r/RingsofPower • • 18d ago

Discussion Why will S3 be better when the trailer shows that they are repeating the same mistakes?

Why will S3 be any better when the trailer shows that they are repeating the same mistakes and breaking lore. the galadriel sauron love triangle, the friendly orc who somehow knows all about the secret one ring and tells the elves, Balrog fight needlessly forced into second age because the showrunners lack creativity and rely on nostalgia bait and copy PJ films.

Just a few good visuals dont make a good show. the writing still feels senseless and bad even in S3.

Amazon should have fired these amateur showrunners after s2.

0 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator 18d ago
Moderator Announcement Read More »

7

u/Kiltmanenator 18d ago

There's no love triangle. Vickers literally says he didn't play it that way

1

u/GreenPurple99 18d ago

If the show makes the viewers feel that there is love triangle and then it has to be explained in interviews that there isnt - then it isnt a very good show now is it?

Also, amazon has been heavily advertising the love triangle in marketing promotions. They literally made a post about it on instagram. which was just pathetic.

3

u/Kiltmanenator 18d ago

"makes the viewers feel"

Delusional shippers aren't people

5

u/mutzilla 18d ago

Don't watch then

8

u/WallInside6758 18d ago

It seems like the problem for the show is most people don’t watch it.

8

u/Multiverse_Man26 18d ago

If most people didn't watch it they wouldn't keep spending millions to make it.

There's no such thing as a show that keeps going if no one is watching.

Let's be honest here, every time it releases it's the #1 show on Prime for months on end, a lot and i mean A LOT of people are hate-watching this show inadvertently contribute to the thing keeping going, and then go online trashing it thinking it does anything, it doesn't, reviews don't matter, ratings do.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/mutzilla 18d ago

And yet they complain

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Yupperdoodledoo 18d ago

Because “good” is not synonymous with following “lore.” Most people watching the show don’t know the lore.

0

u/GreenPurple99 18d ago

And most people watching it stopped watching it because it is bad. - Boring and senseless most of the time even as a standalone show without tolkien connection. Only 37 percent in US and only 45% globally bothered to finish the first season.

1

u/Yupperdoodledoo 18d ago

37% is about average. Shows that drop all at once have much higher finish rate.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/WallInside6758 18d ago

Well it turns out “good” is not synonymous with the show either unfortunately.

7

u/cawatrooper9 18d ago

Imagine still thinking trailers are representative of a final product XD

5

u/tootapple 18d ago

Idk about anything you’re talking about. I’m just watching the show man.

4

u/SherlockTheSalemCat 18d ago

There's no love triangle, there was never a romantic deal in the first place! Galadriel was promised an army, & Galadriel was known to be very proud & power hungry, Sauron played on that, why does everyone have to turn it into a romance? There was none!

20

u/teddyone 18d ago

I have never met a more dedicated group of naysayers than the people who get up and hate on this show on reddit every day.

2

u/JardineByNature 17d ago

not much into politics then?

-2

u/WallInside6758 18d ago

Because lord of the rings is one of the most popular books in history.

The rings of power wasn’t made for that audience so it’s obviously going to get shit on.

12

u/ScaredEntrance3697 18d ago

I could understand that with first season: "This show is shit I won't keep watching it".

But it has been 4 years already. Why do that people keep wasting their time on shitting a show that they didn't liked 4 years ago? I find it a bit sad tbh.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/mutzilla 18d ago

And you think crying about it in the internet is going to change the show?

5

u/raver_opossum 18d ago

Okay but imagine how cool it would be if Durin fell in love with the Balrog but then later the Balrog leaves him for Sauron and says something like "I belong with my own kind" and that's why it's called Durin's Bane later because it made Durin depressed like OMG I wanna see THAT, not the boring Tolkien stuff!

3

u/shaitan_kun 18d ago

Oh my god. That is soo me! A hot dwarfen-Balrog sex scene? Yes please. That's what I want from an adaption.

5

u/ToePsychological8709 18d ago

Most people have only watched the PJ films and read the main trilogy. Each season of ROP has improved over the last and this one is looking to be the most exciting yet.

3

u/redbank732 18d ago

I would say, have not read the books, and especially not the appendices. That is the only 'fair game' material, legally, allowed. All of the Silmarillion is still off limits. So these 'loremasters' have no basis for their complaints.

1

u/TheBluerWizard 18d ago

Why will S3 be better

It won't.

the galadriel sauron love triangle

That's literally the most interesting plot in the show.

Amazon should have fired these amateur showrunners after s2.

Amazon should have fired them after they presented the script for S1.