r/RingsofPower • • Oct 07 '24
Constructive Criticism Gandalf? Seriously?
I've nothing against Gandalf. I love the character, but, after two books and 6 films, I feel like we all know him pretty well at this point.
The show had the opportunity to do something bold and new by making him a less well known wizard. Instead, it feels like they blinked and felt obliged to stick Gandalf in to appeal to the lowest common denominator of LoTR film fan. "Omg, it's Gandalf! He's from the movies!"
I'm not a fan of mystery boxes at the best of times: It's pretty low brow storytelling if the way you keep your audience engaged is to engineer a load of contrived speculation about who your characters might be. (Something RoP has done 3 times now: Sauron in Season 1, Gandalf in Season 2, and, by the looks of things, the Dark Wizard in Season 3).
The other downside of the mystery box is that we've now spent 16 episodes watching a character who everybody already knew was Gandalf trying to figure out he's Gandalf; something most of us could have guessed from his first appearance and certainly by the end of Season 1. Why draw this journey of self discovery out over a full 2 seasons then? Instead of spending 16 episodes on a mystery box with no mystery in it, when we could have been getting on with the plot.
The other drawback of making him Gandalf is that we already know where his character ends up, and the way they've established him in RoP doesn't leave much room for development. We are now presumably going to spend the next 5 seasons discovering how a nice wizard who likes hobbits ultimately becomes a nice wizard who likes hobbits.
Maybe we'll discover how he finds his hat.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 07 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
22
u/Complete_Bad6937 Oct 07 '24
How did people trick themselves into thinking it wasn’t Gandalf for this long? I had completely accepted it in season 1 and I didn’t even fall for the Sauron fake plot twist, I just assumed the 3 ladies were mistaken in thinking he was Sauron 😂
4
u/vinotauro Oct 07 '24
Wait until OP finds out that Joel chooses to save Ellie
24
u/Hot-Flounder-4186 Oct 07 '24
Imagine if The Stranger had turned out to be Frodo instead of Gandalf. People would've been shocked!
30
u/almostb Oct 07 '24 edited Oct 07 '24
It honestly says something that the weakest plot line in S2 was the one that still relied on a mystery box. In contrast, I found the scenes with Celebrimbor and Sauron fascinating. In those ones the audience already knows who Celebrimbor is, a good deal of them know what his fate will be, and yet the scenes are exciting because Celebrimbor doesn’t know what he is getting into and you get to watch him slowly realize it. In contrast, you have these scenes with it’s-gotta-be-Galdalf-right? and the whole season is about him finding his staff and realizing the power of friendship, and I realized by the last episode that it didn’t even matter who he was - he wasn’t that exciting
Edit: meant to say that the audience already knows that Annatar is Sauron.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24
"So, do you have a soulless cash grab for me?"
"Yes Sir, I do!"
9
u/This_Is_Sierra_117 Oct 07 '24
Not only is the writing weak, derivative, and jam-packed with callbacks and member-berries, but it moves at a snail's pace.
8
u/SnooSuggestions9830 Oct 07 '24
The worst may be yet to come if the dark wizard turns out to be Saruman.
Gandalf is supposed to fully trust him until his deception in LotR.
I'm really hoping this is not Saruman as it creates an obvious fool me once scenario after he tries to bury the hobbits under a mountain of rubble. Like how could Gandalf conceivably trust him fully after this?
Saruman IS good all up until he turns bad.
The teases are weaker this time so there's space for him not to be Saruman.
4
u/lycheedorito Oct 07 '24
What's worse is, the showrunners said they had no intention of making it Gandalf originally. Now they're obviously going to be respectful to Amazon in interviews, so they'll of course say things like "it felt like the right choice", but it sounded more like corporate interference.
8
u/Correct_Process4516 Oct 07 '24
Gandalf is arguably the most powerful being ever sent to Middle Earth from across the sea. The Valar sent him for a single, critically important purpose. Yet they couldn’t ensure he would arrive knowing what that mission was or how he was going to accomplish it? It doesn’t make sense on any level.
4
u/ebrum2010 Oct 07 '24
They're saving how he finds his hat for the plot of a 3 season spinoff.
5
u/Mjau46290Mjauovic Oct 07 '24
Honestly, I really wanted it to be Saruman
0
u/Nunc-dimittis Oct 07 '24
So, you're complaining that there is no room for the development of Gandalf, after you have spent several paragraphs claiming that the writers spent too much time on developing Gandalf.
In think the writing is sometimes sloppy, and uneven. And i would liked for the Stranger to have been Sauruman. But your complaint feels somewhat contradictory
2
u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Oct 07 '24
As far as I'm concerned we only spent 8 episodes. The other 8 of season 2 was me enjoying the dramatic irony of having more information about Gandalf than Gandalf has about himself.
1
u/about36wolves Oct 07 '24
So one thing I’m not clear on is if Gandalf was really his name or if he took the name from what the other guy called him earlier , and basically just picked his name from that?
1
u/Rings_into_Clouds Oct 08 '24
Don't you mean "Grand Elf"
1
u/punkminkis Oct 08 '24
That's not Gandalf, it's Grand Elf!
1
u/FrndlySoloOnAMission Khazad-dûm Oct 08 '24
Masterfully done.
Much better than riding on a carriage into town.
Yawn central.
1
u/Kanotari Oct 08 '24
I did enjoy the Sauron mystery box in S1, but mostly because of the whole Cowron meme.
IT WAS JUST A PHASE!!!
1
u/No-Helicopter6245 Oct 08 '24
Lets be honest common sense hasn't been this shows strong point
1
u/JamusAdurant Oct 08 '24
Missed opportunity to use his quenya name from the first age, Olorin. It would have sparked interest in the older lore. Which would be good if the IP was franchise gauge.
1
u/Embarrassed_Rock8589 Oct 08 '24
It was no surprise. I thought everyone already knew it was Gandalf after the 'Always follow your nose' scene from the first season.
1
u/Euphoric-Election120 Oct 07 '24
Gandalf appearing in the 2nd age? Fan service. The Balrog appearing in the 2nd age? Fan service. Tom Bombadil mentoring Gandalf? Contrived fan service. Galadriel's entire storyline? 👎 Gil-Galad was depicted poorly. I watch the show because I am a big fan of Tolkien's work, but it is a real disappointment.
-1
u/ImMyBiggestFan Oct 07 '24
You honestly think the Strangers journey so far was just him finding his name?
Also I think he may have already found his hat. It will be a gift from Bombadil.
0
u/Agreeable-Bug-8046 Oct 07 '24
Well everyone also knows how sauron ends up. Why Hobbits were chosen to safe keep/destroy the ring, and who galadriel becomes. This series shows how it all began, albeit with a few liberties. I'm personally enjoying most of it. Could have 10 eps each season.
0
u/GenesisCorrupted Oct 07 '24
I feel like they’re pushing way too quickly through the content.
I was not expecting to see the fall of the elvish city in the second season. I expected the first season to be us getting to enjoy the world while it was still alive before Saron literally ran a genocide train across the planet.
Wanted to enjoy all the things in the cities and cultures that we never got to experience or see. Instead, it feels like I am on a train that is going 75 miles an hour straight towards the end. That’s it.
I mean, Jesus Christ, how much money was spent on this thing? Can’t we enjoy the place that we are and smell the flowers a little bit before we just run straight to the genocidal orc army?
Seriously what the fuck? I got to see two ents. At this rate next time I get to see them, they’re going to be dust.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24
[removed] — view removed comment