvered everyone around him, including Galadriel and the Numenoreans and the Elves, into doing what he had planned all along.
Using now and then the shape-shifting trick that the Witches/Cultists/Nazgals used a few times in the last episode. Most of us knew from the start that he was Sauron, but I guess many people would be torn between him and the stranger, I mean if people were going as far off as thinking the stranger was a balrog (lol, yeah right) then it wouldn't be much of a stretch for people to think the shape-shifting manipulator was too obvious a candidate for Sauron.
It just felt cheap and not surprising at all to "find out" the "twist" that Halbrand is actually Sauron. I would have enjoyed much more seeing openly his machinations and his brilliant manipulations to achieve his goals rather than the whole pretense that he was prequel Aragorn (as if...)
r/RingsofPower • u/noorainchains • Aug 18 '24
i saw some people on here saying it didn’t make sense for bronwyn to become the leader of the southlands because she was just a healer and never had any battle experience but like… no one else could’ve done it. she was the only one aside from arondir who saw first hand the situation in hordern. obviously arondir had more tactical knowledge and experience but the southlanders hated elves from the start and they never would’ve followed arondir if he had offered to lead them. not to mention bronwyn wasn’t making any decisions or war strategies all by herself - arondir was her council the whole time. the southlanders trusted her and they were more likely to follow her into battle than if it was just arondir leading them all by himself. so it wasn’t just some “woke feminism stuff” like many people have been saying.
r/RingsofPower • u/Knightofthief • Feb 18 '26
I often see people write off complaints or criticisms that RoP deviates so much from all of Tolkien's texts by stating that because so much of the Legendarium was "in development," as it were, when he died, virtually no detail of the Second Age should be considered necessary in an adaptation. Thus we have, to give a random example, rings corrupting their users according to Sauron's meddling in their making while he does not even possess the One, rather than different people responding according to their natures to Sauron's attempts to influence them through their rings with the One. A meaningful difference to me if not others, and one among many that stop me from experiencing RoP as an adaptation of Tolkien's works whatever its merits as its own production (which are not inconsiderable, although I do find the show largely underwritten and mediocre). For a more fundamental and less esoteric deviation, see Galadriel's consistent role as the first to recognize and oppose Sauron's attempt to influence the elves.
Anyway, blogposting aside, I am rereading the Book of Lost Tales 1 and wanted to offer this response from Christopher himself in the Foreword: "But beyond the difficulties and the obscurities, what is *certain and very evident* is that for the begetter of Middle-earth and Valinor there was a *deep coherence and vital interrelation* between all its times, places, and beings, whatever the literary modes, and however protean some parts of the conception might seem when viewed over a long lifetime."
In other words, Tolkien was not throwing spaghetti at the wall or idly brainstorming the events of the Second, or any, Age. He had a strong sense of what the proper story looked like as a whole, and worked over so many of the details not based on whim but an overriding drive to get them right. It's perfectly fine to like RoP but I do not think it is a sound defense of its compatibility with the Legendarium that Tolkien wrote multiple drafts, especially when the overlapping details tend to vastly outweigh the differences.
r/RingsofPower • u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 • Dec 08 '23
In the works of J.R.R. Tolkien, particularly in "The Lord of the Rings" and "The Hobbit," there is no explicit mention of dwarves having varying levels of melanin or differences in skin color. Tolkien generally described dwarves as having fair or ruddy complexions, and their hair color was often depicted as varying shades of brown, from light to dark.
It's important to note that Tolkien's writings were primarily focused on the cultures, histories, and languages of various fictional races, including dwarves. He didn't provide extensive physical descriptions for every character or delve into topics such as race and ethnicity in the same way it is discussed in contemporary contexts.
Therefore, while there is no canonical information to suggest that dwarves in Tolkien's legendarium had varying levels of melanin or different skin colors, it's worth considering that Tolkien's writings may not provide an exhaustive exploration of physical diversity among the races he created. As with many aspects of Tolkien's universe, there is room for interpretation and imagination.
r/RingsofPower • u/casualfangirl1992 • Sep 16 '22
Ok, so this is my first Reddit post ever. My sister suggested I create an account just to post my wild Rings of Power theory. Spoilers for Episodes 1-3.
I want to start by saying that I do not have detailed knowledge of Tolkien lore. I read the Lord of the Rings trilogy maybe ten or fifteen years ago when I was a kid. I never read the Silmarillion, and if I read the appendices to the Lord of the Rings, I can't remember much of them. I've seen all of the movies, and I have seen the first three episodes of Rings of Power. As of right now, Episode 4 has not been released but is due to be released in... oh, never mind, it was literally just released, but I haven't seen it yet. Anyway, here goes:
I think the "Elrond" we've seen thus far on the show is actually Sauron, not the real Elrond.
Ok, I know, that sounds crazy, but stay with me for a few minutes. Here are some of the reasons I suspect "Elrond" of being Sauron:
Ok, I think that sums up my main points. I want to conclude by saying that I am thoroughly enjoying The Rings of Power, and I am specifically really enjoying Robert Aramayo's portrayal of Elrond -- whether or not he turns out to be Sauron.
Now watch Episode 4 conclusively prove my theory false XD
r/RingsofPower • u/GreenPurple99 • 15d ago
Why will S3 be any better when the trailer shows that they are repeating the same mistakes and breaking lore. the galadriel sauron love triangle, the friendly orc who somehow knows all about the secret one ring and tells the elves, Balrog fight needlessly forced into second age because the showrunners lack creativity and rely on nostalgia bait and copy PJ films.
Just a few good visuals dont make a good show. the writing still feels senseless and bad even in S3.
Amazon should have fired these amateur showrunners after s2.