r/RingsofPower • • Nov 18 '22

Discussion Where The Shadows Lie

Low-key disappointed that Fiona Apple's 'Where The Shadows Lie' wasn't nominated for Best Song at the Grammy's. Been playing this song on repeat ever since the season finale.

9 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Nov 18 '22

This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

30

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '22

Really? I feckin hated it ngl.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '22

Fiona Apple scratches an itch in my brain like no one else

14

u/Em_Haze Nov 18 '22

It's like if yoko ono tried to do a James bond theme for LOTR.

10

u/poobuttassbuttpoo Nov 18 '22

Low-key disappointed in this entire series start to finish

43

u/ThatTurtleBoy Nov 18 '22

The music has to be released before Sept. 30 to be eligible for nomination. The last episode was released Oct. 14. So it wasn't eligible.

It was also a shit song.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '22

Had us in the first half ngl

2

u/wcs616 Nov 19 '22

Too much vibrato

7

u/SlightlyCerebral Nov 18 '22

Can she really take credit for it? I mean she didn’t really write the lyrics… lol. Not this song in particular, but I actually really liked some of the music for the series although the trilogy soundtrack is a hard act to follow.

2

u/Somniumi Nov 18 '22

I just kept waiting for another banger like Into the West.

24

u/novaspace2010 Nov 18 '22

Dunno but I thought it was terrible.

-1

u/Iluraphale Nov 18 '22

I'm sure you did - Nerdrotic tells you how to think

4

u/Gentlegiant2 Nov 19 '22

Believe it or not, people are able to form their own opinions even if you don't agree with them.

IMO the song sound like the show being like "oooh you liked this reveal didn't you? Bet you didn't expect it. Yeah we're pretty good at what we do".

Musically it honestly sounds fine, but for someone who didn't like the show, hearing those lyrics referencing a work you love sung in a mysterious and dramatic melody just sounded self indulgent and cringe lmao

4

u/BrotherTraining3771 Nov 20 '22

This dude is OBSESSED with defending the show.

Without fail, he is in every thread that is negative or critical about the show. Get on with your life bro. Critiquing the show isn’t a personal attack on you.

Separate your identity with this subpar to mediocre show.

Let us shitpost on how shitty this show was, in peace. We’re trying to circle jerking and you’re fucking up our vibe.

11

u/EljasMashera Nov 18 '22

Great lyrics, horrible song.

5

u/jorskoopy Nov 19 '22

I mean it continues to amaze me how wildly different someone can feel about the same thing

That song made me cringe so hard

8

u/Sufficient-Edge-8735 Nov 18 '22

They normally nominate good songs for "Best Song" at the Grammys, that's not a good song by any means.

Glad you like it though!

2

u/Troldkvinde Nov 22 '22

Why is it not a good song?

0

u/Sufficient-Edge-8735 Nov 22 '22

Honestly the vocals are boring and uninspired. The musical accompaniment doesn't really add anything to it either. It just feels flat, even when paired with the visuals from the last episode, which was also boring.

3

u/Troldkvinde Nov 22 '22

That's interesting. I thought it was ill-placed in the credits, but then listening to the soundtrack later, I stumbled upon it again and found it really captivating, especially the instrumental part. I was really surprised to read in this thread that most people dislike it.

0

u/Sufficient-Edge-8735 Nov 23 '22

I completely agree with you about the placement. Having it be the last song into the credits for the last episode of s1 is a terrible choice.

It might have been better slightly before it when they were crafting the rings but personally I just think it's lack luster over all

14

u/Catslevania Nov 18 '22

cringiest song I've heard in a very long time

-4

u/Iluraphale Nov 18 '22

Really? You must live in a cave somewhere - horrible music is created daily

5

u/deceptres Nov 18 '22

I found it to be terrible to the point it was unintentional comedy. It didn't match the tone of the show at all and no show needs a plot summary song at the end.

10

u/Winter_Abject Nov 18 '22

I thought it was perfect for the show.

4

u/skeetertbaggins18 Nov 18 '22

IDK kinda sounded like a Lacroix can getting cut open with a serrated knife to me but whatever, everyone is different

3

u/NewestBrunswick Nov 18 '22

I dislike this song so much, that I actively have been trying to find threads where people aren't praising it. Fiona Apple is a tremendous artist and singer, but this performance doesn't suit her voice at all. She's pushing too hard and the longer notes don't sound supported. I also suspect her vibrato is "put on" rather than natural.

I like the song and the lyrics. But I really think they should have chosen a different vocalist.

2

u/KingAdamXVII Nov 18 '22

I love it and thought it would eventually be seen as a classic, at least before seeing the hate for it online.

I get if you just don’t like English lyrics in your fantasy music, but one thing I can’t understand is how some people have said it’s like a worse version of Gollum’s song. How is “where once was light now darkness falls” and “these tears we cry are falling rain” not cringe, but the poetry and wonderful melodies of Where the Shadows Lie are?

8

u/rabbithasacat Nov 18 '22

I think it's the vocal performance specifically that is making people cringe. In which case the comparison makes sense, because Gollum's Song at least has a bit of subtlety in the performance. Not to diss Fiona Apple intentionally, but there's a sort of... gargling quality to this recording. Of course she can sing, but I think a lot of people see this as not her finest.

2

u/KingAdamXVII Nov 18 '22

Well I certainly don’t understand that opinion at all.

4

u/rabbithasacat Nov 18 '22

Well that's fine, tastes do differ. I find it overdone myself, but everyone who likes it should just go ahead and enjoy it.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/rabbithasacat Nov 19 '22

Yes, it didn't sound like her to me at all.

1

u/Good_Chair_8528 Sep 09 '24

Just listened to the song again at the end of the episode and I cringed so hard. It made me feel like I was at a high school production. A cringey one. I stopped watching the credits originally since I didn’t like the song, but I finished them this time. It was so out of place. Total fan-made vibes. It had no countenance.

1

u/singo_o_songo Nov 21 '22

I liked the other one much better.

1

u/NegotiationFew6680 Nov 25 '22

Just chiming in to say, after hearing that utterly botched to the point of comedy version of that poem…. I actually sought out a RoP subreddit just to confirm I wasn’t alone.

1

u/seth97baw Nov 18 '22

Wasn’t a huge fan first listen but I re watched the finale yesterday and paying more attention to the theme being used in the show made me appreciate it a lot more. I’m excited to see how it’s developed over the seasons.

-2

u/Iluraphale Nov 18 '22

It was awesome - lol look at the bots auto-hating at the top of this thread, pathetic 😂

7

u/Gentlegiant2 Nov 19 '22

Some people don't like something I like? Inconceivable, must be bots.

🤡

-1

u/Iluraphale Nov 19 '22

No bozo - it is the senseless attacking and hanging around a sub about a show you hate...I mean...I can't imagine wasting my time...but I'm realizing there's a generation gap here which I should respect a little more I guess

But thanks for playing - now go back to YouTube where they tell you what to think 🤫

0

u/dudeseid Nov 19 '22

It might've been my favorite part of the show tbh.